
Member Reviews

Suraya is a innkeeper's daughter who also dabbles as a bladesmith. She considers herself to be very ordinary, so when she receives an invitation to the capital city as a potential bride for the crown prince she assumes it's a prank. After some prodding by her best friend, she makes the journey to Kaldari. When she finds out the truth behind the contest for the prince's hand, she finds out some hidden truths about herself as well. With the help of an unexpected ally, Suraya sets out to save herself and the kingdom.
I devoured this in a day. It checked so many boxes: enemies to lovers, forced proximity, dangerous trials, hidden identities... Everything I love in a romantasy was here! The mythology was beautiful and I found the characters so charming. The plot twists were perfect and kept me turning the page to see if I was able to figure it out.
I so hope there will be a sequel. If the story goes where I think it will, I know I will kicking my feet and giggling.
Thank you to NetGalley and Avon and Harper-Voyager for the ARC!

Thank you NetGalley for an arc of this book.
Dark, whimsical , immersive with fairytale vibes. Good world building with magic, it’s always interesting to learn new systems from authors. It reads both YA/Adult at times ( or with adult themes).

“Nothing wrong with being beautiful, powerful, AND capable.”
~
“Where there’s hope, there’s always a way.”
~
Perfect pacing, lush and descriptive world-building, intricate story-weaving with emotional and heart-racing moments like, well-placed and indescribably hot spicy scenes, this book had it ALL! I was pulled in right from the very beginning in Sura’s forge. Not only were the main characters, Sura and Ro, endearing and lovable and just ones you had to root for, but the (non-evil!) side characters were some of the best, even some that seemed to cross the good and evil line at times (looking at you, jump scare in the last thirty pages!). This book was truly the perfect blend of romance, intrigue, lore/mythology, and alllll the banter. I have SO many questions that I’ve been assured are the right ones, and I truly cannot wait for the second book to arrive! I don’t want to be spoilery here, but I assure you that even though this is the author’s first foray into Romantasy, it surely will not be her last and this story reads like she was supposed to be here all along. Case in point - exhibit A: my screaming DMs and multitude of tabs. Pick this one up, not only does it have a stunning cover but it’ll leave you at the edge of your seat, unable to turn the pages fast enough!

I enjoyed this book. I thought that the world building was well done. I enjoyed the different places that they had to go and had no issues envisioning them. What I really liked was that it wasn't overly wordy or bogged down by being too descriptive. The other thing I really enjoyed was the magic system. I found that I really liked the majority of the characters. I did find the pacing to be a bit off at times, and felt that it read way more YA than adult. That being said I am excited to see how the story continues into book 2.

Thank you to HarperCollins for providing me with an eARC of this book.
I thought this was a fun read. The plot was interesting and unique to anything I personally had read before. I was definitely interested in learning more about the magic possessed by the FMC. Though the MMC was definitely my favorite- tall, dark, and handsome with a dash of 'touch her and die' vibes. The banter between the main characters was fabulous.
I also enjoyed the setting and the fact that it stems from Persian and Indian mythology. That's not something you see a lot of. It's nice to read a story with some diversity!
I did feel like the middle dragged on in some spots, feeling a little disjointed, with the story feeling just a tad rushed toward the end. The pacing overall could have been just a little better.
Overall, I would recommend to anyone who loves an adventurous story, with a little bit of trials and games, and a unique magic element.

What a way to integrate world building and historical fiction. Well done. I’m not sure if this is a stand alone or a series but I’m praying for a second book. Well written and will recommend to many friends. Mahalo for the eARC.

Classic, fun, and spunky—this is a YA fantasy that hits so many great notes. I really enjoyed the romance as well.

I was able to check out both the ebook and audiobook - ARC’s courtesy of NetGallery. One of my favorite things about this book was the mythology - it had elements that I haven’t read it other books before so it was fresh and interesting. I really want to know more about Suraya’s world, and the political and magical structure of this universe, so I hope there will be more to come in the future.
I felt like the plot had a good pace - there weren’t parts that dragged so I stayed engaged whether I was listening or reading. Suraya’s character was witty and sassy and I loved her from the very beginning, even when she had some whiney juvenile moments. The slow burn romance was good, and the spice was well written.
The ending had some twists, and it definitely left me with questions and wanting more.
A really fun romantasy all around!

The Starlight Heir is a new fantasy romance from Amalie Howard, an author known primarily for historical romance. I think this book proves that there’s a huge overlap between historical and fantasy romances, because Amalie does a fantastic job crossing over.
The Starlight Heir is set in a Persian-mythology inspired fantasy world that delivers a lot of world building while still trying to feel fresh and fun. It was a bit of a difficult start for me – although set in a fantasy world that feels a bit ancient, the characters use modern slang. And it starts off with our heroine forced to take part in deadly trials to win the hand of the prince – which I’ve read before and didn’t feel super fresh.
However, after we leave the palace the book moves into much more interesting and original territory. There’s a rebellion trying to overthrow the evil rulers, a steamy romance with the “wrong” guy who seems to be harboring secrets, and lots of discovering her magical powers. The pace picks up about the halfway point too and the final third of the book is action-packed and full of twists.
All in all, a fun book for fantasy romance fans!

This debut fantasy by prolific author Amalie Howard was disappointing. The story is clearly not set in a modern-like world, and yet the author’s characters use words/phrases that are clearly very modern. Every single time she used modern language it took me out of the story. Then there is the world building which is also not as strong as it could me.
The author’s characters lack substance, too. There were times when it appeared that the author spent more time thinking about the fashions of her world than she had in developing her characters. The main character, Suraya Saab, is amorphous and readers will struggle to relate to her. Her secondary characters are more like stick characters than fully realized characters.
If you love fantasy/romantasy and don’t pay attention to how a book’s dialogue is written while you read and don’t mind characters who are not exactly believable, you’ll undoubtedly love this book.
My thanks to Avon and NetGalley for an eARC.

LOVE! Aboslutely honored to receive an early copy of this book. Was already excited going in but it definitely lived up to the hype I had for it.
The magical system that Amalie Howard had created hooked me right from the star(t), how everything was related back to the cosmos was interesting. The slooowwww burn - oh, so good! Not sure if I would classify MLC as morally grey but he was SWOON worthy nonetheless. I loved watching the relationship between Suraya and the MLC grow. This book was a solid five stars for me, and I'm so grateful the author ended with enough of a HEA while still letting the audience know there was more to come!
One thing I did find bothersome at first was the use of some random modern day phrases. It didn't seem like it fit the time period or the overall vibes, but it never states what time period it was in so could be completely relevant. It wasn't too distracting from the rest of the book and was still a FANTASTIC read. Can't wait to continue on!

This is a solid fantasy book with some romance built in - I wouldn't call it specifically a romantasy, but there is definitely spice. The spicy parts don't overwhelm the entire story though so I'd still recommend you try it out.
Suraya gets an invite to the palace as part of the prince's marriage search. Prior to leaving, there are some signs that she should reconsider, but she feels compelled given the request came straight from the king. Once she gets there, things really hit the fan. The world building and magic system in the book is easy to understand and kept me interested throughout. There were some unresolved plot points at the end of the book so I'll be interested in seeing where it goes from here.
Thank you to Avon and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy!

This world is immersive and well built, set in a desert kingdom where Jādū shards are believed to be the only remaining magic left from the gods. The story is brimming with adventure, magic, political intrigue, secrets, and betrayal as Suraya discovers that the marriage selection she has been requested to attend to choose the bride of the crown Prince, is a competition and death trial set to discover the starkeeper of the gods: her. Someone she previously thought was nothing more than a children’s fable.
Fantasy novels often remind you of other worlds in the genre. While this novel was no different, it also brought a fresh take I haven’t seen much of before in other aspects. The prose fluctuates between descriptive moments and plain language and reminded me of a more YA style of writing. Both the adventure and world building are fast paced, but the author manages to avoid information dumps throughout the novel and even gives you a breakdown of the faction houses of hierarchy at the font of the novel and a glossary of magical terms in the back, which I loved!
Suraya is a loyal, intelligent, and strong woman with a sharp tongue. While I enjoyed Suraya’s character and her journey as she discovers her powers, I would have liked to read more about her learning about, training, and harnessing her gifts. It felt as though she learned to harness the majority of her control from only some sporadic training. I think this would have also opened Suraya up to more personal growth, as I felt that at her core, she did not have much personal character development outside her gifts.
Roshan is a wonderfully layered and compelling character laced with secrets. He is a fiercely loyal protector, and despite being the illegitimate heir to the throne, he only wants what is best for his father’s people. His relationship with Suraya is a slow-burn, with lots of tension, and well paced in a way that makes the connection feel earned.
The book does not end on a cliffhanger, but several threads are left loose, so this could be a stand-alone novel or the first of a series. Hopefully, it is a series as I am interested to learn more about how the god of night ties into Suraya and Roshan’s world.
—
✨Romantasy
🗡️Desert landscape
🐦🔥Death trials
✨Chosen one
🗡️Prophecy & destiny
🐦🔥Political rebellion
✨Female bladesmith
🗡️Embued magical objects
🐦🔥Magic & runes
✨Astrology
🗡️Adventure
🐦🔥Magical mythical animals
✨Open-door
🗡️Love triangle?
🐦🔥Sporadic 2nd POV throughout
—
Story by Amalie Howard: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Narration by Anais Inara Chase:⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Narration by Ramiz Monsef: ⭐️⭐️⭐️
—
Thank you Avon and Harper Voyager, HarperAudio Adult, and NetGalley for these complimentary ARC & ALC - all thoughts are my own! 📚
Publishers release date 1/7/2025

This book was really interesting, and I enjoyed reading it! However, it's really a difficult one for me to rate and review, as I felt very different about the story at different points.
I absolutely loved the beginning and the world-building based off of mythology. It reminded me of Egyptian and Indian mythology mixed, and the magic system was really unique. I loved the side characters and the premise, and it had me hooked for the first 20%.
It kind of got a bit Dune Part 2 toward the middle, not in a bad way... but the pacing just changed in a way I wasn't expecting.
We had some twists and reveals at the end, and it set things up for book 2 quite nicely. I think I would have loved more explanation on what was going on with certain perspectives that did become important toward the very end, though!
I think fans of Powerless would love this book based on the love story and magic system!

One thing I have noticed with romantasy is that many of them keep the world building to a minimum. The Starlight Heir does not. The map needs to be consulted, I could have used a more extensive directory because the one provided was very simplified.. However, this is still an excellent read.
The romance is hot with extreme levels of adventure. It was hard to figure out exactly where it was going, although the leader of the Dahaka was pretty obvious throughout the story.
All in all, a pretty enjoyable romantasy.
Thank you to Net Galley, Avon and Harper Voyager for the DRC. All opinions are my own!

I think the modern slang and the insta-list threw me off the story and I wasn’t able to enjoy it properly.

DNF @ 22% I just don’t think this one’s for me. I’m just really hating the use of modern phrases such as “resting bitch face,” “princesplaining,” “thick thighs save lives,” etc. because it’s really just taking me out of the story. I’m also really not a fan of insta love, and it’s coming across that way since the FMC is immediately lusting over the MMC and imagining them doing shit together after meeting literally twice. Like where is the tension, the yearning?? The world is really interesting though, and I love the middle eastern mythology. Also can we talk about the gorgeous cover?? I think this would be somebody else’s cup of tea but I just can’t get immersed in the story unfortunately.

Can we talk about how STUNNING this cover is? Thank you netgalley, the publishers and the author for my gifted copies of this book. All opinions are my own.
I really loved the premise of this book. I felt like in some ways I knew what to expect and others I did not! I really appreciated Suraya’s strength but would have loved to see her try to control her power more in this book. I hope we see what she can do in the next one!
There is definitely a little instalove..or instalust? I like Suraya and Roshan together but I wish we would have gone a little more in depth on their relationship.
I’m interested to see where this story goes next and the secrets yet to be uncovered! This one is out January 7th and if you like romantasy could be right up your alley!

Rating: 4/5
I received an eARC for my honest opinion.
In a world where there are only Jadu shards left to be the only things left with magic that the gods have left, but is it? This book has adventure, a great magical system, politics, betrayal and romance. You will meet Suraya and Roshan who are the main characters and they’re well done, but so are the side characters that you will get to know more throughout the book. In this fantasy world nothing is what it seems, and you will have to uncover a lot of secrets and betrayals to get the truth out.
I really enjoyed Howard’s book, I found the world building to be interesting and engaging throughout the book. I liked that there wasn’t an info dump on, but information was given out throughout the book. I found the politics in this book not to be a bore, but really helped to add the urgency of the mission. I thought the author did well with world building and made sure that the book was fast paced but still gave the readers what they wanted. I found the glossary in the book to be helpful and I did find myself flipping back and forth a few times just to understand the words sometimes. I thought the characters were well developed and even though I was blown away with how many layers Roshan wears to hide himself, I loved getting to know him more and more throughout the book.
Suraya, she is a blacksmith, helps her father at his tavern, but when she finds out that she has been selected to attend the marriage selection for the crown Prince. Her world is turned upside down and right away she feels as though she is not worthy of the invite, but finds out that the story she grew up thinking was a child’s fairy tale is true, and she might be the key to saving the world or will she burn the place to the ground? I liked her character right away, I found her to be easy to connect with and I found myself able to relate to her feelings of feeling like why me, I’m not special. I liked that she was smart, she didn’t hold back her wits and kept people on her toes, but you still will see her vulnerable moments come through as well. I thought her character's growth throughout the book was well done, and it was mostly done when she was learning to harness her abilities and trying to understand everything that is thrown at her.
Roshan is a character that gave off vibes of being an onion, you would figure out one layer then, soon realize that there is more to go. I found the author did a great job making sure that the readers were not quite sure what to think about him. At times I wanted to love Roshan, other times I wanted to shake the heck out of him, but I loved getting to know each layer that was shown to us. I liked that he was protective of Suraya and wanted to make sure that she understood her power and what she meant to the world. I found him too sweet and caring, but at the same time I still made sure that I was on the fence with him because I had been stirred the wrong way before lol. I love that you really get to see the chemistry between these two grow when they go on the run and just develop from there.
I can’t wait to see what book will bring us, because with that new character that was hinted to us feels like he will be a big player. I know that you will see a few places in the book where you see his character being built up, but it’s not until the ending when you really see it all fall together.
I want to thank NetGalley and Avon Harper for the opportunity to review this book.

❗️Disclaimed: This review isn’t to tell the author that their work is bad or not. This review is simply based on my own personal opinion of the book. I do suggest you give it a chance before you form an opinions about it and decide whether you like it or not.❗️
Thank you to Netgalley and Harper Audio for the ALC and ARC of this book.
This was a though book for me to rate. The start of the book I would say is a 1 maybe 2 stars. I would say because the book reads like a YA even though it isn’t, so the spice scenes surprised me and gave me whiplash even though I knew it had spice. I also found myself quite bored at the start and didn’t care for any of the characters or the story, making me almost dnf at 30%, I found myself zoning out and forgetting stuff because I wasn’t interested in the story but I powered through and don’t regret it. Towards the middle of the book it becomes a 3 star because I can ignore the fact it reads like YA and we are also slowly leaving it behind in my opinion.The story gets interesting there and I found myself actually liking the characters more. I also zone out less and actually start to like the story. Then comes the end of the book which is the best part in my opinion and why I will probably continue this series. I loved seeing more of the magic and the action scenes where really well described. I liked the romance even though I’m rooting for another romance (if you know you know 👀). I do think the romance was very insta lust and a bit rushed for my liking but it didn’t ruin the story for me. In the end I do think I like this story and I will probably continue this series because the ending left me intrigued. I also think we can only go up from here and that this series could become a 4 star maybe 5 star series. If you are like me and find the start difficult to get into I would suggest you power through because it goes up from there.