Member Reviews

As someone deeply interested in the intersections of history, science, and societal change, A Sick History of Medicine by Jelena Poleksic was an absolutely riveting read. Having had the opportunity to listen to this as an Advanced Reader Copy through NetGalley, I found myself fascinated by the dark and often unsettling truths Poleksic brings to light about the evolution of medicine.

Poleksic doesn't shy away from exploring the grim and sometimes unethical practices that shaped modern medicine. From misguided experiments to controversial breakthroughs, this book provides a comprehensive yet accessible examination of how humanity’s pursuit of healing has often been fraught with moral ambiguity and missteps.

The author has a gift for weaving historical narratives with sharp social commentary, making the book both informative and thought-provoking. The balance of well-researched facts and engaging storytelling makes it an enjoyable read for history buffs, healthcare professionals, and casual readers alike.

Was this review helpful?

The information is great and in an easy to understand format.

However- the audiobook has a horrific trumpet-y melody playing behind the narrator. As someone who listens to books faster than 1x speed, I could hardly hear the book.

My rating is strictly for the audiobook version - the regular ebook/physical book would be 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I listened to the audiobook of A Sick History of Medicine, and it was just as engaging as I imagine the print version would be! The facts are delightfully gross, making it both fascinating and entertaining. The storytelling keeps you hooked, blending bizarre medical history with humor. Highly recommend for fans of weird, fun nonfiction!

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this audiobook from netGalley for a honest review.

I enjoyed this creepy, gross telling of the history of medicine. The music in the audiobook was lively too.

Was this review helpful?

wow! That was incredibly interesting and informative. its great for any age. def one for the school library. i highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

This book, written by a doctor, is filled with fascinating facts about the history of medicine. The author's passion for both the history of medicine and science adds authority to the title. It is packed with captivating historical information while maintaining an engaging tone. The audiobook's narration is clear and well-paced. My 9-year-old loved it and has listened to it several times. Books like this, exploring the history of medicine, are excellent additions to public and school libraries. This audiobook was kindly provided to be as an advance reader copy by NetGalley.

Was this review helpful?

This is a interesting book on a niche subject. It is written well and at a level that children of the intended age will understand. The audiobook is not just a listening but an experience. It has nice background sounds as well as the narrator having a good and engaging rate and tone for the subject matter.

Thank you Macmillan Audio for providing this ARC audiobook for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own

Was this review helpful?

A good audiobook filled with fun, gross facts on medicine while you prepare dinner for the kids… if you have the stomach for it. As is the custom for these types of books, I still wish it were longer.

Recommend as a quick read to pass the time, but not for the squeamish.

(I received this ALC via NetGalley in return for an honest review. Thank you.)

Was this review helpful?

A Sick History of Medicine is a no-holds-barred look at the ickiest, grossest parts of medical history. The content of the book is really interesting and offers a new perspective on the topic. My rating of this book, however, is lower because of the production value. As seems to be the trend with many kids offerings lately, this audiobook is just over-done. The narration was over the top, sound effects were obnoxious, and on top of it all, there was music playing in the background. It was sensory overload, and I did not enjoy listening to this with my kids. Can we stop over-stimulating the kids and just let interesting information stand on its own merit?

Thank you to Macmillan Audio for gifting my family with an ALC to review. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Great historical facts read in succession but unfortunately not captivating enough of an audio for my 3yo. Thank you NetGalley for the ARC though. I think I would love it as a hard copy

Was this review helpful?

A Sick History of Medicine will teach you all kinds of fascinating, strange, and sometimes gross things about medicine from ages long past to now.

With jaunty jazz playing in the background, we learn how doctors used the heads of ants and beetles during surgery, what weird things medicines from an apothecary might contain, how maggots and leeches have historically been used in medicine and how they're still used today. We'll learn how a pee wheel might help diagnose an illness and how a fecal transplant could help cure what ails you. Long ago, you might have had a barber working on you instead of a surgeon or a blacksmith in place of a dentist. We learn about dissection parties, and amputation competitions, and so many other weird and wonderful things from the history of medicine. I think my favorite part was learning how frogs may have helped inspire Mary Shelley's Frankenstein story.

Was this review helpful?

This is a collection of interesting and somewhat gross facts about how medicine was practiced in the past, and occasionally even now. I liked the audio effects, and I think it will certainly entertain any kids who listen.

Was this review helpful?

A short concise over view of all the interesting things we use to believe and do in the name of medicine and healthcare. This book is perfect for kids interested in how medicine works or why we do things the way we do now. Some of this stuff I had no clue about and a lot of it is bound to make your kid giggle and laugh and maybe say ewwww. This is a great little book for kids peaking their interest in medicine and the human body. The audio version of the book is even better because they make sure to have fun sound effects in the book and the narrators tone keeps you listening and interested.

Was this review helpful?

"A Sick History of Medicine" by Jelena Poleksic offers a fascinating dive into the gross and gritty aspects of medical history that are sure to captivate older children. The book presents an array of interesting and often revolting facts, such as the bizarre methods of wound cleaning, peculiar ancient bowel remedies, and the use of leeches and worms in treatment.

For curious young minds with a penchant for the macabre, this book delivers on its promise of intriguing true stories from medicine's early beginnings. The humor and quirky details keep the reading engaging, making it an excellent choice for kids eager to learn about the more outrageous side of healthcare.

While the audiobook format is decent, the print version likely enhances the experience, allowing readers to fully appreciate the illustrations and layout that complement the text. Overall, "A Sick History of Medicine" is a fun and educational read that appeals to children’s natural curiosity about the strange and gross realities of the past.

Was this review helpful?

4 Stars ✨

Thank you MacMillan Audio and Netgalley for an advanced audio copy of A Sick History of Medicine, in return for an honest review.

Audio Narration 🎧

Reader beware!! This is definitely a “GROSS” History of Medicine. Written by a doctor, you can tell that it was fully researched. The narrator was absolutely perfect and entertaining. I do however, feel like reading the physical book along with the audio would have been better to get the whole experience, because who doesn’t want pictures when the audio is disgusting enough. :P My kids and I listened to this together as a part of our homeschool. We had a fun time saying “EWWW” and “GROSS” over and over again and laughing a lot. Not only was it disturbing, gross and fun- we learned a lot about the history of medicine. There were facts about inventions, X-rays, vaccines, dental care and how Barbers used to be the doctors in the town. Would recommend for a fun addition to your classroom or home library unless you have a weak stomach… then I would suggest you pass!!

Was this review helpful?

This was hilariously disgusting and fun. There were so many crazy things through history that people used to do, but there were also great explanations about developments in modern medicine. Some of the things from the past were so crazy, but the craziest thing was that I've seen some of the craziest recommended by people who try to be "natural," like drinking your own pee. I kept thinking about this after I finished, and while this is for kids, I think parents listening with their kids will enjoy it just as much. Thanks to NetGalley, I got to listen to the audiobook, which had a fun, energetic narrator.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you MacMillan Audio for an ALC of A Sick History of Medicine!

"Written by a doctor, everything in this book has been scrupulously researched and readers will learn about the development of some of our greatest inventions, from vaccines to X-rays. Amusing illustrations by Ella Kasperowicz make this a book kids will want to return to again and again."

A Sick History of Medicine is such an entertaining audiobook! The narrator Tim Campbell does such a wonderful job of keeping it fun and silly. I'm looking forward to getting a physical copy of the book and the other book in the series!!

Was this review helpful?

First - Please note that while I personally received the Audiobook, my <b>rating</b> is specific to the content itself, the print version.

Certainly pretty gross, this will catch - and keep - children's attention (if they're into that stuff). Thankfully it was never <i>too</i> gross. The way it's written will also be perfect for kids, from the sounds of it it's just a bunch of interconnected fun facts. I'd love to see the book in print, so I could better appreciate the facts individually. Via audio, it feels a little like they're all just thrown at you. I really enjoyed Tim Campbell's voice too. The audio wasn't completely a bust, I'd just recommend it for older kids who will be able to grasp that this isn't really a cohesive story, more of a collection of knowledge. Toward the end of the book though, there are (what I'd guess is) a few pages worth of introductions; Tim Campbell is just saying "I'm so-and-so and I -blah-blah-blah. I'm (a different) so and so and I blah-blah-blah". Again an assumption, but maybe there were pictures of each person so it made a little more sense in context? So if you do choose the audiobook, maybe just skip over that part so it's not confusing.

{Thank you bunches to NetGalley, Jelena Poleksic, Neon Squid, Tim Campbell, Macmillan Audio and Macmillian Young Listeners for the ALC in exchange for my honest review!}

Was this review helpful?