Member Reviews

Does dim rhaid aros yn hir cyn i’r holl gyffro ddechrau yn y nofel hon, y drydedd yn y gyfres ac mae Malkie a Steph yn ymchwilio i dân mewn warws chwisgi. Mae’r nofel yn rhoi darlun cyflawn i ni o’r ddau dditectif wrth iddynt ddefnyddio eu gwaith anodd i ddianc ac anghofio am drallod a phroblemau eu bywyd personol. Mae mentro i ymchwilio i dân ychydig fisoedd ar ôl colli ei fam mewn tân yn dod â hen hunllefau yn ôl i Malkie ond mae’n dal ati er mwyn ceisio datrys y dirgelwch diweddaraf. Mae Steph hefyd yn brwydro yn erbyn bwganod ei gorffennol ac yn ceisio rheoli ei theimladau wrth iddi geisio dygymod â’i bywyd personol. Roedd y cydweithio rhwng yr Heddlu a’r Gwasanaeth Tân yn ddiddorol ac fe wnes i fwynhau elfen ddynol y ditectifs gan ddangos fod gan bob un ohonom ein dirgelion ein hunain. Rwy’n edrych ymlaen at y pedwerydd yn y gyfres.

We don’t have to wait long for action in this novel, the third in the series and Malkie and Steph are investigating a fire in a whisky warehouse. The novel gives us the full picture of both detectives as they use their challenging work to escape and forget the tragedies and problems of their personal lives. Investigating a fire a few months after losing his mother in a fire brings back old nightmares for Malkie, but he keeps going in order to solve the latest mystery. Steph is also battling the horrors of her past and tries to control her feelings as she tries to cope with her personal life. The collaboration between the Police and the Fire Service was interesting and I enjoyed seeing the human side of the detectives proving we all have our own mysteries. I’m excited to read the next in the series!

Was this review helpful?

🔥A bit complex, tortured main characters😰

Normally I prefer murder mysteries focused more on solving the crime than on the lives of the detectives working the case. But Malkie and Steph, the two principal officers assigned to a messy case involving a warehouse fire with two casualties, have complex emotional issues that feature at some length in A Deadly Flame and added nice touches of drama to the story.

I found some of the jargon and procedural safety issues for the fire crew that responds to the blaze and loses a crew member a bit TMI, but the way the fire officials and police had to tiptoe around sharing case information was interesting. And there were some excellent surprises in the end. I would definitely read more in this series, for the cases and for the development of the thread about Malkie's mother's death and how Steph deals with her wretched family.

Thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for sharing a complimentary advance copy of the book; this is my voluntary and honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

Third book from Doug Sinclair I have read. Another Malkie McCulloch adventure of this complex DS. And another enjoyable quick read. Looking forward to book four. Thanks to Storm Publishing and NetGalley for the chance to ARC this book.

Was this review helpful?

2⭐️ Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for an advanced copy of A Deadly Flame.

Malkie and his partner are called to the scene of a building fire. They find a body in the building deceased and a firefighter also dies in the fire. During the investigation they find out that the fire may be covering up something more sinister.

I was not a fan of this book. This is the third book in a series and I did not read the previous two books. I did not enjoy the writing style and it was hard to connect to the characters. I just found the plot kind of boring and it did not grab my attention or interest.

Was this review helpful?

Another excellent book in the Malkie McCulloch series.
Malkie attends a fire in a whisky warehouse where there is a dead body, but the fire is too fierce for the firefighters to retrieve the body immediately. This is a really good police procedural, including the fire brigade investigation, and complicated relationships between the firefighters causing more issues. We also find out what is happening to Malkie's colleagues, friends and family, particularly Steph who is going through a hard time. It's very nice to meet these characters again, and I look forward to the next book.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first book of Doug's and it won't be my last, this was a ride from the start to the end, I got to the end and had to sit for a solid minute just string at it.

Was this review helpful?

A Deadly Flame is an exciting police procedural that will keep you guessing and on the edge of your seat right until the very end. All that you know is a whiskey distillery burned to the ground. A body, as yet unidentified, was found inside, and a young firefighter also died, possibly because of faulty equipment. DS Malkie McCulloch is heading up the investigation and must work alongside the fire investigators to discover how the fire started, was it intentional, was the unidentified person a murder victim or a casualty of the fire?

Fingers are pointed, information is withheld, suspects look guilty except for “gut feelings” which don’t count for much in court. Theories are formulated, discarded, brought forth again. It’s non-stop action and thrills.

In addition to the investigation, there is a lot going on in the lives of Malkie, his co-worker and good friend Steph, and others. Disturbing events that may impact their careers. A Deadly Flame is the third book in the DS Malkie McCulloch series. There is enough in this story to make it work as a standalone but you may want to go back and learn the main characters’ backstories.

Thanks to Storm Publishing for providing an advance copy of A Deadly Flame via NetGalley. It kept me glued to the page wondering what would happen next, guessing over and over who was guilty and who was not, and provided a very satisfying conclusion. I voluntarily leave this review; all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

A Deadly Flame
by Doug Sinclair
Pub Date: Oct 31 2024

A Deadly Flame is the third and latest installment of the DS Malkie McCulloch series written by author, Doug Sinclair. If you haven't read the first two books in the series it can be read as a stand-alone. I felt the plot was very good, it kept me hooked the entire time, it was full of twists and turns with lots of mystery and action. The characters were very complex, a very convincing story!

Synopsis: She opens the door to find two police officers waiting on her doorstep. Fear flashes through her. 'Can we come in?' they ask. 'It’s about your husband…'. Anna Galbraith's world shatters when she hears the devastating her husband’s whisky distillery has burned to the ground and a body has been found inside. But her husband wasn’t the only victim – a young firefighter perished too, leaving behind a grief-stricken fiancée only weeks away from their wedding day.

Many thanks to #ADeadlyFlame #NetGalley and #StormPublishing for providing me with an E-ARC of this 5 star book.

Was this review helpful?

The third book in the DS Malkie McCulloch series and the trials and tribulations of his life continue to haunt him. He and his colleagues DC Steph Lang and DC Lou Gooch are called out to a whisky warehouse fire where a body has been found. Whilst attending one of the fire officers collapses due to an issue with his breathing apparatus so there are now two incidents to deal with. Firstly was the arson and secondly had the apparatus being deliberately sabotaged? Well written and beautifully descriptive this is a compelling read.

Briefly, whilst Malkie and his team are looking into the case we discover that both Malkie and his best friend and colleague Steph have deep personal family issues which remain unresolved and keep rearing their ugly heads. Indeed Malkie is suddenly faced with two shocking reveals which are going to change his life forever.
Whilst both continue to deal with the fall out in their personal lives there is the matter of their investigation to resolve and when a further death is reported matters become urgent.

A gritty story set in Scotland and continues the theme of the maverick detective willing to bend the rules to achieve his purposes. Reading the first two books will give you the background but it is still an excellent read on its own. The plot is so good with great twists and turns and a heightened level of tension as the book progresses. A great read with some terrible acts that have tragic repercussions and what a shocker for Malkie! Loved it.

Was this review helpful?

Third book in the series and Malkie just goes from strength to strength.. He has to overcome quite a lot in this story as it is based around a warehouse fire where the Fire Officer is the same one who investigated the fire in his parents house which killed his mum. His partner is also going through her own crisis but together , they work well and help each other to get things done and overcome any difficulties. I love how Malkie goes on his gut instinct and how his boss whom he did his basic training with, allows him some leeway at times and pulls rank when necessary. The story may be read as a standalone, however I would encourage readers to check out the previous two first.

Thanks to Netgalley and Storm for the ARC to review

Was this review helpful?

A Deadly flame by Doug Sinclair is an exceptionally excellent book. The characters are well developed, and the story will grip you from the beginning. This is a fasted paced book which is full of mystery and suspense. The book is set in Scotland and is a story of DS Malkie McCulloch who is called to a fire in a distillery.
Malkie finds there are two fatality's one is a fire fighter and one a civilian. Malkie and his of sider Steph are thrown into this case which has plenty of twists and turns revenge, and the murder of another fire fighter as they work this case. Also, the story of both Malkie and Stephs lives and the issues they face in their personal lives add to the story. The banter and humour they both share solidify their partnership and keeps the readers in suspense until the end. This is the third book but can be read as a standalone book. “An awesome crime thriller. The story was a grabber for sure. It had me from the first chapter... The storyline is dark and twisted, while the characters are real and raw. The whole book is so professionally written that you feel your part of the action, and the ending has left me wanting more books by this author. Thanks to NetGalley and to the publishers of this book for giving me a free advance copy of the book to preview and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

A Deadly Flame, the third installment in Doug Sinclair’s DS Malkie McCulloch series, brings readers a gripping police procedural set against the dramatic Scottish backdrop. With thanks to NetGalley and Storm Publishing, I had the chance to dive into this thrilling novel ahead of its October 31, 2024 release.

When DS Malkie McCulloch is called to a devastating fire at a whisky distillery, the case quickly turns into a tangle of mystery and personal challenges. The flames not only reveal evidence of a sinister crime but also ignite dark memories for Malkie, who’s still haunted by the tragic house fire that claimed his mother’s life. As he works alongside his loyal partner, DC Stephanie Lang, Malkie must set aside his painful past to pursue justice while navigating the complexities of the case.

Sinclair’s ability to evoke the atmospheric Scottish setting—complete with rain-drenched landscapes and misty hills—adds a layer of intensity to the narrative, making the reader feel as though they are right there with Malkie and his team. The plot is beautifully crafted with twists and turns, each clue expertly placed to keep you guessing. Sinclair’s writing is sharp, and his characters are impressively nuanced; Malkie is a complex, relatable detective, balancing his vulnerabilities with his relentless pursuit of truth, and his rapport with Stephanie provides both humor and warmth to the story.

For fans of suspenseful, well-paced crime fiction, A Deadly Flame is a must-read. With its intriguing plot, richly developed characters, and emotional depth, this book cements Sinclair’s series as one of the best in contemporary Scottish crime thrillers.

Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

A good mystery with plenty of interesting characters. The insight into police a fire services helped give the book depth. Well paced, it draws you in and keeps you guessing.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for my copy of A Deadly Flame by Doug Sinclair.
Malkie, DS Malkie McCulloch is called to a fire in a distillery, where there are 2 fatalities, one of them a firefighter.
Is it arson? Malik e and the team will find out.
For me this book was more about Malkie and his detective constable Steph than about the case.
And it was so gloomy and long winded, I nearly didn’t finish it. In fact I skipped chapters, because it was so depressing.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the world of the book. Malkie and Steph are great central characters and the supporting cast are diverse and interesting. The mystery itself was intriguing. I am looking forward to reading more in this series.

Was this review helpful?

Scottish-noir, grief, grieving, depression, friends, friendship, arson, crime-thriller, suspense, series, investigations, investigators, police-detectives, Police Scotland, fire-service, survivor's guilt, PTSD, panic-attacks, family-drama, family-dynamics, family-history, spousal-abuse, group-dynamics, cruelty, psychological, psychopath, triggers, self-worth-issues, mental-health-issues, secrets, lies, wrenching, unputdownable, firefighters, angst, anger-issues, unpleasant-co-worker, murder, vengeance, justice*****

DS Malkie McCulloch is a seasoned detective with Police Scotland who acquired a full-blown case of PTSD eight months ago when his mother died and father seriously injured in a house fire.
His offsider/partner DC Steph Lang has self worth issues and more due to family issues. Each of them are substantially messed up by their newest case. The fire is not at a residence, but at a distillery, but there was a corpse and also a fireman died. This whole mess is unwoven one thread at a time and there is even suspicion that one of the fireman was the arsonist. The blasted story grabbed me and held on through supper and into the night!
I requested and received a free temporary EARC from Storm Publishing via NetGalley. Thank you!
#ADeadlyFlame #NetGalley #DSMalkieMcCullochBk3 Avail Oct 31, 2024

Was this review helpful?

DS MALKIE MCCULLOCH SERIES:
A DEADLY FLAME, #3 - Interesting story lines and good characters made this a difficult to put down read. The intensity of emotions and the effects of horrible happenings on the police and the firefighters in their daily lives added to the depth of this immersing story. Source: Netgalley. 5*

LAST TO DIE, #2 - I had to finish this entertaining story in one sitting. I found it predictable because this is how I would have written the story. Interesting and intriguing story lines blended with a variety of interesting characters wove an immersing tapestry of justice, revenge and murder. The last chapter was a perfect ending to this well written book. I enjoyed the fact that although this is the second book of a series, there was no rehashing of the first book, which I have not read; just an interesting story on its own. Source: Netgalley. 15*

Was this review helpful?

A Deadly Flame is the third and latest installment of the DS Malkie McCulloch series written by author, Doug Sinclair.
Set in Scotland, this one opens with the discovery of a body in a recent Whisky House fire. Haunted by the loss of his mother in a house fire, this case takes on special meaning and triggers for DS Malkie.
I enjoy Malkie's tough wit in this one, third is the series.
This can be read as a standalone, while reading the first two will give a little more flavor to Malkie.

Was this review helpful?

Quite a bit of angst in this one so if you are looking for a put-you-to-sleep read, better save this for another time. Having said that one of the reasons is that it keeps you reading long after bedtime.

Was this review helpful?

First and foremost, a huge THANK YOU to NetGalley, Storm Publishing, and author Doug Sinclair, for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review. Publication date is currently set for October 31, 2024.

A Deadly Flame is the third and latest instalment of the DS Malkie McCulloch series written by author, Doug Sinclair.

Full disclosure; I’ve not yet read the previous books in this series - but was drawn to this one by its title, the blurb, the cover, and - the setting - Scotland.

Scotland: known for its bagpipes, whiskey, imposing landscapes, its moderate and changeable weather, and, the Loch Ness monster; but, Scotland is also a uniquely atmospheric setting for crimes, detectives, and murder.

When Detective Sergeant Malcolm (‘Malkie’) McCulloch and his team are called out to investigate a suspicious warehouse fire, it sets off some serious triggers. Arriving on scene, the team come face to face with a fire that has engulfed the entire warehouse complex. Inside the building, huge stockpiles of whiskey – all stored in wooden barrels ageing gracefully are helping to feed the monstrous inferno.

We learn that Malkie lost his mum in a housefire, when the flame of a lit candle sitting on her bedroom window ledge caught the curtains and engulfed the whole house. Will Malkie be able to put aside his own nightmarish memories of that fateful night and the staggering amount of grief and responsibility he still feels over losing his mum to work this case?

🔥Flaming Yays🔥

🔥Well illustrated characters. Malkie McCullough is a complicated man but an excellent detective. He’s often referred to as being in his ‘Columbo’ pose when he’s mulling something over about the case. And for those of you who are familiar with that reference will immediately relate to DS McCullough. The working relationship between DS McCullough and his partner, DC Stephanie Lang is one of the many things this reader enjoyed about the book. It’s a pairing where there is a deep respect for each other’s strengths and abilities despite the differing age gap. And, as always, things go better with humour, and the pair have their own special type of banter which solidifies their partnership.

She [Lang] turned a page. ‘Graham Cormack. The big, dishy one.’
[Malkie] ‘Can’t say I noticed, but carry on.’

🔥The plot. But first, let me fast forward to the Author’s Note at the end of the book: As I said about books one and two, I never set out to write police procedurals in the traditional sense. I want to write books about the impacts of terrible acts inflicted by ordinary but desperate human beings on others.

👏Kudos, Mr Sinclair, for you have executed that brief superbly.

As in any good police murder mystery there are several story lines which intermingle nicely – think of a jigsaw puzzle – there is only one right combination of pieces to make the whole picture, and Malkie and his team must join the pieces correctly to solve the mystery.

🔥The writing. Sinclair’s writing is succinct and concise, with vivid descriptions of the Scottish landscape and his depiction of the fire and those that fought to contain it was clearly perceptible. The plot is peppered with twists and turns, and the reader is kept in a state of high suspense throughout.

Safe to say this reader is a #teamMalkie convert now.

With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Storm Publishing for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. The publication date is currently set for October 31, 2024.

Was this review helpful?