Member Reviews

This was a light and fun Christmas novella.
The author was able to take me from my hot and balmy location straight to the snow and chill of South Lake Tahoe.
Sam and Cole's story was sweet and uplifting, and the added thrill of a down to earth, genuine rockstar brought the swoon to a story that delivered great Christmas vibes.
It's a novella, having said that, I would have loved some depth to both characters and a bit more meat on the plot bones.

Was this review helpful?

I loved this Christmas rockstar novella! Cole & December are so sweet together! Loved the dynamics between the two of them and also with December’s family. A really cute quick read that I heartily recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Book Review: This December by Gillian Archer
Gillian Archer’s This December is a charming and spicy holiday romance that pairs a relatable heroine in the throes of a quarter-life crisis with a swoon-worthy rock star seeking solace during his off-season. Set against the picturesque backdrop of snowy South Lake Tahoe, the novel delivers a delightful mix of humor, heart, and steamy chemistry.

Meet the Characters
Samantha (Sam):
Sam is the everywoman protagonist navigating a challenging chapter of her life. At 26, she’s back at her parents’ house after losing her job and apartment, delivering groceries to make ends meet. Her self-deprecating humor and inner monologue are instantly relatable, making her a character readers can root for. Sam’s vulnerability and wit shine through as she grapples with her circumstances, ultimately embracing the idea of a no-strings-attached fling with a rock star.

Cole Jackson:
Cole is the kind of rock star every romance reader dreams of: effortlessly cool, yet surprisingly down-to-earth and attentive. While his public persona is larger than life, Archer does a fantastic job of peeling back the layers to reveal a man who is lonely, kind, and craving genuine connection. Cole’s interest in Sam feels authentic, and his ability to see past her chaotic exterior to the resilient woman beneath is heartwarming.

Chemistry and Romance
The relationship between Sam and Cole sizzles from their first awkward grocery delivery interaction. Archer captures the thrill of an unexpected connection, making their banter and flirtation feel natural and engaging. As their relationship progresses, the chemistry heats up, with steamy scenes that are as emotional as they are physical.

What sets This December apart is how Archer balances the fantasy of dating a rock star with grounded, realistic moments. Sam’s reluctance to fully trust Cole and her awareness of the inevitable expiration date on their fling add depth to the story, as does Cole’s struggle to reconcile his chaotic career with his desire for stability.

A Scenic Holiday Escape
South Lake Tahoe serves as a dreamy winter wonderland backdrop, with its cozy chalets, snowy vistas, and lively ski culture. Archer’s vivid descriptions of the setting enhance the festive atmosphere, making the book a perfect holiday read. Whether it’s Sam delivering groceries through icy roads or sharing intimate fireside moments with Cole, the setting feels alive and immersive.

Themes of Growth and Self-Discovery
While the romance is the heart of the story, This December also explores themes of self-worth, resilience, and rediscovery. Sam’s journey is as much about finding her confidence and rebuilding her life as it is about her relationship with Cole. Her internal struggles—feeling lost, inadequate, and unsure of her future—are universal, making her triumphs all the more satisfying.

Similarly, Cole’s arc involves confronting the emptiness of fame and his desire for authenticity in a world that often demands artifice. Together, their relationship serves as a catalyst for growth, pushing each to face their fears and embrace the possibility of happiness.

Strengths
Relatable Heroine: Sam’s voice is sharp, funny, and deeply authentic.
Steamy and Sweet Romance: The balance between emotional connection and physical attraction is well-executed.
Engaging Writing Style: Archer’s prose is conversational and accessible, making the book a fast and enjoyable read.
Holiday Atmosphere: The festive setting is perfect for readers looking to get into the holiday spirit.
Potential Criticisms
Predictability: As with many holiday romances, the story follows a familiar arc, with few surprises in its resolution. However, the journey is so enjoyable that the predictability feels more like a cozy comfort than a flaw.
Limited Depth in Secondary Characters: While Sam and Cole are well-developed, the supporting cast—particularly Sam’s family and Cole’s entourage—could have been fleshed out more to add richness to the story.
Final Thoughts
This December is a delightful blend of escapist fantasy and heartfelt romance, perfect for curling up with a blanket and hot cocoa during the holidays. Gillian Archer crafts a story that is equal parts sweet, steamy, and inspiring, with a protagonist whose struggles and triumphs will resonate with readers.

For fans of holiday romances with a touch of celebrity glamour, This December delivers everything you could hope for: a swoon-worthy hero, a relatable heroine, and a love story that will leave you smiling long after the final page.

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
Recommended for fans of Jenny Holiday, Christina Lauren, and festive, feel-good romances.

Was this review helpful?

The holiday season has barely begun and I was already in need of some festive escapism. This novella came through with the fairytale like story of a woman down on her luck, delivering groceries and living with her parents while she figures out her next steps who meets and charms a rock star. Not just any rock star, mind you -one who invites himself to family events and happily decorates cookies with the kids. Far fetched? Sure. Still exactly the dose of fantasy my heart needed.

I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

this review will contain spoilers.

I am glad this book was short because I was rolling my eyes. Maybe Im cynical because I am a divorced woman, but how quickly these two fell "in love" was crazy. It didn't feel like they knew anything about each other besides physical stuff. Then the sister was a really awful person to her.

I dont plan to share this title on instagram because I don't want to input my negative thoughts to the world, but just because I didn't like it does not mean that others wont. Their is an audience for every story.

Was this review helpful?

4 1/2 STARS!

Fast paced and highly addictive! If you're looking for a sexy holiday novella to get you in the mood for Christmas, look no further! Gillian Archer is delivering on a holiday fling turned forever with a rockstar and the down-on-her-luck delight he sweeps off her feet. Yes, obviously in a novella length story it's quick and could be developed more, but there's a whole lot of living and loving between Cole and December and not a whole lot lacking for a believable relationship. I loved every minute and only wished there was more! Great plot, fun characters and more emotional depth than you might expect.

Was this review helpful?

This December, is the perfect holiday romance novel. It's got a famous person who is down to earth. And someone who could care less about the fact that they are famous or not. It also was great that December's family was so into the Christmas holiday that they named their children after the holidays. I thought that was so unique.

Was this review helpful?