I read this entire book in 9 hours. I was so worried to read this next one because the last one was not as good as the others. Let me tell you, #5 is hilarious, witty, laugh out loud funny, heart racing, amazingness. Finlay, Nick and Vero are all back and better than ever.

I hope this series never ends. Elle, are you writing #6?

Finlay Donovan appears in this fifth book in the series as a frazzled single mother of two. Donovan has a bad habit of encouraging dead bodies that are involved with dangerous people. This time, a body has been discovered in her neighbor's backyard and of course she is drawn into the mystery. Elle Cosimano has developed Donovan into a character that has agency and is no longer simply reacting to her circumstances. In this volume, the supporting characters are developed more fully. I look forward to the next one!

Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave is the fifth book in the series by Elle Cosimano. I must say I enjoyed it a lot more than the previous book, which included altercations with a Russia mob. In this book Finlay and her nanny, Vero, are involved with a crime that entangles their neighbor, Mrs Haggerty and the plot seemed to be more down to earth and, dare I say, realistic.

I enjoyed the characters a lot, the humor was well-done, and the book was entertaining. However, the introduction of new characters in the last couple chapters was jarring and the plot lost some of its momentum. The ending was disjointed and there were lots of explanations that weren’t presented very well. Finlay’s relationship with Nick is also a problem and seems to be increasingly dysfunctional and aggravating.

But, I still like this book much more than the previous one, except the author had to toss in a cliffhanger. I’m definitely not a fan of this kind of ending. It feels like a sneaky way to rope in a reader for the next book. I’m just not sure it will work with me. NetGalley provided an advance reader copy.

Thanks St. Martin's Press | Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the ARC!

Synopsis -

Finlay and her nanny Vero have yet another problem on their hands. This time it’s in the form of their elderly curmudgeon of a neighbour, Mrs Haggerty. After the police discovered a body in her backyard, she needs a place to stay once she is deemed not a potential suspect. Having had enough on their plates the past few months, the last thing Finlay needs is getting tangled up in another murder case.

Review -

Just like all the previous books, Finlay and Vero find themselves in impossible situations and we all know by now how they have a knack of attracting trouble.

Cosimano excels at building up a serious murder mystery at the heart of the plot while equally balancing it with laugh out loud humour and cheeky grin inducing scenes. There is a parallel romantic thread with Finlay’s boyfriend, policeman Nick, which spices up and adds charm to the narrative.

Mrs Haggerty brings her own sass and kickass personality into the storyline and this combined with Finlay and Vero’s shenanigans - we have an amusing and enjoyable cozy mystery on our hands.

I loved how the book addressed an important subject matter at its core and although the measures the characters undertook were extreme, it was a wakeup call that will definitely help raise awareness concerning the issue.

Overall a fun-filled ride that will help you forget all your problems for a while, while you worry about Finlay’s!

This was another engaging and humourous Finlay Donovan story that had me laughing all the way through. I love the rapport between Finlay and Vero so much. That really is the heart of these stories. What trouble will they get into (and get out of) today?

Thank you to the publisher for the advance copy.

She does it again folks! The Finlay Donovan series is the best. I fell in love with Mrs. Haggerty this book! The banter was amazing as usual! Top read of 2025 so far!

I enjoyed this book much better than the previous one! I love following Finlay and Vero's crazy adventures. I don't think that Elle Cosimano misses with this series at all. I look forward to every book and power through them.

I usually prefer the audiobooks, but I physically read the last two due to getting the ARCs from Netgalley and I'm still enjoying it just as much. Might give the whole series a re-listen!

Thanks again Netgalley, St Martins Press and Minotaur books!

I have enjoyed the previous books in the Finlay Donovan series, so I was very excited about the opportunity to read about Finlay’s latest adventure.

This is a series where the books need to be read in order to fully appreciate the larger story arc. The plot of this book begins not too long after the events of the previous book. Finlay is hoping for a respite from the murders, but no such luck. Not only does she have to play host to the elderly neighborhood busybody, but she also has to prove that her ex-husband didn’t commit the aforementioned murder.

Fans of the series will appreciate the return of beloved characters and light mystery. There’s enough danger to create tension but it’s never enough to provoke anxiety worrying whether the characters are going to survive. For the most part, only baddies fail to survive the turmoil that Finlay Donovan can’t seem to avoid attracting, but there’s always a tiny bit of concern that the plot is going to veer away from cozy and right into gritty territory.

I would absolutely recommend Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave. I listened to all the previous books in the series, so I wondered whether reading the book would lose some of the frenzied magic of the audiobook. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that reading the book without all the fun voices was just as enjoyable. I’m already looking forward to the next book in the series– like the previous books, something happened at the end to set up the plot of the next book. I can’t wait!





I received a digital ARC of this book from St. Martin’s/NetGalley

What a fantastic addition to the Finlay Donovan series! I love that we returned to Finlay’s neighborhood and the nosy old biddy across the street gets her story told. The author continues to write Finlay involved in twisty and surprising mysteries, with her sidekick Vera. They are my favorite duo and I can’t wait for their next adventure.
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the eARC to read and review. All opinions are my own.

Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave is an absolute winner!! I don't know how Elle Cosimano continues to come up with the crazy situations Finlay finds herself in, but I am sure glad she does. I absolutely love the dialogue between Vero and Finlay--I laugh so much while reading about their escapades. Fun read! Thank you, NetGalley and Minotaur Books, for the advance reader copy of this book.

The Finlay Donovan series is my favorite series of all time! I read a lot of books, and there’s just something SO special about this series. Each and every book is consistently amazing and always delivers with punchy quips, hilarious scenarios that Vero and Finlay find themselves in, and sweet romance that leaves you swooning. I especially enjoyed this book because there’s just something so fun about curmudgeonly old women in books. It was fun that this storyline was different from the previous books, but still had the classic Finlay feel. I’m already excited for the next book!! As per usual, Angela Dawes provided a flawless performance with the narration. She IS Finlay and Vero to me, and I hope that she signs on to every single book. I’d even be down to have her play both characters in the movie adaptation. Just put her in a wig and call it a day

This is probably my favorite of Finlays series. I laughed, I cried and I cheered. The cast of characters were back and I love them all.

3.5-4 stars
Another fun book of mystery and humor in the Finlay Donovan series. I thought this one was a bit better than the others I had read, as it didn't seem to be trying quite so hard to be funny. Also, the plot didn't seem to be as over the top as previous ones.

Not loving the romance with Nick, but I did enjoy Mrs. Hagerty!

Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for a free e-ARC of this book.

Still as fun as ever, and Finlay is as much of a mess as ever. I loved that Mrs. Haggerty was featured more in this one and that we got more of her backstory so we can understand why she is the way that she is. I l led the twists and turns and finding out how Finlay and Vero repeatedly got themselves in and out of trouble this time. Yay for more hot cop! Nick was back and, boy, am I rooting for them to work out. This was just as delightful as the rest of the Finlay Donovan series and I can’t wait for the next installment! I wish I could savor these a little more, but I always end up binging them in a day or two because I just can’t put them down!

Finlay…honestly, girl, how much more can you get into!? I felt like this one cleared up some things from the past but very much left the door open for book 6.

While I did switch between ebook and audiobook format, the narrator for this series is SO good that I can’t help but prefer the audio!

Shenanigans a plenty, another great Finlay story!

This fifth book in this series is hilarious and perfectly captures the chaotic adventure that first hooked me. Finlay and Vero’s wild adventures remain as funny as ever, bringing back that first-book magic I loved in book 1. The involvement of Finlay’s family including the kids adds a lovely layer of warmth and mess, and Vero continues to shine with her sharp wit and growing depth.

The audiobook is truly the best, it’s impossible not to laugh out loud hearing Finlay and Vero come to life. I can’t imagine experiencing their escapades any other way now. This installment answers plenty of my questions, but the ending practically begs for another book, or maybe it’s me begging. I’ve loved every step of their journey, and this chapter feels like a perfect blend of fun and growth. Here’s hoping the adventures continue! 🤞🏽

I loved this book! Date I say even more than the last one? And I am so excited to read the next one…assuming there is another one! Thanks for the ARC! I thoroughly enjoyed it!

Thank you Minotaur for the advance copy. All opinions are my own.

Just when I think that I am going to give up on this series, Finlay Donovan Digs Her Own Grave changes my mind! Rolls the Dice felt a little too out there for me but Digs Her Own Grave four FD back on track. The dynamic between Finlay and Vero and Mrs Haggerty was the best.

Plus, the cameo of a certain character really made me smile.

Finley's young daughter has just gotten in trouble for beating up the little boy who pulls her hair on the playground. She is suspended from school, her. neighbor, who covertly watches her house for gossip, can't stay in her own freezing house, so she has decided to stay at Finlay's. She is a pesky old lady. And Finlay is already a massive ball of chaos. She copes by making funny observations.
She tries to be discreet. But when push comes to shove, she is willing to take care of the problem and the instigator. She is a real firecracker. Who pushes the boundaries of the law and gets things done. A mystery is unfolding across the street from Finn's house. Hence her unwanted guest, now embedded in her house.
Looks like the police could use a little help, so Finn investigates. As it moves towards involving her own circle, she and her nanny turn up their own investigation.
Will they solve the case and expose the killer who dumped the body across the street from her house? Will she expose the killer or will this be her last hurrah!
The crime itself involves a shockingly complex web of deceit that proves creative. Laughter and disbelief abound in a sea of shocking revelations.
Here's hoping many more adventures .
Thank you to the publisher and author for providing me with a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
A fun and funny madcap adventure.

Thanks, Minotaur Books, for the arc!

I love that Mrs. Haggerty is the main focal point of FINLAY DONOVAN DIGS HER OWN GRAVE. Even though this is my least favorite of the books so far, I still laughed a ton and would 100% reread it, unlike the novella. I'm not sure exactly why it didn't wow me. This is a Finlay Donovan plot to the extreme, and it had me giggling. I'm not sure it was so over the top that it kept pulling me out of the moment. Or should I have paced myself and taken a break between books four and five? I don't think that's the problem, though, since I read books one through novella (3.5) almost back to back.

I loved Cameron and Mrs. Haggerty's relationship. I hope we get more of that duo in the future. And the ending has me super intrigued for book six!! I love how Cosimano solves the mystery and ends with a cliffhanger for the next book in each one!