I do love the story but I have a hard time to understand what is saying because of the accent of the narrator.
I will be reading it physically and then go back to the audiobook.

So I received this as an audio ARC
I liked the voice actors however the accent for the female is so thick it made it incredibly hard to understand when you sped it up at all.

OK onto the book itself
I’m giving this three stars because it’s not necessarily my cup of tea, but I also didn’t think it was horrible
It was like the author watched Dune and the Netflix version of persuasion one after the other, and decided to write a book.
The vibes are very much western Asia/Middle East, a lot of Persian and Indian influence but with random modern language thrown in.

Honestly, the modern language being thrown in kind of takes away from the story and really jars you out of this world that you’re trying to let yourself sink into.

But while we’re talking about sinking into things, the sex scenes are not it, they are so cringe.

It’s giving YA but with random awkward smut thrown in. The language used rivals the embarrassment you’d fell if your grandmother publicly said the word “moist” or “girth” to you crush.
I got second, third, fourth, fifth hand embarrassment.
My children’s children will be embarrassed
I skimmed the hell out of those scenes

Imagine the vibe of Shadow and Bone meeting the soul of Damsel with Millie Boddy Brown but spiced with Persian and Indian mythology, and you've got The Starlight Heir. It’s a romantasy that has you tasting the edge of a low fantasy blade, dripping and emerging with hidden powers! (I need more, by the way. Lol)

Now, let’s talk about the plot. The Starlight Heir races along at the pace of a runaway chariot, throwing our FMC into “marriage tests.” These challenges are really "marriage material." I perched on the edge of my seat, thinking, "What's next?" Spoiler alert: These trials don’t take long to derail gloriously. (Not really, a spoiler as the realization comes quickly!)

The slow-burn tension here isn’t just slow—it’s a gourmet stew simmering for hours. At one point, I was practically serenading the book: “Sha-la-la-la-la, don’t be scared, kiss the girl”—except it wasn’t the prince on the receiving end. Nope, cue the Prince’s half-brother swooping in. I love how deliciously it's nontraditional with falling in love with "Prince Charming."

The pacing is as ferocious as a mythological beast on the hunt, and while I’d love to spill the beans about where these tests lead, I’ll keep my lips sealed tighter than a genie’s lamp.

Also, the audiobook? Phenomenal. Anais Inara Chase and Ramiz Monsef deliver outstanding performances. As someone who hoards audiobooks like a dragon guarding gold, I can confirm their narration is an enchanting blend of voices.

In short, The Starlight Heir is a must-read (or listen). Mythology, tension, romance, and enough unexpected twists to keep you gasping—it’s everything if you are sliding into the romantasy genre. Read it. Now. You're welcome.

The Starlight Heir by Amalie Howard is a fast-paced, scorching romantic fantasy that will leave readers spellbound. Suraya Saab, a bladesmith blessed by the stars, receives an unexpected invitation to the capital city of Kaldari. What she believes is a simple request for her skills turns into a dangerous journey filled with court intrigue, dark magic, and a simmering romance.

Suraya’s encounter with the crown prince's illegitimate half-brother, Roshan, is far from what she expects. Instead of a potential match, she finds herself entangled in a hunt for the Starkeeper, a girl with magic running through her veins, and rumors swirl that Suraya might be that girl. As unrest builds between the noble houses and a rebellious militia, Suraya and Roshan must navigate a city on the brink of war, all while denying the growing attraction between them.

The stakes rise even higher when Suraya finds herself drawing the attention of a dark god—an immortal being who might prove to be the greatest threat of all. With her powers spiraling out of control, and secrets lurking beneath every corner, *Starlight Heir* is a thrilling adventure of magic, destiny, and self-discovery.

The audiobook narration is a standout, deserving a 5-star rating. The voice performance enhances the intensity of the plot, bringing the characters and world to life with rich emotion and suspense.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ARC in exchange for my honest, unbiased review.

The Starlight Heir by Amalie Howard hit that sweet spot between familiar fantasy comfort and fresh, engaging twists. If you’re into worlds packed with magic, political intrigue, forbidden romance, and a pile of spice, this one’s worth your time.

Suraya Saab is everything you’d want in a protagonist—bold, skilled, and with a quiet vulnerability that makes her easy to root for. She is, of course, driven by emotion over logic quite often. Her bladesmithing craft and connection to jadu set her apart, giving the story a unique hook. Then there’s Roshan, the brooding illegitimate prince who will have readers swooning and rolling their eyes in equal measure. The chemistry between them? Let’s just say it’s intense enough to make you keep flipping pages late into the night.

While the setup feels a little reminiscent of ACOTAR or Fourth Wing, that’s part of its charm. It has all the beloved elements—high-stakes battles, a touch of court drama, and simmering tension—but spins it in a way that feels new with its “Starkeeper” mystery and star-bound magic. The pacing falters in places (sometimes the tension between Suraya and Roshan overshadows the bigger plot), but the rich worldbuilding and solid twists kept me hooked.

I’m absolutely here for the sequel—I want more chaos, more secrets, and even more from that dark god. This is a must-read for romantasy fans who love a bit of danger alongside their romance.

2.75/5

Thanks to Netgalley, the publisher, and Ms. Howard for the ARC of the audiobook!

Suraya is a bladesmith minding her own business when she gets an invitation to a royal ball, where Prince Zarek is seeking a bride. Despite her father and aunt having trepidation about her going (hinting that there's something hidden from her, about her past), Suraya goes to see the city of Kaldari.

Once there, she undergoes a series of challenges to demonstrate herself as the most worthy bride - something she's not particularly keen on winning. The other prince, Prince Roshan, is far more interesting. And the forge and castle library are more appealing than the royal ball.

But when the rebels attack the castle, the truth as to just why Suraya had received an invitation to begin with is revealed: her magic. And all the challenges that she faced to be the best "bride" pale in comparison to her challenge to overcome her magic, the people hunting her, and the revelations of her life, past and present, hiding around every corner.

I enjoyed being in the story of this world, and the idea of a Starkeeper being imbued with magic that can change the world. What I didn't enjoy was the very modern references that were scattered throughout the text. It brought me out of my suspensions of disbelief and took me completely out of the novel more than once. I don't mind the occasional f-bomb , but Ms. Howard also had wonderful in-world oaths that I think were detracted from by using modern swearing. And some of the phrases said are things I hear day to day now, outside of this second world and very much in English/American vernacular. It just didn't settle well with me and made it easier for me to break concentration.

I wish there was a little more description of the world and the magic, and a chance to really immerse myself in it a bit more. There was just enough to keep me intrigued and yearn for more, but it didn't seem to materialize. But I am used to reading epic fantasies so I acknowledge that the point of this genre may not have been a detailed history on the royal family (which Ms. Howard does give!). I also wanted some more bladesmithing! What an interesting profession for an MC that wasn't able to be used too often.

I didn't find the twist with Roshan particularly surprising, and I think it was laid out pretty well from the start. Suraya's characterization also seemed to oscillate between overly competent and fearful. I think it solidified toward the end, as she came into her own, but there were a few parts that made me pause.

Overall, not a bad story in the least, but just not for me.

This had a LOT of potential, but really fell flat for me in a number of ways.

Let's start with the good: the world, magic, lore and aesthetics of this book are really stunning and drew me in quickly. I loved the idea of the Storekeeper being born into a bloodline of Magi, and I initially thought I'd really like the tournament of potential brides (more on that later, though). The way magic is explored and described is really beautiful and captivating, and I really liked the overall lore and how the lesser gods relate back to the larger gods. I enjoyed the banter of the romantic couple, and their premise upon first meeting.

However, a lot of the things I initially liked (or suspected I WOULD like) led to things I didn't. The lore wasn't explored as well as I wanted it to be, and I felt like the aesthetics and rather vague language surrounding prophecies and the gods was actually covering up how poorly developed it all was (or at least how poorly explained.) I liked certain premises related to the romance, but it also felt like their attraction to each other was really shoved down our throats with a lot of "Ugh he is so sexy I can't even stand it!" type of internal monologue and comments, that just came about so often that it felt really clunky and disingenuous. The pacing also felt quite off, and while the ending was exciting if you didn't think about it too hard, it also really illuminated the lack of exploration of the world I've noted before.

I'm still deciding whether I will continue this series with the second book, but overall it just felt a bit meh and disappointing to me. I'm grateful for the opportunity to ARC read this regardless, and am still interested in this authors other works! Thank you to Avon & Harper Voyager and NetGalley for this early copy!

I really enjoyed this unique fantasy setting and magic system! I was under the impression that this was a stand alone, which explained the rapid pacing of the book, but the epilogue leads me to believe we'll be getting a sequel.

Thank you Netgalley, HarperCollins and Amalie Howard. This is the first book by Amalie Howard that I've read and I really enjoyed it. I liked the worldbuilding and the somewhat unique types of magical elements, I found the characters engaging and liked the FMC quite a bit and was intrigued by the MMC. Some of the plot twists were thinly veiled but there were a couple that really did surprise me. Overall, I liked this book quite a bit and look forward to seeing what happens next. I appreciated that while this leaves an opening for a sequel, it didn't end on a dramatic cliffhanger - it kind of did, but not to the point where you're left with NO closure.

Thanks HarperCollins and NetGalley for this audiobook copy of The Starlight Heir.

Overall: 3.25 Stars out 5

I really wanted to like this book. My main critique is twist of the love interest was so easy to spot early on. It tried to make it a surprise similar to From Blood and Ash, but it was obvious right away. Thus, it kind of took away from it being a twist at the end.
Overall the magic system was interesting although a little confusing. Honestly I don’t think I’ll pick up book 2, but book 1 ended well enough that I’m satisfied with leaving it as is.

Thank you so much Netgalley for giving me the opportunity to read The Starlight Heir! This was my first Amalie Howard novel, to be honest, I haven't heard of her before, and I am so thankful I had the opportunity review this one. This book was gut-wrenchingingly beautiful. The feelings by the protagonist were real, and not your typical idiot woo is me character. Suraya is strong, confident, yet raw and still has the typical emotions that they don't measure up to everyone else. This is so real. The romance was so on point, however I was confused by the last chapter, maybe I'll have to research Indian mythology.

I enjoyed this overall. The magic system was interesting and I appreciated the different myths that the fantasy was based on. The main characters were interesting. The major drawback I have here is the language and writing style. It’s a personal pet peeve of mine when fantasy books use modern slang. There was just so much of that in this book. I found myself getting irritated and didn’t want to pick up the book because of this. I would probably rate it 3.5 stars overall.

Thank you NetGalley and publisher for the ARC. I really enjoyed the overall story but the audiobook narrators really made this. The dual narrative with two narrators were great. The male voice was delicious and mysterious. Overall quality was great and I was able to speed up with no issue.

I absolutely loved this book! In a very saturated genre, this one stands out for the uniqueness of the world-building and magic. I have read the author’s historical romance books and so was unsure what to expect, but it vastly exceeded my expectations..l also think that Anais Inara Chase is one of the best audiobook narrators in the game. My only complaint was that some of the dialogue felt too modern for the world and out of place. That being said, I still couldn’t put it down and it really wasn’t that big of a deal. Can’t wait for the second book!

Princesses on parade! (Basically) When it’s confirmed her invitation to the palace to compete with other eligible ladies for the Crowned Prince’s hand, Suraya Saab is conflicted. Crowned Prince Javed has a not-so-savory reputation, but this opportunity will get her closer to the royal forge! And her blacksmithing (and Jadu-imbuing) really wants to see it in action! Turns out, though, this competition has a nefarious agenda, to seek out the Starkeeper of myth.

Between horrendous challenges and heated moments with the prince’s brother Roshan , Suraya learns a lot about herself and her destiny!

I was so quickly drawn into this book and I’m ready for a sequel!!

Amalie Howard delivers an immersive fantasy tale with The Starlight Heir! This is definitely a solid 4-star read in the Romantasy category. While earlier in the book it gives YA vibes, this is definitely a New Adult book.

The world-building and unique setting immediately drew me in. I especially loved how the main character, Suraya, is a bladesmith—a refreshing and strong female protagonist that stands out. Suraya is drawn to Roshan, who turns out to have many secrets that are reveled throughout the book.

That said, I found it a bit challenging to keep track of all the characters, often needing to pause and reread (or relisten) to clarify who was who. The plot is packed with twists and turns, which kept me intrigued, but at times it felt like there were a few too many "untwists," making it harder to follow.

I listened to the audiobook (thanks, NetGalley!) and supplemented it with the Kindle Unlimited e-book. The narrator was fantastic, with a slight accent that felt authentic and added depth to the world without being overdone.

As the first in a series, this book lays a strong foundation for what's to come. I’ll definitely be picking up the sequel!

I have read four of Amalie Howard’s previous historical romance books and I had a great time with them. I loved the adventure, the romance, and the characters in them and this was no different. I had such a great time with Suraya and Roshan and I had a great time with the antics they encountered throughout the book.

Personally, I didn’t love the female narrator in this one. I felt like her tone was pretty flat the whole book. I knew I’d heard her voice before and it’s because she was the narrator in the first Amalie Howard book I read which I didn’t like very much because I didn’t love the audiobook.

This was very much a me problem, not the books. I did enjoy the story, but the narrator just didn’t vibe with me.

Thank you to Avon Books for the eARC and final print copy and Harper Audio for the ALC.

4.5 stars.

The beginning of The Starlight Heir was a familiar concept: women are brought to the kingdom to compete for the Prince’s hand in marriage. But then hoooo boy, all hell breaks loose and the story runs wild.

Roshan, the Prince’s illegitimate brother, and Suraya escape the castle in a whirlwind. Roshan was a very likable character, although you can tell he’s keeping some secrets. Naughty, naughty boy…but can’t stay mad at him.

The plot was crazy and everything moved so quickly. And yet, I couldn’t stop listening. I was so invested and enthralled and oh my god everything that happened was wild. I can’t wait for the next in the series, to see how this all unfolds.

A wondrous and entrancing fantasy read.

Starlight Heir is a quick pace story with lots of twists and turns. There’s action, adventure and, yes, love scenes. I enjoyed the way the book was written. The intimate scenes were woven wonderfully to the story, and not just thrown helter-skelter to tick a box for spice.

I’m excited to see where the rest of the story takes us, as we are left with a cliff hanger. I’m a sucker for a good cliff hanger.

I also read this as the audiobook. The performance was great, and added to the overall story

When I received this as an ELC I was SO excited. I really wanted to LOVE this book. Its magic system is original, but it also felt confusing at times. The pacing was just too fast to fully flesh out details of the world building and magic, in my opinion. The characters and plot were enjoyable, I loved that the story felt like it was going in the typical romantasy direction and totally went a different way, but again, the pacing was just so fast I felt like my brain was always a few second behind trying to catch up and put pieces together (but not in a good way). Overall I enjoyed listening to The Starlight Heir, but I never found myself excited or wanting more and probably will not opt to continue the series.