I simply had to read this first as I was asked to review book 2 - Tis the season for secrets by NetGalley.

Such a cute festive story and as I say NEVER too early for a festive read even in an Indian summer.

This was a fun, quick read. Lyla a lover of Christmas (same here) she is the daughter of a retired Chief Executive of a toy company. She was supposed to recieve shares in this toy company but bah humbug her father leaves these to Mason Klaus - who surprise surprises loathes the festive season.

Things get worse as Mason cancels the companys Christmas party! but in another twist Lyla decides to spend the festive season with his family!! in another twist she is transported to a village called Yule.

All quite strange especially as she cannot stand Mason, so will this be the chance to get her shares back- well read this festive book magical and unusal.

What a great novel for Christmas. It’s a fun enemies to lovers romance set in a place called Yule . Great take on Santa clause. My only issue? I’m not keen on the cover !

What a fun take on Santa Claus and turning it into a whimsical, cozy, magical romance. I absolutely loved this and will be recommending it to everyone for the Christmas season!! Faked engagement, workplace enemies to lovers, forced proximity when she has to spend 12 days of Christmas up at (dare I say the North Pole) with Mr Klaus - this was so fun. I can't wait to get a physical copy in my hands and make videos about this for Christmas must-reads!

Thank you to NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for an honest review.

Thank you to NetGalley for giving me access to to this book.

Christmas in September? Yes. It is time.

This was such a meh and mid book. Like yes it was cute. Yes I felt feelings. Yes it was a cat in the book and I like cats. Like a lot. But it also lacked so much depth.

We have two people that “hate” each other at work and then WHAM the male character doesn’t have any other friends so he brings his coworker to Yule? Because… His name is Clause… And you know what Clauses do at Christmas? Yeah. And her last name… I thought it was a joke at first…

This is supposed to be an enemies to lovers with the fake dating trope and eh. Like why are you guys hating each other so much? Pretend like you like the person as the rest of us.

I don’t know, I feel like I’m rambling as I’m writing this. But I just feel kinda “eh” about it.

The ending was also just rushed and boring. Maybe that was the word I was trying to find. This was pretty boring.

Overall it was still cute and it was short, I do like that. I feel like they needed to work on their relationship to become friends before they start liking each other and all that. But it was cute. I’m ready for winter now (I’m really not).

First of all thank you for approving my request!

I thoroughly enjoyed this book! The authors writing style had me hooked throughout this book.

I didn't want it to end, a book I really couldn't put down.

What a precious Christmas novel! I loved the characters and the storyline. I cannot wait to read the next in the series!

I loved The Naughty and Nice Clause from the very beginning. The enemy to lover story between Lyla and Mason was a fun banter back and forth. The characters were perfect. The description of Yule brought the reader right into the heart of the fantasy town. I would recommend reading for a fun Holiday read.
Thank you to NetGalley , BooksGoSocial and Kate Callaghan for this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

A sweet fun Christmas story with good characters about A town called Yule anddifferent take on Santa Clause.
About finding the family connection you lost.
A easy read.
Voluntarily reviewed

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for this ARC!!

I LIVED this Christmas book!! I loved the magical feel of it! I loved the romance! I loved the setting of Yule! What a great book! I couldn’t put it down!! On to my next Yule book!!

I can't believe I missed out on “The Naughty or Nice Clause” when it first came out! Where was I? Now that I’ve finally read it, I can wholeheartedly say it was worth the wait.

The story follows Mason Klaus, a man estranged from his magical hometown of Yule. After leaving years ago to build his own life in the city, he’s forced to return home for the Christmas season following his father’s passing. To make matters more interesting, Mason asks his co-CEO and professional rival, Lyla Smurfit, to join him in Yule — despite the complications that bringing an outsider to this enchanted town might cause.

Lyla has never been particularly fond of Mason. Since the day he stepped into her family’s business, she’s viewed him as an insufferable opponent who constantly challenges her decisions. Yet, when Mason pleads for her to accompany him to Yule during this difficult time, she reluctantly agrees. What follows is a heartwarming journey where the festive magic of Yule, and the Christmas season itself, start to reveal the layers beneath their icy professional relationship. Can the season work its magic to bring these two closer?

I wish I’d discovered this book sooner! I’ve always been a fan of brooding, mysterious male characters whose cold exterior slowly melts when the right person enters their life. Mason fits this mold perfectly — he’s protective of Lyla, and while they often clash over business and personal choices, he is quick to forgive and is always looking out for her well-being.

One of the more profound aspects of the book is its exploration of familial responsibilities and how they can sometimes conflict with personal dreams. This theme is deeply relatable, as many readers will empathize with the challenge of balancing obligations to loved ones while staying true to their own ambitions.

And of course, there's something magical about Christmas-themed stories. They bring joy and anticipation for the holiday season, which is already the most wonderful time of the year. Add in a blossoming romance amid festive cheer and last-minute holiday chaos, and you’ve got a winning combination.

A big thank you to Kate Callaghan for bringing “The Naughty or Nice Clause” to NetGalley once again. I truly enjoyed diving into Mason and Lyla’s story and am excited to explore the next installment of the Village of Yule series.

If you love Christmas-themed stories, magical towns, fake engagements, and the enemies-to-lovers trope, then “The Naughty or Nice Clause” is a must-read. It will charm you from the very first page and leave you smiling all the way to the last, making you wish you could visit Yule yourself!

Lyla and Mason can't stand each other. But when Mason gets a call to go home to the North Pole he takes Lyla with him. Did I mention that Mason's last name is Klaus? Cute Christmas story.

This was a cute and fun holiday read with some
Magical realism which is my fav! Super cute cover, likeable characters, Christmas magic. Loved!

The Naughty or Nice Clause by Kate Callaghan is a stand-alone romantic comedy about Lyla and Mason, two coworkers who hate each other but end up getting tangled up in Christmas hijinks when Mason convinces Lyla to come home with him for Christmas. Lyla is headstrong and accident-prone and Mason is guarded and a closed-book making it difficult for the characters to know anything about each other but outward appearances. I absolutely loved the “world” building in this story, although it was just a town. It truly felt magical through the pages and I thoroughly enjoyed it. I couldn’t, however, relate to either main character and their interactions felt a bit stilted. Some of the situations they go through felt a bit rushed and didn’t flow as well with the rest of the story. I would still recommend this book if you wanted a light-hearted read with a magical backdrop and a happy ending. Thank you to BooksGoSocial for proving this for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.

Very cute holiday lit with some new twists. I loved the fact that there was diversity but it wasn't the focus -- it just was. Much more like life than when books usually attempt these things.

This book had everything I could ever want from a book in it! It was cozy, Christmasy, fantasy, romance with fake dating, forced proximity AND enemies to lovers all in one!!!! Perfect Holiday read!

I enjoyed reading the Naughty Or Nice Clause by Kate Callaghan. You will fall in love with all the characters. I received an ARC of this book courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions expressed in this review are my own and given freely. Happy Reading!

A fairly decent Christmas themed tale. More enemies to lovers than romance so if you like that trope you’d be into it. Found family, squabbling exes, strange magic. This book has a lot in one package. My only gripe would be the tiny amount of spice in the book was awkward and seemed forced rather than natural and romantic.

This was a really cute, quick read, Christmas romance. A simple, feel-good story for a little boost of holiday spirit.

As co-owners of a toy company, Lyla and Mason are total opposites that constantly clash in the workplace. When Mason unexpectedly asks Lyla for help when he needs to visit his family, she reluctantly agrees with no idea of what she's getting herself into.

With Lyla's dream of running the company on the line, she thinks helping with Mason's family is a way for everyone to get what they want. But she doesn't expect her heart to be at risk in the process.

The ending felt a bit rushed to me, but that also wasn't surprising for this type of story and being a fairly short book. Overall, a very enjoyable cozy holiday romance.

Read if you like:
- workplace rivals
- fake fiancée
- Christmas cheer
- happily ever after

**There may be some spoilers in this review**

The Naughty or Nice Clause is a delightful holiday romance that brings warmth, charm, and a touch of magic to the festive season. Kate Callaghan crafts a fun and engaging story with quirky characters, witty dialogue, and just the right amount of holiday cheer. The slow-burn romance between the leads is heartwarming, showing how right they can be for one another, and the unique twist on the Santa Claus legend adds an enchanting layer to the plot.

The characters were easily loveable and Callaghan's writing showed the family spirit between the Klauses and how they welcomed Lyla with open arms. However, I feel like the last couple of chapters were a little rushed and that their argument which resulted in her leaving was resolved a bit quick. I think we could have done with a bit of dual pov on seeing Mason and his family after Lyla had to leave Yule and seeing what they said to him to go get her back.

While some parts felt a bit predictable, it's a perfect cozy read to get you in the Christmas spirit!

Very cute Christmas story!
I think I’ll buy the book and read it again during the holiday season!
It really surprised me, I didn’t think it would be so good, I loved it!🤩
Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book!