So stinking good. Thank you for picking the perfect voices to bring Hunter, Greedy, Levi, Sionne and Kabir to life. The flow was good, and really made you feel like you were apart of the story! I loved it!

Did I devour this book in less than 24 hours? Yes you bet I did. After that last cliff hanger I gobbled this up as quick as I could.
I’m really enjoying the way these characters story arcs are coming together. I love how Abby has the juxtaposition of dual timelines, they are done so well. I also really enjoyed the “phases” if you know what I mean. It really solidified the PMDD rep and I really enjoy. I also loved having our beloved Joey and her boys making cameos.

I’m loving how the dynamic of Levi and Greedy is shaping up to be. It’s a different take having additional men added to a why choose as the books go on. I did feel like I wanted a bit more from Siones time alone with Hunter. It felt like he was just kind of thrown in and their relationship didn’t get as much time to developed compared to Spens. Who, BTW, I ADORE. Honestly I don’t think I could pick up a favorite.

A great why choose! Make sure to read the other two books first, this is not one to just jump randomly into. I also think it’s be beneficial to read the Boy of Lake Chapel first as well if your a lover of knowing all the things.

All the narrators do a fantastic job with each character. Such a great audiobook as well!

Honestly this series is losing me. The spice is fantastic. But the FMC can just be insufferable. And I know it's a why choose but we are collecting men like Pokemon at this point. I want to continue the series to see how the storyline plays out but I also am not that invested.

This series just gets better and better. After that cliffhanger in book two, I couldn’t get to this one fast enough, and it didn’t disappoint. I love how this story progresses and never gets to a point of monotony. Just when I think things may be settling, we get another character introduced or a veering in the plot line. I love the relationships between each member of this group and the way it all remains fluid. And of course, we get one more cliffhanger that has me counting down to the next book.

The audio aspect of this one has been phenomenal. The accents are a fun addition and each narrator does a really good job differentiating between characters. It’s been a pleasure to listen to this story unfold and hear each emotion coming to life through my headphones.

I picked up *So Rare* by Abby Millsaps on a whim, drawn in by its intriguing title and promise of a steamy, emotional romance. While I enjoyed the book overall, I was surprised to find myself a little lost at times, as it turns out this is the third book in a series! I didn’t realize this going in, so the established relationships and ongoing storylines left me scrambling to catch up. That confusion knocked down my rating, though I admit that’s more on me than the author.

What stood out despite my lack of context were the emotionally charged moments and the authentic, flawed characters. Magnolia is a complex heroine grappling with family struggles and personal growth, and her relationships with Greedy, Levi, Spence, and Sione are deeply layered. The romantic tension and personal drama were gripping, even if I didn’t have all the backstory to fully appreciate the dynamics.

I listened to the audiobook version, which was a fantastic experience. The cast of narrators did an incredible job bringing each character to life, making the multiple perspectives easy to follow and engaging. Their performances added depth to the emotional beats of the story and kept me hooked even during the moments I felt a bit out of the loop.

While I would strongly recommend starting with the first book in the *Boys of South Chapel* series to avoid the confusion I faced, *So Rare* is still a beautifully written story that delivers on angst, romance, and heart. If you enjoy steamy, emotional reads and audiobooks with great narration, this one’s worth checking out—but maybe don’t make the same mistake I did and start with book one!

Absolutely obsessed with the boys of South Chapel series. Big fan of Abby’s work. The cast for this audiobook was great, really brings out something different having a full cast. Hunter is one lucky lady.

This book picks up where “So Real” left off - Hunter is gone from Greedy’s dad’s cabin and Greedy thinks she’s running.

This book was a wild ride. We find out Kabir has a tracker implanted in Hunter (wut??) so luckily they can find where she’s doing. Kabir saves the day by swooping in and PURCHASING THE MED SPA where Hunter’s evil mom took her.

The spice in this book was top tier, specifically every single scene with Levi (ESPECIALLY the scene with Levi and Kabir). 🫠

Have you ever read a series that you knew was going to stay with you forever? Well this series is it for me. I’ll just be going about my day and Hunter and the guys will pop into my mind. Hunter is a part of my soul and this book just built on it.

I loved this audiobook! I just finished and let me tell you, if you love audiobooks this one was phenomenal. The full cast of narrators were amazing, they truly brought hunter and the guys to life!

I am so in love with this book- we get to meet Sione and we get to watch the dynamic build between Levi, Greedy and Spence. The relationship that they’re all building together is absolutely beautiful and I cannot wait till I get to see where it goes!

This series has been a very interesting trek in living with chronic conditions and navigating mental health. I liked that each of Hunter’s connections serves as a milestone in her mental health journey. Each has a role and serves a purpose. Excited for the finale ! Audio note: very well done! Each performer brought their character to life.

This audiobook was so fun to listen to! I loved all the different narrorators. They really brought the story to life.

As usual the plot was a wild ride and there were many nice stops along the way with the whole gang. I was surprised to see how well Si fit into the group. The ending was so shocking and I can’t wait to see the conclusion of the series!

OH MY GODDDD!!!!

The twists and turns that Abby puts Hunter through are diabolical. I absolutely love the story that has been told through this series. The representation is *chef's kiss*. My jaw is always on the floor at the end of Abby's books and this one was no different. I am just hoping she does not wreck me beyond repair before this group's HEA.

The narrator choices fit these characters so well, and it felt like I was listening to a podcast of people telling their life stories! This book has so much heart and showcases everyday people's struggles. Hearing the group's personal journies really helped me connect to these characters on a deeper level. I loved everything about the audiobook!

Thank you Dreamscape for the opportunity to listen to the ALC on Netgalley!

I was so excited to see the audiobook for this one! It’s the perfect timing since the final book comes out later this month. All of the narrators did such a wonderful job! I love seeing everyone together as well as Greedy exploring different sides of himself. All these men care so much for Hunter. And that ending?! Wow I was not expecting that at all!

3.5⭐️At this point I am here for the spice and half hoping Greedy, Levi and Spence run away together. 🔥

I really loved The Boys of Lake Chapel series but I think my biggest problem with this one is Hunter and all her drama.

That being said of course there was a cliffhanger and now I need to see this through.

Thank you to the author Abby Millsaps and NetGalley for the advanced listening copy. All my opinions are my own.

I loved this book when I first read it at release, but the audio made me love it that much more! Each narrator embodies their character so well, and really brought this story to life. The story itself is written so beautifully. All the mental health representation with Hunter continues to impress me. I love that each of her guys gives her something different, but they are all things that she needs.

Again, the narrators did so well bringing the right energy to each character and I am so impressed. I will be recommending this audiobook. I think having a different male narrator for each of the guys really helped with bringing the story to life in the way this audiobook has. Just a really great production all around.

Abby does it again hitting us with another Cliff hanger!!! Ughhh I really need to just wait until the series is over so I’m not at the edge of my seat everytime I get to the end of one book lol! Nonetheless I would recommend and read this 1000 times over! Thanks NetGalley for the ARC

These characters being brought to life in my ears is everything. It helps me to feel their emotions so much stronger. The narrators do such a great job. I am so excited to find out what transpires after that cliffhanger!!

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the alc in exchange for an honest review.

Another emotional ride with one new character, Sione, someone that Hunter met in Italy after leaving Britain. She considers him her soul match.

Kabir knew about him and called just in case he might have info after Hunter’s mom takes her in the middle of the night to some sketchy medical spa.

Sione didn’t have any info, but now wants to be kept updated and gets on a flight to North Carolina. What will the others think of this?? Will he be accepted to the group? Will Hunter recover from the weird med spa / memory loss stuff?

Similar to other books, this has POV from multiple characters and past and present Hunter to her first days meeting and connecting with Sione. I feel like there was less Kabir which is fine bec he’s my least favorite.

Overall, another bice addition to the Chapel boys ! That ending 😳

Thank you to NetGalley and Dreamscape Media for the ALC in exchange for an honest review. Audiobook releases on 1/7/25 and the whole series is available on Kindle Unlimited !

I absolutely loved So Rare! This book had me on chokehold! I was hooked from start to finish, just when I thought things were starting to settle down, Abby Millsaps hit us with yet another cliffhanger, I need the next book already! I’m still reeling from the whirlwind of emotions it delivered. The story is everything a why-choose romance should be: intense, steamy, and filled with moments that hit you right in the feels.

From the very first chapter, I was drawn to Magnolia’s determination to fight for her found family and the love she shares with Greedy, Levi, Spence, and Sione. The tension Magnolia faced with her manipulative mother added just the right amount of drama without overshadowing the love story. Each man brought something unique and beautiful to the story, and their dynamics felt so raw and authentic. It was impossible not to root for their happily ever after. It’s rare (pun intended) to see so many characters with such distinct personalities come together in a way that feels so seamless.

The audiobook narration brought this story to life in such a vivid way. The voices perfectly captured every ounce of love, pain, and joy. You could feel the chemistry between the characters as individuals and as a group. If you love angsty, steamy why-choose romances with a strong emotional core, you need to listen to So Rare. It’s an unforgettable story about love, healing, and finding the kind of happiness that’s worth fighting for. I’m already planning my re-listen, it’s that good!

.5⭐️
Despite it being released a couple of months ago this book was still available on NetGalley and I was desperate for an audiobook.
I had listened to book two so I wanted to see the difference

I did enjoy it slightly more but maybe it’s because I knew what I was getting into? It’s angsty smut. So you need to take it for what it is.

It passes the time and provides some frivolous entertainment. So for this type of book what else could I ask for? It’s not winning a Pulitzer anytime soon but for what it is it’s decently written.


I am thankful to have gotten the ALC for free from Dreamscape Media through NetGalley to read which gave me the opportunity to voluntarily leave a review.

My rating system since GoodReads doesn’t have partial stars and I rarely round up.

⭐️ Hated it
⭐️⭐️ Had a lot of trouble, prose issues, really not my cup of tea (potentially DNF’d or thought about it)
⭐️⭐️⭐️ Meh, it was an ok read but nothing special
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Really enjoyed it! Would recommend to others
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Outstanding! Will circle back and read again

So Rare by Abby Millsaps is the epic, enthralling & exhilarating third book in one of my new favorite author’s wonderful why choose romance.

This is book #3 in the Boys of South Chapel series & this cannot be read as a standalone. I also recommend starting with this author’s incredible series Boys of Lake Chapel for the best experience.

So Rare is great for those looking to read…
🩷 Why Choose Romance
🩷 Chronic Illness Rep.
🩷 One Bed Trope
🩷 Multiple Awakenings 🏳️‍🌈

This series is like the sweetest, most dazzling onion with each story peeling & unveiling a new major book in the main characters life & romance. It is beautiful watching them blossom, heal & fall in love. I have to keep things vague as to not give away any spoilers.

I am so grateful & thankful for the chronic illness representation. My heart fills with so much ache, joy, understanding & so much more with the way this author has made chronic illness so intertwined in their stories.

I also listened to the audiobook of this & I loved hearing the characters brought to life. I sat in awe & wonder at being able to listen to this lovely story in audiobook form. I listened at 2x speed & it was perfect for my ADHD brain.

If you are looking for a truly gorgeous, emotional & spicy why choose romance, I cannot recommend the Boys of South Chapel enough.

Massive thanks to NetGalley & Dreamscape Audio for the gifted copy, which I voluntarily read & reviewed.