Loved reading the inspirational and captivating story. While Samantha is walking the pipeline for her father, Samantha waves at the train with a bone in her hand, but when Leo sees the bone, it looks like a dinosaur bone and gets off the train to talk to Samantha. Read the highly recommended, wonderfully written, and a must read riveting romance story.

Hope’s Enduring Echo is the first book I have read written by Kim Vogel Sawyer and I look forward to reading more. This was an easy read, but also well written. It hooked me in from the start.

The character development was great. There were many layers to this. I loved getting to know Jennie and her relationship with God, her family and Leo. Watching the Ward family struggle through Mr. Ward’s struggle with depression and how they worked together.

I enjoyed the storyline and setting. Having lived in Colorado for some time, I had such a fun time envisioning Jennie walking the line in the mountains. I also really loved the Paleontologist storyline. It is not very often that comes along in this time setting, so this was a fun one to read and imagine. Going on a dinosaur hunt in the mountains was a joy.

The romance was so sweet and well written. It was very light and nothing over the top. It was a slow build; friendship to love relationship. It was absolute perfection for this reader.

Kim Vogel Sawyer did a great job intertwining faith throughout the book. Even touching on some fun issues like evolution, and still sharing the gospel while doing work that was different then the family pastoral role. Dealing with depression in a time when it was not as widely known about. This was really encouraging and well written.

*I received a complimentary copy from the author and voluntarily chose to review it. All opinions are my own.

Hope's Enduring Echo by Kim Vogel Sawyer

This is a sweet story about a 17 year old girl, living in Canon City Colorado in 1915. Her father was hired by the Water Works Department to check the water pipes for any damage. They live in a cabin in an isolated area where Claude walks the pipeline every day. But two years ago Claude fell and broke his leg. Which did not heal correctly. Leaving Claude unmotivated and depressed. Jennie has been walking the pipeline ever since.

Leo Day, a student from the University of Denver, saw Jennie waving a old bone that appeared to be from a dinosaur. This is exactly what he has been looking for. Jennie and Leo form a friendship as they hunt the mountain for more bones.

This story has great character development, with lots of lessons that are learned along the way. I enjoyed the secondary characters were well. A faith based clean story. Kim Vogel Sawyer is an excellent writer as testament to her other works. She weaves faith throughout as her characters find hope in their reliance of God.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received via NetGalley. All views expressed are my honest opinion.

Kim Vogel Sawyer always writes a pretty story and Hopes Enduring Echo is a lovely story. Do you love dinosaurs, adventure and romance? Then you’ll love this book!

I really enjoy this author’s writing. She is very clear and does a wonderful job building her characters.

I like that she uses the narrative of 3 different characters to share the story. The story is not too dramatic but wonderful lessons about faith and patience.

Hope’s Enduring Echo by Kim Vogel Sawyer

Jennie is seventeen-years-of-age and lives with her parents, Etta, and Claude Ward, near Canon City, Colorado in an isolated little house. Six-years-ago, Claude was hired by the Canon City Water Works Department to check the water pipes that run right past their property for any damage. If the pipes are not regularly checked and become damages and break there will be no running water to the city.

Two years ago, Claude broke his leg, and it did not heal right leaving Claude depressed and always in a dark mood. Jenni and her mum live under a cloud of constant tension never knowing when Claude’s mood might go dark. Now Jennie does the long walk each day checking the pipes.

Leo Day is a student of Paleontology from University of Denver, he is passing Jennie on her walk, and she started waving while holding and old bone which Leo recognises as a Dinosaur bones. Leo is so excitement, this is exactly what he has been dreaming of, to find a dinosaur skeleton and now there is proof that somewhere nearby there is one.

A wonderful book that portrays Gods love, mercy and hope when all seems lost.

I would like to thank Net Galley and Water Brook & Multnomah Publishers for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review

Another wonderful Christian historical read!
Set in the hills of Canon City, Colorado in 1915, it is a story full of deep spiritual insights, characters who struggle with family issues and keep going through tough situations. This well-written story by a seasoned author will have you rooting for the underdogs and cheering with them in the end.

"Hold onto hope."
Leo and Jennie have a wonderful, caring friendship that is rare these days. Unselfish and hard-working young people who encourage each other and reach for hope, restoring their faith along the way. "Patiently waiting on the Lord is the essence of hope, Jennie."

The topic of biblical creationism that is woven into the storyline is interesting, alongside the theory of evolution that was pushed forward at that time. Also addressing mental health issues when psychology was a newer area of medicine, added even more depth to the story.

Highly recommend for readers who enjoy a solid Christian historical read, with a bit of squeaky clean romance. A good read for teens and up.

(An ebook was provided by the author via NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.)

This author does a great job of portraying hope throughout her stories. I loved how the character was standing in the echo of someone else's hope. I could almost feel the peace in the setting as Jennie walks the line each day.

The mental health struggles that Mr. Ward experiences during the book may be difficult for some readers. The author is able to fully describe the struggles that he is facing which is hard to read about.

It was exciting to delve into the world of paleontology and looking for dinosaur bones. Leo is such an insightful young man and shares Biblical truths easily.

Mrs. Ward is such a picture of grace and loving and respecting your spouse in sickness as well as in health. She was a great character.

Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.

HOPE’S ENDURING ECHO by KIM VOGEL SAWYER is the beautifully written story of the Ward family who live in a cabin on the outskirts of Canon City Colorado in 1915, whose job it is to check the wooden pipeline running next to the Arkensaw River. The story is sensitively told and the characters’ emotions are brilliantly analysed. The book’s title is very good, underlining the message of hope running through it. We see Jennie taking hold of her mother’s “echo of hope” as she faces her beloved father’s physical and mental breakdown and mourns the man he used to be……
There are two things Jennie asks the Lord for. One is for Him to heal her father and the other is for a friend.When Leo Day sees her walking the pipeline, brandishing what looks like a dinosaur leg, it seens as though they have each had their prayers answered…….
Leo comes from a long line of Presbyterian pastors, but, although he is a committed Christian, his passion is for paleontology, much to his father’s distress. I like the way Leo takes care of the Ward family, and also the way he believes strongly in creationism…….
I am not going to tell you any more for fear of spoiling things for you.
I cannot recommend this lovely read strongly enough.
I was given a free copy of the book by NetGalley from Waterbrook & Multnomah. The opinions in this review are completely my own.

When I requested to read this book, I wasn't sure what to expect, as I haven't read many of Kim Vogel Sawyer's novels. However the plot really intrigued me, and I was pleasantly surprised when NetGalley approved my request!
As I started reading, though, I realized this book was so much more than it seems!
The growth of the characters, the author's love for God evident on every page, the characters that held steadfast to their faith, even when time's were tough, and our main characters that helped each other so much in their faith and hope were such beautiful elements of the story.
I was really intrigued by the paleontology elements, and the dinosaur hunt.
I felt that the mental health topics were done very well, and in an educating and positive way!
The only thing I wished, was that it had an epilogue.
I very much enjoyed this novel, and look forward to reading more from Kim Vogel Sawyer!

A young woman in 1915 Colorado prays for a friend while she walks miles a day inspecting a wooden water line in place of her father, who was injuring in an accident and remains despondent. When a young man jumps from a train to meet her, and investigate the dinosaur bone in her hand, both of their lives change forever. An enjoyable read, even if I disagree with the author's premise on creationism.

Kim Vogel Sawyer is one of my favorite authors when it comes to Christian fiction and her new release each year instantly becomes one of my most anticipated releases so I was thrilled to receive a copy to read and review early (a big thank you to the publisher and to NetGalley!).

This author’s books always have characters that tug at your heartstrings and this book was no different. Jennie and her mother Etta were both dealing with so much and through it all managed to keep positive attitudes. Etta, in particular, never lost her faith. There was no villain to the story per se, but Jennie’s father is dealing with quite a bit as well, which added some conflict to the story.

I liked both Jennie and Leo (the MMC). Leo, who comes from a long line of pastors, wants to study paleontology instead and feels somewhat ostracized from his family because of that. He was very much a faith filled character as well (despite not wanting to be a pastor) and I liked that he encouraged Jennie in her faith.

I really enjoyed the secondary characters as well, like Jennie’s aunt and uncle and Leo’s mentor (for lack of a better word). I also loved the puppy as well. I love how the dog came into their lives at just the right time and how devoted they all became to the dog as well. (And for those who are worried, the dog does not die!). As a dog person, I loved everything about that puppy.

My main complaint would be that the book definitely needed an epilogue! There is a segment set one year later, but I would have liked a check in to see how everyone was doing, especially given the changes they all went through. Overall this was a lovely read with an easy writing style and a wonderful, faith based story. I can’t wait to read more of this author’s books!

I knew this book was going to be great because I love the author but it was even better then I thought it would have been. I couldn’t put it down and finished it in one day. I highly recommend this book.

Kim Vogel Sawyer has a way with creating characters to love and get frustrated with. I also like how she incorporates things that maybe aren't as well known into her stories. Hope's Enduring Echo explores part of the great dinosaur bone hunt of the 1800s, but it also explores how mental illness like depression affected people during that time and how it was treated (for good or bad).

I didn't realize there were wooden water pipes like what was mentioned in the story-or that they had to be checked on by walking the full length.

I enjoyed Jennie's story. I felt she had great growth over the course of the story. Leo was quite the gentleman who supported her and never made her feel less because of her lack of formal education and background.

I felt that the handling of Jennie's father's mental health was done in a very positive light showing the ups and downs and challenges for that time. The worry of being put in an insane asylum was always a concern--

There are great inspirational messages (as usual!) woven into the story about encouragement in the middle of storms and trusting in God for all outcomes.

4 stars

*Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for the ARC of this to review. All opinions are 100% my own.

Such an inspirational read. As I face my husband's illness and disability it is an encouragement to keep my eyes firmly focused on God and his love for me. God is faithful and this story was a huge reminder to keep seeking him.