Member Reviews

I chose to read this book about the discovery of a possible forgery of a Picasso painting because I actually own a signed and numbered Picasso lithograph that I inherited from my parents. Ironically, for many years I had assumed I had a mere print, not an original. It turns out it is an original! Lily, the main character in this novel, is more discerning than I was, and she has a lot more at stake in her judgment of the authenticity of a Picasso painting that the Tate museum in London is exhibiting. Her job is at risk, as well as her reputation in the art world. Adventure and danger ensue as she searches for the evidence of the possible forgery. The author did her research very well into the times and places of 1970's London, as well as the dynamics of acquiring art for a major museum. I will be recommending this novel to my book club.

Was this review helpful?

This worked well as a mysterious and historical element going on, it had that plot element that I was looking for and enjoyed the concept of this. It was great that Picasso was being used and how it was used in the story. The characters had that feel that I was looking for and enjoyed going on this journey with them. Katherine Reay wrote this perfectly and thoroughly enjoyed what was happening.

Was this review helpful?

I will confess that for a good while, I had a difficult time getting into the story. I was frustrated by Lily’s attitude about life and how it put distance between her and the people she cares about. But at about 60%, the plot picked up and the way the story unfolded was interesting and I appreciated the resolution between characters. If you enjoy art and intrigue and self-realization, push through the build-up because the payoff is worth it.

Was this review helpful?

When you finish a book and you are sad to leave the characters, you know it was a good read! The setting was wonderful, descriptions well done, and characters interesting (even if the main character drove me crazy at times!). I loved the delve into the art world and there is a fun surprise cameo in this book too! 🧐 There’s a bit of a twist that is slowly revealed, cleverly and I loved the two POVs that told the whole story.

I got an #arc of this book thanks to @netgalley and this review is my honest opinion. I already have an #ebook, but I will be getting a physical copy too! It comes out in June, so go pre-order now!

I’m a sucker for @katherinereay and this book just solidified it even more. I would recommend this book - first 5⭐️ read of 2025!! 🎉

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley, Harper Muse, and Katherine Reay for allowing me to read this wonderful arc.

I really do not have many words to describe how beautiful this book was.

In this story we follow Diana and Lilly-Who both work in the world of art.

But things are not as the seem, especially when a certain painting end up being, well-you are going to have to read this book to find out.

The plot was great! There was laughter and tears when reading this.

I am so excited for the world to read this one.

Was this review helpful?

I’ve read books by Katherine Reay before, which I enjoyed but this one is not one of my favorites. It starts out very slowly with single events taking up an entire chapter (that could have been told in one page.) Not until the 30% mark does it start to get interesting. It gets exciting at about the 90% mark. I also struggle with the darkness of the story. The main character, Lilly, is incredibly hard on herself and so is her family. I really like the art info, the provenance, how museums work, etc. There are definitely unexpected twists which redeem the story somewhat. I’m not into extensive detail and lots of exposition, but if you are, this is a book you don’t want to miss.

Many thanks to Harper Muse and NetGalley for a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

As an art lover, this historical fiction book was just what I needed to start of the new year.

Set in London during the 70s, there were times I felt like I was part of the scene. Incredible writing. I also really liked how history was weaved throughout the story as the crime is solved. As someone who studied Nazi looting in college, I was pleased to see it included, as often it’s forgotten.

Great read!

Was this review helpful?

Katherine Reay is one of my favorite authors, so I am always excited to have the opportunity to read an early copy of her newest novel and give a review. My favorites have been, “Dear Mr. Knightley,” “A Shadow in Moscow,” and “The Berlin Letters”. Reay’s newest book, “The English Masterpiece,” sounded especially intriguing with a mystery surrounding a stolen fine art painting set in the early 70s. I could tell that the author did a lot of research on the topic, and I came away feeling that I had learned a great deal. However, the writing, primarily in the first two-thirds of the book, reminded me itself of abstract art. Instead of the creative style of writing, I would have preferred a more defined understanding of the characters. Overall I did enjoy the book, but it didn’t wow me like some of Reay’s previous novels. My thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy of this book!

Was this review helpful?

This was an excellent historical novel that dove into the art world in London. I learned much about the business of selling and acquiring artwork, from the perspective of a “keeper” at the Tate Museum. The mystery at the heart of the novel kept me intrigued until the end and the subplots of family, identity and romance added to the story. It was nice to read a historical fiction not completely surrounded by war, despair and heartbreak.

Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC and an honest review of the book.

Was this review helpful?

Cozy historical fiction meets art.

The book tells the story of Lily, assistant to Diana, the Tate's Modern Collection keeper. Lily loves her job and deeply admires her boss and mentor. That is, until one day when, without thinking, she blurts out that an art piece is a forgery—right in the middle of an exhibition. From that moment, everything begins to unravel, like dominoes falling one after another.

I called it "cozy" because the plot and characters feel familiar and uncomplicated. However, if you assume the story itself is straightforward, you’d be mistaken. The author excels at capturing and unraveling complex emotions—some even uncomfortable—that Lily and the other characters have spent their lives avoiding. Themes of admiration, guilt, and staying true to yourself are woven beautifully into a narrative that’s hard to put down (even when you know you should be sleeping).

Art and history aren't just a backdrop—they’re essential elements of this story. There's even a delightful cameo, which I won’t spoil, but it absolutely made me smile. Unexpected yet completely fitting.

Honestly, there isn’t much I didn’t like. At times, the story felt a bit too straightforward, but that simplicity is part of what makes it so comforting.

I’d recommend this book to anyone who enjoys art—especially fans of Picasso and the masters—or historical fiction that steers clear of being overly sad or depressing.

At the publisher’s request, I must mention that I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Thank you to NetGalley and Harper Muse for the ARC in exchange for an honest review. The English Masterpiece will be published on June 10, 2025.

Was this review helpful?

This an exceptionally well-crafted story about a Picasso art forgery set in London Museum. The story was engaging and Reay developed the characters so that the reader really cared about them. This book falls in line with Jeffrey Archer’s art mysteries and I suspect this will be a breakout hit for this author. I have read a couple other titles by Katherine Reay and loved them and this makes me want to find all her backlist titles so I can read them.

#TheEnglishMasterpiece #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely loved this story! From the very first page, the suspense was gripping, and it was masterfully sustained throughout, keeping me on edge until the very end. The pacing was excellent—every twist and turn felt deliberate and well-timed, making it impossible to put the book down.

I also appreciated the thoughtful execution of the romance subplot. It was beautifully woven into the narrative, adding emotional depth without overpowering the central themes. In particular, I loved that the romance complemented, rather than overshadowed, the theme of women’s empowerment—one that I can never read enough of. The protagonist’s journey was both inspiring and compelling, and it was refreshing to see a strong, multifaceted female lead navigating challenges with resilience and intelligence.

This was my first time reading a book by Katherine Reay, and it certainly won’t be my last. Her storytelling captivated me, and I can’t wait to explore more of her work.

Overall, The English Masterpiece is a brilliant blend of suspense, romance, and empowerment, delivering an unforgettable reading experience. Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

This book is set in London in the 1970s following Pablo Picasso's death. The story alternates between the perspectives of Diana Gilden, the keeper of Modern Collections at the Tate Gallery, and her assistant Lily. Diana decides that the Tate must have a special exhibit in the Memorium of Pablo Picasso for both Diana and Lily to get promotions and secure their places in the Tate. Their success seems achievable until the day of the unveiling when Lily is walking around the exhibit and blurts out that one of the pieces is a forgery.

As this crime gets investigated, we soon learn that Diana and Lily aren't as they seem. Both have parts of themselves hidden away as they feel like what they are doing will bring them happiness even if it keeps them away from their true love of being artists.

This book is fantastic. I couldn't put it down. Katherine Reay does an amazing job of making you doubt what is going on and whether the painting is a forgery. The author also did a great job of weaving in history about Nazi occupation and how it impacted the art world during WW2. There were so many issues touched in this book as well such as dealing with family trauma, dealing with guilt, and acceptance of those in your life and yourself.

Was this review helpful?

I love art and especially books about art. What I didn't expect was for this to be an absorbing thriller!

The story takes place in 1973 when Lily, an art aficionado is hired to assist the Tate's Modern Collections keeper, Diana Gilden. Lily is thrilled when she is asked to set up a last-minute art installation showcasing Picasso's work as the artist had recently died. Everything is set, everything is perfect. But it's not and Lily sees it. What she doesn't expect is that it may cost her reputation.

The details in this story had me referring to the internet constantly to see the artwork described in the book. It was not only a fun read but super interesting as well.

Was this review helpful?

Lily has her dream job. She is the assistant to Diana Gilden at the Tate Modern Gallery in London. She's working on a big assignment. It's a memorial display of Picasso's paintings from around the world, following his demise. But in looking at one of the paintings, Lily blurts out that it's a fake. That's not a good thing to do in front of the press, her boss and the owner of the painting.

Things are tough at home and Lily really needs to keep her job. So, she sets out to prove that the painting is, indeed, a fake, and to find out who is behind it. But things get complicated when the police think that she is the forger.

This well-written novel was a pleasure to read. The characters are well-developed. The plot moves along at a smooth pace. The ending isn't a real shocker, as we are introduced to the real forger early in the book. But, like a good episode of Columbo, it only adds to the level of intrigue as the mystery is solved. I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed Reay’s exploration of happiness and career fulfillment. Both Diana, as Tate Gallery’s Keeper of Modern Collections, and Lily, as her assistant, have broken all barriers in the UK as the first female keepers in a major institution. Their personal lives are as curated as their workplace. When Lily discovers that happiness isn’t what she does but how she feels about what she does, she’s willing to undertake gasp-worthy moves! The art of sacrifice kept me intrigued.

Although I’ve read plenty about the art world during the Nazi regime, it was good to see how Reay linked this to equality and freedom for women in the workplace. It was equally interesting to learn about the art of forgery and Picasso.

This story about risks, scandal and personal/professional growth will resonate with many; especially those who take time to peel back the veneer.

I was gifted this copy by Harper Muse and NetGalley and was under no obligation to provide a review.

Was this review helpful?

THE ENGLISH MASTERPIECE by KATHERINE REAY is the extremely well written story of Lily Summers, a talented young woman who loves art, seeing a flaw in a Picasso painting which is part of a special exhibition at the Tate Gallery, causing mayhem in the art and insurance worlds, as well as involving Scotland Yard, and a search for the forger.
Lily works under Diana Gilden who is the first woman Keeper of Modern Collections and feels guilty for causing the person who has done so much for her to lose her job. Still she is sure she is right. She has always followed Diana’s tastes and directions assiduously until she is in trouble and realizes she needs to be her real self and trust her own opinions and feelings. This is true in her painting and in her family life. She needs to be more accessible to her family and friends and trust in her own ability rather than copy famous artists……
The story is gripping as the author takes us through these two women’s emotions, and we wonder at the outcome.
There are other interesting characters as the author, who is obviously knowledgeable about London’s art scene in the 1970’s and passionate about art, creates a scenario that is full of mystery, even going back to the Nazi’s art thefts during World War 11…….
I cannot recommend this interesting and exciting novel strongly enough.
I waa given a free copy of the book by NetGalley from Harper Muse. The opinions in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

The English Masterpiece by Katherine Reay is a fantastic story about the possible forgery of a famous Picasso painting in 1970s London.
We meet Lily, the assistant to Diana, who runs a Collections Gallery. Picasso has recently passed away so they create a collection by bringing in Picasso art to display. This is where Lily thinks she can see one of the paintings as a forgery.
This story had me captivated from the start. I loved the characters in this novel.
I really didn't know much about Picasso's work and was intrigued. I found myself looking him up online so I could see his paintings.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book and received an advanced complimentary copy. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.

Was this review helpful?

When Picasso dies in 1973, Diana Gilden, Keeper of Modern Collections at the Tate Gallery asks for her assistant Lily’s help in planning a memorial exhibition that will secure both of their places in the art world.

Their success seems inevitable until Lily unexpectedly ruins the exhibition opening by declaring one of the paintings to be a forgery.

As the police and insurance inspectors work to investigate the claim, readers begin to realize that both women are living carefully curated lives, lives they convince themselves will bring them happiness, even if it demands they sacrifice embracing their true selves.

Katherine Reay does a superb job of keeping readers guessing about the authenticity of the painting while layering in connections to so many other conflicts. She touches on the Nazi’s theft of hundreds of thousands of paintings during WWII. She explores the difficulties of being women trying to establish themselves in a male-dominated field. And she highlights the complicated nature of families where trauma, guilt, and desperation for acceptance can all get in the way of love and connection.

This was my first time experiencing Reay’s work, and I’m eager to read more. Thanks to Harper Muse and Netgalley for providing me with a complimentary ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

THE ENGLISH MASTERPIECE is a thoroughly enjoyable novel to sink yourself into. Lily and Diana are terrific POV protagonists, and the differences between their lifestyles are immediately noticeable. I had a little bit of a hard time believing Lily's outburst, which serves as the inciting incident, but I suspended my disbelief and was able to immerse myself into the story. The 1970s art world in London is vividly conveyed, and the mystery surrounding the alleged forgery kept me turning the pages. The resolution is completely satisfying. This is another winner from Katherine Reay. Highly recommended for fans of historical fiction and women's fiction. You don't need an interest in art to enjoy the novel, but readers who do have such an interest will find much of interest here.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an advance e-galley; all opinions in my review are 100% my own.

Was this review helpful?