Member Reviews

Amazing and varied recipes for delicious holiday baking. The recipes are all paired with photographs which I really appreciated, and the instructions are simple, clear, and easy to follow. The book also featured a nice variety of treats that depart from the standard Christmas cookies and pastries, such as custards and pies. I can’t wait to start baking the recipes for my friends and family!

Was this review helpful?

I cannot wait to bake my way through this book this December! The recipes seem easy to follow and the photos accompanying them are beautiful. Such a wide assortment of holiday treats, thank you to the Editors of Cider Mill Press for my net galley copy!

Was this review helpful?

4/5 ⭐️
Thanks to NetGalley and Cider Mill Press for an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

This is quite a collection of holiday dessert recipes! Mostly cookies, but there’s plenty of other goodies too. All the classics are here, but there’s enough unique recipes to tickle your fancy and get you excited about trying something new too. My only complaint is that the photos didn’t seem to perfectly match what the recipes told the reader to do do.

Was this review helpful?

I would definitely purchase this cookbook to add to my collection and I will be trying some of the recipes during my holiday baking this year!!
The photographs of the finished product are very high quality and give a very good idea of what your final product should look like!


There are a few gramatical issues that I found, also the inconsistency in units of measurement for ingredients is bothersome and could prove to be challenging in the kitchen, and I feel that some of the recipes should be in different categories but putting those small issues aside this is a very well designed and thought out cookbook.

Was this review helpful?

Well it is now November and we all cooking and baking for Christmas so thank you NetGalley this was downloaded intime to get ahead with Christmas baking.

Love the fact this is well illustrated and it has a good selection of festive bakes to choose from Chocolate crinkle cookies, fab youle log ( who doesnt make a yule log at this time) spent a few days ech year at the Dresden Christmas markets so was please to see lebkuchen which i have never made - will be this christmas.

Something for everyone and all levels of baking skills would make a great Christmas gift.

So recommended

Was this review helpful?

The Christmas Baking Cookbook is a fun cookbook that includes many unique recipes. I appreciated that this cookbook isn't simply regular Christmas recipes you can find on the internet. Though it has some classics, it includes many recipes from different cultures and places and twists on traditional recipes. For example, one of the recipes I immediately saved was gingerbread madelines and another was cranberry, orange, pistachio biscotti. These recipes will surely be a hit and this cookbook is a great resource for anyone who loves holiday baking or who is looking to expand their holiday baking offerings, like I am. One thing I missed in this book was personality; this will be different for every reader. For me, I wanted a lit bit of narrative about the recipes -- are there any keys to success? Anything the author learned making them? Or maybe a reason they're special or something they might symbolize? Or even an idea for how they've wrapped them or paired them for gift giving. If you're a person who wants just a cookbook with recipes and nothing else, this will be perfect for you. If you want just the facts this is for you. I would recommend this as a fantastic gift for any baker; anyone who loves to bake will surely use and enjoy this and it would be great paired with a nice baking tool.

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful cookbook! I loved the presentations, the form of the book. I will be enjoying some of these recipes this Christmas season.

Many thanks to Net Galley and Cider Mill Press for a copy of this cookbook in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book has it all: custards, pies, tarts, pastries, breads and breakfast treats, cakes, and cookies.
The recipes are written in an easy-to-follow way, but I wish the measurements were also given in grams, to save non-American readers from having to do the additional search.
The photos make the baked goods look super delicious and motivate you to try the recipes.

Was this review helpful?

This cookbook was promising but the recipes don't have photos of all the steps and some are particularly difficult to prepare if you don't already have experience

Furthermore, some recipes, although festive, are not strictly Christmas

I like that it has measurement and temperature conversion tables and some basic recipes at the end of the book

I'll try some of the recipes

Thanks to the author and publisher for making it available on NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

This is a pretty basic christmas baking cookbook, but I don't think this is a bad thing. It's a good go-to resource that keeps you from having to spend hours scrolling through Pinterest comparing recipes and websites congested with ads and pop-ups. I appreciate the global aspect to this book too, having sweets from around the world and not just traditionally European and American recipes you often see. I'm excited to try the Alfajores and the gingerbread muffins. I think it's a solid book to have on your shelf for the holiday baking season.

Was this review helpful?

A great cookbook! There are so many recipes I cannot wait to try. Love the pictures and the instructions seem clear

Was this review helpful?

This cookbook has every possible dessert you can think of, from cookies, to cakes, to desserts I hadn’t even heard of before. The pictures were stunning and the recipes were easy to follow. I highly recommend this cookbook for the holiday season or even as a gift.

Was this review helpful?

I begin planning out my Christmas baking starting in August or September each year, poring over cookbooks and seasonal baking magazines from years past, looking for new recipes or new twists on old recipes. I will always reach for a cookbook that has the words “Christmas” and Baking” in its title.

This cookbook contains plenty of new-to-me recipes and ideas but also plenty of old favorites. The instructions are relatively clear and the photography depicts some luscious creations. My only issue with this book is that there are no introductions or words of wisdom with each recipe. You get the title, the ingredients, and the instructions. This makes it a completely serviceable book but somewhat disappointing for a cookbook reader like me. Bakers who prefer a no-nonsense approach to cookbooks will definitely appreciate the stripped down character of this book. I will definitely buy it for the recipes.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t recall ever having to mop up drool before, but I certainly did while reading this amazing new book, The Christmas Baking Cookbook: ‘Tis the Season for 100+ Festive Treats from Cider Mill Press. It is absolutely GORGEOUS!

Some years I can be a bit of a Scrooge, but paging through this book makes that an impossibility. All I want to do is go into the kitchen and bake; there are 40 recipes for cookies alone! Often times baking books will just regurgitate recipes from the past that, while we all enjoy, we don’t need to see again. That is not the case in this book. I don’t think I have ever seen such a varied assortment of recipes, 90% of them new to me, 100% I want to get into the kitchen and bake.

The book is divided into six sections as follows:

Cookies
Cakes
Bread and Breakfast Treats
Pastries
Pies and Tarts
Custards and Other Decadent Confections

Each section features a wide variety of offerings, one more mouthwatering than the other. There is a corresponding photo for nearly every recipe, and directions that are clear and concise.

At the back of the book, there is a comprehensive conversion chart, as well as an index, something I used to expect in every cookbook, but that are, sadly, beginning to disappear. This index is well put together, and at least in my case, will be well used.

For the holiday season coming up, this could be your baking Bible. I can’t wait to dig in and get started. This would make a wonderful gift or hostess gift.

Many thanks to NetGalley and Cider Mill Press for providing me with an advanced digital copy in exchange for review.

Was this review helpful?

This is a wonderful cookbook that brings together an incredible variety of recipes from all corners of the culinary world! Some dishes are so unique that you rarely see them in any other cookbook, so it’s fantastic to have them all in one place. This is definitely a cookbook worth considering if you’re on the lookout for something comprehensive and eclectic.

The only downside is that the measurements are designed solely for American readers, which means that as a European, I need to convert them—an extra step that can sometimes lead to slight inaccuracies. Additionally—and this is just a thought—it would have been interesting if each recipe included a note about its origin or a bit of backstory. Learning about the cultural context or history behind a dish can really add to the cooking experience.

Otherwise, this is a very thorough cookbook, and I plan to try out plenty of recipes from it. After all, the holiday season is right around the corner! 😊

Thank you so much, NetGalley and Editors of Cider Mill Press, for this fantastic reading experience and for the ARC copy!

Was this review helpful?

This is a great cookbook perfect for the upcoming Christmas season! The photos showcase all the recipes well. The recipes are diverse and include both classic cookies and unique new recipes. There are recipes for Cookies,Cakes,Breads and Breakfast Treats,Pastries, Pies, Tarts and Custards. I think everyone could find a recipe they would like in this. The recipes that I'm most excited to try are Polvorones, Chocolate & Peppermint Cookies, Chocolate Crinkle Cookies, Peppermint Bars,Baumkuchen,Chocolate Souffle,Cinnamon Buns,Cinnamon Twists,Palmiers,Apple Pie, Cookies 'N' Cream Tart, Pumpkin Pie and Peppermint Meringues. Special Thank You to the Editors Of Cider Mill Press and NetGalley for allowing me to read a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for making this book available!

So many great choices of Christmas baking recipes! It includes cookies, muffins and cakes, gluten-free options, bread and breakfast options, pastries, pies and tarts from different cuisines along with glazes and fillings and conversion tables for metric system.
If you are looking for a new recipe (either easy or fancy) to incorporate in your holiday traditions or just want to try something new, look no further!
I love that there are pictures of the end results. And so excited to try all of the recipes! This book will for sure get a good use in my household. Happy Holiday Baking!

Was this review helpful?

beautifully laid out and a wide variety of cookies with very clear directions. a nice addition to the kitchen shelves for the holidays

Was this review helpful?

Awesome cook book, love making Christmas cookies so many good recipes classics of course and new to me to try-- if you like to bake especially cookies for the holidays definitely pick up a copy or buy one for a gift for that person in your life who loves to bake

Was this review helpful?

This cookbook is a delightful blend of tradition and creativity, offering a range of recipes that span from classic, nostalgic dishes to inventive modern takes. With its easy-to-follow instructions, it’s perfect for holiday enthusiasts and baking lovers alike. The stunning photography breathes life into each recipe, making the book as visually inspiring as it is practical. The cover alone invites readers to dive right into the kitchen, while the detailed, step-by-step guidance makes even ambitious recipes accessible. Whether you're preparing holiday treats or simply exploring new ideas, this cookbook combines nostalgia and innovation in a way that’s both heartwarming and fun. It’s a true gem for anyone looking to add festive joy and variety to their kitchen.

Was this review helpful?