Member Reviews

Thompson's art is still strong. Flowing dark lines and a limited color pallette of red, black, and white work while for memories and the story of the USA and China. The story of his family's poverty and Wisconsin's ginseng farms is interesting, but it ends so abruptly that I felt like it needed to develop the larger theme of how it relates to how Thompson sees himself now after the early success of his first graphic memoir.

Was this review helpful?

This is a good graphic memoir. The art is beautiful and it tells a compelling story. Thompson's experience as a child laborer and its effects on his life are worth noting: he lends a perspective that is somewhat uncommon, which is always valuable to read.

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge fan of Craig Thompson, so i was very excited to get this ARC of Ginseng Roots. If you are a fan of Thompson's previous work, this graphic memoir will be an excellent addition. However, even if you haven't read Blankets, you can read Ginseng Roots. The graphic memoir fill in some "gaps" from Blankets, exploring Thompson's family working ginseng fields in rural Wisconsin. You learn *a lot* about the history of ginseng, how it's farmed, the political and historical angles of it--a lot. However, it's all done alongside learning about Thompson's upbringing as he and his brother worked in the different aspects of the field and how his work there actually got him into comics in the first place. As in Thompson's previous work, the drawings are ink and shading. It would be a good fit for adults and some older teens. Thank you to the publishers and Net Galley for this ARC.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully detailed illustrations with plenty of character. There is a lot of history packed into this book and it can feel pretty dense. I tend to like graphic memoirs for the personal elements, but I did appreciate how much research and context went into this book. Felt like a bit of a time capsule, looking in on a very specific type of experience in rural America. A much needed reminder about what we take for for granted in terms of where our food comes from, who is growing it, and what it takes to make it all happen.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for my Advanced Reader's Copy.

I think my favorite part of this book was the drawing. Every page is just beautiful. I have never read Thompson's bio Blankets but I may now just to see the artwork. I also loved learning all about the production and usage of ginseng. I would absolutely recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

As someone that grew up in Marathon County and did ginseng work, not because I got paid but because we were voluntold by my father the pastor, this book hit a lot differently than I expected. Craig talks about growing up working in the ginseng fields to help get money for his family and for comics. Coming back home for a visit, he starts talking with family and locals about the changes in the work and how it has changed Wisconsin's environment throughout the last 50 years of mass commercial production. A brief history of Wisconsin's founding and trade through the cultivation of ginseng, and the changes in the political and environmental areas show that Wisconsin has adapted in the past, and how we need to adapt again. This book ends in a sudden but hopeful note, and really focuses on how we need to pay attention to the past in order to improve on the future. A worthwhile read.

Was this review helpful?

The artwork in this book is beautifully done. I love how the myths behind the ginseng root is illustrated. It really helps bring the story to life.

Was this review helpful?

Anyone who is familiar with Craig Thompson's previous work will know that he is an incredible artist and graphic designer. His attention to things like page layout and his mastery of the black and white format are again on full display here in Ginseng Roots, an autobiographical story that falls somewhere before Blankets in Thompson's life.

The first thing to know is that this is a pretty slow book. Thompson really digs into the details of monotonous summers spent weeding Ginseng Fields, while also delivering a bit of a history lesson on the plant itself. I feel that the book is best read in pieces (which is actually how he initially published it), so that you can digest it in smaller bits and take the time to really appreciate the artistry involved. Don't go into this looking for action or fast paced development, there are other books for that. Ginseng Roots is a lovely and quiet personal narrative about Thompson's youth in Wisconsin, and how his understanding of those experiences has changed as he grew up.

Was this review helpful?

Blankets is one of the first graphic novels I ever read, one of the first books that really hooked me on the genre, and graphic memoir in particular. I knew I had to read Ginseng Roots as soon as I saw it was coming.

Ginseng Roots follows Craig and his siblings to tell their story growing up in the Wisconsin ginseng farming industry. Another great graphic memoir that also taught me a lot about ginseng, Wisconsin, and farming in general. Craig Thompson has a beautiful way of telling his story that I've not experienced with other graphic memoir artists. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?