Member Reviews

This was a fantastic job in the genre and had that feel that I was looking for, it was a strong opening chapter in the City of Shadows series. The characters were everything that was needed in this universe and worked with the plot of the book. I was invested in what was happening and am excited for more. Harry Turtledove wrote this perfectly and everything worked overall.

Was this review helpful?

Got lost a few times reading the book, however I give it 5 stars it was very good. The getting lost part may have been my own fault. Will definitely be looking at more books from Mr. Turltedove.

Was this review helpful?

As much as I’m having a hard time believing this, I’ve never read a book by this author until now. I think it’s because, after reading this, his books are on the cusp of what I like. For instance, I requested this book even though I’m not fond of books that take place in the past. Anyway, I did read this latest, and I’m glad I did. The author’s writing, buildup, and plotting is great, even though there were a couple things that weren’t a personal preference, not a problem with the book. His way of immersing the reader in the timeframe is exceptional without losing sight of the characters and what’s happening. Fans of his are sure to be happy with this series starter, and I will probably read the next one. Recommend. I was provided a complimentary copy which I voluntarily reviewed.

Was this review helpful?

Wow, 75 and still going strong as the dean of alternate-historical fantasy.
The opening shows us how desperate a gumshoe Jack is, with the notion of undead infestation in LA casually dropped on the way to open the door for a beautiful dame. Lots of specific details tell us the rules of magic in this world and that she’s a vampire before he figures it out. He interviews to low-lifes, cats, and ghosts. A lot of poking around finds that his case (one of three) is linked to a drug developed by the Nazis that even they wouldn’t use. The tone has echoes of Lovecraft Country or LA Confidential with supernaturals. Though the plot progresses slowly at first, the ending had several Call of Cthulhu adventure-style boss battles and revelations.

My only negative comment is the narrator digresses too much about writing, which feels out of character.

Was this review helpful?