Member Reviews
What an important but also devastating story. I had no idea about the MVP before and thought this book might be about a pipeline from a long time ago. Turns out it’s very current news that I hadn’t heard of. It’s great how the author includes a lot of diverse voices and perspectives to highlight the importance of community organizing. Highly recommend
Thank you, NetGalley for an advanced ARC of this graphic novel
I have always been interested in history to do with the world we live in and also the people who helped change it for the bigger or worse, this book talks about a few people who did all they could in their own ways to make it better - the first story we get is
Paula Mann
She was an elderly woman who lived on a farm with her parents and after they passed on she stayed and loved the nature she was a part of, during the time of new pipes being planned to be built under the forest she took the time to take pictures of the areas it would go through as well as letting them know the damage that could happen both with the nearby towns and also the forest, this made them redo their plans
She is one of a few people talked about in this graphic novel who did what they could their own way to fight for change.
These stories all come together to show the impact a few people can have that can change the lives of so many as well as save the beauty of nature that we have around us and take it for granted.
I think this is a great way to show children serious issues without making it too hard to understand or possess
Short but sweet. Profiles of folks leading the way in pipeline resistance in Applachia. Great artwork, important storytelling, but I did feel this fell short of being classified as a memoir.
CW: classism, racism, colonialism
I would like to thank NetGalley and Timber Press for providing me with a free e-ARC of this book in exchange for a fair and honest review.
Direct, on-the-ground storytelling of the active resistance against the Mountain Valley Pipeline (MYP) project, climate activist Denali Sai Nalamalapu's debut graphic memoir is a poignant and powerful story of community-based climate activism.
Through the vignettes of six frontline activists, Nalamalapu provides a concise look into the lives of these activists as they navigate unjust systems, corporate greed, and some who even travel to the nation's capital to speak out against the MYP project. Holler shows more of the multitudes of the realities behind activism, including activism burnout and the need to take of one's self, but Holler also recognizes the work that we can do to provide a better tomorrow for future generations. I felt that the information about MYP project was easy-to-understand despite not knowing about the project until reading this book, and Nalamalapu does a great job with interspersing these vignettes with their own experience fighting against the MVP project.
If you like memoirs about climate activists and/or you want to gain more of an understanding about Appalachia and the work done to protect its resources, I would definitely recommend checking out this book.
I am not sure if this is a Young Adult title but I have not problems having it in my HS library. I love the six individual stories of activism and motivation. The art and limited colors help focus on the story and the emotional strength of all the interviewees.
I was really excited by the title and the premise of this book. I enjoy books set in the Appalachian region and the history around the people living and working there. This book fell really flat for me. I didn’t connect emotionally to the author or any of the people highlighted. I understand that the author was trying to make a connection between these real humans and their values, morals, lives and the destruction of the land but I failed to feel emotional connection with them and so the authors intent didn’t feel realized. I just feel like a graphic novel is not the correct format for this story.
Holler is a graphic novel/memoir which tells the story of the Mountain Valley Pipeline fight, where protestors, activists, and organizers did their part to work towards climate justice and equal treatment of American citizens. There's lots of strong messages within about helping your community, listening to your heart, and using your strengths to do what you can. Each of the pipeline resisters described, Paula Manin, Karolyn Givens, Becky Crabtree, Crystal Mello, Michael James, Desiree Shelley, and the author, uses their own abilities and ideas in order to share with the community and strengthen the movement. Progress depends on organization and coalition-building, as shown in past civil rights movements. We should take lessons where we can, and Holler reminds us of how important it is to look to others who have been where we want to go. Another aspect I appreciated was that Holler takes place in Appalachia, where most people are facing poverty, lack of resources, and climate distress. I am a big believer that lifting up the most vulnerable makes the world better for all of us - and Appalachia and climate justice is a great place to start if you are able to participate in any way you can.
I would like to end by sending a huge thank you to Denali Sai Nalamalapu, the publisher, Timber Press, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read Holler. I will share my review to Amazon, Goodreads, and Barnes & Noble as well. I hope more activism-based memoirs/graphic novels will follow :)
I just finished an ARC of this graphic novel and I think it's an absolute MUST for young adult readers and adult readers alike. It outlines stories or people living in Appalachia, their love of this place, and how they were impacted by the mountain valley pipeline project. It's a story of hope, community, and passion and it's absolutely brilliant.
I want to be clear- you don't have to be a graphic novel reader to be able to appreciate and enjoy this book. I personally have a difficult time tracking stories in a visual format in most cases, but between the simple color palette and the clearly defined order to read along, this graphic novel was so easy to follow.
Additionally, I so appreciated that this followed a number of people's stories and reactions to navigating the Mountain Valley Pipeline. It allows the reader to learn, listen, and appreciate diverse voices and experiences.
Please pick up a copy of this book. Please request that your library purchase this book. Please purchase this book to gift to loved ones. Its story is so important and beautifully told.
An outstanding exploration of the women involved in preventing the Mountain Valley Pipeline from coming to completion. Many of the people in this book, as well as others involved in the protest, face criminal charges. This is important witness to an environmental struggle.
Some solid comics journalism, Denali Sai Nalamalapu interviews six different climate activists, from different backgrounds and ethnicities, who have fought (and continue to fight) the construction of the Mountain Valley Pipeline in the Southern Appalachian mountains. Nalamalapu illustrates in a spare style with a fairly uniform line and a few flat colors (often just two or three tones), which draws attention to where color is used dramatically, especially with drawings of destruction or environmental impacts.
The stories of the individuals are presented (in terms of pacing and framing) in a documentary style, mixing in elements of interviews with personal narratives of how each came to acts of resistance and disillusionment with official channels and government. Holler is not a difficult or particularly graphic read, but it doesn't shy away from loss and explanation of the local consequences of the destruction of the pipeline construction or its possible impacts from an explosion or leak.
It's a brief read, that doesn't overstay its welcome, but it might have been nice for the individual narratives to have a bit more breathing room to give us a more three dimensional sense of each person. Still, it's a solid entry on the local impacts of national issues that are too easily reduced to talking points and abstraction, here given some real concrete examples of the immediate environmental effects of pipeline construction on the communities affected.
This is the most fascinating and inspiring read on the most burning topic of recent times. Gripping illustrations add flavor that keeps you hooked till the last page. It offers a wider perspective on the issue interlinking many themes, keeping the stage open for the audience till the very end. I had to ask my friend to read it too so we can debate on many compelling ideas that this work evokes. I highly recommend reading this book in pairs
My family has lived in the mountains of Southwest Virginia for centuries, and I'm only now truly starting to appreciate that history and our connection to the land. When I came across this book, I knew I had to check it out; I'm so thankful that I did! I hadn't heard of these tenacious, everyday activists who are taking things into their own hands and working endlessly for a change. I'm so deeply inspired by their resistance and resilience! Mountain people have guts and grit, and it's more than evident in these profiles. Nalamalapu does an amazing job of showcasing their hearts and authenticity vs. the overwhelming, greedy powers they're up against.
If you have even an ounce of concern about the environment and climate crisis, read this and prepare to be inspired.
Thank you to NetGalley and the author for providing me with a free eARC in exchange for an honest review.
this is empathetic journalism at its finest. denali sai nalamalapu captures the hollers of appalachia with such grace and delicacy, using sparse backdrops in the illustrations to highlight the bigness of the topic at hand. the mountain valley pipeline is something i feel that the masses don't know much about, and this graphic memoir captures the beauty of the region while educating on a very impactful issue. this is done so, so well.