This book had a good premise, but it dragged on and on, with the exact same scenario happening over and over again.

Release: June 23, 2025
Publisher: Atria Books

Rating: 4.25 ★ 

Nina Swann is still reeling from the shocking death of her husband, Paddy, who was pushed onto the train tracks. In the wake of her loss, she meets Nick Radcliffe, an old friend of Paddy’s, who quickly becomes a source of comfort. Despite Ash’s growing suspicions, Nina allows Nick into their lives, and before long, he moves in with them.

Meanwhile, in a nearby town, Martha, a florist, is juggling life with her husband, Alistair, their infant daughter, and two sons from a previous marriage. Alistair’s frequent business trips and their ongoing financial struggles leave her feeling lonely and increasingly doubtful of his honesty. As she starts noticing discrepancies in his stories, her suspicions about his faithfulness deepen.

As the truth unravels, Ash begins digging into Nick’s past, only to uncover a shocking reality—Nick and Alistair are the same man. He has been living a double life, deceiving both Nina and Martha. When the two women finally piece everything together, they unite to confront him, setting the stage for a tense and dramatic showdown.

What stands out most is Jewell’s talent for creating an unsettling atmosphere—every chapter leaves you questioning the motives of those involved and doubting what’s true. The pacing is perfectly balanced, gradually revealing shocking truths without overwhelming the reader. The ending is both unexpected and satisfying, tying up loose ends while leaving just enough ambiguity to linger in your mind long after finishing the book.

Favorite Quote:
"But then she clearly didn't have any idea who she was back then, what she was capable of, how badly she could possibly mess everything up. She'd thought she was normal back then. And now she knows she's not"

I was so intrigued at the beginning of this book, but then I kept waiting for something big to happen, and it never did. By the time I finished it, I felt let down. This book felt repetitive because of the male MC’s double (triple?) life. In my opinion, this did not pack a punch like LJ’s other thrillers do.

I really liked the idea of this book, it was interesting to follow the different relationships, and the main character was so wildly likable and unlikable at the same time. I did find it a little hard to follow at times, and I wish that they put the name of the women he was seeing at the time with the chapter or something like that. But overall good interesting story, but slightly hard to follow along!

Okay, lemme preface this review by saying Lisa is still my favorite despite that this book sadly and bewilderingly wasn’t for me.

Bewildering really is the main word that comes to mind. This just…didn’t feel like other LJ reads. 😭

I’ve talked to a few people who felt similarly, and we all agreed the multiple timelines were confusing and unsuccessful. I’m a big fan when they bolster the plot, but the character + time jumps didn’t add. 😵‍💫

I can’t say I was a huge fan of any of the women (nor were they that memorable). And while it can be super fun to know who the villain is from the get go (see: The Nothing Man by Catherine Ryan Howard), our bad guy in this one felt borderline caricature. I just stopped caring about him getting his comeuppance by a certain point.

All in all…meh. I hate feeling this way about an author I typically adore, but you can’t win ‘em all. Wish I could say I loved it but I’m always going to be honest with y’all. 💔

Lisa Jewell is a master when it comes to writing wild and twisty thrillers with ending you won’t see coming. This story is an absolute page turner.

Lisa is absolutely brilliant!! And his book gave me whiplash from an emotional rollercoaster. This one is another page turner. Don’t let him in will be a must read for 2025!! Wow!!!!!

The story hooked me from the very first chapter. Filled with twists and unexpected turns that kept me on the edge until the very end! This was fast paced and a book I could not put down!

I'm a sucker for multiple POV storytelling and different timelines and this book did not disappoint! The MMC was written perfectly to inspire the feeling of outrage. It may not be all men, but it is definitely Nick Radcliffe!

A Kaleidoscopic Thrill Ride!

Lisa Jewell has outdone herself this time, conjuring a binge-worthy tale that captivates like an irresistible spell. Three women, each tangled in their own saga, are linked by what feels like a shape-shifting man. Add two timelines brimming with deceit and manipulation, and my thoughts spun like dark magic dust caught in a storm of deception, desperately trying to untangle the layers of treachery that kept me wide awake well into the witching hour.

Here lies the genius of Lisa Jewell’s craft: she layers each mystery, revealing just enough at every turn to keep you hooked. I should have trusted the magic she wove and let my overactive mind rest, and let the story carry me along

Dark Secrets and Unforgettable Twists

The story blends raw, real-life drama with heart-pounding suspense. Every revelation, every turn, feels fresh, exciting, and unpredictable pulling me in deeper with each page.

Embrace the Chaos!

It’s messy, it’s chaotic, and it’s so satisfying. Once I let go of my frantic overthinking, I embraced the exhilarating fun of this one.

This was a Witches’ Words buddy read with Norma, Mary Beth, Debra, and DeAnn. Without them, I wouldn’t have realized how much I needed to give the overthinker in me a break.

Thank you Netgalley and Atria for giving me the opportunity to read this book and provide my honest feedback.

I DNF this book at 50%. I was very disappointed. I can't remember the last time I was this frustrated reading a book. All the women are pathetic and let themselves be manipulated by a man multiple times. They are happy being doormats and being walked all over. The plot is straightforward and frankly, very boring. I usually like Lisa Jewell's books but this was just not it.

Don’t Let Him In
Lisa Jewell
Pub 6/24/25
4☆

Jewell never fails to entertain me and such was the case with her upcoming release. Don’t Let Him in was wholly engaging and had me questioning pretty much everything to the very end.

This was a bit of a slow-burn start but ultimately a jaw-dropping, whirlwind of a read. With alternating timelines and multiple POV’s there is A LOT going on here. But as all of the storylines start to intersect and the puzzle pieces start falling into place I was flipping pages eager to see how it all played out. Jewell effortlessly brings it all together with one satisfying ending.

What I enjoyed
🚪Twisty Mystery
🚪Multiple Timelines/POV
🚪Kaleidoscopic Thriller
🚪Short Chapters

Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for the advanced copy in exchange for my honest review

I loved this book and the dual POVs! Very fast paced and kept me guessing. I really enjoyed this thriller

not all men but somehow always a man…

take my rating with a grain of salt as i am just not one for thrillers with ten billion POVs and characters to keep track of… this is only my second book of Lisas but i was as underwhelmed with this one as i was with “none of this is true” both of which i felt it was interesting until it wasnt. by no means is it a bad book its just not one of my favorite formats of books so it was hard to keep me in interested.

A great psychological thriller from Lisa Jewell. I was absolutely hooked from the start. What kept me from giving it 5 stars is that it was a little too long (almost 400 pages) so I kept thinking of things that weren't necessary to the plot. 

This one was very TWISTY, which made it tedious to get through. You had to suspend belief just a bit because if I was Martha he would've been out the door!

Soooo, this was a good one for sure, but not as good as Then She Was Gone. 

https://www.mandimoore.com/january-book-review-2025/

GOD! This book was hard to put down and made my head spin wondering what was going to happen!

I never thought I could hate a character so much but Lisa did an amazing job at making me want to punch the MMC in the face! He was a true villain with the qualities that made you realize he wasn’t going to repent for his sins.

I enjoyed the ending so much and loved how the author wrapped it up. She did a fantastic job making it easy to follow along throughout the chapters too.

I don’t think stories about women getting scammed are for me…. I wish there were a few more twists or push back from the women during the novel rather than just the last 10%. I also found it fairly predictable. Still a Lisa Jewell fan though!!

Thank you for the ARC <3

Thank you so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc of this one in exchange for an honest review!

This was one of my most anticipated books of 2025 and it really let me down. We follow a con man and a bunch of women who get duped by him.

Basically, this whole book was just listening to women be dumb and fall for this guys antics. He wasn't even very smart or anything, the women were just so dumb! I am so sad that I really disliked this book.

I hope others love it.

WOWZA!!! What a tangled web we weave! Whew! Lisa Jewell kept me on my toes the entire book and left me wanting more! This became the ultimate page turner for me! Readers need to be on their game and pay close attention because Lisa Jewell has spun such a tangled web that spins one way and then the other way in this twisted tale! Secrets, lies, manipulation, twists, and turns all come into play in this riveting, shocking, wonderfully written, and tense book!!!!

Nina and her daughter Ash are devastated when Nina's husband and Ash's father, Paddy Swann is pushed into the path of a train! Nina thought she would never recover from such a loss until she met Nick...

Martha is a florist living with her husband, Al and her children. Al's job takes him away constantly and while they both work, they always have money problems....

Holy Moly! This book is twisted, jaw dropping, shocking, and intense!!!! I had a lot of fun reading this book. There are a lot of characters and, as I mentioned, one needs to stay on their game while reading this book! There are also some creepy scenes as well that might have the hair standing up on the back of your neck.

I went through many emotions and had various thoughts while reading this book. I did my fair share of booing and hissing at one of the characters and my neck is sore from shaking my head at other characters.

Lisa Jewell did a fantastic job of creating tension in this book. The plot is well thought out and left me reeling. I had to get my barring a few times while reading and loved every second of it. Lisa Jewell has delivered once again and left me in awe!

Gripping, thrilling, jaw dropping, shocking, and twist filled!

This was a fun book!! I was a little confused for the first 50%. Once it clicked, it was a total roller coaster ride.

Overall I enjoyed this book. It took me a little while to get into the groove of the myriad of characters and how they all fit together, but once I did the plot pulled together well. My one complaint is that I did have to suspend my disbelief--there is no way so many women would accept the great amount of the main character's strange behavior, and that made the story not realistic to me. But really, most thrillers aren't. The solid writing, twists and turns, and satisfying ending made up for that though.