Member Reviews

Such a somber slice-of-life manga. There's a degree of Spy X Family-ness without the lightheartedness and family element. There's the same kind of division between the 'everyday life' and the 'action' worlds the characters occupy, but they interact very differently in this story. Shimazaki is running from a life of death and terror, desperately cherishing any glimpse of normalcy he can find. Rather than a comedic dramatic irony like in SxF, the slice-of-life elements are tinged with a kind of sadness from the life Shimazaki wasn't able to have before. In terms of the re-contextualizing of a trope, this could be seen to Spy X Family as Madoka Magica is to Sailor Moon. When the 'action' world intrudes into his life, it can be quite brutal. I imagine it will only get more so.

Was this review helpful?

Okay, how do I go about this...

It's easier to talk about the titles you enjoyed, and I'm still a bit ambivalent on what this first volume made me feel, but at least I can say I didn't like it. I understood that the series wanted to go for the "ex-killer turning a new page but still has to uses his old skills here and there" and do it in a less "Way of The Househusband" comedic way where Tatsu's dangerous past is diluted until nothing's left of the fact that he actually killed people. Unfortunately, the way series tried to take the matter seriously didn't work for me.

What really made me upset, however, was that whenever there's something dangerous has to happen in manga, and in Western media as well, it always happens in the Middle East. I'm tired of this part of the world solely being remembered for instability, war, or ruin. I think the series tries to balance that with introducing cultural foods/drinks from places Shimazaki visited over the years, which is supposed to serve as a "but they have good stuff too"! It was... nice, I guess? But not enough to save the series.

Was this review helpful?

This was pretty decent. Not my usual taste in manga, but glad I got the opportunity to read it.
Don't know if I'm going to continue with the rest of the series tho, like I said not really my usual taste in manga...

Was this review helpful?

"Shimazaki in the Land of Peace" is a haunting tale about being an ex-member of a terrorist group named LEL. These ex-members find themselves in colonies located in Japan trying to attain a better way of living. Unfortunately, everything doesn't become peaceful for them. Their new path is almost as dangerous as their former way. I didn't have any expectations for this story, but I was definitely drawn in by our main character Shimazaki. Shimazaki is kind and sharp. He is thoughtful and careful. I loved seeing his views through his art. The action in this manga is pretty good, but the plot is heavy with brutal imagery.

Was this review helpful?

This book caught my attention because the main character looks like an actor I like. I wouldn’t have normally even given this a second glance from the description. But reading it I became very engrossed in Shingo’s story, a little John Wick-ish with him helping the manga artists he starts working with and even the restaurant people with the violence he ran away from after being taken by the LEI and brainwashed as a child.

I’m very intrigued and do plan on reading the second one when it comes out so I highly recommend this title.

Thank you NetGalley and Kodansha for letting me read this in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I took a chance on this because the description immediately brings into mind The Way of the Househusband, and I need to stamp out any expectations on that front, as they will be to the detriment of the reading experience of Shimizaki.

Househusband lives firmly tongue in cheek, intending to be light and humorous and a bit silly but with loads of heart. Shimizaki follows the same basic idea of a man of violence retiring to a quiet life, but it does not intend to be light or heartwarming. Parts of it certainly are heartwarming as Shimizaki builds his new life, but it's a more quiet sort of story. There's no goofiness here, not really. It's pretty straightforward and more serious, as each chapter provides more of the violent backstory of Shimizaki's life.

Kidnapped as a child and raised in a terrorist organization, Shimizaki has a lot of heaviness on his shoulders as he returns to his childhood home of Japan and tries to retire and live a quiet life. He makes friends. He has a job. But the specter of his past is constantly hanging over him, and certain events means he still has to use his deadly skills to keep his quiet life quiet.

This is a decent story, but ultimately it fell flat for me. It's just...well, it's boring. I don't have much to say beyond that. Even with getting good chunks of backstory, I didn't find myself caring much for Shimizaki as a person.

The art is serviceable, but not very dynamic or exciting either. Characters often exist in blank white space in panels, and when backgrounds or other people are drawn, they're mostly there as a reminder that the world exists and that this isn't taking place in a completely blank void.

It's fine. Chapter 1 is free on the Kodansha website - give a try, it's a great indicator of if this story will work for you. It didn't for me, unfortunately.

Many thanks to Kodansha and NetGalley for the eARC for review. Shimizaki in the Land of Peace Vol 1 is available now.

Was this review helpful?

This book follows a man who has gotten out of a extremist group as he tries to readjust and assimilate into normal life. The art style was a bit gritty which showed the darker nature of what the main character has been through. The character development and the world building were a little lacking so there were many instances where I was confused. But an interesting start to a series nonetheless.

Was this review helpful?

After reading the comic I knew the same exact things I did by just reading the synopsis. It still feels not so much like a story, but a series of notes on a story; or, at least, a series of scenes set in someone's life... that we still don't know. It's also true that it's only the first book of a series, so we'll see how it goes.
Not really my style, but the idea behind it seems cool enough.

Was this review helpful?

This is just not my speed. The storyline is dull, but violent and a bit confusing. The art is good, but I'm just not a fan.

Was this review helpful?

I am very excited to see where this goes - I didn't expect to love the art style so much as its somewhat simple, but I ended up loving it by the end of volume 1.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley for the ARC! this manga was really intriguing and I'm excited to see what happens to Shimazaki in future volumes!

Was this review helpful?

You're thrown into a 50 year conflict between The League for Economic Liberation (LEL) and the International Community over economic inequality. Thirty years ago, Flight 0457 was hijacked and kidnapped by the LEL. After years of murders and brainwashing, a lone boy, Shingo Shimazaki, is the sole survivor of the hijacking. This is his story thirty years later.

Shimazaki is a man who longed for his home for 30 years while enduring training and missions that turned him into a soldier. I like how the mangakas did not make him an intimidating, stoic person. He can be happy. He hypes himself up for work, like someone at their first job. People can see how genuine he is, even if they don't know his past or unique set of skills.

He diffuses heated situations and tries to avoid conflict unless something happens to people he cares about or himself. This is a person the reader will be rooting for and want to see avoid his bloody past in exchange for an ordinary life. That's why the end of each chapter brings up a sense of tension where you know things will change but want to bask in the ordinary of Shimazaki's current life.

Each chapter has great pacing and leaves you wanting more. The authors blend the action and the mundane very well where nothing drags.

The volume introduces another member and friend of Shingo who were part of the LEL currently living in Japan. Counter of Shingo's active involvement in and attempts at peaceful resolutions, his friend's approach to situations is not getting involved in the community or their problems and suggesting people retaliate to resolve their issues.

I don't have any complaints nor suggestions on things the series could improve upon. I think the story was really good and each of the characters introduced were very interesting.

Overall, if you're looking for a series about a man with a dark, bloody history trying to achieve an ordinary life, I would highly recommend Shimazaki in the Land of Peace.

Was this review helpful?

I dig the warrior in the garden vibe of the story. The imagery is on point and the story is going in a good direction. I’d love to continue this manga and see where he ends up. I hope the character finds the peace he’s looking for.

Was this review helpful?

I've not read many comics, but I thoroughly enjoyed this story of an ex spy for a terrorist organisation, turned man who just wants to live a normal life.

The everyday mundanity of his life combined with flashbacks and violence as the organisation slowly tracks him down works so well.

Loved the art, and there were some powerful words that stood out to me, for example: If you ask me, we need imagination to protect ourselves. It's art that can reach the human heart. Violence doesn't have that kind of power.

Was this review helpful?

3.25☆

The story follows Shingo Shimazaki, who's returned to Japan after spending many years training and fighting for a terrorist organisation (the LEL). He's trying to lead a simple, quiet life, but his past doesn't seem to want to stay behind him.

Part 'slice of life' and part action, this was an engaging story. There were some flashbacks thrown in to help explain character backstories, but I was still left a bit confused about why Shingo was being followed, and what happened in his past that led him to flee the LEL - maybe this is resolved a bit more in further installments?

The novel has an interesting art style that worked well with the story, and I got a fair impression on who our main character was and how he lives. I enjoyed the side characters, and I'm looking forward to reading more and discovering their stories too.

Was this review helpful?

4/5 ⭐️

I really liked this volume! It starts out with Shimazaki escaping the LEL which is a terrorist organization and going back to his home in Japan. He wants to live a normal life after 30 years of being away from everything. The plot of the story was concise and gripped me till the end. I like that it explored political and societal concepts in each chapter and how it relates to the community Shimazaki surrounds himself with. It was nice seeing how episodic this was and the art style really matched the aura of the manga. I would like to see where the rest of the story goes and would recommend If you like slice-of-life thrillers!

Thank you NetGalley and Kodansha Comics for this e—ARC!

Was this review helpful?

Rating:3.5/5 ⭐
Review:
✨Overall, this is a quite easy read because this volume is the introduction of this series.
✨In terms of plot, it is still easy to understand with few flashbacks in it.
✨However, for characters, especially other than Shimazaki, I haven't really truly warmed up to them yet, but for me it is understandable for this volume.
✨I would say that because the backgrounds of many side characters were not told yet.
✨Even for Shimazaki, he’s still quite mysterious to me. Like, what actually happened to him? What triggered him to escape?
✨Although Shimazaki is in the land of peace and trying very hard to fit in with help from people around him, chaos still adamantly follows him. I feel bad for him.
✨In terms of drawing, I felt that the style portrays some kind of chaos a little bit, quite contrasting with the manga’s name, but on other hand, suits the plot.
✨For me, this series suits readers that prefer stories with main characters that have a dark history behind them.
✨Thank you to Kodansha Comics and #NetGalley for this ARC! This review was voluntarily written by me.

Was this review helpful?

Shimazaki is the biggest man child ever in this, but in the absolute best way possible.

While it doesn’t reinvent the wheel—there are plenty of manga with similar premises—but it’s really well done. I love stories where the main character is older and just now trying to figure life out, although this is from a former terrorist trying to start over angle.

Since Shimazaki has been all over the world, they even included foreign dishes, coffee, and little cultural details, which I thought was such a nice touch. Like, sure, he learned how to murder people, but he also picked up a lot about other cultures along the way. I love when stories sneak in little things like that—it’s always fun learning something new in the most unexpected ways.

This one kind of has it all—it’s a slice of life with comedy, but it also dives into heavier issues and, of course, has action and fight scenes. For something that covers so much, it’s surprisingly well-balanced. The writing even caught me off guard a few times with how deep it got.

Overall, I really enjoyed this one. It wasn’t necessarily my usual cup of tea, but it had some really great touches that stood out. If you’re into action manga or the synopsis catches your interest, I’d 100% recommend giving it a read~

Was this review helpful?

Shimazaki in the Land of Peace is very interesting! This is an alternate historical political thriller about Shingo Shimazaki, who was kidnapped by LEL as a kid and trained to be a killer of sorts. LEL is a terrorist organization brainwashing people to believe in their agenda. After thirty years Shingo Shimazaki managed to free himself and now he has returned to his native country, Japan. He just wants to live in peace. This isn't like Sakamoto Days, but darker and there's no humor as such. There's this depressing and suffocating feeling to the manga, which is super delicious. I also loved the whole setting and how LEL feels so familiar considering real history. I wish there were more stories like this, political ones I mean.

The art looks great and realistic. The flashbacks are awesome and overall the rhythm is nice, everything flows with easiness. I think I have to keep reading this, since it's hard to find series like this - they aren't made anymore. Their peak was in the 1980s. But! This surely is refreshing and somehow so different.

Was this review helpful?

An equally heartwarming and gory narrative that follows Shingo Shimazaki, a man who, after spending thirty years fighting for a terrorist organisation that kidnapped him as a child, has finally made it back to Japan and is planning to lead a quiet life, but old habits die hard, and his past just won't stay in the past.

Shimazaki in the Land of Peace is a riveting and genre-bending manga with a healthy mix of slice-of-life humour and gore. I loved the art style and the realistic depiction of PTSD. I highly recommend it particularly to readers who enjoyed works such as The Way of the Househusband and Spy × Family.

Was this review helpful?