4.5 -


Thank you Netgalley for providing me with this advance reader copy.

O Sinners! is a story told in three parts. We’re following Faruq, a young journalist processing the recent loss of his father, as he travels to redwood forest to live among a cult that goes by The Nameless led by Vietnam war veteran Odo. As the mysteries of The Nameless begin to unfold Faruq’s stay is extended as he learns more of the cults teachings and begins to grow closer to Odo himself. Alongside this story set in modern day, we’re also following a documentary script about The Nameless’ time in Texas and their clash with a fundamentalist church as well as following Odo’s service in the Vietnam war and the infantry he fought alongside.

Cuffy’s ability to weave these stories together seamlessly, while allowing each section to feel very much separate from the other was incredibly impressive. While a sharp change in story telling can sometimes pull me out of the plot, this did not occur during my time with this novel.

While I didn’t find this O Sinners! to truly be a thriller, there were often drawn out moments of uncomfortablity the reader is forced to sit and witness, which is a tactic in horror I always find myself enjoying.

An exploration of grief processing, how we grapple with the world and unknowns around us, longing for human connection, and overall desire for one’s life meaning. This story will leave you understanding and sympathizing how those who are lost after tragedy can fall into the togetherness that a group like The Nameless can provide.

I’ll be shocked if this isn’t one of the most talked about lit fic books of 2025.

Thank you Random House Publishing Group - Random House One World for the copy of O Sinners by Nicole Cuffy. I love books about cults, and I liked Faruq’s story, even though I didn’t really understand it all. I didn’t enjoy the Vietnam War story or the documentary transcripts because I wanted to know more about Faruq, and didn’t care about Odo, so much of the book didn’t catch my interest. If you want more of the backstory of the cult, you will love it though. I liked the descriptions of the cult and its members so that was a big plus. 3 stars

I genuinely can't stop thinking about this book. I've recommended it to everyone I know, saying "just WAIT until this comes out." The multiple perspectives are wholly unique from one another and unlike anything I've ever read. There is truly something waiting in Cuffy's writing for everyone.

3 stars.

Faruq Zaidi, a young journalist has recently lost his father, a devout Muslim; Faruq pretended to be observant for his father’s sake. He reacts to the death by investigating then becoming involved with a California cult called the nameless. The group is led by a Vietnam vet, Odo, and they follow the 18 Utterances as laid out by him.

The story is told from three perspectives: Faruq’s experiences with the nameless, Odo’s time in Vietnam alongside other Black soldiers and portions of a documentary that chronicles a clash between the nameless/Odo and a fundamentalist church in Texas.

The novel examines belonging and what we seek in those whom we admire, looking at Faruq’s relationships with both his father and Odo. The strongest parts of the book are those set in Vietnam; Cuffy does an excellent job with the futility of the fight and the ongoing, never ending, low level terror. Soldiers no sooner meet someone than he has died. Cuffy also uses an interesting conceit in the Vietnam section that I won’t spoil, but I quite enjoyed it.

This may not appeal to the wide masses, but if the description sounds good to you, give it a try.

O Sinners by Nicole Cuffy was a very intriguing and fascinating read. It follows two storylines and a documentary script. A Muslim journalist, Faruq, investigates a cult in the redwoods of California. Another being three men in the jungles of Viet Nam. The documentary script is about the cult. I found the characters very interesting and complex. Thank you to NetGalley for the electronic ARC.

O, Sinners! is the investigation and exploration of a chaotic cult. Combining elements of literary fiction and thriller, this story reads like a deeply layered, complex mystery. Overall, the reading experience was unique in that you could tell Cuffy made very intentional choices in establishing the context and the setting for this story.

I really was not sure what to expect going into this book but I overall enjoyed it. I’m fascinated with cults so I appreciated that aspect, and I really liked the buildup toward actually getting to the location. I also enjoyed the diversity of the characters and the relevant cultural aspects that played into the story as well.

"O Sinners!" is a captivating and thought-provoking novel that delves into themes of guilt, redemption, and the human condition. The author’s writing is rich and evocative, with vivid descriptions that create a powerful atmosphere. The characters are deeply complex, each struggling with their own moral dilemmas, which adds emotional depth to the story. The pacing is generally strong, with the plot unfolding at a steady, engaging pace. While some parts may feel heavy-handed, the overall narrative is compelling and thought-provoking. It’s a gripping read for fans of literary fiction, offering a raw and honest exploration of personal and spiritual conflict.

3.5 stars rounded up

O Sinners! is an interesting and winding look at religion, community, and family where a journalist travels to California to learn more about the nameless, who are very cult-like despite them claiming otherwise (insert that "y'all with the cult?" King of the Hill clip).

Faruq is an interesting character. He is traumatized from the death of his mother, and he is still living in the wake of the death of his father, with whom he had a very complicated relationship. A lot of Faruq's journey in this book is coming to terms with everything that happened with his parents. Though he doesn't get sucked in to the nameless, as Faruq spends time with them he is repeatedly forced to face the past that he is trying to avoid. I was scared for a minute that he was gonna join the cult, but he pulled through and left thank god.

Then there's Odo, the founder of the nameless. He's a Vietnam vet, and we get snippets of his past every other chapter in flashbacks. I wasn't a fan of the first two flashback chapters, but as I got further into the book my interest was piqued. I do think the author also managed to subtly slip in commentary of who tends to flock to these sort of new age religions (i.e., wealthy white people) and how some bigotry might seep its way in (see: Faruq's experience towards the end). The discussion of the similarities between the nameless' philosophy and those of other religions (Faruq immediately notices similarities to Islam), and even fairy tales put me in mind of discussions of white Wiccans appropriating deities and practices from religions like Hinduism. Also, in the wake of everything that Ruby Franke did, the use of the word "distortion" in this book was really interesting. I wonder if that was a coincidence or if Cuffy used that word as a purposeful reference.

I think one of my big hangups with this book is that there are a couple instances where Faruq catches the nameless in a lie, and those moments feel important, like they're going to come up again. I'm mainly thinking of Minh-An's religion, Faruq's belongings getting messed with, and the foals. The former especially is such an "aha!" moment that I thought Faruq would bring it up during one of his many verbal sparring matches with Odo. Instead, those things never get much consideration outside of the general "I think this cult is fucking with me" thoughts that run through the whole book. It made the ending feel more unsatisfying than it should've been for me.

There's also the fact that the reveal of Odo's former identity didn't really have much impact for me. Of the characters we're introduced to in the Vietnam flashbacks, I don't think we got much of a sense of Odo as he was then. It's possible that I missed something, but I can really only pick out one consistency between Odo of the past and the present. There just didn't feel like there was enough of a tangible through-line between these flashback and the present. When talking with Faruq in the present, Odo is very cryptic about his past, so I think I would have liked to see just a bit more to bridge that gap between the past and the present.

Overall, I liked this book and thought it was well-written, but it introduced a lot of different threads, and I don't think it fully tied some of the most important threads up by the end of the book.

An astonishingly expansive and ambitious novel, Nicole Cuffy masterfully weaves together three intricate storylines through flashbacks, first-person narratives, and creative use of transcripts, Instagram posts, and even music from a documentary. At its heart, the story revolves around Faruq, a highly respected journalist struggling to find his footing in the aftermath of his father’s death. Faruq attempts to channel his grief and focus his energy on investigating the enigmatic Nameless cult. His pursuit takes him deep into the Redwood Forest of California, where he begins a series of unsettling meetings with Odo, the cult’s infamous and magnetic leader.

Running parallel to Faruq’s narrative are two equally compelling storylines. One follows a group of soldiers in Vietnam, grappling with the physical and psychological tolls of war, as their paths intersect with the cult’s growing reach. The other storyline focuses on a tight-knit religious community in South Carolina determined to resist the colonization of their sacred land by the Nameless cult. These narratives converge in surprising ways, painting a rich tapestry of resistance, survival, and the human need for connection and meaning.

Cuffy’s ability to juggle these narratives is nothing short of extraordinary. Through the use of Instagram posts, transcripts, and other unconventional storytelling methods, she creates a vivid and immersive experience. The complex and deeply flawed characters breathe life into the novel’s exploration of grief, identity, purpose, and the dangerous allure of religion as an answer for all.

O Sinners! is a profound and daring exploration of the ways we cope with loss, seek purpose, and wrestle with the larger forces shaping our lives. With its intricate structure and bold storytelling, Cuffy delivers a novel that is both an emotional journey and a sharp commentary on contemporary issues. It is a story that lingers, asking questions about the nature of faith, the cost of devotion, and the price of redemption.

#randomhouse #osinners #nicolecuffy #cultfiction #literarythriller

Thank you Netgalley for this ARC of O Sinners! by Nicole Cuffy.

This was a really interesting book, I've never read anything like it. It essentially has three sections.

A modern day journalist goes to seek information about a cult in the Redwoods called the Nameless.

A charismatic Black soldier fighting in the deepest trenches of the Vietnam war.

A documentary of the cult clashing with a fundamentalist church in Texas.

All three tie together, and are endlessly fascinating, especially Faruq's interactions with Odo, the cult leader of the Nameless, who consistently challenges him. It was interesting to see how Odo's wretched time in Vietnam shaped him, as well as the conflict displayed in the documentary. Overall, this was a fresh read, full of intrigue and conflict, but also a lot of heart.

Oh man, this book ended up really hooking me. It's slow and tense and I was never sure what was going to happen next but I really adored the main character and was rooting for him. Would have loved to have had more insight into the cult and its motives, but understand that leaving it more vague lent to the larger story. I almost wish I hadn't ready this as an ARC because all I want to do is talk to people about this book and watch interviews with the author and get into her head about the story.! Overall really fantastic writing and storytelling, I think it's a book that will be worth re-reading.

Thanks for the ARC NetGalley!

I really enjoyed this book. I think I enjoyed the backstory a little more than I did the present day scenes. If you enjoy books about strange cults then you will enjoy this. It's a pleasant read. I love the cover too.

In the story we follow Faruq, a journalist who is writing a piece on a cult. He is lost after the death of his Muslim father and prior to that the death of his mother. Then we met the “The Nameless”, who is a former Vietnam vet and from here the story weaves his Vietnam experience with cult life. I loved how this was written in to seem like a documentary transcript.
What was supposed to be at least a 6-week experience to gather material for his journaling piece as now turned into months and while I enjoyed this, I was left wondering if the wolf was even real…
Thank you Penguin Random House and NetGalley for the arc. Even though I was confused at times, it was a great read.

Beautiful book spanning many years and viewpoints. I enjoyed reading and couldn’t wait for more. I’m looking forward to this book’s debut to follow the discussion on a few loose ends for me.

This book was really solid and I can see why people are already raving about it! O Sinners! follows three interwoven narratives—the journey of a group of Black soldiers in the Vietnam war, a cult-exposé documentary (in script form!!! <3 ), and the efforts of our narrator, Faruq, to learn the truth about this controversial group, "the nameless."
You will see that, unlike the synopsis, I tragically did not refer to these narratives as "seamlessly interwoven." I found that, in an effort to have endings and reveals line up, some of the narratives felt incredibly stretched out, while others were prolonged. While they all had their brights spots, I wouldn't say that I was equally interested in the storylines throughout the whole book.
I also think cult-curious readers (like myself) should adjust their expectations to fully receive this different story. O Sinners! is much more a book of self-discovery than conspiracy-uncovering. It wasn't quite what I expected, but I did really enjoy it and will definitely be looking for more from Nicole Cuffy in the future!
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an early copy in exchange for an honest review. <3

5/5 ⭐️ This was a hell of a great read! I really didn’t know what to expect because I didn’t read the synopsis so I went completely blind! The past and present chapters were phenomenal but I do have to say the past chapters were the best along with the recordings of old footage! The ending I was expecting but the execution of it was superb and psychological! And I’m a fan of psychological storytelling!

A fluidly written and surprisingly harrowing story of an investigative reporter who digs deep into the life of a new religious movement (NRM). Faruq Zaidi has just lost his strictly orthodox Muslim parents and is following up on a movement that just calls themselves the nameless (small n intentional) and their founder, Odo. The novel slips back and forth between the present (told from Zaidi's point of view), third-person recollections of Odo's time as a grunt in Vietnam, and the script from a documentary about the nameless' clash with fundamentalist Christians in Texas. Cuffy artfully tells each story so that there is no clear answer to the novel's most important questions: Is the nameless a cult? Is Odo a prophet, a charlatan, insane, or all three? Will Faruq enter into the nameless' enlightenment or resist being sucked into their delusions? Cuffy never answers the questions of truth or veracity, leaving it to the reader to decide - much like anyone who has ever encountered an NRM, or had a family member become part of one. The reader can almost feel their own grip on reality sliding away. Whether they allow that to happen or resist it with rationality mirrors the journey of Faruq, of Odo, and of all of us.

3 ⭐️

This book lost me at 22% and I didn’t feel interested in reading anymore. I understand there needed to be the backstory of how Odo became Odo, but I just felt meh about his backstory up to this point. Once the author got into the descriptions of him realizing he was actually being shot at, I just put the book down. His backstory just wasn’t connecting with me at all and I frankly just wanted to skip the “Before: 1969” chapter because I found Faruq far more interesting.

I love the premise of the book, I love books having to do with cults and how their followers end up there but I just don’t think this is the book for me! Maybe I’ll pick this up again in the future and give it another try.

"O Sinners!" is a compelling and well-crafted novel that grabbed my attention from start to finish. The writing is sharp and engaging, and the alternating chapters between different storylines add a layer of intrigue and variety that kept me hooked. One standout feature is the inclusion of a documentary script format, which is not only creative but adds depth to the narrative. The topic itself is fun to read about. The exploration of a cult is both fascinating and inventive, offering a fresh and creative perspective that makes the story stand out.

That said, my expectations may have been shaped by a misunderstanding of the genre. I found myself waiting for twists that never came, which left the ending feeling a bit anti-climactic. While the resolution was fitting in its own way, I couldn’t help but hope for a little more payoff.

Overall, "O Sinners!" is an enjoyable read with strong writing, unique storytelling elements, and a creative exploration of its topic.