The Naming of the Birds, Paraic O’Donnell’s sequel to The House of Vesper Sands, hooked me from the beginning. I will say, though, that Inspector Henry Cutter was a little too pedantic for my taste. Although I read almost all of his lengthy lectures, I really just wanted to tell him to get on with it.

Sergeant Gideon Bliss has only worked with Cutter for thirteen months, but even he can tell that his supervisor is upset about something. Cutter received a note that seemed to unnerve him, and the murders that followed seemed to be connected. The first victim was an older man, Sir Aneurine Considine, whose niece was was waiting to meet the police. But, Considine and subsequent victims were all killed in unusual ways. And, there were unusual messages left behind.

While Bliss despairs of his supervisor ever telling him what he’s thinking about the murder cases, Cutter hides his investigation from interfering officials. And, he sends Bliss to search through old records in archives, and, then, finally sends him to meet with Miss Octavia Hillingdon. Octavia is a journalist and newspaper owner, a shrewd researcher. She’s the one who connects the current murders with a fire twenty years earlier.

As I said, I was hooked on The Naming of the Birds because of my interest in characterss. Bliss and Octavia were fascinating, both orphans. Bliss failed when he studied to be a minister. Octavia was luckier in the “grandfather” who took her under his wing, and taught her to be a journalist.

But, I felt at times as if the author was trying to not only set the book in Victorian times, but write in flowery Victorian language. And, that became a little too much. O’Donnell’s message was clear. The conclusion of a case is not always in the name of justice. But, he took a little too long to get there.

The Naming of the Birds picks up where The House on Vesper Sands left off with another eerie case investigated by Inspector Cutter. The book begins in 1874 after a fire in an unnamed orphanage sends the surviving children to someplace even more isolated and grim. Although the author is intentionally vague about the specific horrors being perpetuated, it is almost worse because he allows you to imagine them yourself. 20 years later, the murders of several prominent men come to the attention of Scotland Yard. Inspector Cutter and his apprentice Sergeant Giedon Bliss are called to investigate and from the outset Cutter seems to know more about the case than he is saying. Eventually they enlist the help of journalist and researcher Olivia Hillingdon to dig into old records to discover the connection between these men and to a tragic asylum fire years ago. This is not a fast-paced read. It is written in a way that makes you want to read every word because the author has a fantastic way of perfectly describing thoughts and details and adding in sharp bits of sly humor where you aren’t expecting them. I thoroughly enjoyed being immersed in this dark story and hope that there will be more books with Cutter, Bliss, and Hillingdon to come. #TheNamingoftheBirds #NetGalley

This is a dark tale, and O’Donnell doesn’t shy away from showing the evil lurking in us. It’s a sequel to The House on Vesper Sands, which I have not read but has been on my TBR. It was fine, for me, as a stand-alone but I’m sure I would have gotten more out of it if I knew the history and backstory.

There’s an Inspector, Henry Cutter, and a Sergeant, Gideon Bliss, living in London and solving crimes in the 1840’s. There are a string of disturbing murders with a history that goes back decades. Bliss teams up with journalist Octavia Hillingdon to find out what is going on before there’s another victim.

Haunting and mysterious, at the core was the question of Justice and how it is served. Who is truly good and who is evil? Can the victim also be the perpetrator? At times almost theatrical in style, this slow paced thriller really came together at the end. To be honest, the middle was less thrilling to me and I considered not finishing it. But I’m really glad I stuck through it until the end. There was a slow build up and a thoughtful finale. Worth the read.

This book was a bit of a paradox. I loved some things and disliked others. Sometimes, it was both. The prose for instance. It was beautifully written, when it made sense. Sometimes it didn't and that pulled me out of the story. I didn't like that. Less would have been more.

I loved Nightingale. This book wouldn't have been worth reading without her. I think she was, by far, my favorite character. And the way she spoke was inspired.

The setting was beautiful and the characters were well written. However, they did not speak or behave in appropriate ways. The F Bombs and swearing for instance. I seriously dislike swearing. I can overlook some but I won't read a book if it's too graphic or common. In this case, there was a bit much for my liking and it was completely inappropriate for the time period. A double negative.

If plot holes were actual holes, this book would look like Swiss Cheese. A good mystery is supposed to answer most, if not all, major questions. Or at least provide enough information the reader can make a reasonably satisfying assumption. This book failed on both counts.

It was an enjoyable read but not a satisfying one. 2.5 stars rounded down. Okay, 3 stars because Nightingale.

Also, it was slow pacing. Exceedingly and unnecessarily so.

The Naming of the Birds is the second book by the author Paraic O'Donnell featuring the verbally bombastic Inspector Cutter and his awkward, timid Sergeant , Gideon Bliss. I loved the first book, The House on Vesper Sands and you should definitely get your hands on it as well if you missed it. In this second book, Cutter and Bliss become caught up in an investigation of a series of ritualistic slayings of some of the British Empire's most prominent elder citizens. The chilling case is doggedly pursued by Cutter, whose colorful dialogue is highly entertaining even if it does go on at some length at times. Sergeant Bliss whose mind is sharper than his reflexes more often than not, joins in as well as fearless newspaper reporter Octavia Hillingdon. The trio will unearth a shocking history of cruelty, brutality, depravity, and madness that define the very word Empire itself. The definition of Justice is perhaps more elusive.... I loved this book. The author has a wonderful gift for dialog and his characters truly come alive like flesh and blood from the page. I do occasionally want to tell Inspector Cutter to shut the hall up and felt as a reader that the story was bogged down in his Minolta at times. The conclusion of the book quite honestly left me stunned and awed by the power of storytelling. No are facts history book can do this, no matter how shocking and grim those facts are. Only powerful storytelling can knock the breath out of you in this way. Although the events of this book are fictional, they are True.

Love this book! It's suspenseful and will keep you hooked. I was not a fan of the repeat cover. There are at least two other book that have this same cover.

After a devastating fire a group of children are rehoused in a remote, secretive and abusive facility. Some time later, Inspector Cutter and (almost) Sergeant Bliss are working a very unusual case which seems to be related. Fans of gothic suspense and historical fiction might enjoy it.

This is the sequel to The House on Vesper Sands and It was just as good if not better. We are still following Inspector Cutter and Sergeant Bliss along with Octavia. In this book they are trying to solve the murders of prominent people that were involved in deaths of children in an asylum in 1872. The Naming of the Birds by Paraic O’Donnell. 4.5 stars

I enjoyed this book. It was perfect for the spooky season. It was a dark and twisted gothic read that I enjoyed very much. I thought the author did an amazing job through characters and story line. I look forward to reading more from O'Donnell. I will definitely be recommending this book to others.
Thank you Net Galley ARC

This was a very strange read. It was gothic and dark and some parts did not make sense. I think the writing was decent but the story itself was just weird and felt like it had no point. Not my type of book

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for this complimentary ARC in exchange for an honest review!!