I love thrillers based on longtime friends with hidden secrets, but This Stays Between Us really didn't click for me. There were too many characters introduced back-to-back and not enough suspense to pull me in. Also, some of the writing felt repetitive (for example, "smattered" being used twice in a span of about 100 words).

This book transported me on an outback adventure from the very beginning! A "who done it" mystery that takes place in Australia 10 years ago & present tense. A group of friends reuniting to help solve the murder of their friend, but who can you trust? Who isn't whom they appear to be? This thriller kept me interested the whole way through! Thank you for the ARC Netgalley & Sourcebooks Landmark!

Wow, Wow, Wow!
This novel has so many twists and turns with the ' who done it' feel, but also having you know EVERYONE is a suspect! If you liked the movie scream I really think you'll enjoy this. Sara does such a great job pointing you in all directions having you always second guessing yourself! We are following two POV's, Claire and Phoebe, from then and now. Both girls are recounting their time be it past or present for them respectively. As I said before the twists and turns make this mystery so suspenceful! This would also be very fun to annotate if you are into doing so. I need to read more of Sara's works and am wondering if she will be an autobuy for me... Chances are YES!

Thank you NetGalley for providing me this arc from Bantam to read in exchange for an honest review

If you’re at all similar to me then you know there’s just something addictive about a thriller set in the Australian Outback, something about the vivid landmarks, the heat, the possibility of poisonous animals and the back packing travellers, I’d personally love to travel to Australia but the thought of the giant spiders deters me 😂

“This stays between us” divides its attention between two main characters, one from a past timeline who we know is currently deceased, and one in present day who is slowly unwinding the events of the past as its colliding with her present day.

Present day Claire finds herself having to return to Australia many years after studying abroad. The original purpose for the trip is a school reunion which quickly dissolves into a police investigation after Phoebes remains are found.

Although it seems to inform you of what happened at the beginning of the book we soon learn that the narrator is in fact unreliable leaving a few twists in store for the reader.

If you want to get a jump start on your summer reads and feel some sunshine whilst it’s cold out then this is a great book to ease you into a warmer climate.

Thank you to Sourcebooks and Sara Ochs for the earc!

Publish date: July 15th 2025

My sincere thanks to NetGalley, Sara Ochs and The Sourcebooks Landmark for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.

As much as I hate writing negative reviews, I probably hate writing lukewarm ones even more. But sadly that would be exactly the case here. “This Stays Between Us” captured me at first thanks to the presence of one of my favourite tropes: reunion of school friends. In this case, a group of students from all around the world is spending a month in Australia. It should be mostly party time for them, but soon they are confronted with a tragedy, and another one is already lurking in the shadows. On the last day of the course a student named Phoebe goes missing... and years later a body is found. The former friends are reunited in Australia, but almost every one of them is protecting a secret, especially Claire, Phoebe's roommate.
The sad thing about this book – and my main complaint, hence the lukewarm review – is its painful predictability. I was able to guess correctly not only major twists, but also everything in between, how people will react to something, what will they say and so on. It was tiresome, disappointing, not to mention boring. And boredom is not something I like to associate with thrillers. Plus Claire, the protagonist, was infuriatingly dumb and gullible. Surely not a heroine for a reader to identify with.
Overall it's an OK book, that's all – no more, no less.

#ThisStaysBetweenUs #NetGalley

Thank you Netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Sara Ochs delivers an atmospheric and suspenseful thriller with “This Stays Between Us,” a gripping story of secrets and the deadly consequences of a past that won’t stay buried. Set against the hauntingly vivid backdrop of the Australian Outback, the book brings together two timelines—Claire’s present-day search for the truth and Phoebe’s past experiences leading up to her death—slowly unraveling a mystery packed with tension and unexpected twists.

The book follows Claire, one of several former study abroad students who return to Australia after the remains of their long-missing friend, Phoebe, are discovered. From the start, Claire admits to playing a role in Phoebe’s death, making her an unreliable narrator whose perspective keeps the reader questioning what really happened that fateful night. But as the story unfolds, it becomes clear that Claire wasn’t the only one with secrets. Each member of the group is a potential suspect, and as more people start to die, the stakes skyrocket. Was someone seeking revenge, or was the past being buried—literally?

Ochs skillfully balances the dual timelines, using Phoebe’s flashbacks to provide crucial insights into the toxic relationships, betrayals, and personal struggles that shaped the group’s dynamic. Phoebe, dealing with deep-seated trauma, emerges as one of the most complex characters, while Claire, though sometimes overshadowed by the others, has hidden depths that are fully revealed in a mind-blowing epilogue, which some people may or may not like. Clever clues and red herrings are scattered throughout, keeping you engaged and second-guessing every character’s motives.

The Australian setting plays a key role in the book’s immersive atmosphere. Ochs’s detailed descriptions of the Outback add to the sense of isolation and foreboding, making the environment feel as dangerous as the characters themselves. The pacing is well-crafted, with slow-burning suspense that escalates into a fast-paced, high-stakes conclusion.

While the book’s core mystery is compelling, its themes of friendship and trauma add emotional weight to the story. Every character has something to hide, and as secrets come to light, the true nature of their relationships is exposed. The final twists, especially in the epilogue, will leave you reeling, making for a truly satisfying—and chilling—ending.

Perfect for fans of locked-room mysteries and psychological thrillers, “This Stays Between Us” is an addictive, atmospheric read that keeps you guessing until the very last page. Highly recommended for anyone who loves dark secrets, unreliable narrators, and thrillers packed with tension and shocking reveals.

An excellent book to read in between all the romance novels I've been into lately. I liked the back and forth between different time periods in the MC's life. I think Ochs did a great job crafting a variety of characters and the Australia setting was majestic to read about. Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC.

This is another thriller novel by Sara Ochs.

The book is about a group of former students who did a study abroad program ten years ago have to return to Australia where a previous member of their group was found murdered. There are two narrators throughout the book. Claire’s who is in present day and Phoebe whose has taken place in the past. Throughout the book it switches back and forth between their POV’s. Little clues are delivered throughout the book and Claire is trying to figure out who murdered Phoebe or was it even herself that did?

Overall I liked the book and found it to be a medium-paced book.

Thank you NetGalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for the eARC.
This book has had stellar reviews and I feel bad that I can't add to them. For some reason I just couldn't get into the story. The premise of a group of former students going back to Australia, where they spent a month in the past really appealed to me. There's a murder being investigated by the police after finding one of the group's remains and they want the students back to Australia to be questioned.
Unfortunately I didn't like any of the characters and really didn't care about their relationships and who did what and got bored. Sorry!

**Book Review: This Stays Between Us by Sarah Ochs**
**Rating: 5/5**

I absolutely loved every minute of *This Stays Between Us*! From the moment I started reading, I was completely captivated by the intricate web of secrets and suspense that Ochs masterfully weaves throughout the narrative.

The reunion of old friends—who once embarked on a daring foreign adventure—immediately drew me in. I was enthralled by the way the author reconnected these characters, each harboring their own hidden truths, and how their past suddenly collided with a shocking present when a dead body surfaced.

What truly made this book unforgettable for me was the perfect balance of pacing and tension. Every chapter left me eager for more, and the clever character introductions deepened my connection to the story. The bone-chilling secrets and unexpected twists kept my heart racing and my mind buzzing with anticipation.

The final chapter was an absolute revelation—it completely blew my mind and left me in awe of the insane plot twist. It’s rare to find a book that not only meets but exceeds your expectations in every possible way, and *This Stays Between Us* did just that.

In short, this book is a thrilling rollercoaster ride of suspense and emotion, and I couldn’t have been more thrilled by the experience. Highly recommended to anyone who loves a story packed with mystery and unforgettable twists!

Thank you NetGalley and Publisher for allowing me to read and review this book.

I very much enjoyed this book. The writing was great and the characters were well developed. I hope to read more from this author in the future.

Sarah Ochs delivers another gripping thriller with This Stays Between Us, a tense and twisty follow-up to The Resort. This time, she takes readers on a dark and dangerous study abroad trip to Australia—one that ends in a tragedy no one has truly left behind.

Ten years ago, Claire and her best friend, Phoebe, joined a group of students for what was supposed to be the adventure of a lifetime. But what started as sun-soaked travels and late-night parties quickly spiraled into something more sinister, culminating in Phoebe’s mysterious disappearance. Now, a decade later, Phoebe’s remains have been found, forcing Claire and her former classmates to return to the scene of the crime. But Claire isn’t just searching for answers—she’s hiding a terrible truth. Because she knows what really happened that night. And she’ll do anything to keep it buried.

Ochs masterfully builds tension as the narrative flips between past and present, revealing the tangled web of jealousy, betrayal, and hidden agendas that led to that fateful night. The shifting group dynamics, the slow unraveling of trust, and the oppressive atmosphere of a foreign landscape all add to the suspense, making this a read that keeps you second-guessing everyone’s motives—including Claire’s.

With shades of Lucy Foley’s locked-room mysteries and the social drama of Society of Lies, This Stays Between Us is a sharp, compulsive thriller that keeps the tension simmering until its final, chilling moments. If you love messy friendships, unreliable narrators, and dark secrets that refuse to stay buried, this one belongs on your TBR.