I first want to thank HarperCollins and NetGalley for allowing me to read All the Painted Stars by Emma Denny. This review is solely my personal opinion. I was excited to read this book when given the chance. It is a sequel, I wouldn't say this is a stand alone story, but I didn't read the first book and eventually felt like I got enough information throughout this story to understand information I missed by not reading it. That being said, I still thoroughly enjoyed this story. Here, we are following Jo and Lily, sisters, to each of the main characters in book one. Jo and Lily became friends due to Penn and Raff's relationship. Lily receives word that Jo's family is holding a tournament, and Jo's hand in marriage will be offered. Lily feels as though she can't standby, and she enters the tournament to try to "save" Jo. There were a lot of twists and turns in this story that kept me on my toes. Also, there is a strong female empowerment within the story, I learned a little history while reading. I give this story a solid 4 stars. I definitely recommend this book. I would suggest reading Penn and Raff's story first.

A medieval sapphic romance. Absolutely stunning! I loved the first one and was so excited to read the sequel. It has a sapphic knight fighting for her lady. Do I need to say anymore than that? Read it!!

I was really hoping I would like this book but I had a hard time pushing through. A lot of the character writing fell flat for me, and the whole time it bothered me that Johanna and Lily were sister-in-laws. The pacing was okay, but I just wish there was more adventure rather than fluff. This was cute and I think others might enjoy this. It just wasn't for me.

This books was the perfect blend of a romance and and fantasy all in one! It had adventures and drama with unexpected twists that drew me in. Excellent book!

Honestly this is everything I could want out of a medieval sapphic romance - we've got a knight tournament, explorations of what it means to be a noble lady and the expectations that come with it, ale brewing, and questions of what freedom means in a world where choices are limited and past trauma lurks around every corner.

Jo and Lily are so sweet together - I love the friends-to-lovers aspect, but even more so, I love it set against Lily knowing she's in love and Jo realizing that both she is allowed to be in love/what love even feels like, and that she is in love with Lily. It's just all so sweet and kept me grinning.

I also really loved the fact that the tournament is really just the jumping-off-point for the rest of the book, and the realistic nature of Lily knowing she won't be able to win, she just wants to prove her worth. It's a refreshing change for something that I didn't even realize I was tired of until presented with this alternative. It just makes me love this story all the more, to have both the escapist romantic nature of it, as well as the grounded, realistic nature of the reality for noble ladies and the options for women in general.

All in all, I absolutely loved this, and I can see myself returning to re-read it again and again.

I loved the idea of someone fighting for their love, it was wonderfully done and was enjoying the use of 1362. The characters felt like they belonged in this world and still felt like they belonged. I enjoyed the romance going on and was engaged with how everything worked. Emma Denny has a great way of keeping the reader and I was glad I read this.

Sapphic lady knight romance? Yes. Please.
This story was adorable and I loved every second of it. A noble lady who never wishes to marry as she is attracted to women accidentally falls for a noble lady who has no idea who she’s attracted to, her life has been nothing but surviving this cruel man’s world to even consider anyone.
Lily finds out that Jo is to be married off for the wellbeing of her family and does not want to be. So lily does what she does best, rides off in her brothers old clothes and armor to pretend to be a man in the tournament that Jo’s family is hosting as a way to find a favorable match for her. Lily doesn’t really have a plan, but to compete as best she can and hopefully win the favor of Jo so she can save her from an unwanted marriage to a man she doesn’t know.
What could possibly go wrong?
Well, a lot of things.
The story starts where Lily looks to be doing well and there’s so much hope, but then things start to devolve from there, one thing going wrong after another. But are they really going wrong if they end up in the right place?
Full of sweet first love and quiet yearning and blooming from a friendship to something much greater. I loved Lilys fiery spirit and Jo’s gentle but determined nature.

“You are wild and free and utterly mad: this is why I love you as I do.”


Thank you to NetGalley and HarperCollins / Harper 360 for the e-ARC of All The Painted Stars!

All The Painted Stars is an immensely enjoyable historical sapphic friends-to-lovers romance centered around Johanna, a Lady whose hand is being offered in marriage as a tournament prize, and her adoring friend Lily, who enters the tournament as a knight in disguise in order to fight for Johanna's freedom and right to choose. I normally am not a fan of historical settings but was swayed by the lovely cover and the concept of a queer lady knight, and I'm glad I gave the novel a chance. I read the first 40% in one sitting despite starting it after midnight and dove eagerly back into it the next day as soon as I could. The characters are both very likable despite holding very different values, and the care and concern they show for each other is clear and consistent throughout the book. The writing is comfortable and easy to sink into, and both Jo (Johanna) and Lily (Cecily) deserve all the happiness in the world.

Note: sex depictions and mentions in and after chapter 20

All the Painted Stars is a wonderful followup to One Night in Hartswood. Following the sisters from the first book, we follow Jo as she's dealing with the fallout from her brother's departure from the keep, and Lily who is desperate to return to her. Jo's family is hosting a tournament and whoever wins also wins Jo's hand in marriage. Learning this from a letter, Lily decides to enter as a man to save Jo from her fate. The two women keep finding each other and find their own way to fight fate together. I loved all the different turns this story took, and all the side characters we meet add heart and depth to the story. I can't wait to see what Denny writes next.
Thanks to Harper 360 and NetGalley for the ARC in trade for an honest review.

I requested and received an eARC of All the Painted Stars by Emma Denny. I really enjoyed this other’s previous work in this series, One Night in Hartswood, because I need all of the fourteenth century queer romance in a bad way. Luckily, Denny has done it again, this time with a Sapphic spin. In All the Painted Starts, we follow Raff’s sister Lily Barden who has just discovered that her best friend, Johanna, is to given away in marriage to the winner of a tournament. Lily, determined to stop this, dresses herself as a knight and enters the contest herself. Unfortunately, this decision is not received well all-around, and Lily is forced to escape with Johanna to avoid danger.

I really enjoyed the blossoming romance between Lily and Jo, the sort of cluelessness about what their feelings really mean before it dawns on them. In the beginning of the novel, I really got a kick out of the tournament and Lily’s successes. I was always amused when Ellis appeared on the page! Who doesn’t love a young earl? I sympathized with Jo’s plight, but I was very drawn to Lily’s character. Her boldness and sense of adventure both make for an excellent protagonist to root and swoon for. As Lily prepared to enter the tournament, under the name William, I wanted nothing more for than her to sweep the competition and dash away with Jo’s heart.

All the Painted Stars is a charming and very sweet read. There are moments of action and suspense and these both helped to capture my attention in this story. Denny also offers a lovable (and detestable!) cast of supporting characters that make this story feel well-rounded and worthwhile. I found the romance to be handled especially well and crafted with so many moments of tenderness and longing that I quickly became a JoLily (LilyJo? Are we over couple names?) fan. I don’t always love the “hidden progressives” in historical queer romance, and while I understand they are often necessary to help facilitate the story or create a sense of found family, it always takes me out of the story a little bit. My attention did wane during the middle portion of the story, but overall I really enjoyed this book. The strong beginning and the rewarding ending, combined with Jo and Lily’s outstanding chemistry, made it a success for me.

I'm not into medieval English history BUT I have always wanted a romance between a lady and a female knight-errant for obvious reasons. And that's what we have here! It's also a sweet friends-to-lovers relationship. The plot is pretty much broken up into three arcs:

Part One: Tournament
Part Two: Brewery
Part Three: Arranged Marriage/Say No to the Patriarchy

Part One was my favorite. Lily's master plan was just peak sapphic fantasy: disguise yourself as a man, enter the knights tournament, win and therefore win the hand of your bff, live happily lesbianly after. I feel like an amazing book could be written based on that premise alone. Part Two was slower plotwise but focused on Lily and Jo's romance. Part Three moved much faster. It introduced/brought back some queer antagonists (sort of? as antagonisty as this book gets) to hinder the ladies' HEA and had THE BEST "I object" wedding scene ever.

This had a lot of queer rep for a novel based on this time period in Christian European history, but it seemed pretty realistic and as positive as I imagine most people could've been back then. I don't believe you need to read the previous book One Night in Hartswood to enjoy this.

so i definitely would not have requested from NetGalley this book had I known that it was a sequel, but i was still interested in reading it, so I did, and I probably would have liked it more had I read the first book, but I have not and wasn't planning on it. I liked the romance a lot, but I feel like the world of the book is too small, so everyone either knows each other or is related to each other, and all of the conflict is resolved and set up a bit weirdly. not really my thing I guess

Sweet and cozy read, perfect for fans of medieval romance, lady knights, A Knight's Tale and Chappel Roan's VMA performance.

Lily is determined to save her friend Jo from a marriage she doesn't want. The solution she comes up with? Chop off her hair, steal her brother's clothes and some armor, and fight for her friend in a jousting tournament. While obviously impractical, Denny does a great job of giving us realistic action around an obviously unqualified knight. Lily is stubborn, brave and impulsive, while Jo is practical, dutiful and perhaps overthinks things too much. I love the interactions between Lily and Jo, as well as the secondary characters like Mabel and Ellis. The friends-to-lovers romance is sweet and slow, with a luscious amount of tension (made better by getting both POVs and feeling that "just kiss each other already!" feeling). There is a prequel book that involves some of these same characters, but enough to discussed/revealed in this story that you don't feel like you need it, and LIly and Jo are the stars.

If you are looking for cozy sapphic romance, fight the patriarchy in a fun way vibes and found family - highly recommend.

We love a lady knight. When Cecily "Lily" Barden hears that her best friend Lady Johanna is hosting a tournament for her hand in marriage, she knows that she needs to enter. Even though Lily knows she won't win, it's a chance to see Jo before she's wed. Jo's hand as the prize is a bit of a farce though, because Lord Adam has already offered, and his status and wealth are worth more to Jo's family than an errant knight. When Lily is injured and her life threatened, she and Jo make their escape to the countryside. And for the first time, they can be themselves, and share feelings that Jo didn't know could exist and that Lily is too afraid to share.

I enjoyed this sequel to One Night in Hartswood! Jo and Lily have a relationship built on friendship, and while it takes 2/3 of the book for Jo to realize what this means, the mutual pining is palpable. I thought the book got a little weighted down by plot, especially at the brewery, but overall loved the medieval sapphic tale.

I loved All the Painted Stars, it is a breathtaking romance, and the letters between Lily and Jo are wonderful and are woven in seamlessly throughout the plot. I am a huge fan of One Night in Hartswood, so i was thrilled to read this. It has everything, forbidden romance, turmoil, bravery, and stunning LGBTQIA+ leads. I couldn’t ask for more, except, maybe a sequel in the future... ;)

My heart was so, so warm while reading this book. The love between Lily and Johanna was palatable with every page that I read. There was solemn and silly moments that equalized themes of the book which I loved.

All the Painted Stars follows Jo and Lily, Jo's hand is being given to a worthy knight in a tournament, and Lily competes undercover in this tournament, because she thinks Jo needs saving from marriage. Along the way, the two reconcile and begin to develop feelings for one another.

This is a very sweet historical romance, that would be perfect for fans of Emma R. Alban's "Don't Want You Like a Best Friend" or anyone who's life was changed by Chappell Roan's VMA's Joan of Arc performance. I really enjoyed how Denny depicted the medieval setting, as this was my first sapphic romance from that time period. I read this without reading "One Night in Hartswood" and while I think this can still be read as a standalone, you'd learn more about Jo and Lily's early years by reading both.

4.25 stars

Jo, sister to a young Earl, is about to be married off, but not if Lily has anything to say about it. Lily dresses up as a knight and enters into the tournament to try to give Jo her freedom.

I feel like I would have liked this book better had I read the first before it as it's built on the friendship that began in book one. And it kept referencing things that happened in the first book without actually revealing much of anything, so I guess it could be read out of order. Even so, this is a fun Sapphic lady/knight, slow burn, friends to lovers romance. While it was a bit predictable, it was also pretty cozy, and I definitely cheered at a certain character revelation. I've heard it gives A Knight's Tale vibes, and that's pretty accurate for the first half, but I actually enjoyed the second half more.

Thank you to NetGalley and publisher for the opportunity to read and review.

I was absolutely thrilled to get my hands on an advance copy of this book--I adored One Night in Hartswood and couldn't wait for more in Emma Denny's world, and this did not disappoint! Jo and Lily are both delightful in their own ways, and the burn between them is so slow I was practically screaming at the page for them to figure themselves out. Like the first in the series, All the Painted Stars has a delightful blend of angsty yearning, genuine danger and adventure, and a glimpse of 14th century life with details that feel real and goes in surprising directions (I was expecting more of the book to take place at the tourney rather than a brewery, but the change in setting was quite nice and provided a fascinating look at ale brewing that I absolutely drank up). I hope there are more in this series, and either way I'll be eagerly anticipating whatever Emma Denny writes next!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc! Opinions are my own.

I absolutely loved One Night in Hartswood so I jumped at the chance to read this one. IT BLEW ME AWAY. I need a thousand more sapphic historical romance BECAUSE WHAT HAVE I BEEN MISSING MY ENTIRE LIFE