Member Reviews

"Flesh" follows the story of István, a young man in Hungary whose life takes a dark turn after a series of uncontrollable events. After a tragic accident, István emigrates to London where he becomes a driver for the wealthy, navigating a series of encounters that shape his life. The novel explores themes of trauma, immigration, and the impact of strangers on one's life with a mix of sensitivity, observation, and tragedy. It delves into István's intimate moments with others, revealing the lasting effects of unresolved trauma in a constantly changing and sometimes violent Europe.

As I delved into this book, I initially questioned whether it was just another run-of-the-mill novel. However, I was pleasantly surprised by the level of detail provided, which forced me to pause and reflect. The story began on a strong note, but gradually lost momentum. As an immigrant myself, striving for a sense of normalcy in a foreign land, I found elements of the protagonist's journey relatable. Despite encountering setbacks along the way, the character's story felt authentic and genuine.

Although the narrative seemed to meander at times, I continued reading, intrigued by the protagonist's youthful perspective. The depiction of the settings, particularly Hungary and London, resonated with me due to my own experiences visiting these places.

While some readers may find the book challenging, I found the initial premise engaging. However, as the story progressed, it veered into the realm of everyday occurrences that are often beyond our control. Perhaps this tale would be better suited for an audiobook format.

Ultimately, reading preferences vary from person to person. I encourage you to give this book a chance and form your own judgment.

Thank you, Scribner for digital ARC copy. I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Interesting. A real chin stroker of a book. I read and enjoyed the author's Turbulence, so I thought I'd check out more of his work. This is a very different book. The thing is I'm not quite sure how much of that is on purpose.
Flesh is essentially a biographical book that follows its protagonist, Istvan, from age 15 to late middle age. It follows him very closely and yet feels strikingly distant. Mostly because Istvan is such a muted character. He barely speaks or expresses emotions. Most of his actions are reactions. Basically, he's the kind of person to whom life happens.
This life is described in leaps and bounds, occasionally skipping years, as he goes from one experience to another, with very pronounced ups and downs. And yet seldom if ever do you feel like you know him or get him or care about him at all.
The author uses a very spare style of narrative, which makes for a quick read, but feels a bit like a conversation with one-word answers. Most of Istvans are "Okay." Not just him, either.
I'm surprised the author didn't just name the novel Okay for how often he uses the word. And it would have bene rather accurate, too, since as a reading experience it was just okay. Thanks Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

Enigmatic and detached, this is a novel that chooses not to explore its main character, Izstvan, instead delivering a noncommittal central figure at the mercy of life forces. Sex occurs often, but almost always in loveless relationships, or one-sided ones in which love is mentioned but disbelieved. Feelings come as a surprise to Isztvan, as much as the curious events that shape his life - an affair, a death, incarceration, emigration, wealth and then a return to the working class. The narration is bald, as is the book’s ending.
What to make of this? It’s compelling enough, as narrative goes, yet also hollow and somehow flat. There’s melodrama and a certain amount of so what in the events. Why do the characters do X? Or go to Y? Or turn down Z? This feels sketchy, unresolved. As does Isztvan’s unsupplied inner world.
Perhaps this is the author’s style. He’s certainly won praise and awards, so maybe I’m missing something.

Was this review helpful?

A very literary tale of immigration and trauma. Szalay writes about a Hungarian teen named István. Istán is sort of a flat character in many ways, reporting on what he observes and we quickly are spun in to a story that cascades into tragedy. When István becomes involved with a neighbor woman, we are already alert to what could go wrong. Szalay takes us on a cross Europe tour as the teen becomes a young man and continues to be colored by the trauma of early life. This Booker prize runner up has done it again and I recommend to all that love a literary tale, a tale of immigration and a coming of age (which is too commonly painted as average).
#scribner #flesh #davidszalay

Was this review helpful?