Member Reviews

A fantastic biography of Randy Shilts, who wrote "And the Band Played On" - one of the most important books about the AIDS Crisis. I have read that book as well as "Mayor of Castro Street" about Harvey Milk and many articles he wrote for The Advocate, Bay Area Reporter,, etc. We learn about Randy as a son, brother, friend, employee, journalist, and lover. He was definitely a complicated person who could be prickly and yet tender towards friends and his dog. He had difficulty getting coverage for his book in the NY Times, so the publishers suggested the homophobic NY Post instead and pushed to Patient Zero myth that ended up demonizing one man (a French-Canadian Flight attendant) as the super-spreader "Typhoid Mary" of AIDS. This has been completely disproven (I saw a compelling and poignant documentary about him a few years ago that debunked this myth). As Randy reported on the push to close the bathhouses in San Francisco, just like Larry Kramer in NYC, he was villainized for this view, although in Randy's case he claims he was just reporting not expressing an opinion. The writing in this book is very good and kept my interest. I highly recommend this book.

Thank you to Netgalley and IPG | Chicago Review Press for an ARC and I voluntarily left this review.

Was this review helpful?

I was a little confused by the fact this was first published in 1975. By my calculations Randy Shilts was only 24 years old.

In the 1980s Rolling Stone did a series of articles about HIV/AIDS and it was enlightening. When I finally got around to reading And The Band Played On in 2019 I was riveted and angry at how the government ignored the evidence and medical researchers acted irresponsibly, seemingly not caring for the patients but more from what they could gain personally.

When the Band Played On is a biography of Randy Shilts and while I learned more of what he did, how he became a prominent gay journalist I don't feel I really learned more about the man. I feel that with his death we lost a great writer and wonder what other things he would have explored and exposed.

Thank you to Netgalley and IPG - Chicago Review Press for providing me with a digital copy.

Was this review helpful?

The comprehensive biography of journalists Randy Shilts. The author did not pull any punches presenting Randy warts and all. Reading this book brought back memories of the AIDs crisis, homophobia that existed and the governments failure to deal.with the AIDS crisis. I did not realize how much hate Randy dealt with from the gay community for his reporting and the call to close the bathhouse. I all found the reporting of patient zero fascinating.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley for this e-copy of When the Band Played on by Michael G.Lee in exchange for a honest review..I remember in my early 20s reading Randy’s book “And the Band Played On “ which was an eye opener to a heterosexual person like me and a glimpse into the gay community and how AIDS was affecting its members.I learned so much from that book so I was very interested to read a book about its author, .Randy Shilts. Randy was a complicated and at sometimes troubled person who through his books helped gays find a place at the table.He helped educate the world about AIDS, about the prominent politician, Harvey Milk and helped change laws for gay servicemen and women.This book portrayed Randy as a honest human being who battled his own demons and who wasn’t perfect but tried to make the world a better place for the homosexual community.Very well researched.

Was this review helpful?

This book is an interesting summary of the life and works of Shilts. It focuses on his activism, writing, and his life surrounding all of that. While it was interesting, there were definitely moments where I questioned the accuracy of what I was reading, considering everything seemed to be from a white, cis, male perspective (such as when the author claimed trans women sex workers were treated well in a certain jail). I think believe this book is an important read, and I accept the fact it was written a while ago, so I don’t expect it to be perfect. For when it was written, it does a good job of showing the struggles of the times for those involved in Shilts’ life. Thank you NetGalley for the arc.

Was this review helpful?

"When the Band Played On" tells the story of the journalist behind one of the most influential non-fiction works of modern times.

Randy Shilts "And the Band Played On" became one of the first fact based source that exposed the masses to the AIDS crisis. He deftly personalized the science and the politics and the struggle.

But he remained a mystery, which is typical for most journalists, but now long after his death readers are getting a chance to meet the Shilts behind the book. What influenced his life, fed his passion and led him to become the voice he did for the gay community and beyond.

This book intricately weaves his personal diaries and interviews within the news of the time to help see the progression of his passions. We meet the human and the journalist.

It's a well deserved profile of a groundbreaking man and his legacy.

Was this review helpful?

I learned a lot about Randy Shilts in this biography, I really didn’t know anything about Randy Shilts and was glad I got to read this. It was great to read the interviews and how the narrative worked overall. Michael G. Lee has a strong writing style and was able to bring Randy to life in this and can’t wait for more from Michael G. Lee.

Was this review helpful?