I wanted so badly to love this book. From the title and the description, it was right up my alley. But I was almost immediately confronted with amateurish writing, dialog, plotting, and pacing. It felt like something a high schooler would write...if they were an old gay man. Every single thing in this book is predictiable, the author always makes the easiest, most obvious choice with dialogue, settings, characters, plot. I kept waiting to be pleasantly surprised but the disappointment just continued.
I'm sad to say that you should look elsewhere for a great book that combines 80s queer life and the supernatural.

Disco Witches is a great historical fiction/ fantasy about the community on Fire Island during the height of the AIDS crisis. When Joe, a young gay man, joins his friend Ronnie for a first-time trip to summer on Fire Island he soon finds it's not just fun and games as he was led to believe. He is already reeling from the loss of a loved one and afraid to commit to anyone else who might soon be taken by the rampant virus. I loved this book for its sense of humor, the immersion into a culture I've never experienced and the hopefulness the characters all maintained through the very darkest times.

This book definitely will want you grab your dancing shoes> I loved all the magical bits, I just wish there was more of them! Also I wish there was more world building to help with the understanding of it. Love the 80's setting and made fire island just feel cozy in a way.

Fire Island Pines is a hedonistic gay paradise in 1989. Joe & Ronnie can't wait to spend the summer working on the island. As the summer goes on, they begin to notice odd things, supernatural things. As the summer goes on and they begin to discover things that are happening, they get pulled into the supernatural things that are going on and the Disco Witches of the island.

This was an interesting read. And, to be honest, I still don't quite know if I mean that in a good or bad way. I will say, I loved how this book brought to life the uncertainties and the struggles that the LGBTQ+ community was facing back at the beginning of the AIDs crisis. I think that topic is so important to be discussed and I appreciated the way that this book discussed that time. However, I really struggled with this book. I didn't find myself invested in this until maybe over halfway through the book when I found things finally got interesting. I found it, overall, to just be a very weird book but I did not hate it. It was definitely enjoyable at some parts and the inclusion of "disco magic" was fun and made it easier to get through. I also did enjoy how the book was told from multiple POVs so I got a wider perspective of the goings on.

Oh my GOD this was such a treat! I always love a well crafted story, but the supernatural elements woven into the perfectly realistic plot? Goodbyeeeeee it was perfect!

Spoiler free review is that this book was absolutely wonderful. I love stories that are mostly based in realism with a touch of the supernatural and this one definitely delivered! I loved the entire cast of colorful characters (although Ronnie did take quite a bit to grow on me) and the stories and relationships interwoven throughout the book. I especially loved Howie! This book put me THROUGH it with emotions. It made me laugh, it made me cry, it made me have all sorts of feelings and I felt a lot of gratitude for those in the LGBTQ community who came before me.
The magical elements in the book were so interesting! I've never seen magic used in the way that the author chose to use it here. I especially loved the dancing and Disco music part of it and even found an instrumental disco playlist to listen to while I read! Adored this story and can't wait for the rest of the world to read it!

If historical romantasy isn't a thing yet, bet you it's about to be. Disco Witches of Fire Island is set on an island off of Long Island in NYC that's a gay vacation haven at the height of AIDS in the 80s, and you have a young man who comes to try and deal with a bad breakup (his partner got AIDS and slowly isolated himself and passed suddenly) and move forward, and the group of gay men who use the magic of disco music to try and help him move forward. The focus is mostly on Elliott's hangups and personal journey, and it's a pretty solid read.

2.5 ⭐️. these characters were so pure and melted your heart. I did find a lot lacking in the execution of this novel -- it felt like the characters would make decisions that didn't feel true to who they were and the commentary read like a cheesy rom com to me. this gave CAMP to the highest degree.

thank you to Alcove Press and NetGalley for an advance reading copy in exchange for an honest review.

Thank you to NetGalley for allowing me to read it.

This book definitely has an audience and I am not a part of it.

There is nothing really wrong with this book, besides it being a bit predictable and a tad too long. But I just didn't connect to any of the characters. I have a lot of other books to read (both with a deadline on NetGalley and random books I own), so I did consider DNFing it a few times. As a "compromise" I skipped a part of the midsection and read the last few chapters. I could fill in any missed information pretty easily and was satisfied with the end.

If I were to rate the book on my personal experience alone I would give it a 2,5*, but since many people seem to be enjoying it and it was well-written I think a three star suffices.

I you love anything witch related you should read it.

I think that I had expected this to be a fun, light romance about gay witches on Fire Island, but it ended up being so much heavier. This feels most like the literary fiction that I haven't read in years, just with magic sprinkled in. It's a tortured young man who still grieves his lover who died from AIDS and learns how to move on.

It's the summer of 1989, and Joe's best friend Ronnie has convinced him to spend the summer bartending together on Fire Island. Ronnie the extrovert has taken Joe under his wing and seeks a hot, rich husband. Joe's first love Elliot died two years ago, and he's been frozen ever since. But when they get to Fire Island, things don't go quite as expected, and Joe ends up taking a room with a pair of older, eccentric gay men named Howie and Lenny. Meanwhile, Howie and Lenny are trying to figure out which young man on Fire Island is the innocent man that needs to be protected from a great evil, and the leader of their coven, Max, is sick and unable to help. In a summer of love and heartbreak, Joe and Ronnie find friendship, love, and most importantly, themselves.

Side plot of trying to attract your crush while organizing an ACT UP benefit.

I think that I was not 100% the right reader for this book, but it was still good. I had expected something either more campy or more paranormal, and this was much more focused on Joe's personal journey through grief and fighting his figurative demons. I think that the intended reader will enjoy this book.

The couple does get their own Happily Ever After but I think I would consider this more of a 1980s historical fiction (lol) with light fantasy than a true romance novel.

Big CW for: drugs, alcohol, grief, AIDS epidemic

Thank you to Netgalley and Alcove Press for this ARC.

4 stars

The cover and the title brought me here, but the emotion and the sense of time and place kept me going. This book might look like a party, but it's a lot deeper than that.

Anyone who lived through this time or is old enough to have been deeply impacted by the immediate aftermath will be totally gripped by the plot, setting, and characters. You basically need to be a disco witch to come through the horrors of this period with any shreds of hope left, and that's reflected in multiple ways through these compelling characters and situations.

I really enjoyed the quirky characters, touching motifs, and general descriptions of love and lust and especially the struggle between loving someone and fearing the inevitable moment when you have to part from them. This one got to me in an unexpectedly good way.

I don't know if it's the current political climate or the time of year, but this book was just what I needed.

In a time of rhetoric about division and the dreaded "otherness" lurking in the wild, ready to corrupt The Children, I just needed a cozy story about some elderly disco witches.
In lieu of summarizing the plot, I want to talk about why this novel was effective for me and how books don't have to be narratively perfect for them to feel like a cozy hug from an old man in a caftan.

Queer community, especially one that spans generations, is so important to everyone in said community. From the disco queens to the baby gays to the lesbians who were a pillar of help and hope during the AIDS crisis, everyone plays a part and makes the community stronger with shared knowledge and tradition.
Fire Island is known for being a hedonistic paradise for wealthy gay men to let loose during the summer. The hedonism of the era was dampened by HIV and AIDS and I thought this book did a great job showing both sides of the spectrum. There were people who had either contracted the virus or lost multiple loved ones to it who wanted the world to stop and acknowledge what was happening. There were others in the same circumstances who wanted to pretend that things were normal and that these summers could continue like any other.
The discord in the community is heightened in this story. The disco witches live in their magical house which has shrines and tributes to the ones they've loved and lost prominently displayed. They check in with one another and look out for everyone on the island. Whereas, the rich assholes who plunder this community for a profit are shown to be selfish and unrelenting when it comes to destroying these tight bonds for monetary gain.

I think that's what this book does incredibly well is showing that a tight-knit group can always make magic as long as they believe in their cause. The history of HIV/AIDS activism and gay rights has been rainbow-washed in the media. The first pride was a riot. Every single progression toward equal rights was fought for by thousands of people who laid the path for their future brothers and sisters on which they might walk a bit easier. Having the disco witches be from that generation and seeing them watching out for the younger men on the island, trying to save them from self-destruction, really hammered home how much we owe our elders in marginalized communities.
In times of crisis, the most important thing to have is a community of people who know exactly how to organize.

The mystical spin on the very real pain and fear that accompanied being a young gay man living during the AIDS crisis was a nice touch. The egregor (in the form of a muscled gladiator man) chasing Joe throughout the book being a symbol for self-destructive behavior, disease, self-hatred, and being as old as time itself was a chilling reminder of all the things that plague young people who are still trying to figure things out. Living with the guilt of being healthy while so many of your friends and partners waste away in front of your eyes, living with the shame of knowing that your family has disowned you and finds your lifestyle morally repugnant because of religion, living with the disgust and scorn of the general public because the president of the US refuses to acknowledge the epidemic that is killing everyone you love and the majority of the country is cheering on the disease to eradicate you.

Sometimes the only thing that can save you is five disco witches burning down the dance floor.

Highly recommend this book. Thank you to NetGalley and Alcove for supplying me with an eARC in exchange for an honest review. I honestly cannot wait to buy a physical copy of this one.

This book did an amazing job of putting me in a time & place in history. I feel like the early days of the AIDS crisis is not brought up in books lately so it was interesting to read one where it affects so many characters. I however did not like it was advertised as fantasy but that wasn’t true. Magical realism maybe, but not a full blown fantasy.

3.5

📚 Review: This book was sweet! I feel like there was a lot of care put into the topics discussed, and into the characters. While not all of them were likeable, I liked most of them anyways. And I love a book with old gays 🙌. I did feel like the pacing was kind of slow, but overall I enjoyed the book and the writing. There were some sentences I had to stop and read multiple times because they hit hard. There was a lot of personality in this book and I’m glad I read it.

To be completely honest, I was a little disappointed with this book. Based on the title alone, I was hoping for a campy, witchy read. I think the writing could use some polishing, and maybe some of the minor story lines could be reined in a bit to create a more cohesive story as a whole. I liked the characters, but again felt they needed some polishing. Overall, I did like the concept, and I loved that there was significant character growth and development throughout the book.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy of Disco Witches of Fire Island in exchange for my honest review.

It would be difficult to argue that this book doesn't commit to itself and its premise. If you can buy in to the vibrant, immersive world and the fantastical cast of characters, you will have an amazing time on Fire Island. There is a certain amount of cynicism that has to be checked at the door to do so, but I feel like that's a worthwhile exercise for most of us nowadays anyway.

Rather than being a hardcore fantasy book, I would say that this feels almost more like a "through the looking glass" kind of story; there's something about the magic that feels contained to the place and time of the events, even as we know that the disco witches have moved and practiced their arts over a variety of settings over the course of time. Our main character, Joe, encounters this mystical new place as many characters do: heartbroken, afraid, ashamed, and in denial about most of it. When he leaves the island at the end of the summer, he has a new outlook on life all thanks to the life-changing season he has passed.

With that perspective in mind, it's safe to say that I enjoyed my time with Disco Witches of Fire Island. It's one of those books that leaves you feeling like a wide, open road lies ahead, waiting for your adventures. Not because you've never encountered any difficulties, but because you've been able to leave them behind you.

Absolutely pulled in by that cover.

Historical fiction with a bit of magic. Set in the late 80s during the AIDS crisis-Joe is trying to heal from losing his boyfriend Elliot and is convinced by his bff to spend the summer working at fire island.

A quirky story about love, healing, grief and all consuming fear. I enjoyed this book and would love to be in a disco witch coven…

Thanks to netgalley and alcove press for an eARC.

Let me start this by saying that this was, for me, one of those rare books where I felt such affection for this group of characters that I was a little sad to leave. It also reminded me of two things: one was reading Tales of the City for the first time after moving from my small hometown to the city at the same age as one of the main characters. Just being able to live her adventure as I was also living mine. And two, going to one of my favorite clubs with my friends on Sunday nights when they had “trash Disco”! In other words, this was a combination of those two feelings for me.
Summer of 1989- the AIDS epidemic is still a death sentence that the government cares nothing about but cannot be ignored by the gay community. So many have lost lovers, friends, mentors, or family. Every new acquaintance gives everyone pause wondering if they are infected. This is where we find Joe. Having lost his first and only love to the disease two years earlier, Joe is mired in grief and a feeling of nothingness that he can’t move past. Random hookups are all he can handle at the moment. This is how he meets Ronnie. They understand afterwards that they can really only be friends. Ronnie takes it upon himself to try and teach Joe how to flirt, pick up men, and basically get him to aim higher in life.
When Ronnie presents the opportunity to bartend on Fire Island for the summer so they can find rich men and have fun, Joe reluctantly agrees. Unfortunately, when Joe arrives he finds out the plan is not going to go the way they planned- no housing or bartending job awaits Joe. Luckily, when he got off the ferry he was fortunate enough to meet two quirky men named Lenny and Howie who gave him their number and a promise to help him out if he was ever in need. They turn out to be as good as their word and give him a room for the summer and help him get a bartending job. This is where our summer adventure starts!
Little does Joe know, Howie and Lenny are actually Disco Witches whose job it is to look out for the troubled and protect them from the Great Darkness. The truth about their abilities unfolds slowly throughout this story. Like I said, every character has secrets. But it’s worth the wait in my opinion.
Every chapter starts with a paragraph from the Disco Witches Manifesto, which I loved. The story takes place over the whole summer, every character has a moment , and there are many ups and downs throughout- just like life. I don’t want to give too much away, so I’ll just end with this: I loved these characters and I hope you will too.
**Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book early!**

Thé mystery and fantasy of this book was something out of my wheel house but I loved it. These characters were so vibrent I feel like I met them in real life.