Overall, this book was fine. As a queer pirate book with themes of saving the world, grief/anger, etc. I feel like it had promise but ultimately missed the mark. The storyline itself, however, did feel unique enough for me to want to finish the book.

The characters seemed very surface level to me. I feel like our main character Adra was supposed to morally grey, yet her motivations for different choices and emotions seemed out of place at times.

The plot was a mix of unique storytelling, too much going on, and lots of typical pirate-y things. It was enough for me to want to finish the book, but not enough for me to downright love it. The world building was eh- it could have used some work and some more explaining, but like I said I did finish it because I wanted to know what happened.

I loved every second of this book! This was a fast-paced sapphic pirate fantasy that somehow felt cozy even though the stakes were high and there were literal monsters. The magic system was unique, and the characters were relatable. I loved that there was a crew list and a map because when I read fantasy, I need to know where they are and who is there! lol Also, I think there's something to be said of writers who've been writing for a while because you know the book is going to flow really well, which this did! I definitely recommend this!

Thank you Netgalley and Page Street Publishing for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

“The Devourer” by Alison Ames is a YA fantasy adventure that takes you on a wild journey through treacherous seas, with captivating pirate captains, ancient sea monsters, and a plot that grips you from the very first line. If you're looking for a story that blends the swashbuckling energy of “Daughter of the Pirate King” with the dark magic vibes of “The Witcher,” then this is a book you won't want to miss. Plus, there is some fantastic LGBTQ representation throughout this book as well as the found family trope, which I absolutely love.

The story follows Adra Dantes, a fierce and morally complex pirate captain, driven by a single goal: to hunt down her half-brother Cameron, who betrayed their family by stealing a priceless treasure map. Her pursuit of vengeance is disrupted when a surge of magic causes ancient sea monsters to rise, and she discovers that the ship she has been chasing is captained by a girl impersonating Cameron. Adra is forced into an uneasy alliance with this rival captain, Quinn, as they both confront the monstrous threat known as The Devourer that’s wreaking havoc on the seas.

One of the strongest aspects of “The Devourer” is its characters. Adra is a standout protagonist—her amoral tendencies, sharp wit, and relentless drive for revenge make her a refreshingly fierce (anti-)heroine. What’s particularly engaging about Adra’s character is that her flaws aren’t excused or softened; instead, they are acknowledged and embraced, adding layers to her personality. Quinn, her hardened love interest, shares Adra’s tough exterior, making their dynamic feel like a meeting of equals rather than a cliché opposites-attract romance. Their relationship has just enough tension and chemistry to keep you invested, and while romance is not the primary focus, the hint of a future together adds a sweet touch to the otherwise fast-paced plot.

The friendships in the story are equally compelling, with side characters Merrin and Diana providing both emotional depth and light-hearted banter. The history and bond between these characters add to the story's richness, showing a blend of camaraderie, grief, and forgiveness that makes their interactions feel real and poignant. The found family aspect with Adra’s shipmates was my favorite part of the book as the different characters are so unique and breathe life into the story.

Ames’s writing is fast-paced and engaging, perfectly suited to the story's action-packed plot. The adventure on the high seas, combined with the incorporation of magic and mythical monsters, creates a world that feels both expansive and immersive. There is some good world building throughout, though the prevalence of magic is a bit overwhelming at first. The tension builds beautifully as the characters race against time, not just to find Cameron but also to face off against the fearsome Devourer lurking beneath the waves.

Overall, “The Devourer” is a fast-paced, addictive read that fans of YA fantasy will devour in one sitting. With its mix of dark magic, pirate battles, and fierce, morally complex characters, this book is sure to captivate anyone who loves a good adventure on the high seas. Alison Ames has crafted a world filled with danger, intrigue, and just enough romance to keep things interesting. This debut is a must-read for anyone looking for a magical and action-packed escape into a world where monsters lurk beneath the waves and pirate captains will do anything for vengeance.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.75/5

The Devourer is a riveting, addictive YA fantasy with captivating characters, fascinating monsters, and a propulsive plot that hooked me from the first line.

Gosh, this was a good one. I wanted to highlight every line. The characters were fierce and strong, while showing emotions and development. The sub-plot sapphic romance was *chef’s kiss. The banter, pacing, and adventure were wonderful, and I adored the Daughter of the Pirate King X The Witcher vibes. I soaked this book up and did not want to put it down. It was magical, addictive, dark, twisty, and tender. The writing was beautiful and fit the story perfectly. I also adored the incorporation of monsters, strange magic, and adventure on the high seas. I highly recommend this wonderful debut!

Thank you to the publisher for the free ARC!