Member Reviews

A wonderful collection of some of the finest fantasy and science fi short fiction. The authors represented stretch across the 20th Century and to the present day. These stories are well written and very enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

Very good quality of short stories, but I usually prefer the Year's Best Horror which is edited by Ellen Datlow, and I also like the Year's Best Dark Fantasy and Horror, which is often co-edited with Paula Guran.

Was this review helpful?

What can one possibly say about something titled "The Very Best of..." when it's covering stories from what is arguably the very best magazine publishing fantasy and science fiction stories? Well...you know it's probably pretty darned good!

There have been over thirty "Best of Fantasy and Science Fiction" anthologies, collecting years and decades worth of stories published between the pages of the magazine and there's even been a previous "The Very Best of" anthology. That's a lot of history of a lot of very good fiction and a daunting task for editor Gordon van Gelder to select the very cream of the crop.

The book opens with a story from 1952, "The Third Level," by Jack Finney. The story manages to reflect the thoughts and fears of its time, while remaining timeless (perhaps because our thoughts and fears don't change so much, after all?).

I won't go through, story by story - there were a few that didn't really have much impact on me (it's the same when I read this, or any other, magazine) - such as C.M. Kornbluth's "The Cosmic Expense Account" and Robert Heinlein's "'--All You Zombies--'" and "Attack of the Giant Baby" by Kit Reed.

But more often than not I was impressed by the stories ...only a small handful that I remember reading back in the late 1970's/early 1980's when I subscribed to the magazine: "Jeffty is Five" by Harlan Ellison is such a story, as is George Alec Effinger's "The Aliens Who Knew, I Mean, <em>Everything</em>." Ellison's work was always cutting edge and 'Jeffty' is one of the classics that continues to stand the test of time. Effinger is someone who's work I saw a lot of at the time but who doesn't have the following that he should. This is a great way to introduce him to new readers.

I stopped reading F&amp;SF in the 1980's - not because I wasn't interested, but ...well...life happens sometimes. My point, though, is that the writers here that appeared in the magazine after the 1980's are authors who are 'new' to me (though I've recently become acquainted with those still publishing). I enjoyed Charles de Lint's "The Bone Woman" and Maureen F. McHugh's "The Lincoln Train" - an alternative history story.

"Maneki Neko" is by Bruce Sterling - one of my favorite 'new' authors (though he's pretty established now) and this story shows his deft hand. He's known as one of the leaders of the 'cyber-punk' category and here he combines his noted cyberpunk skills with humor. A fun story, and it's these fun stories that always made me appreciate <em>Fantasy and Science Fiction</em>.

As I wrote at the top, there's a lot of good fiction here, since it's the best of the best, and it's difficult to choose an absolute favorite, but Paolo Bacigalupi's "The People of Sand and Slag" would be my selection for most powerful, moving story.

This collection contains the following:

Foreword - Gordon van Gelder
Introduction - Michael Dirda
"The Third Level" - Jack Finney
"The Cosmic Expense Account" - C. M. Kornbluth
"The Country of the Kind" - Damon Knight
"The Anything Box" = Zenna Henderson
"The Prize of Peril" - Robert Sheckley
"'--All You Zombies--'" - Robert A. Heinlein
"A Kind of Artistry" - Brian W. Aldiss
"Green Magic" - Jack Vance
:Narrow Valley" - R.A. Lafferty
"Sundance" - Robert Silverberg
"The Attack of the Giant Baby" - Kit Reed
"The Hundredth Dove" - Jane Yolen
"Jeffty is Five" - Harlan Ellison
"Salvador" - Lucius Shepard
"The Aliens Who Knew, I Mean, <em>Everything</em>" - George Alec Effinger
"Rat" - James Patrick Kelly
"The Friendship Light" - Gene Wolfe
"The Bone Woman" - Charles de Lint
"Maneki Neko" - Bruce Sterling
"Winemaster" - Robert Reed
"Suicide Coast" - M. John Harrison
"Have Not Have" - Geoff Ryman
"The People of Sand and Slag" - Paolo Bacigalupi
"Echo" - Elizabeth Hand
"<em>The New York Times</em> at Special Bargain Rates" - Stephen King
"The Paper Meagerie" - Ken Liu

Looking for a good book? <em>The Very Best of Fantasy and Science Fiction, Volume 2</em>, edited by Gordon van Gelder is a book that can't help but appeal to anyone who already loves the genre and is a great way to introduce great science fiction and fantasy to new readers.

I received a digital copy of this book from the publisher, through Netgalley, in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Chock full of stories! I like how they put the year of publication with the story title. Too many just have it in one place, but they do the introduction and the year right there before you read the story - very convenient!

I liked a lot of the stories, and some fell flat. I just skipped through the ones I didn't like. If you like Science Fiction & Fantasy as a genre, this book is worth it!

Was this review helpful?

This anthology has been a pleasure to read. It compiles some of the best stories published in Fantasy & Science Fiction magazine during over 65 years and the result is a well-balanced and highly enjoyable mixture of old and more recent stories; of classic and less known tales (although all of them are by really well-known authors); of stories I had already read and of stories which were new to me; of deep, dark, sad, light and funny works.
I didn’t care for all the stories, of course, but I didn’t dislike a single one, and most of them were notable and even excellent. Among those new to me my standouts were those by George Alec Effinger, Stephen King and C. M. Kornbluth; and among my re-reads, those by Robert Sheckley, Harlan Ellison, and “The People of Sand and Slang”, by Paolo Bacigalupi, my absolute personal favorite.
Highly recommended for any short fiction lover and a must-read for SF/fantasy fans.
I will definitely include it in my next Recommending Reading post.

Was this review helpful?