Member Reviews

Thank you to NetGalley and @AlcovePress for this ALC, in exchange for an honest review.

This audiobook was incredibly entertaining! From start to finish, I was completely obsessed by the author’s writing, which was so polished and engaging, it felt like the work of a seasoned pro rather than a debut. The characters were wonderfully crafted, and I found myself rooting for both of them right from the beginning. The “enemies to lovers” dynamic between Rosie and Aiden was executed brilliantly, making it impossible to look away.

Their journey from constant bickering to slowly discovering each other’s strengths and, eventually, developing a deep romantic connection, was portrayed with such authenticity. The tension between them was palpable, and their gradual transformation into a couple felt natural rather than forced. There were bumps along the way, and that made their relationship all the more believable and satisfying.

If you're a fan of heartwarming romance, this one is a must-read. It’s witty, touching, and leaves you with that warm feeling that only a truly great romance can. Can't forget to mention that the narrator Katie Holt did a fantastic job. She brought the characters to life and made the story fun.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, just wow this enemies to lovers romance novel with forced proximity has to be the best romance novel I have read in a very very long time.

I am going to be honest I am not huge on romance but this is written so well and the characters are so easy to connect to that I found myself quickly being pulled into the story and wanting more.

I like that the sexual scenes weren’t there just for the basic plot of smut but that when it did get sexual it was actually adding to the storyline and to the characters themselves which is refreshing.

I highly recommend this book to everyone even to people that maybe aren’t so into romance or are just getting into romance, I immediately went out and bought a preorder for my girlfriend and myself.

As for the audiobook part of it Frankie Corzo did an amazing job at narrating the book and really brought the characters to life.

Was this review helpful?

An opposites attract / enemies to lovers romance. Rosie is from the south but strongly rooted in her Peruvian culture. She dreams of moving to New York as an aspiring writer. Aiden, also a literary fiction writer, but not a fan of romance, is the opposite of Rosie. Outspoken, obnoxious and rude.

When they continue to disrupt the class, their professor gives them an ultimatum if they want to stay enrolled- they have to write a book together.

Beautiful writing blending in their own feelings into the book they’re writing and seeing their relationship grow. The co-writing of the sex scene- so good !

As they start to build a relationship, they find themselves in a battle again for a writing opportunity. Once they enter the lovers stage, I felt like the plot fell apart and it was just one spicy scene after the next, aside from the final fall out/ misunderstanding.

Audiobook narration was great- cute, fun, spicy romance.

Thanks to NetGalley and RB Media for the ALC in exchange for an honest review. Out on 12/10/24.

Was this review helpful?

4⭐️ - “The entire time we were together all I could think was you were better than any dream, any piece of fiction I could ever write.” 🥹

Ohhhh my goodness, my romance loving heart ate this book up! This will speak to your soul if you are a lover of romance movies and books, ones that feel cheesy (in a good way) and classic and warm your heart.

Rosie and Aiden are exactly what I want in enemies to lovers in romcoms. I loved their banter and rivalry, and even before the romance heated up you could feel their romantic tension. Their character developments were done so well, and nothing felt forced. I am a huge fan of a grand gesture/happily ever after, and this book delivered! I was tearing up, basically crying in the last 10%….i don’t know if I’m hormonal or if it truly just made me emotional but… 🥹

I read the physical ARC as well as listened to the audiobook through NetGalley & RB Media. The narrator, Frankie Corzo, did a great job! I enjoyed her performance. The one thing I dislike, which is really no “fault” to her, is when a female tries to make a male voice and vice versa. That’s honestly my only critique. This would’ve been a 10/10 audiobook if it had dual narration.

Was this review helpful?

I'm going to say a 3.5 on this but I may change it. This is a really great debut romance novel and I liked the audiobook format of it but the ending really chafed me.

Overall the FMC was a bit much at times and made...interesting decisions. The MMC was fine but I wanted a bit more from him. The ending really killed the book for me. I rather not have an HEA than all that.

Them writing back and forth was kinda hot though. Def Hating Game vibes (maybe too much idk). I could see this translating to screen easily. I'm recommending it but with a grain of salt.

I would absolutely want to check out more from this author, really promising. I read this book as an audio ARC and am leaving my review voluntarily and honestly.

Was this review helpful?

I listened to this book in one day. I loved the chemistry between Aidan and Rosie/ Hunter and Max. It was enemies to lovers at its best! I also loved how they wrote their book together. The audiobook was good, but I think it would have been better with two different narrators. Sometimes it was hard to tell which character was narrating.

Was this review helpful?

This book was so great! There are few audiobooks that my boyfriend enjoys as much as I do and this was one of them. When I find him asking if we can relax on the couch and listen to the book I was listening to earlier I know I have found a winner. Not in My Book follows Rosie who is putting herself through school working on becoming a writer in New York City after moving away from her family and hometown in Tennessee. Feeling like she has a lot to prove she enters into her writing group with confidence and strong opinions. When the most attractive man she has ever seen catches her eye and announces he hates romance books with a passion. A rival begins and tension seems to always be rising.

What I really enjoyed about this book is that there are tender moments and deep feelings mixed with some laughter and spice! This book felt like When Harry Met Sally with it's romantic New York Scenes and trying to balance this love hate relationship they are constantly building. Plus there is great Christmas scenes which was a great surprise seeing as it's starting to be Christmas time now! I genuinely really enjoyed this book and Cannot wait to see what else this author puts out. I will definitely be continuing on with whatever else this author puts out.

I would recommend this book to anyone looking to read a rivals to lovers romance! Thank you NetGalley for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

Bookish Enemies to Lovers? Yes please!

Rosie and Aiden study at the prestigious NYU graduate writing program. The catch? While Rosie is a romance author trying to prove her and her genre's worth, Aiden writes Literary Fiction and despises romance - he doesn't even believe in Happy Endings! Their professor, Rosie's heroine and a romance writer herself, finally has enough of their antics and forces them to write a book. Together. Blending their genres. Suffice to say neither of them is thrilled. But a prestigious short story award by a literary magazine is Rosie's big hope for the next year of her studies, guaranteeing her tuition and a chance to bring romantic fiction the honour it deserves. But does the romance writer even stand a chance at her own happy ending?

I listened to the audio version of Katie Holt's newest book and the narrator did not disappoint. It was very lovingly narrated and well paced.

The book was enjoyable, well-written and well plotted. Plenty of humour and depth made for a great reading experience. There was some meta level with the excerpts from the book Rosie and Aiden write over the course of the novel, which was amusing and insightful. The family and friends are likeable secondary characters (mostly!).

If you are looking for a secretly sweet grump, bookish enemies to lovers with some spice, this book is for you!
Fincancial struggles and psychological abuse are mentioned, as are acts of a sexual nature, so be aware.

Overall, I would say the book is well written, with believable and relatable characters, a cute romance and a nice take on two very popular tropes: enemies to lovers and writers' romance.

Was this review helpful?

Honestly? I’m obsessed. I love a good enemies to lovers and the fact that they’re forced to write a romance book basically detailing their lives but still in denial about it until the first kiss scene, in the book and in their lives, is amazing. The banter and insults are hilarious while they were also able to dig deeper and be open and honest with each other while writing

Was this review helpful?

5 star debut from Katie Holt! I loved the premise of Not in My Book and this book was a slam dunk for me (one of my favorite romances from 2024!). I loved listening to Rosie and Aiden's story unfold as well as Rosie's family relationships. I look forward to reading more from Katie Holt in the future.

Thank you to RBmedia, Katie Holt and NetGalley for an advanced audiobook in exchange for my honest review. Not in My Book hits shelves on December 10, 2024.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you RBmedia for granting me an ALC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own and not influenced by the publisher.

Amazing debut! Loved this so much that I preordered a physical copy.

What to expect:
- BIPOC FMC
- Grumpy/Sunshine
- Forced proximity
- Enemies to lovers
- Slow Burn
- Steamy 🌶️🌶️🌶️
- HEA

Was this review helpful?

this was very cute! i loooved that rosie and aiden were forced to write together - the scenes where they were going back and forth writing had me laughing out loud. it was a pleasant surprise to have scenes taking place in NYC at christmastime too.

my only (small) complaint is that i didn't love the conflict. i correctly predicted the cause of it and that aiden had tried to stop it, but didn't like how he reacted when it inevitably came to light and he was confronted about it. i would have preferred immediate regret and groveling because he was truly in the wrong for not being honest with her.

i will definitely be watching to see what Katie Holt comes out with next because this was such a great debut 🫶🏻 thank you netgalley and RB media for providing me with an advance listener copy in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This book was slow-burn, angsty enemies-to-lovers perfection following two writers, Rosie and Aiden, who are forced to write a book together. From the very first chapter, the book felt like the perfect blend of Beach Read and The Roughest Draft, and it more than lived up to those comparisons with the self insert novel writing and genre swapping.

As they work on their enemies-to-lovers novel, the lines between fiction and reality blur. The inclusion of excerpts from their co-written story was a brilliant touch, amplifying the angst and yearning. Every snippet they write is a window into their hearts, filled with raw emotion and unspoken longing that had me completely hooked.

The romance is a masterclass in slow burn, delivering everything from charged glances to gentle touches and so much pining. The moment of them writing a sex scene over a phone call together was packed with tension.

I can’t believe this is a debut! Katie Holt’s prose is polished, and the characters are so vividly drawn that they feel real. This book is an unforgettable love story.

Was this review helpful?

OMG this was a masterpiece.
Enemies to Lovers was perfect.
The way the Maxine and Hunter intertwined with the real life events of Aiden and Rosie.
This was the best debut novel and you truly would not know Katie Holt hasn't been writing forever.
The narrator Frankie Corzo was perfect for this audiobook and could not be faulted.

Was this review helpful?

Audiobook Review 🎧 | NetGalley ALC

I wouldn’t call this an enemies to lovers but rather rivals to lovers.
These are two writers, one loves romance and the other literary fiction. They’re forced to write a book together and things get interesting.

Up until the last chapters I actually thought this was duet narration 😅 Frankie Corzo did a great job at embodying each characters!

I had to trust the process on this one because my biggest pet peeve with romance is the lack of communication and misunderstanding being the point of contention.
I wish this was a true rivals to lovers or enemies to lovers without them liking each other and just not knowing how to deal with these emotions other than despising each other.

Overall I did enjoy it and read it fairly quickly and with ease.

My rating system:
Narration: 5/5
Story: 3/5
Entertainment: 3/5
Emotions: 3/5
Overall: 3.5/5
Spice level: 🌶️🌶️

Thank you to NetGalley and RB Media for providing an advanced listener copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

THIS WAS A DEBUT?! Excuse meeee.... 🤯

GUYSSS, this enemies to lovers romance had me hooked from the VERY beginning. Two competing writers in a master's writing class that cannot get along AT ALL. Rosie and Aiden are at each other's throats about 99% of the time, but my oh my, the freaking tension between these two was honestly amazinggg 🔥 After fighting a bit too much, their professor forces them to write a book together to prove they can work together. These two literally fell in love while writing a romance book and holy gods, not only was this concept amazing, but damn was I INVESTED. I mean, this book brought me to literal tears at a few different times.

Truly cannot recommend this one enough! Also, Rosie's friend group was so so good - these characters added a whole other level of depth to the storyline that I really enjoyed.

📖 enemies/ rivals to lovers
📖 grumpy (MMC) / sunshine (FMC)
📖 slow burn romance
📖 both MCs are aspiring authors
📖 academic setting in NYC
📖 multicultural FMC (Peruvian/American from Tennessee)
📖 great banter
📖 open door

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley and rb media for the opportunity to listening to this audiobook. All thoughts are my own. Unfortunately the narrator made this hard to actually enjoy the book, i believe i would of enjoyed this much more if I chosen to read it instead. Rosie came off a little whiny and stuck in her ways, while Aiden was a little more relatable as a character.

3.5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, RBMedia & Katie Holt for the chance to listen to this book in exchange for my honest review.

This book. This book. This book. When they said The Hating Game meets Beach Read- they weren't kidding. The angst, the tension but then the tenderness. I'm still thinking about the chapter they wrote together... wooooo eeee. I loved this book!

Narration was incredibly well done- but I do admit- even as a pretty much ride or die audiobook listener- due to parts of the book being the text of the novel they were writing- it was sometimes hard to realize the narrator was reading that, rather than book. I almost, ALMOST would suggest a person might enjoy more reading from the page on this one. Or to those of us that enjoy listening AND reading- you'll have no issues!

Was this review helpful?

"But what makes romance novels so good is the fact that they’re a complex dive into human emotion. There’s so much more to a romance than just love."

Thank you to Netgalley for this Audio-Arc!

The Banter was fun, albeit infuriating but in the best way.
I had high hopes from reading the E-Arc reviews and the narrator did not disappoint either.

Being forced to write a novel with someone you loathe? Easy right? They spend a lot of time roasting each other in front of their whole class. While everyone around them just wants them to get it on already.

The optimist who believes in happily ever after's writing romance; and the man who's a realist who writes literary fiction...

Definitely worth the listen!

Was this review helpful?

This book felt like a typical enemy to lovers, except I couldn't really connect with the characters or plot. Neither of the main characters, Rosie and Aiden, stood out to me. I didn't get that feeling that they were meant for each other all along or that their relationship would even be a good one.

The other issue that I had with the book is that the pacing felt off at times. The first half is mainly them focusing on their writing class and writing a romance novel together. The transition from them going from hating each other to starting to like each other happened rather abruptly. They then went from liking each other to sex so fast. After that, it felt like there were sex scenes nonstop.

Overall, I did enjoy the book besides the couple of things that bothered me. It was a cute romance and easy to follow. I like how they were able to be more open with each other and move forward from their pasts. They both had some past traumas that they struggled to work through, and it was caused some issues here and there. Thank you to Netgalley, RBmedia, and Katie Holt for an ARC of this audiobook. This review is my own honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?