Thanks to NetGalley and Dreamscape Media for the E-ARC Audiobook.

A whodunnit thriller that suffers from shallow exploration of the characters. The characters in the book lack dimension and come off very one note. Dr. Daniels is a creepy old man; Ryan is a volatile, aggressive man; the dad is also a creepy old man; etc. While we as the reader are supposed to keep guessing between the main male characters as to who murdered Jess, we aren’t given enough information and exploration into their characters to really have clear distinctions between them other than they exist to make us think all men are trash. I think early on most readers can guess who was responsible for Jess’s disappearance. As for the “big” twist that lowered my rating for this book. It felt forced, and it ruined the rest of the story. I found myself getting bored around the 70% mark and finished out listening to the audiobook at 2x speed.

I am conflicted on the interjections of the podcast throughout the book. I do like how they are intentionally conveyed as being tone deaf and obnoxious while discussing a missing woman’s case. I can’t stand a lot of popular true crime podcasts because the hosts tell jokes and make quips that feel insensitive to the victims and their families *side eyes the My Favorite Murder podcast*. This book does a great job of pointing that out while Jess’s younger sister Lindsey is listening to one of them covering her sister’s disappearance. While at time those breaks feel very out place in the narrative.

In summary, this book is okay. There were good and bad parts to the writing, and none of the flaws were so immense that I wouldn’t recommend this book, as some of what I count as flaws are personal nitpicks. I would say if it’s not keeping your interest at the halfway point, just go ahead and look up spoilers because you won't really miss much on the buildup to the reveals. To end on a good note, the narrators did a fantastic job, and a large part of what kept my interest in the book as far as it went was excellent narration.

Female students are missing from Southern State University and over 20 years later, the mystery of their disappearance remains. Katherine Greene’s “Lake of Lost Girls” tells the story of four vanished young women by deftly moving from past to present. The changes in points of view add to the drama of the tale, particularly in the audiobook format. The narrators realistically give voice to the podcasters and you always know who is speaking. This book will keep you awake and guessing as the mystery of these cold cases unfolds.

I definitely enjoyed the way this audiobook was done. Different POVs as well as a small portion being podcast style. I will say, the podcast girls were annoying and didn’t provide much information at all.

The ending didn’t come as a shock. I guessed who the killer was for each girl early on. The relationship with Jess and her dad was gross, but it added to the storyline.

All in all, this was an entertaining audiobook.

his is one of those books that you will either love or hate. Told on alternating timelines and from different viewpoints it centers around one woman who lost her sister 24 years ago. I honestly had one of the characters pegged as the killer and I was partially right. I did not see the other part of the ending coming….and I’m not sure if I liked it or not. But I will say that it kept my attention and I was intrigued enough to say 3.5/4 stars for me. Rounded up to 4 here.
I received an ALC of this title, all opinions are my own.

Freshman in college Jessica finds herself caught up in the case of a series of missing girls. Twenty-four years later, Jessica's younger sister Lindsey starts unearthing the past with the help of an attractive journalist.

This was such a good thriller. It's hands down one of the top thrillers I've ever read! Here's what I loved:

The thought behind it all: This book was so well developed and laid out. You can see the care in which Greene put into crafting this book. All of the ends are connected and the story moves along so smoothly.

Lindsey: I found myself very attached to her story. I loved how she put herself into finding out what happened to her sister while still navigating her own adult life. You see a growth in her by the end of the book.

The twists and turns: There is so many twists in this one. A few of them I didn't see coming at all.

The audio: I loved the multiple narrators in this one. It really helped separate the narrations of Jessica and Lindsey.

All in all, a really good thriller!

Thank you to the author and publisher for the gifted copy!

This was my first book by this author. I really enjoyed the mixed media aspect, especially the podcast part. Loved the different narrators for each role. I also liked the alternating POVs and dual timelines. I wish we had spent a little more time in Jess’ POV, especially as she interacted with the other missing girls. At different times I suspected everyone and liked the twist.

Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape Media for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.

This story is told through alternate timelines and by sprinkling in podcast clips and was just so well done. Admittedly, Im already a sucker for a story with a podcast premise but I particularly enjoyed how this one does it as a way of showing us how these stories can be mishandled while moving the story along and keeping us guessing. Another thing this one does well is explore what it looks like when there’s a m*rder in the family and how it affects each family member then and now. This was a perfect read for October (or honestly whenever you’re in the mood for a mystery thriller) and had me hooked the whole way through. I also consumed it as an audiobook and highly recommend doing so as well, the narrators and production were fantastic and did a great job bringing the story to life. Biiiig thank you to Katherine Greene, Dreamscape Media, and NetGalley for this advanced copy, it truly was a terrific read and has me excited to read more from Katherine! :)

This book was a 3 star read for me but almost got rounded up to 3.5 because I just didn't think the author was going to go there. And I'm glad she did. It was a strong first half and the book sort of tapered off from there for me. I was losing interest about mid way through but I stuck with it because I was still eager to find out who was responsible for the lost girls. I was pretty convinced that it was going to be one of two characters, but I was happy to report the one I didn't think would ultimately be responsible was and I thought that was a good little twist on the author's part. I would definitely read something else by this author.

Wow, this was quite the messed up “true crime” story.

The Lake of Lost Girls recounts the story of college girls who go missing and the podcast that details their story 24 years later. We follow the sister of one of the missing girls as well, on her hunt for the truth.

It has the feel of a small town mystery with multiple, very sketchy persons of interest. There’s a lot of us vs them mentality with the college and town, which also adds a fun layer of intrigue.

Katherine Greene really knows how to string along a reader without you feeling like she’s doing it to extend the plot. Truly a fun mystery to follow.

Stick around for the ending - I was kept guessing the whole time!

Even though I was able to put together the big twist at the end, I still enjoyed the ride that was this story. Creepy atmosphere, fear of the unknown, and good connections to the past vs. present.

I read this as an Ebook and I liked it enough. The ending is really intense and I was glad it was a little different from what I was suspecting. It is twisty and sad. However, while I was reading it I was thinking "this reads like it should be an audiobook". The podcast portions are just fun that way.
So I was overjoyed to give this a listen. I loved it! This is a great story and the narration really adds some magic.

I have a hard time rating this book, and I think in general The Lake of Lost Girls is going to be polarizing. I love mysteries and thrillers, and this one definitely kept me guessing until the end. I usually love when a book has twists that I can’t predict. But this one honestly just depressed me. The content was heavy and so very sad. This is a book that will stay with me for awhile, but not necessarily in a positive way. On the flip side, I do think the storytelling is good and the author sparked some strong feelings in me. I know some people will really enjoy The Lake of Lost Girls; it just wasn’t for me.
Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape Media for this free ALC in exchange for my honest opinion.

Thank you to the authors, narrators, publisher and Net Galley for providing a free e-audio version of this title in exchange for my review.

This was a hard miss for me. I kept listening, hoping for a switch at the end, hoping the whole plot line of the podcast and the 'need' for far too many narrators would result in a big pay off ... but it didn't. This book felt like it was trying to be a lot, lot, LOT more than it actually is. And felt like the authors were deciding 'whodunnit' as they were writing it. The flash backs got to be so confusing, the large cast of characters got to be confusing, the constant "Jess is so perfect" was annoying. I don't know, it didn't work for me. I just really don't get it.

1 star for 'didn't like it'

I may come back and take a star away once this book really sinks in but…

I’m pissed off. That ending PISSED me off. I had high hopes and I was enjoying the ride until about 70% of the way through, hence the 3 stars.

It was an uncomfortable ride more often than not (I don’t think I liked a single character, except my girl Daisy) but I still hoped a well thought out, socially responsible conclusion was coming. There were so many opportunities to do right by the countless Tammy’s and Megan’s and Phoebe’s of the world. But maaaan was I disappointed. I’m sure the author thought it was going to be a satisfying plot twist reveal but it just made me angry instead. Some people will be into it I’m sure but… I disagree with those people.

Would I recommend this book? Maybe. In the way you want your friend to watch the same shitty movie you can’t believe you just spent 2 hours watching, because you need someone else to also go “Wtf was that???” So that you can go, “Riiiiiight?!”

Thank you to NetGalley for this arc in exchange for an honest review!

WOW!! Talk about whiplash?! I thought I had the culprit picked out about 5 times… and although I was kind of/ maybe partially correct…. Holy Cow!!
I did NOT see that coming!!!! 👀👀👀

Meet Jessica. She’s a college aged girl in the year 1998 who has a remarkably close relationship with her parents. But, more so with her Dad…but…Daddy’s little girl and all. I can totally understand that! (With both myself, and my daughter…)
While away in her first year of college, several girls go missing. AND, Jess starts to see things that don’t quite add up…. Oh…and she’s friends (or at least friendly) with these girls…

Her life starts to change as she discovers drinking…boys…and freedom.

BUT, she still returns home frequently to spend time with her parents, and her sweet little sister, Lindsey.

When Jess herself goes missing, her family is torn apart…

Years later, Lindsey is all grown up and running a hotel in her hometown in North Carolina. When a reporter comes in and (kind of) corners her to get the story on her big sister, she wants no part of it. BUT, at the same time, there’s a new podcast that’s generating all sorts of attention on her sister’s cold case…and just maybe, they’ll be able to shed some light on it, and find out who’s responsible??!!

That’s it. Not giving anymore, as I don’t want to give anything away!

BUT, this one will keep you glued to the pages…and wanting to get to the next chapter!

First I’ve read from this author (authors), but looking forward for what’s to come!

#TheLakeOfLostGirls by #KatherineGreene and narrated beautifully by a full cast, including: #HelenLaser, #FrankieCorzo, #SaraYoung, #HaleyTaylor and #DavidBendena.

Thanks so much to #NetGalley and #DreamscapeMedia for an ARC of the audiobook which is ******* due to be released in about TWO WEEKS ******* on 11/5/24! So, LOOK 👀 for it then!!

5+ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✨✨✨ for me!

⭐️ Suspense…that just kept..on..going…
⭐️ Kept me guessing AND engaged throughout
⭐️ Podcast format
⭐️ Dual timelines (1998 and now)
⭐️ Terrific main characters
✨ Ancillary characters that you love, but also hate!
✨ Holes in the original story that keep you guessing!

Feel free to like, follow and friend me on: Goodreads,
Insta @ #BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine.

Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️

When a popular podcast shines a spotlight on the 1998 disappearances of a number of Southern State University students, Lindsey Fadley is forced back into the mysterious disappearance of her sister, Jessica, who was one of the girls who went missing nearly a quarter of a century earlier. Lindsey was just a kid when her sister vanished, but now as an adult she's determined to get answers.

I really enjoyed this one. I absolutely loved it jumping back and forth between the perspectives of the two sisters and I thought it had enough substance and moved well enough that the entire podcast segment was unnecessary. I did enjoy the stylized production of those bits, it did break up the audiobook, but the hosts were mostly just recapping what we'd seen firsthand through the girls. I liked that there were a number of men in this book who are borderline creepy depending on the perspective and you're not 100% sure until the end who the bad guy is.

I blew through this one until about 95% and then the last 5% got kind of gross; there were definitely incest vibes that I don't think were intentional because (I think anyway) that when you get the whole explanation it wasn't actually like that, but it was pretty icky. It's also very hard to explain without spoilers but while the end was surprising there was an element of it that was both absolutely turn-your-stomach-disgusting, highly, highly, HIGHLY implausible, and totally unnecessary. Again, difficult without spoilers, but literally any other final detail would have made more sense and yet the authors chose the one that in no way could gone undiscovered for 25 years.

Since the last detail really didn't have any effect on the plot or the resolution, I was able to look past it easily so overall I really enjoyed this one. it's a quick read, good writing, good characters, dual timelines, 95% excellent!

Thank you Netgalley for the ARC. I absolutely loved this book. I could not listen fast enough. I highly recommend the audiobook. I love podcasts and even though it is a small part of the book it really felt as if I was listening to Crime Junkie or My Favorite Murder while also trying to figure out the mystery as well. Throughout the book I was all over the place on who did it. How did it happen. When I would think someone then all of a sudden I would think someone else. Yes, I will say one of the person I thought at one point did end up being involved BUT there was also a twist that I didn't see coming. Well I guess now looking back I can see the little nuggets that lead to the answer but during the book it didn't all quite click. I can't wait to read more from this author and am actually sad the book is over as I really loved it.

The Lake of Lost Girls
Katherine Greene
11/05/2024
Crooked Lane Books

This book checks all the boxes for me. Alternating timelines, unsolved cold cases, dark secrets, multiple unreliable characters and a sister who wants to know the truth are perfectly woven together to make this a haunting novel that you do not want to miss. (Let’s not forget the podcast clips that are thrown in – AHHH its perfect!)

Jessica Fadley left for college in the fall of 1998. On her sister Lindsay’s 6th birthday, she goes missing from her home. Jessica isn’t the only girl from college that went missing that year. There were three others, and no bodies or clues have ever been found. The investigation went cold, and no answers were given. There are clues and similarities that tie the girls together, but apparently some secrets are best left hidden. Twenty four years later when a podcast picks up this cold case and a journalist, Ryan, comes to town, the heated story picks right back up as secrets, lies and bodies are found in the lake.

This is a fast paced bingeable read. It is also one that you want/need to read with someone because when the ending hits – you are going to need to talk about it out loud. You can’t hold it in. I am really looking forward to seeing what else Katherine Greene writes. I will be following her closely!

4.5 stars.

Dreamscape Media killed it with this production, seriously. I loved the podcast format thrown in and the narrators were great. The story itself was perfection, I was sucked in immediately to the mystery of the girls in the lake. I had an inkling about 50% through who was guilty and I was still happily shocked when all was revealed. I think I might have gasped at one point in the story but I don't want to spoil anything. The dual timelines were done well and kept my interest the whole time and the characters had me invested, particularly Jess as we watched her downward spiral...a truly great book!

Thank you Dreamscape for the audio review copy! Four star audio, 3 star book. My rating here reflects the quality of the audiobook as that matters for feedback to the production team.

This was great on audio, I love the podcast drop ins and the voice acting/stylish production. At times I felt the voices/change from the past to present was a bit hard to follow but that is possibly more the book than the voice acting!

So this was great in terms of audiobook production and the plot held me for a good part of the story, I am always interested in stories about missing college students and the complexity of the life as a college student. But as a mystery.... the ending did not make a lot of sense. To say more is to give spoilers and I liked some of the ending but it was way to rushed and one part was highly implausible, it just did not make sense.