Member Reviews

(3.5) It's the beginning of summer vacation and before the start of high school. Amber, Nico, and their friends have a strong friend group, but when Amber and Nico confess their feelings for one another, they notice a new distance between them and their friends. First love has the young couple oblivious to those around them and it takes a shared dream for them to realize their part in the rift. Their dream also provides a sounding board for their relationship. High school has made the already shy Nico even quieter, making him wonder why someone as upbeat as Amber would be interested aside from the fact they grew up together.

This was a sweet story accompanied by nice illustrations, especially during the dream sequence. I do wish there had been a deeper look at especially Nico's character in particular as there is a lot of vagueness around him. We don't see too much of Amber and Nico's connection until the dream. That said, this might not be as big of an issue for the younger readers this book is geared toward.

Thanks to IDW Publishing | Top Shelf Productions and NetGalley for providing a free digital ACR of the book!

Was this review helpful?

2.75, not bad, was fun but it wasn't my cup of tea I thought ut woukd be more magical realism and while it did have a little of that vibe at some point it fekt a little pointless, but it wasn't bad.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for the arc in exchange for an honest review.

This book was just okay. It didn't feel like like it had a lot to say, and even though the book goes into a shared dream sequence I found myself bored. Which is wild considering how interesting a concept that could be in a graphic novel.

It's pretty low stakes, and I could see the getting picked up in the kid's section at the library.

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, I think that this story could have been more than it was.

While I enjoyed it overall, the pacing was uneven and it causes the message to get lost. It focuses to much on build up and the final resolution between the friend group feels rushed. It also took me a fair bit into the novel to get used to the art style, which is neither here nor there in terms of reviewing.

The fact that it seems like less than 50% of the book actually has to do with the "dreamover" puts me off from wanting to recommend it. 2.5/5 Stars

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley, Top Shelf Productions and IDW Publishing for this eArc.

3.5 stars

A lovely middle grade graphic novel that walks the line between slice of life and magic realism. The Dreamover explores first love, young friendships and growing up.

It follows Amber and Nico, and their friend group, as they prepare to start high school together. A new school is not the only change in their lives, after years of friendship and months crushing on each other, Amber and Nico are finally dating. They are happy and excited, but first love has its own challenges too.

The artwork is lovely. When the story turns from contemporary to magic realism, the illustrations of the dream landscapes and adventures are beautiful to see. The art style fits perfectly in this coming of age story.

It was a very sweet read. If you like middle grade stories, give this one a try.

Was this review helpful?

A relatable middle-grade (suitable for teens/younger YA audience too) read about life as it is. The artwork could have made more of an impact had it been more thoughtful at times, but it’s all good – it goes well with the text and the story is good.

Was this review helpful?

2.5 stars - This was just ok. I didn’t love the art style for the majority of the book, but that’s just personal preference. I really liked the art during the dreamscapes, though. I didn’t really understand the point and it didn’t feel like a realistic depiction of middle school dating/romance. I did enjoy a lot of the dialogue.

Was this review helpful?

Two best friends become more than friends, have a sleepover, can't wake up from their joint dream - but do they want to?

I honestly had a great time reading this Graphic Novel (read this in one sitting); the graphics itself is one of my favorite styles.

This is definitely one of those books that hit home because it's so relatable & nostalgic: the obsession & clinginess that comes with a first love, the neglecting of friends, and not prioritizing the correct things/people.
Although, as much as I understand this book had lessons to be learnt but I did wish for more of the 'dream world'.

Loved this experience, thank you NetGalley and IDW Publishing | Top Shelf Productions for this ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this arc.

Dreamover was a very cute middle grade graphic novel. I really like how you see Amber and Nico navigate having a relationship. The graphics were really pretty.

Overall, I enjoyed this book.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley and Top Shelf Comix for the ARC of this graphic novel.

This is such a cute wee graphic novel about a first middle school/high school romance. I really loved the nostalgic nod back to the early 2000’s technology and communication. Dani really captures the essence of a first love in the early stages of high school and how easily it is to become infatuated with a person to the point of accidentally forgetting everyone else around you.

Nico and Amber are the epitome of little emo boyfriend with high energy sunshine girlfriend. Such a cute, feel good story. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC for this graphic novel. I thought it was an interesting idea, we probably all went through something like this at some point growing up, and I think that I would be fine with my daughter reading it when she gets older. There isn't anything questionable, I think I expected more of the dreaming, to be honest. But it was a sweet story with a good message. Well done to Dani Diaz and team!

Was this review helpful?

2.5
This just did not land for me. I think it was meant to show the struggle of transitioning from middle school to high school while trying to maintain a romantic relationship, but...I'm not sure. It also shows the consequence of new love, and being so obsessed with your significant other, you ignore all of your friendships. It's pretty cliche, many other teen stories have done this exact concept before. The dream section of this graphic novel took up a little over half of the entire novel. The dream sequence was sort of cool, but it didn't make much sense. Yes, I know dreams in general aren't supposed to make a lot of sense, but this honestly made the story more confusing for no real reason. I don't know, this just felt bland to me. The art style was okay, it looked a bit amateurish but honestly, that did add some charm to it. I think with a little bit of plot revision the story could be made better.


Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!

Was this review helpful?

This magical realism ish graphic novel broaches the all too common high school phenomenon in which you get a significant other that you’re obsessed with and completely neglect your friendships. I’ve done it. I’ve gotten in friend fights over it just like Amber. I’ve been the friendship third wheel just like Drew. I’ve felt like I’ve held back my boyfriend’s life and happiness because I’m a sad girlie™️ just like Nico. The story definitely brought me back to high school and all the huge feelings teen me experienced.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced copy from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
This graphic novel has me lost and very confused. I’m going to have to dnf this one.

Was this review helpful?

In fact, this is a very sweet story about friendship, first love and life priorities. Good storyboard, good choice of colors. The author's drawing technique is pleasant. The story itself is warm, although quite naive, like all similar teenage novels.
Thanks IDW Publishing and NetGalley for e-copy.

Was this review helpful?

A cute illustration of young love taking over every aspect of your life and realizing that you have to maintain your other friendships...it's all about finding that balance.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an e-copy of this book. This was a totally adorable YA graphic novel. I adore books like this and it was a pleasant quick read about friendship and love.

Was this review helpful?

This was a short and sweet coming of age graphic novel about two long time bestfriends navigating the big leap between frienship and romance, the switch between middle school to high school and the evolution of their friend group not to mention some wacky stuff in between. This was cozy, nostalgic, and bittersweet. A good read for YA or anyone that wants a feel-good story. Thank you, NetGalley, for allowing me the opportunity to read read this!

Was this review helpful?

A very forgettable story about 2 middle school friends who decide to start dating each other and in the process start ignoring their other friends. Then they have a dream together? Somehow? And fight in the dream and then stop talking in real life for some reason, then without any effort or reasoning their friends randomly forgive them and everything is fine. I don't know, this was just some weird nonsense honestly.
Story: 2 stars
Art: 1 star

Was this review helpful?