Member Reviews

⭐️ 4.5/5 Stars - 📚 The Killing Plains by Sherry Rankin

📖 Thank you to NetGalley and Thomas & Mercer for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

Sherry Rankin’s The Killing Plains is an atmospheric thriller that plunges readers into the unforgiving landscape of West Texas, where danger and secrets simmer beneath the surface. As a thriller enthusiast, I was hooked from the first page – Rankin masterfully crafts a suspenseful read.

Set against the stark beauty of the plains, the novel follows Detective Colly Newland as she’s pulled into a chilling murder investigation that mirrors a crime from twenty years earlier. A boy is found dead, and all fingers point to Willis Newland, just released from prison for an identical murder. But Colly isn’t convinced – and the deeper she digs, the more tangled the web of secrets becomes.

The pacing is spot-on, with each chapter ending in a way that makes it impossible to stop reading. Rankin’s descriptive writing brings the desolate, windswept plains to life, creating a haunting sense of isolation that mirrors the unease coursing through the story.

Colly is a brilliantly complex protagonist – determined, vulnerable, and relentless in her pursuit of the truth. Her personal stakes in the case add emotional weight, while the supporting cast adds layers of intrigue (and suspicion!). The townspeople, each with something to hide, make for an unsettling backdrop that keeps the reader guessing.

Just when you think you’ve cracked the case, Rankin throws in a twist that turns everything upside down. The surprises are well-executed and feel organic to the plot, making the final reveal all the more satisfying.

💭 If you love atmospheric thrillers with rich character development, unexpected twists, and a strong female lead, The Killing Plains is a must-read. I’m already looking forward to more from Sherry Rankin!

📌 The Killing Plains releases 1 February 2025.
📚 For more reviews, visit instagram.com/liisalovesreading

Was this review helpful?

Viking Jam
1,263 reviews
26 followers

Follow
September 16, 2024
Review: A well written mystery with great characterization and amazing visual renderings. So why only three stars? Someone with this kind of talent needs to make the whodunnit more intricate. As it was, by the 20% mark, you should pretty easily be able to figure out who is doing it and why. Yeah there are familial secrets and sudden clashes with the townsfolk, but those are obivious red herrings that tend to markedly separate the guilty party.

One of the better mysteries I have read without the constant olde english verbosity or the man-crushing.

Was this review helpful?

The Killing Plains is a gripping thriller that takes place in Texas after a series of unfortunate events and two murders. In an effort to clear her son’s name regarding the murders, the family matriarch insists that her daughter in law, a former cop, comes to their town to conduct a separate investigation. Colly brings her grandson with her while she investigates. The child has been through a great deal of trauma and that doesn’t stop during the course of the investigation. Colly worries about the course her young grandson is on as well as having to decide if she can trust what information is being delivered by her deceased husband’s family members. Everywhere she looks there are conflicts with the investigation. The tangled family web runs deep! The story is a little slow to start in my opinion, but takes off running mid-book. I felt that the ending wrapped up rather quickly with a lot of details being explained after the fact. I would have liked to see some of the details emerging more during the investigation. All in all a good read!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book immensely. This is Sherry Rankin's first published book. I think it was well written and it had a twist. Part of me figured it out, but it was still a great book. I recommend this book to anyone who loves thrillers and a good mystery. I can't wait to see what Sherry Rankin comes up with next. I will definitely be reading it.

Was this review helpful?

This was a typical whodunnit, with quite a collection of possible subjects. I enjoyed the storyline at times, and at other times, I felt it dragged. Good ending, though!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book for an honest review

This is a well written good old fashioned thriller mystery . The plot keeps you guessing as the clues are revealed. I recommend this book and give it 4 stars

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for this compelling eARC.

Sherry Rankin’s “The Killing Plains” is a gripping and atmospheric novel that plunges readers into the heart of a desolate landscape where secrets and danger lurk beneath the surface. As a book reviewer with a penchant for thrillers and mysteries, I found this book to be a masterclass in suspense and storytelling.

“The Killing Plains” is set in the vast, unforgiving plains of the American Midwest, where a series of brutal murders disrupts the quiet life of a small town. Rankin expertly weaves a complex narrative that keeps readers on the edge of their seats. The plot unfolds through multiple perspectives, each adding depth and intrigue to the story. The pacing is impeccable, with each chapter ending on a note of suspense that compels you to keep reading.

Rankin’s writing is both evocative and immersive. She paints a vivid picture of the stark, haunting beauty of the plains, making the setting almost a character in itself. The tension is palpable, and the sense of isolation and vulnerability is expertly conveyed. The book’s twists and turns are well-crafted, keeping readers guessing until the very end.

The characters in “The Killing Plains” are richly drawn and multifaceted. The protagonist, a determined and resourceful detective, is particularly compelling. Her personal struggles and relentless pursuit of justice add emotional depth to the narrative. The supporting characters, from the enigmatic townsfolk to the chilling antagonist, are equally well-developed, each contributing to the story’s complexity.

Rankin excels at delivering unexpected twists that challenge readers’ assumptions and keep the plot fresh. Just when you think you have figured out the mystery, she throws in a curveball that changes everything. These twists are not only surprising but also seamlessly integrated into the storyline, enhancing the overall impact.

“The Killing Plains” stands out for its originality and creativity. Rankin’s ability to blend elements of psychological thriller, crime fiction, and atmospheric storytelling is impressive. The novel’s unique setting and the intricate web of secrets and lies make it a standout in the genre.

“The Killing Plains” is a must-read for fans of thrillers and mysteries. Sherry Rankin has crafted a novel that is both chilling and captivating, with a plot that keeps you hooked from start to finish. Her skillful storytelling and deep understanding of human nature make this book a memorable and rewarding read.

Whether you’re a seasoned mystery reader or new to the genre, “The Killing Plains” is sure to leave a lasting impression. This was my first book by this author, but it definitely won't be my last!

Was this review helpful?

Title: The Killing Plains
Author: Sherry Rankin (Debut Author)
Genre: Mystery Thriller
Publisher: Thomas & Mercer
Pub Date: February 1, 2025
My Rating: 3 Stars
Pages: 365

Crescent Bluff, West Texas is a place where; everybody knows everyone - their families as well as their secrets’. So when a young man is found dead with the skin of a hare’s head everyone knows who killed him—as Willis Newland was just released from prison after serving twenty years for an identical murder.

Retired Detective Colly (Columbus) Newland reluctantly agrees to investigate a case that seems to involve the whole town, including her dead husband’s extended family.

I wanted to give Willis the benefit of the doubt but the snake as thick as your arm did freak me out.
Also want to give support to debut author however to me this was an okay read – which doesn’t mean it wasn’t good. In fact, I checked reviews and saw that many readers love this story.

Which reminds me ~
The difference between an amazing story and a so-so one depends on who is reading it!

Want to thank Thomas & Mercer for this early eGalley.
Publishing Release Date scheduled for February 1, 2025.

Was this review helpful?

I love a good mystery, especially one that I can't pick the killer.

This felt like a good old fashioned mystery thriller, with enough character development and clues thrown in to keep you engaged and guessing. I enjoyed how we slowly learned more about our main characters background and her motivations for her decisions.

4 stars! Definitely recommended.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Easy to figure out early on, but not a deal breaker in terms of finishing. I liked the main character.

Thanks to Netgalley for the free copy in exchange for an honest review

Was this review helpful?

I really liked this book. It wasn't the usual modern day fare. More like the older, better, thriller books. (I seriously dislike the trends seen in modern mysteries/thrillers.)

I picked the bad guy from early on. Mostly because of a hint I read in another review. It's a bit spoilerish but of all the red herrings in this book, and there were a lot, there could have been some suspicion directed towards the actual culprit.

I also liked the inclusion of the Mcdonald Triad and the brain scans. Though they are more likely to be indicators of trauma in a child than predictions of future violence. I'm really glad the author didnt leave his or her audience with the belief that bedwetting or pyromaniac tendencies automatically indicates psychopathy.

A few things I disliked:

The amount of suspects. Literally everyone in the book was either a suspect or lying about pretty significant things.

The sidekick (Avery?) was spoiled and borderline useless. I don't understand why she existed, other than that one scene where she explains her past. Which was a thumb piece to broaden the story. I don't think her behavior would have been tolerated anywhere in real life.

I dont like the MC's motivation. And I don't like how Satchel was treated. Why even bring the kid? If he couldn't handle being separated for a short period, she should have stayed home with him. He should have been a higher priority than he was and all that didnt fully make sense. Why transfer him to an entirely new school for a week? Then transfer back? I know he was a plot point but still

Was this review helpful?

This was such a fantastic read. It had so many twists and turns and honestly kept me on my toes the entire time.

I would think I had figured out who did it and then a curveball would come along with new information and I'd have to start over. Near the end, I did have it down to 2 choices, but just couldn't choose between then. But when it was revealed, everything clicked into place. I def hope this is the start of a series!

Was this review helpful?

Such an amazing read. I loved it sooo much.
The Book was a little bit slow at the beginning but after a few chapters, everything changed it turned to be so engrossing and keeping you at your toes. It was so amazing how everything came to make sense by the end and the author laid all the evidences to help connect the dots and .making everything so clear.

5/5


My first ARC from netgalley so grateful for it hope for more

Was this review helpful?

It was overall a good mystery set in west Texas with a likeable protagonist and I thought it was well plotted and paced with good readability
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for letting me review book

Was this review helpful?

A well-written murder mystery with a likeable protagonist and a distinctive setting.
Colly, a widowed ex cop, is asked by a serving cop, the brother of her late husband, to investigate a possible serial killer case that implicates a third brother.
Despite the implausibility of family members being on a police case, and the lead detective not even a serving officer, the plot reads well. Colly works her way around various witnesses and suspects in the rural Texas location and negotiates delicate relationships with other family members, including head of the family, Iris, mother of the three brothers.
I guessed the culprit early on, as I think many seasoned thriller readers will. However, being proved right added to, rather than detracted from, my enjoyment of the story. I'd happily read another book by this author.
With thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read an early copy in exchange for an independent review.

On publication, I will post my review on my blog, Amazon and GoodReads.

Was this review helpful?

“The Killing Plains” is a gripping mystery novel set in Crescent Bluff, West Texas, where secrets run deep and everyone knows each other. The story revolves around two victims who are murdered twenty years apart, leading to the suspicion of a single elusive killer.

The narrative begins with the shocking discovery of a boy found dead, clutching the skin of a hare’s head in his hand. The town quickly points fingers at Willis Newland, who has just been released from prison after serving two decades for committing an identical murder. This immediate assumption raises questions about the reliability of public perception and whether they could be wrong about Newland’s guilt.

The novel explores themes such as family loyalty, the impact of past crimes on present lives, and the complexities of relationships within small communities. It challenges readers to consider how well we truly know those around us and what lengths individuals will go to hide their truths.

“The Killing Plains” presents a compelling narrative filled with suspense and intrigue as Detective Colly Newland seeks justice while confronting her own family’s dark history.

Was this review helpful?

The writing in Sherry Rankin’s debut mystery, The Killing Plains, shows why she won the Crime Writers’ Association (CWA) Debut Dagger Award. Set in Crescent Bluff, West Texas, it’s a gritty, atmospheric story.

Colly Newland retired from the Houston police department after her husband and daughter were killed. For the last couple years, she’s been raising her grandson, Satchel, a troubled young boy still struggling with the trauma of finding the family bodies. Colly’s reluctant to return to Crescent Bluff, her late husband’s family home, but his brother, Russ, the chief of police, asks for her help. Twenty years ago, a young boy’s body was found by a pond. Willis Newland was arrested and went to prison for the crime. Now, another boy is dead, and the town suspects Willis. But, Willis died before the Texas Rangers could prove their case. Now, Willis’ mother, Colly’s mother-in-law, pulls strings to have the case reopened. And, Russ wants Colly to investigate.

But, someone in town doesn’t want Colly around. She starts to get threats soon after she arrives. And, she’s torn. Should she work to find the killer, or protect Satchel from all the family and local drama and take him home to Houston? Colly doesn’t even feel up to looking after herself in a community that thrives on rumor, rattlesnake rodeos, and drunkenness. How can she investigate and look after her seven-year-old grandson?

Rankin’s years in West Texas enable her to capture the heat, the dust, the atmosphere of the setting. It’s a gritty, at times, ugly, story. But, her true strength lies in the character of Colly, a woman struggling with her past, her attempt to raise her grandson, and her attempt to find the truth.

Was this review helpful?

What a fantatic debut! I'm not at all surprised it won the Debut Dagger. The sense of place is just brilliant - the heat and the vastness of the Texas landscape is vividly brought to life. It's a deftly written plot with enough twists and turns to keep you guessing and a BRILLIANT slow-burn lead up to a really tense and dramatic finale.

I loved Colly as a central character and the relationship between her and Satchel, as well as that with her dead husband's family is beautifully done. I did guess the killer early on but, crucially, not their motivation which I thought was very clever and believable.

This felt like the first in a series, which I very much hope it might be! A cracking new addition to the world of crime fiction!

Was this review helpful?

The author's writing really pulls you in, with great descriptions that make everything feel alive without being too much. The characters are relatable and easy to like, even if their motives are a bit questionable. The mystery is cleverly plotted, giving you a handful of suspects to ponder over. I definitely suggest this book for anyone who loves a good mystery read.

Thank you Netgalley and Thomas & Mercer for allowing me to read this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Small town in West Texas. Everyone knows everyone- their secrets, their families, their most embarrassing moments. A young male is found dead- the skin of a hare's head clutched in his palm. Super weird, I'd say probably very unique calling card for a tiny Texas town! Willis Newland- slow, touched in the head- has been released from prison after 20 years for committing a murder against a young boy found in the same manner as the recent one. He must be the killer, right? Colly Newland, a retired detective and caretaker of her fragile seven year old grandchild, is called back home from Houston to assist on the case and get it off the ground running. In true crime fiction fashion, Colly is sent threats to back off- aren't they always? No disrespect toward anyone- it's just so overdone and obvious for this particular genre.
As a lifelong resident of a small Southern town, I felt right at home in this town and plot- aside from the gruesome murder. I liked the characters in this- they really reminded me of Karin Slaughter's beloved Will Trent characters, which I loved and delivered quite the dose of adrenaline. The plot moved along quickly, but was also slow at times. The culprit was quite obvious, but the book was still genuinely so fun to read. The parts with the snakes- terrifying, creepy, hate that. Altogether, really enjoyed reading this book. Thank you so much to the author and publisher for the eArc.

Was this review helpful?