Member Reviews

Yan and Tohru meet on their way to apply to the Spellbook Library. They become fast friends and go through the application process together. Adventure awaits!

I wasn't quite sure what to expect from this manga, but I ended up enjoying it a lot. From the very first chapter it subverted expectations and went in interesting directions. The characters are already showing their own distinct personalities, and the world shows a lot of promise.

In The Spellbook Library we can see the influence of the author's past in shoujo and seinen manga. The manga feels more unique and more nuanced in its storytelling than your typical shounen.

The only thing I liked less about this manga was that the pages sometimes felt a bit crowded between backgrounds, characters, sfx, and speech bubbles.

This book is perfect for people that love Ascendance of a Bookworm, The Ancient Magus' Bride and Negima!

Thank you Kodansha Comics and Uta Isaki for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Kodansha Comics for a free e-copy for an honest review.

This is a shonen manga by an author who has not much experience in the genre, but I couldn't tell. I enjoyed the art in this manga and it did not feel confusing during action scenes and sequences. The world and towns are revolving around these Spellbooks. Everyone has one for their job, they buy the books or borrow them from the Library. I believe it paves a good path for future volumes. There are dangerous and wild Spellbeasts, as well as useful and tame Spellbeasts.

The story follows our 3 MCs, Yan(former degenerate thug), Tohru(mysterious sheltered bookworm), and Emel(a princess).

Starting with Yan, at the beginning of the manga, Yan has a flashback to a time when he was being attacked by a Spellbeast. The special Sealing Unit, a group of 3 elite strangers, saved his life and sealed the Spellbeast attacking him. His life goal was now to meet them, and thank them. However, this goal is shortly (to us) achieved after 10 years, when Yan is admitted to the PR department at the Spellbook Library, he briefly meets the only remaining Elite member in the special sealing unit, the Captain.
Clearly dubious, the Captain seems very condescending and, is probably a bad guy, because he talks down to one of our MCs, Emel, who is the princess, and head of the PR department.
After completing his life goal, Yan is at somewhat of a loss, but he has come up with a new life goal, to join the Elite sealing unit.

Tohru bumps into Yan on his way to the Spellbook Library's entrance exam, vaguely we learn of his life, he was sheltered, and his only hobby was: Reading. It is his life goal to work at the Library, regardless of the department. Tohru is described as having a mysterious aura, by Emel, and she has been keeping an eye on him, as has Yan, because he has a mysterious necklace that seems to protect him with shields, and shock potential threats.
Before passing their exam, I enjoyed the dynamic forming between the two MCs. Yan, as a former lowlife has garnered a certain reputation in town, and is seen as such. He tells Tohru maybe they should split up because Yan is worried about Tohru's reputation now. Tohru declines the idea to separate, and would rather stick by his new friend who saved him earlier from some other thugs trying to mug his mysterious necklace.

After passing their exam, and being admitted to, only Yan's dismay, the PR department, Emel has full control of their activities now. Emel is obviously more than just a princess, but we don't get to see too much of that in Vol 1. At the end of this Volume, it ends on a bit of cliffhanger, with foreshadowing to some of Emel and Tohru's abilities and resolves.

The creatures are cute, well drawn, and the magic system holding the Spellbeasts in books is very cute. It reminds me of Mashle and Black Clover. I am looking forward to reading Vol. 2.


#TheSpellbookLibrary #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I was given a copy of this manga in exchange of my review

In short, this was a fun but forgettable read.

The story really focuses on action and there is not really a moment where it slow down. As a big ready, I was really intrigued by the concept of a magical library and I am still intrigued by this part of the world-building.

Unfortunately, the major fault is that this manga lacks some character development. The main characters are not really fleshed out. You will learn a few things about them but it will feel mostly superficial. I felt a big disconnected from the story because of this: anything good or bad can happen to them and I would feel the same way.

I might read a second volume to see if this improve but will not go beyond if not

Was this review helpful?

The Spellbook Library is a small bundle of intrigue, world building and secret powers all wrapped in one.

Two individuals, pulled together by sheer coincidence, find themselves on common ground, applying for the Spellbook Library. This is place of central significance in the magnificent world created by Uta Isaki. It is place where rare few employed with high standards and strict examination are trained to control and capture beasts. But getting in is only the first problem for our MMCs in the long list of problems they are about to face inside the library.

I loved the groundwork this comics laid for the series to come. What surprised me was the tough themes of prejudice and nepotism the story is set up to tackle in the coming instalments. I am eagerly waiting for the next instalments.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Kodansha Comics for providing a copy for review. All opinions are my own.

3.5/5 rounded down

The spellbook library is the first outing of Kodansha Comics' new "portal series" a set of English-first manga publishing first on Kodansha US.

The concept of this story is unique and quite fun. Yan and Tohru meet on their way to an employment exam to join the spellbook library. A library where all books hold magical creatures. This volume depicts their entrance exam and part of the first day on the job, ending on a cliffhanger.

Whilst unique, there were some pacing issues that made it hard to follow the story at times. Overall I am looking forward to seeing how the story will progress in future volumes.

Was this review helpful?

This manga had a really interesting concept about magic, libraries, and creatures. I loved how all the characters had goals surrounding the library where the books containing magical beasts are contained. I liked how there is some mystery around the motivations of the characters and their backgrounds. I want to know more.

Was this review helpful?

This is the exact kind of manga I love, goofy with the undertone/hints of something darker, characters with tragic back stories, and beautiful art. I loved this volume and I'm so excited for the next one!

Was this review helpful?

Yan was saved as a child and has dedicated his life to joining the Spellbook Library
Tohru is a soft tempered magical child who seems to be going with the flow of the world
They agree to work as a team to secure jobs with the Library and encounter a member of the royal family, the Princess, as their instructor
I would describe this as Attack on Titan with Books, so fun and mysterious!

Was this review helpful?

A Magical Journey into the Heart of Enchanted Libraries

The Spellbook Library by Uta Isaki takes readers in a world where magic and knowledge blend. The protagonist's discovery of an ancient library filled with spellbooks is captivating, and the world-building creates a vivid, enchanting atmosphere. The story balances action with quieter, introspective moments, allowing readers to connect with the characters, particularly the curious and determined protagonist. Isaki’s integration of magic into everyday life makes it feel alive, with spellbooks almost acting as characters with secrets of their own.

Though the first book leaves some questions for future stories, it offers enough closure to stand alone. Fans of magical realism and mysterious libraries will find this novel a delightful and immersive experience.

Was this review helpful?

This one was not for me. The pacing felt off. The artwork was not my favorite, there was too much line work that it looked blurry and made it hard to determine what was happening and that unfortunately made it hard to read. I was really excited to read this and was pretty let down.

Was this review helpful?

A fun and unique concept that’s overshadowed by some pacing issues. The story is about a group of people who enroll themselves to take tests in order to work at the spellbook library, where there’s multiple different kinds of jobs that all center around working with the books and the magical creatures that inhabit them. The art style is great and the main character Yan and Tohru seem likable enough but I wasn’t fully invested. I wouldn’t be against reading any other sequels but it’s not a top priority for me either.

Was this review helpful?

The Spellbook Library (1) is the first outing of Kodansha's new "portal series", a set of English-first manga they're publishing first on kodansha.us, written by the mangaka of Is Love the Answer?. With how much manga has exploded over the last 20+ years, it's fascinating that Kodansha has started a little niche of manga specifically made from Western audiences?

I didn't really get that feel from this volume at all-- it has a lot of things that are pretty standard in fantasy manga- a magic school/business, a test to get you there, great beasts, a main character with a mysterious aspect to him... a small girl with pigtails that's pretty high ranking and powerful...

In the end it didn't make too much impact on me personally but I think the concept is good and the execution is fine. It was fine!

Thank you to Kodansha and NetGalley for the eARC!

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

This is a fun and fast paced manga. The idea of the spellbooks is fantastic along with the library housing them. It is definitely not what I imagined when I first read the title. Tohru seems like an interesting character with hidden secrets and is my favourite. I am not quite sure about the princess yet or what her ambitions are. Yan is lacking some development in my opinion which I hope we will see in the coming volumes.

The artwork, while amazing, is incredibly chaotic in some places and makes it a bit hard to follow the story as the readability is not there.

Overall the plot is something fresh and exciting. I am looking forward to seeing where the story will end up.

Thank you to NetGalley and Kodansha Comics for the opportunity to review this manga.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for this e-ARC in exchange for an honest review!
3 stars

This is a fun manga. Monster defeating type stories are fun, though I'm not quite sure which angle this series will take given where the MCs end up. The main trio is really enjoyable, with Yan's original image vs the one he's going for, Tohru's mysteriousness, and the princess's predicament. Honestly, the princess is my favorite (even if her name slips my mind). I really like the dynamic around her and how she's really trying to prove herself. Definitely a series I'd like to check out more of!

Was this review helpful?

Yan and Tohru were both such good characters that were instantly endearing. A cute story with good art and much more of a plotline than I was expecting.

Was this review helpful?

Didn't like it all that much.

I wish the art was clearer and the flow of story a little more organised. I liked the concept but the story was a little messy from the start.

Thank you @netgalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Definitely continuing this!! Didn’t expect to like this as much as I did! The fantasy school type setting mixed with the magic work setting and royalty drew me in immediately. The magic system/test was so cool and the art style is gorgeous. I am definitely going to pick this series up! I would love to see this as an anime as well. This is an easy fan favorite. Also, it’s one of those effortlessly hilarious ones! There are some little parts that make you laugh and some scenes that make you unexpectedly laugh out loud (which I did). And it mixes the serious and funny very well! Definitely recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Volume one of The Spellbook Library focuses on setting the scene and the world and introducing the characters. Each of the characters seems to have a secret that will come into play in future volumes, and the concept is fun! Overall the art was good, although the writing could be improved.

Was this review helpful?

First I want to Thank NetGalley, the Author and the Publisher for this ARC.

So this one started a bit.... ¿weird?
I still don't know what to think of it. I looks and feels intriguing, but also a bit boring.
I do like the idea of magic trapped in books, it being a creature, beast, elemental or just plain magic, I would like to know more. To be honest, any manga that's got magical books in a magical library is going to attract my attention. And so does everything with Dragons.
It did remind me a bit "very little bit" of "To The Abandoned Sacred Beasts", although, that one is a LOT darker.
In the end, It leaves you with a lot of questions, enough to make you want to read vol.2 but also leave you wondering if vol.2 is going to be better.

Overall it was a fun read.

Was this review helpful?

This is Volume 1 in the series.

Yan had decided to join The Spellbook Library when he was sabed b the Sealing specialists. Tohru isn't particularly fussed about which department he is assigned to but he seems to have a secret that Yan hasn't yet figured out...

This was a quick read and at first the story seemed really similar to Black Clover. It is also quite fast-paced and action-packed.

Was this review helpful?