First of all, I absolutely love Noelle Ihli and everything she writes. Just like all her other books this was extremely well written and researched. However it did not read like a thriller. It read more like historical fiction. So while she is a talented and amazing writer, I personally could not get into this. I pushed through but did not love it.
Posted on Goodreads

Historical Fiction/Thriller about the Mountain Meadows Massacre in 1857 Utah. So well done. Such a horrific true story in our US history. Five stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

3 ⭐

Thank you netgalley for an Arc for an honest review. This book definitely taught me about an important part of history that I was unaware of, that I did like and appreciate. I did find it hard to connect with the story and hard to keep up with whose who and what was going on. I typically don't read true crime, so that may be why I was struggling with this story, so I would definitely give it a read.

Thank you to NetGalley and Dynamite Books for the ARC! While the premise intrigued me, I had a hard time connecting with the story and ended up not finishing it. I appreciate the opportunity to preview this title.

⭐️⭐️⭐️
Promising Premise, But Didn’t Fully Deliver

None Left to Tell started off strong with an intriguing setup and a lot of potential for a gripping thriller. Noelle West Ihli definitely created an eerie, suspenseful atmosphere that kept me curious about how it would all unfold. There were some tense moments and twists that caught my attention, and I appreciated the overall concept.

That said, the story didn’t quite live up to its potential. Some of the character development felt a little thin, and I had trouble fully connecting with the main cast. A few plot points were either predictable or wrapped up too conveniently, which took away some of the suspense. I kept waiting for it to really ramp up or surprise me, but it never quite got there.

It wasn’t a bad read—it just didn’t stand out as much as I hoped. Still, if you're in the mood for a quick, light thriller, it might be worth checking out.

I tried this twice and I just couldn’t get into it either times. It was a DNF for me, but someone else might enjoy it more.

🔪🖤 Book Review: None Left to Tell by Noelle West Ihli 🖤🔪

If you’re craving a dark, suspenseful thriller with twists that keep you guessing, None Left to Tell is a must-read! Noelle West Ihli crafts a chilling tale of secrets, lies, and the price of truth.

What it’s about:
When a close-knit group of friends is shattered by a shocking betrayal, Detective Jane is determined to uncover what really happened. As she digs deeper, long-buried secrets come to light, and everyone becomes a suspect. Can the truth set them free—or will it destroy them all?

Tropes You’ll Love:
🕵️‍♀️ Murder mystery
🔍 Small town secrets
🖤 Psychological thriller
⏳ Twists and turns
💥 Dark suspense

Perfect for fans of intense thrillers that keep your heart racing until the very last page.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

#NoneLeftToTell #NoelleWestIhli #ThrillerReads #PsychologicalThriller #MysteryBooks #Bookstagram #SuspenseReads #BookReview #DarkReads

4.5 ⭐ Just really really good. The narrative is weaved together so well and I cannot believe this event is not talked about more.

This was a brutal, haunting, heartbreaking story based on the despicable event of the Mountain Meadows Massacre. I wasn't aware of this and I was angry and sad and disgusted this could happen. Noelle West Ihli writes in such a beautiful yet tragic way. You can't help but feel the pain and fear and heartache of her characters. As a mother, this was very emotional to read and made me very grateful for the safety and health of my children. The list of people affected by this tragedy was shocking. Thank you to Noelle for writing such a beautiful book about such a difficult subject.

None Left to Tell had me hooked from the very first page. The tension is perfectly paced, the twists genuinely shocked me, and the characters felt real—flawed, layered, and hauntingly relatable. Just when I thought I had everything figured out, the story veered in a direction I never saw coming. This is the kind of thriller that lingers with you long after the final chapter. If you love a dark, smart, and gripping mystery, do yourself a favor and read this book. One of the best thrillers I’ve read all year!

This being my very first Noelle West Ihli book, I was caught off-guard by it being essentially a historical fiction novel. I had heard she was a great thriller writer, so that is what I was expecting. It took me a while to get into this one as it was not really a thriller at all. Instead it was a speculative fiction story about a true event that I had never heard about before: The Mountain Meadows Massacre. Once I finally settled into the fact that the book was not what I had expected, I started to enjoy the different POVs that were offered by three different females of different groups in the story. The most shocking thing to me was how vicious the Mormon's were in this event. My limited knowledge of modern day Mormonism is that it is a pretty peaceful religion. I was genuinely shocked to learn of such a violent period in the religion's history. I would recommend None Left to Tell to anyone who loves historical fiction based on factual events.

In her latest offering, Noelle West Ihli masterfully blurs the lines between historical fiction and thriller, delivering a narrative that is as heart-pounding as it is profoundly moving. While the initial pace might be a gentle current, trust that it builds to a torrent of thrilling moments and scenes that will undoubtedly bring you to tears.
A Tapestry of Courage and Hardship
Ihli sets her deeply researched narrative against the harrowing backdrop of the 1857 Mountain Meadows Massacre, introducing us to three unforgettable women whose paths intertwine amidst unimaginable adversity:
* Lucy, haunted by the echoes of past persecution, stands defiant. Ten years after anti-Mormon mobs drove her family from Illinois, rumors of their return to Utah ignite a fierce resolve within her to finally make a stand.
* Katrina, a young mother of four, embarks on the arduous journey west, unknowingly stepping into a maelstrom of chaos. Her unwavering determination to shield her family from peril pushes her to the absolute limits of her endurance.
* Sally, navigating the isolating reality of being a fourth wife, strives to find agency in a life not of her choosing. Yet, when her husband becomes entangled with a vengeful faction, Sally is forced to confront agonizing choices about her allegiances and, ultimately, her very survival.
Beyond the Pages: A Historical Reckoning
It's clear that Ihli poured her soul into this story. The meticulous attention to historical detail is remarkable, creating a vivid and unflinching portrayal of a tragic chapter in American history often overlooked. This isn't just a novel; it's a poignant exploration of resilience, loyalty, and the devastating consequences of prejudice.
While the story eases into its stride, the profound emotional depth and powerful themes quickly elevate it to a must-read. Noelle West Ihli has once again crafted a truly captivating novel—one that is both exceptionally special and deeply touching, leaving a lasting impression and encouraging vital reflection on a historical event that deserves broader recognition.
Have you ever read a book that made you want to learn more about the historical event it depicted?

Not like any book I have read.

I knew nothing about this event before reading the book and found it was depicted very respectfully. You can clearly tell how well researched the book is.

This isn’t a typical genre I read but I love Noelle W. Ihli. I decided to give it a go and I am glad that I did. It was a little difficult for me to get into at first but overall very happy with the read

Growing up Mormon, I had no idea about the Mountain Meadows Massacre. It wasn't until I was an adult that I found out the horrifying truth about what happened. This book was beautifully written, and I love the way that the true history was woven into the story of these brave characters. There was incredible character development, and even though the plot is heartbreaking, I think that everything wrapped up so beautifully in the end. Such a fantastic book with so much heart put into it. Definitely recommend this book to everyone, even if you aren't Mormon.

However, I think this should be a must-read for Mormons - history is important, and this is an entertaining (?) way of putting yourself in those ancestor's shoes.

Absolutely fantastic experience from start to finish. Everything exceeded my expectations — the quality, the service, and the overall attention to detail were top-notch. It’s clear that a lot of care and thought went into every aspect. I felt valued and appreciated throughout the entire process. Whether you’re new or returning, you can count on consistent excellence. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this to anyone looking for something truly reliable and worthwhile. Five stars well earned! I’m already looking forward to coming back again. Thanks for such a smooth and enjoyable experience. Keep up the amazing work!

Brace yourself—this thriller grabs hold and does not let go. Noelle W. Ihli crafts an intensely suspenseful, twisty narrative that keeps you guessing until the very end. The story unfolds with the discovery of multiple murder victims, each seemingly unconnected, but as the investigation deepens, dark secrets start surfacing. The tension builds masterfully, creating an atmosphere of unease with unreliable characters, shocking reveals, and chilling psychological elements. Ihli’s sharp writing style adds to the urgency, making this an unputdownable read. If you love thrillers that keep your pulse racing, None Left to Tell is a must-read!

Historical fiction fans will enjoy this account a little known story for many of us. In 1857, families crossing Utah in a wagon train were brutally massacred. Blamed for years on local native Americans, the Church of Latter Day Saints has more recently taken responsibility. The book uncovers local sentiment at the time for both the Mormon community and the natives tribes both forced from their homesteads to the dusty Utah plain. Bingham Young’s leadership is detailed including excerpts of his sermons.
At times it was difficult to keep the characters straight and I wasn’t sure where the story was going. I recommend the audiobook as there are many tearful accounts which are heart wrenching and I likes hearing the singing used throughout the storyline. I enjoyed learning about this event and recommend it to other fans of historical fiction.

I had a very hard time reading this book. I started and stopped many times. I really appreciate the opportunity to read this book for an honest review.
I just think it was not my style.

Fans of survival thrillers and psychological suspense will likely enjoy this gripping story based around true historical events. It did take me on and off due to my schedule to finish it, but the layers and story are life changing.

Overall, this one is an intense, emotionally fueled ride with just the right balance of character depth and high-stakes action while highlighting some very important history!

Thank you, Netgalley, for my ARC in exchange for my honest opinion.