If you liked “You Got Mail” and “The Hating Game” you will love this! “Last Night Was Fun” is an Enemies to Lovers book about Emmy and Gabe. Both work together as analysts for a Major League Baseball team and are up for the same promotion. With industry one for the boys, Emmy, feels she has to put on a tough exterior to keep up and win especially with handsome and experienced Gabe who is a former baseball player. Emmy has her eye on the prize and there should be no distractions.

One night, Emmy gets an unknown number text and instantly hits it off with the stranger. She breaks her own rules and finds herself texting mystery man more. She unexpectedly found someone she can connect and banter with and asks to meet up and come to her sister’s wedding with her. Much to her dismay, her pen pal is none other than Gabe, her work nemesis. Both are shocked by the reveal. With the pressure of knowing her awful ex-boyfriend will be at the wedding, Gabe still agrees to go. What Emmy doesn’t realize is that there really is a fine line between love and hate.

This book was so cute. I read it in one day and it had me giggling and clutching at my heart. Really loved the banter between the two characters. It was a 10/10

I received this book through the published as an ARC on NetGalley. Cannot wait for the book to come out!

5 stars! I absolutely LOVED this book - baseball! Banter! Bird puns! What’s not to love?

I loved everything about this book - the setting (we love a SoCal moment), the career of both MCs (stats/data nerds), the banter/comedy, && that it was an enemies-to-lovers sports romance is the icing on the cake! There were several points throughout the book that I was literally cackling and also points where I was giddy as all hell. I also appreciated that the MCs had some similar trauma and that the story wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows, this made it feel like their connection was even more real.

I loved Gabe, the MMC, from the jump. At first, I was frustrated with and wanted Emmy to be a bit more confident - but I quickly came to appreciate that as a reader we were on that growth journey with her!

I read this book in less than 24 hours, and will definitely recommend to my friends!

Thank you to the author, Holly Michelle, Avon and Harper Voyager, and NetGalley for the eARC of this book. I am voluntarily leaving an honest review after reading this eARC. I will post to Amazon when the book is published!

Emmy is one of few women in her field. She battles to prove herself and fit in amongst her male colleagues and often finds herself in competition with one in particular. Emmy will not let him beat her for the promotion she’s been working so hard to get. Work seems like all she has after her last boyfriend gave her the ultimatum of work or him. So dating is not a top priority.
Then she receives a text from an unknown number clearly meant for someone else. What could have been a quick “sorry wrong number” conversation turns into friendly banter and the wish for something more.

This was a cute, albeit predictable read. The characters are likable and realistic and the writing is better than average. I enjoyed it but it kept me wanting more substance. The storyline followed a simple path that didn’t have any twists or turns. The foreshadowing was painfully obvious. Based on other reviews, my thinking may be in the minority but the tropes felt overdone and clunky. You had secret identity, forced proximity/ one bed, enemies to lovers, he falls first, a bit of grumpy/sunshine, fake relationship to make an ex jealous, hot jock, and some. And I really couldn’t enjoy their nicknames for each other: are ‘bird girl’ and ‘axe murderer’ suppose to sound cute? I found both cringy. Even a simple ‘birdie’ and ‘axe’ would work for the joke without sounding insulting.

Thank you NetGalley and Avon and Harper Voyager for this ARC in return for my truthful review.

I loved this one. Sports? Check. FMC killing it in a male-dominated field? Check check. Workplace romance, enemies to lovers, fake dating, one-bed. Check, check, check. Oh and a wrong number. All the things we love to see.

If you enjoyed The Hating Game, you'll like this one.

My only beef with this one? There was so much character development and the characters were handling the relationship in such a mature and adult way that the third act breakup was so frustrating. It was such a whiplash of over-reactionary tactics that it almost threw me out of the story entirely. Had I not fallen in love with both main characters and wanted to see them get their happy ending, I might have stopped reading entirely. But don't let that deter you -- overall it's a 5 star, stick with it!

To start, I absolutely love books that start with a wrong number. It's always so fun and leaves me feeling super giddy. Overall, this was a really cute and fun romance!!

I was awarded a NetGalley ARC from publisher Avon/Harper Voyager in exchange for my honest review.

What a cute, fun, romance!!!! This combined several of my top loves....love, baseball, and Southern California. What's not to love??? This was such a cute story. I loved the "unexpected" romance that went from spark to wildfire in an instant. The characters take a chance on following their heart with a love that probably shouldn't work out but does. Take those chances people....you never know what might happen! And a story of a woman trying to make her way in a typical man's world....always inspiring to me! I would have liked the MFC to be a bit stronger and more confident, but leaning in and growing in her confidence and sense of self is part of what made the story come together. She learned that she had more respect than she had thought from those around her all along.

Predictibale.....yes. Probable...no. Fun to read....ABSOLUTELY! Just curl up and ENJOY.

My first read from this author and I will definitely be looking for more!

#LastNightWasFun #NetGalley

Alright, let me just say it— Last Night Was Fun by Holly Michelle/James was delicious. Like, giggling-while-reading, clutching-my-chest, heart-eyes delicious. I’m already pre-grieving the day it leaves my NetGalley shelf because I need this on my actual bookshelf. June 2025 cannot come fast enough.

Emmy is super focused on her career as a baseball data analyst, navigating the pressure of being the only woman in her role and constantly proving her worth. Gabe, her equally talented coworker, is confident, occasionally blood-boiling, and carrying his own weight of expectations and regrets. Their professional rivalry simmers with tension (I mean I DEFINITELY would have thought they were hooking up if I worked with them lmao), but behind the scenes, an accidental text sparks an anonymous connection neither of them expected.

Here’s what I loved most: Emmy and Gabe talk. Like, really talk. Their relationship isn’t built on grand gestures or constant misunderstandings—it’s built on vulnerability, genuine connection, and the willingness to show up for each other, even when it feels scary. Sure, they hit a bump in the third act (it’s romance, hello!), but it didn’t feel contrived or dragged out. Instead, their relationship helps them grow, teaching them to trust themselves and each other in ways they hadn’t before.

The emotional depth in this story is so well done—grief, guilt, and the weight of family expectations are explored with so much tenderness. Emmy and Gabe are both carrying their own quiet heartbreaks, and watching them help each other heal was such a beautiful thing to witness.

And the tropes? Absolutely delivered:
✨ You’ve Got Mail vibes (without feeling dated—so charming).
✨ Slow burn (the kind where every glance, every touch makes your chest flutter).
✨ Workplace tension meets emotional connection (yes, please).
✨ Only one POV (Emmy carries the story perfectly).

Oh, and let’s not skip over the spice—it’s thoughtful, it’s meaningful, and it’s woven in so naturally that it feels like an extension of their emotional intimacy.

At its heart, Last Night Was Fun isn’t just about falling in love—it’s about learning to let yourself be seen, even when it feels risky. It’s about healing old wounds, breaking free from assumptions, and finding someone who feels like home.

So yeah, pre-order this book, clear that weekend, and let yourself sink into a story that will make you laugh, swoon, and maybe even tear up a little. It’s so, so worth it. 💛

Thank you netgalley for the chance to read this!
So I adore "You've Got Mail" so it was absolutely no surprise to me that this plot hooked me: a chance encounter over text between two singles leads to a not so exciting meet cute: Emmy and Gabe aren't actually strangers, but bitter work rivals. I adored all the extra smattering of tropes: fake date at a wedding, one bed, work rivalry: every single one of them worked for me. This is the kind of tension I crave: bubbling right under the surface until it crashes together. I also really loved that this was set in the baseball world of analytics (such an under-represented field!) but also really touched on issues like substance abuse and misogyny in the industry. It was done in a super tactful but impactful way and I loved that.
I really love Gabe in this: he is at times really oblivious to how his actions have undercut Emmy's career, but he clearly wants to stand up to those things and I thought his genuineness really shined. The banter is delicious, the chemistry is perfect, and while I didn't love the third act break up it got resolved quick enough that it was ok.
ALSO: yay for a quick Name Your Price shoutout! Loved it.

This book was fun! Wrong number, enemies to lovers, baseball, nerdy main characters, one bed, and San Diego. A nice, predictable, quick read. 3.5 stars.

The description of "You've Got Mail" x "The Hating Game" was spot-on with this one! I adored Last Night Was Fun. I won't be surprised if this one gets turned into a movie!

hurtful and humorous romantic comedy that examines the complexities of love, relationships, and self-discovery in the modern world. Readers seeking a humorous yet thought-provoking read will enjoy this new and captivating tale. This book was fantastic! I was unable to put it down because it was such a great workplace romance. Although the conflict in the third act was a little predictable, it was still excellent overall!

I highly recommend Last Night Was Fun. Such an enjoyable romantic comedy that starts with a text to the wrong number..... I couldn't book this book down, once I started reading it. I can't wait to see what Holly Michelle writes next.

I loved this book so much. Normally I'm immediately turned off by a book written in 3rd person - but this one was so good, I didn't even mind.

Yes, the plot is predictable, but it was so well done. I loved the dynamic between the characters. I loved the backgrounds and how all of that influenced who they were as people.

It was excellent and I'm definitely going to go through this author's backlist and start reading all her books.

Last Night Was Fun by Holly Michelle is a charming and witty romantic comedy that explores the complications of modern-day relationships, love, and self-discovery. It’s a fresh, engaging story that will appeal to readers looking for a lighthearted yet meaningful read.

A charming romance set in the world of professional baseball, this story features a workplace rivalry that transforms into an unexpected love story. It has a delightful mix of humor, heart, and a touch of intrigue reminiscent of "You've Got Mail." The plot revolves around Emmy Jameson, a brilliant data analyst for a Major League Baseball team, who excels at her job despite the many challenges of being a woman in a predominantly male industry. When a promotion puts her in direct competition with Gabe Olson, another talented analyst, sparks begin to fly—but not just in the way you'd expect.
Emmy is intensely private and keeps her personal life strictly separate from work. She’s also sworn off dating, but everything changes when she receives a mysterious text from an unknown number saying, “Last night was fun.” As it turns out, a stranger at a bar handed out a fake number—Emmy’s number—and what starts as an awkward mix-up soon turns into a series of engaging text exchanges. Over the next few weeks, the anonymous texter becomes someone Emmy can confide in, and she starts to feel a growing connection, even considering inviting him to her sister’s wedding in Cancun.
Here’s the twist (and don’t worry, it’s not really a spoiler—it’s hinted at early on): the mystery man is, of course, Gabe. The gradual build-up to this revelation is filled with clever banter and genuine emotion, making it all the more satisfying. Emmy’s nickname for the anonymous texter, “Axe Murderer,” adds a comedic touch, while the deepening connection between the two characters highlights the vulnerability and trust involved in falling for someone who truly sees you.
The book also delves into the challenges women face in male-dominated fields, portraying Emmy’s workplace struggles with authenticity and frustration. It’s a reminder of the resilience and effort required to thrive in such environments.
With its blend of sports, sharp dialogue, and a compelling enemies-to-lovers dynamic, this story is an excellent choice for fans of romantic comedies. Perfect for a summer getaway, it’s equal parts entertaining and heartfelt.
Special thanks to netgalley and avonbooks for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.

The rating I gave this book was a 4.5/5 rounded up. Last Night Was Fun is classic enemies to lovers with a playful twist of the unexpected. The book is such a cute romcom. I would have to say the few spicy scenes in the book did not feel as intrusive as I would have expected and I love that. It felt more intimate. My only complaint about the book was the fact it was written in 3rd person point of view. I want to feel like I am experiencing Emmy's emotions first hand not just her outside world but I have to admit I did feel I knew what was happening inside her head but I think first person point of view would make it more personal to the reader. But overall this cute romcom is a must read.

I absolutely loved this book! It was such a good work place romance, I could not put it down. I loved the MMC and thought it was so sweet when he went fishing with the MFC's dad. I definitely want a physical copy for my bookshelf and will be rereading and recommending this book.

Cute enough to make me want to read some of the author's other books at some point. I always love the women in men's fields storyline and baseball is my favorite sport so that hooked me right away. Not the most original of stories, but enjoyable enough.

I really enjoyed reading this, it had that element that I was looking for and enjoyed the concept of enemy to lover. It had that baseball feel that I was looking for and was engaged with what was going on in this. I thought the romance element was perfectly done and was glad I got to read this. Holly Michelle has a strong writing style and was glad I was able to read this.

This book really is a combination of You’ve Got Mail & The Hating Game. It was so cute and sweet. The text messages were funny and hooked you from that first one. Gabe is adorable and romantic. Emmy is strong but stubborn. The moments at the wedding were my favorite. I loved that they got to work out personal issues they were struggling with and it helped them grow as characters. You won’t be disappointed in this one. Swoon-worthy moments!