If you’re looking for a book for either a reluctant reader or an adventure lover, this is the perfect pick! It’s action-packed, funny and full of mystery, and is also a quick read. The cliffhanger at the end will leave readers dying to read the next book. The fabulous series opener.

This book was a very cute middle grade book, and very much true to the authors style. It was great to read and the ending was great, can’t wait for the next one.

I picked this up on a whim and am so glad I did—it was such a fun read! Everly "Benny" Benedict is a fantastic character, and following her on this whirlwind adventure to solve riddles and uncover long-buried secrets was a total blast. The story has such a great mix of mystery, fantasy, and adventure that I couldn’t put it down.

Jen’s writing pulled me in immediately. I loved the charming characters, especially Benny and her friends, who felt so real and relatable. The setting of Greenport, Long Island, was so vivid—I could picture every detail, and it added so much to the magical feel of the story. The dual timeline was a nice touch, too, giving extra layers to the plot without ever feeling confusing.

Even though I loved it, I felt like the story ended too soon—I wanted more! It left me eager for the next book, and I’m thrilled that this is the start of a series. I can already tell I’ll be following Benny’s adventures for a long time.

This is perfect for readers who enjoy solving puzzles, going on exciting adventures, and a little touch of magic.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC in exchange for my honest opinion.

This book was SO fun! Once I got into it, I read most of it in one sitting. I was eager to figure out the riddles and mysteries alongside Benny and her friends, and I know my middle school students will as well. I really enjoyed the dual timeline as well as the fantastical elements of this book, the touches of fantasy were very enjoyable. My only complaint is that I now have to wait for book two, because WOW what a cliffhanger! I will absolutely be purchasing this for my school library and promoting it to my students.

This book was so much fun! Jen Calonita is my tween's favorite author and I know she's going to love this one just as much as her other titles. It has Inheritance Games vibes and readers will love solving the puzzles along with the characters. And that cliffhanger!! This isn't even out yet and I am anxiously awaiting part two!!

This is sure to be a hit for fans of The Inheritance Games. This was fast paced and I cannot wait for the next in the series!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an eARC.

The ending of “Isle of Ever” was cruel and abrupt. We were in the middle of the climax when I turned the page... and nothing but a little note that said the story would continue in book two.

The perfect book to cozy up with and read on a cold, rainy day. Benny is to inherit a beautiful estate, inn, and large sum of money–with a catch–if she can win the game her ancestor, Evelyn, created 200 years prior. Evelyn left her clues hidden around the estate and surrounding area that would uncover a mystery, lead to a secret island, and break a curse. Benny is challenged to learn to trust and make friends. With a lot at stake and a deadline looming, you will be biting your nails during this read!

I enjoyed Calonita's "Isle of Ever" for the suspenseful storyline and likable main character. While some of it was predictable, I think a child reading this would be invested in the mystery and very excited/proud if they discovered the truth before it was revealed. Looking forward to reading the next one!

I really love Jen’s writing and am thrilled that this is the start of a new series. I absolutely adored this book! It was fast-paced and so engaging that I finished it in a single day because I couldn’t wait to see what would happen next. The characters were both likable and charming, but even after finishing, I found myself wanting more from the story. I can’t wait for the next installment!

A time-travel focused MG novel that was, for me, too slow to be enjoyable. The novel is part of a series and the main thrust of the plot is not resolved here and instead kicked down the road to the second (or third?) book in the series. The various mysteries in this book aren't particularly interesting or hard to figure out and it feels like the book it just starting to get interesting when it suddenly stops. I'd be interested in knowing how the story ends (although I am pretty sure I can guess), but the necessary slog is honestly pretty off putting.

What an interesting start to a series! I cant wait to see where this goes in future installments. There is always time to read a good puzzle mystery and I can see many younger readers as well as older who want something fun to read picking this up once it's released. I look forward to giving this a reread then as I suspect my 3 star rating was just a result of my current mood reading not quite matching up with these vibes at the moment.

Calonita's book Isle of Ever is an exciting adventure with a puzzle to solve. Everly Benedict "Benny" is a character readers will cheer for as she attempts to solve a riddle left to her by her ancestor Evelyn. Can Benny trust the people she meets along the way? Will she find Evelyn's Island based on the clues she has? as Benny seeks answers, the reader will most surely think they have found the answers, but the plot is always one step ahead. This book is highly recommended for readers who seek a good riddle and adventure.

I really enjoy Jen’s writing. I am so happy that this is going to be a new series. I absolutely loved this book. It was fast-paced. I read it in a whole day because I wanted to know what was going to happen. The characters were likeable and charming. But I was wanting more from the story even after it ended. I cannot wait for the next one.

Thank you to NetGalley and SOURCEBOOKS Kids for this eARC in exchange for my honest review.

This was delightful and I am so glad I stumbled upon it! The first of a brand new magical series, i cannot wait to read the sequels!

Thank you to NetGalley for this eARC in exchange for my honest review.

Absolutely incredible! Gave me strong inheritance game vibes mixed with a historical mystery and pirate lore. I loved the setting of greenport, Long Island. Benny and her friends adventures are only just beginning!
Jen calonita has another winning series on her hands!

I really enjoyed the start of this series, it had that element that I enjoy from Jen Calonita and was enjoying the concept overall. It had that charm that I was looking for and left me wanting to read more in this world and characters. It works as a opening chapter and was glad I got to read this and worked in with the children’s fiction genre.