Member Reviews
Thank you to NetGalley for a copy of this book!
This book contains many great examples, both in the greater animal kingdom and in humans of sexual differentiation and varying expressions/interactions among these individuals.
The presentation left a little lacking for me. When referencing some controversial or outdated studies, the author spoke in absolutes about the lack of value in these studies, often using language that felt very condescending (like “eye roll!”, among other sarcastic comments). It was unclear in these moments who the author’s audience was. The book started out sounding as if the purpose was to show the biological backing for non-heterosexual/non-monogamous relationships, but these comments seemed to judge or ostracize people who weren’t already fully onboard with the author. I would have preferred a stronger argument and less asides.
There are also a few times where a single example is provided, but sweeping generalizations are made. There is discussion about what “true monogamy” is, but only uses the example of the Roosevelts. While it’s possible the author looked at multiple scenarios to come to his definition of monogamy in humans, this is unclear and feels like a jump.
Overall, a decent read, but I was left wishing the author would defend his views a bit more solidly at times.
This book was incredibly informative and thought provoking. As someone drawn to animal behavior, Chapters 1-4 were full of intriguing facts, but I found Chapters 5-8 particularly inspiring and informative. I loved the message that "if you assume a bimodal model, you ignore all of the points in between" because it highlights a lot of the issues both with past research and with societal bias today. As it is a more scientific read, there are lot of examples/evidence which can make it seem slightly dense if that isn't what you're looking for, but all of his claims and theories are explained very clearly, and he tied together biology, sociology, psychology, and history together seamlessly, making this book accessible to just about anyone.