Member Reviews

mystery, detective, multicultural, situational-humor, verbal-humor, fun, investigation*****

Let me whine a bit because the ebook is Not TTS enabled and my vision is not working well. I could only read part of it, but enough for me to go ahead and preorder the audio so I could laugh my way through another Vishi Puri mystery with that incredibly delightful cast of characters.
I requested and received a temporary uncorrected reader's proof from Severn House via NetGalley.
Avail Mar 04, 2025 #TheCaseoftheElusiveBombayDuck by Tarquin Hall #VishiPuriMysteriesBk6 @SevernHouse #NetGalley #CozyMystery #MurderMystery @goodreads @bookbub @librarythingofficial @barnesandnoble @waterstones ***** #Review @booksamillion @bookshop_org @bookshop_org_uk

Was this review helpful?

I hadn't read a Tarquin Hall mystery in so long, but was excited to reconnect with this cast of characters and see what they were up to! My favorite character by far is Tarquin's mother, who is unstoppable and such an entertaining and lovable read.

This book actually takes place mostly in London, which was a fun change. The description of the Desi community in London seemed accurate to me (or at least close enough for someone who has only visited), and the cultural differences and misunderstandings were funny but not too contrived or trite.

The mystery itself was two fold as Tarquin's wife and mother in law were involved with a mystery of their own, and we still got to hear about some of the other wonderful characters from past books as they did investigative work and research back in India.

I highly recommend this book to any mystery fans - it is a compelling read with fun and well developed characters. It would work as a stand alone read even though it is part of a series, and the mysteries are layered and complex so the resolution will be a surprise (or at least was for me).

Was this review helpful?

For those fans of Vish Puri, this is another great read in the mystery series this time set in London. All our favourite characters are there - his wife and his mum. It is not an easy adjustment for Vish Puri with the rainy cold weather and the underground but they all seem to enjoy their stay and accomplish a lot of problem solving. I am so thrilled to see Tarquin Hall add another book to his series!

Was this review helpful?

I was eagerly awaiting this one as I had read all the previous books in the series and the last one was a while ago.

This one really didn't work for me though. I understand the use of exaggerated humor (as in how Vish Puri's family talks) but with a very thin plotline, the same bits seem to be repeated with the intent of comedic effect. In the previous books, there were some funny bits (or atleast, that's how I remember it). This book just seems to be a rehash of the same, just in London. Once or twice is novelty, 6 times is not.

Was this review helpful?

‘The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck" by Tarquin Hall is the sixth book in the Vish Puri series, featuring India’s Most Private Investigator. I’m a new reader to this series and can’t wait to read the others as I really enjoyed this one.

Our hero is Vish Puri, a brilliant private detective and has a group of agents at his disposal: all of which are fun, colourfully written characters. The mystery is an intriguing, fun and engaging. As a first time reader jumping in, I really enjoyed it.

Was this review helpful?

Superb book, with delightful oddball characters, beautifully drawn. I loved the main character Puri, and his wonderful mother. Hadn’t realised that this is number six in a series of books featuring Detective Puri.
A treat awaits me in the form of the previous five books!

Was this review helpful?

The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck by Tarquin Hall is another delightful entry in the Vish Puri series. Vish, India’s top detective, is sent to London to find a fugitive while dealing with his meddling mother, Mummy-ji. The book is full of humor, cultural insights, and delicious descriptions of Indian food. Mummy-ji’s antics are a highlight, and Vish’s team adds charm to the story. Though it can be read alone, earlier books offer a richer experience. A fun, light-hearted mystery perfect for fans of witty, character-driven stories!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed reading about Delhi and London, the foods that Puri enjoys in both cities, and especially finding out about the Indian community in London, the foods, the nearby Hindi temple, etc. I was hoping for a light read with the humorous detective, but though the book started out that way, it became cumbersome to read. So many different people involved in the case, in India and in England, so many different cases of corruption and crime, and so many people arrested in the end.

Making the plots a little more streamlined and less elaborate would have made it a better read for me.

Was this review helpful?

"The Case of the Elusive Bombay Duck" by Tarquin Hall is the sixth installment in the delightful Vish Puri series, featuring India’s Most Private Investigator. As a long-time fan of the series, I was thrilled to see a new addition. And it is just as good as the other books!

The hero of the piece is Vish Puri, a brilliant private detective and owner of a detective agency who is offended when people dare to compare him to the fictional Sherlock Holmes. Unlike other classic detectives, he does not work alone and has a host of colorful agents at his disposal: Handbrake, Tubelight, Flush, to name a few. Also, there is Madam Rani, his secretary and the recorder of his exploits.

Vish is 59 years old, smart, patriotic, a master of disguise, and a passionate lover of everything fried and spicy (even if he's not allowed to). He is a detective in the old-fashioned sense. His main tools are common sense and intuition, combined with the technological skills and daring of his assistants.

When he wins the International Detective of the Year award, he is asked to keep it a secret. Within hours, it seems all of Delhi knows – including his indomitable Mummy-ji, who announces she will come with him and his wife Rumpy to the ceremony in London, much to their dismay. The plot thickens when a senior government bureaucrat asks him to track down India’s most-wanted fugitive, billionaire pharmaceutical fraudster code-named Bombay Duck, rumored to hide in London, a request he can't refuse.

Vish’s predicament is both humorous and chaotic as he juggles keeping the investigation secret from Rumpy - who would not approve of him working during their much-anticipated vacation - and from Mummy-ji, who has her own ways of meddling. Alongside his nephew Jags and Bromley, an English police detective, Vish dives into the case while his mother pursues an investigation of her own.

I absolutely loved the book! It’s brimming with humor, clever wordplay, mouthwatering descriptions of Indian food, and comparisons between the Indian and British cultures. Mummy-ji is a sharp, hilarious force of nature, and her adventures were a highlight. The story seamlessly weaves between London and New Delhi, juggling multiple plotlines that all tie together brilliantly.

While the book can be enjoyed on its own, I recommend reading the earlier installments to fully appreciate the characters and their dynamics. The chapters include helpful explanations of cultural concepts, and a glossary of Indian words and terms at the end enhances the experience.

Overall, this was a thoroughly enjoyable read that captures the essence of its settings and cultures. I found myself smiling at Vish’s struggles to find non-vegetarian food while staying with his vegetarian hosts, or when he failed to catch the irony of Inspector Bromley. If you’re a fan of Alexander McCall Smith’s series, you’ll adore this book even more - it delivers a richer mystery, vivid characters, and plenty of substance. Highly recommended!

* Thank you NetGalley and (publisher) for the opportunity to read this arc. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Thoroughly Engaging..
The sixth entry into the Vish Puri series of mysteries and the long awaited rerun of India’s finest and most enigmatic of detectives. Puri has discovered that he has won the International Detective of the Year award - supposedly a guarded secret, although it appears that the world and his wife already know of his success - and is to attend a ceremony in London. With wife and mother tagging along, an unexpected undercover mission on his plate (a fraudster code named Bombay Duck), Puri is at his wits end and, so, he enlists some help….what could possibly go wrong? A delightful instalment to the series, brimming with wonderful characterisation, perfectly executed backdrops and a pacy plot bubbling with wit, humour and satirical observations. Thoroughly engaging.

Was this review helpful?

Vish Puri, India’s Most Private Detective (and quirky gentleman), has won the International Detective of the Year award and travels to London to accept his prize. Mayhem and murder ensue, and author Tarquin Hall explores the intersection of Indian and British culture clashes to poke fun at the characters. Vish is a delight, a not-young detective genuinely curious about the world around him. The crimes explored in the book seem a bit caricatured (and the resolution of the Mummy-ji plot line feels rushed), but this is an excellent and fun read. Highly recommend!

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This had everything that I was looking for from the description. It had that mystery element that I was looking for and enjoyed the overall concept of this. I enjoyed the way the characters worked in the story and how everything worked to tell the story. It was written well by Tarquin Hall and enjoyed this as a entry in the Vishi Puri Mystery series.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Severn House for the eARC.
Detective Vishi Puri's dreams have come true: he's won the coveted International Detective of the Year award and is travelling to London. His wife and mother (Mummy) are accompanying him.
He's tasked with finding India's most notorious criminal,
Bombay Duck, who's supposedly hiding in the UK.
This is such a fun book, Vishi is such a delight and so is Mummy. Plus, the setting is London, what more can a reader want?

Was this review helpful?