I love a good witchy ya book, but this one had a plot twist that made it even better! It is beautifully drawn with interesting characters and I'm super excited for the second one!

A couple of typos and inconsistencies aside, this is perfect! I love a NOLA witch story, and even though some of the story beats are predictable, they're still very satisfying and the read is an exciting one! I'm looking forward to purchasing Vol 1 and reading the next installment(s)!

I wasn’t expecting to love this book as much as I did! The art and plot really held my attention and by the end I was begging for more ! I’m glad that I’m giving graphic novels/mangas a chance this year or else I would have missed out on the beauty that is Muted.

I’d never heard of this webcomic before I read this ARC. Muted follows 21-year-old Camille, a niece of the Severin witch family matriarch (and daughter of the former, before her mother and twin sister died in a greenhouse fire). Camille and her cousin, her only confidante, are coming up on the Severin ritual to summon a demon and … choose the next matriarch? I’m not totally clear, but things go awry and Camille discovers that her past and future may not be what she thought.

This graphic novel is gorgeous. The colors are vibrant but definitely fit the witchy vibe of the story. The chapter cards in particular could be sold as prints. Stylistically this novel would be a nice crossover from superhero comic books that middle grade audiences might already like. I could see it being a good gateway into new topics and plot lines—and there was certainly more diversity seamlessly woven in than in most traditional comics I’ve seen. I loved the budding (no pun intended) sapphic romance and all of the mystery within the plot. Some of my students would eat this up.

Even though this first volume didn’t really get anywhere conclusively, it was still satisfying to learn a bit about the different covens. I’d read the next volume to see not only where this story goes, but also to hopefully learn more about the other covens and the members of Camille’s own family who have clearly been hiding some secrets. I’d love for more depth from the characters we’ve already been introduced to—Camille’s cousin Avaline needs more screen time as the daughter of the wretched Athalie! And I need more of Nyra and why she’s even at the Severin estate without Athalie knowing… I want backstory on Camille’s parents. I want to know what’s going on with the demon witch (???) and greenhouse demon (???) and if everything will wind up being connected. Basically, there are A LOT of threads here, and I’m apprehensive about whether this series will stick the landing, but I’m interested to go along for the ride. (So many mixed metaphors.)

I am very much hoping that the many, many typos are fixed before this is published because they often took me “out” of the story, but I’m trying not to worry because this was just an ARC!

This ARC was provided by Clarkson Potter/Ten Speed Press via NetGalley in exchange for my honest thoughts!

Soft DNF at 20%. I enjoyed the artwork and found the premise of this graphic novel really interesting, but I was having a hard time connecting with the story. There are also a few grammatical/spelling errors (e.g., "witches genetics" instead of "witch's genetics") that were a bit distracting to me even though I imagine they'll be fixed in the final version. I might come back to this at some point but don't want to force myself to finish something I'm not really liking.

This graphic novel was so good! I can’t wait for volume 2! I just read 3 bad graphic novels back to back and this was a breath of fresh air. Loved.

I really enjoyed Muted: Volume 1 by Miranda Mundt. The story is gripping from the start, with a dark atmosphere that really pulls you in. The art is gorgeous—there’s something about the color choices that perfectly sets the tone for each scene. I loved how the illustrations helped bring out the emotional depth of the characters.

The characters themselves are well-developed, and I found myself really connecting with their struggles. The theme of mental health is handled with care, and it made the story feel both powerful and real. I can’t wait to see where the next volume takes us!

Definitely looking forward to continuing this journey. Big thanks to NetGalley and Ten Speed Graphic for the early copy

Muted is set in Louisianan and follows a young witch Camille, struggling with her witchy powers and disappointing her family. The story follows her as she learns more about herself and this is definitely only the beginning of her story. Loved the diverse characters and the different types of witches we encounter in this story.

The art style was super cute and fun. My only complaint is that it wasn’t longer! Looking forward to when they publish more.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an advanced copy of the book in exchange for an honest review!

‘Muted, Vol 1’ is a beautifully crafted story filled with magic, romance, and emotional depth. Miranda Mundt creates an enchanting world with compelling characters and stunning illustrations that fully immerse the reader. With a blend of mystery, heartfelt moments, and rich storytelling, this book is a delight from start to finish.

Plot: ★★★★★
The plot is captivating, balancing intrigue, romance, and sweetness effortlessly. The story unfolds with a perfect mix of tension and tender moments, keeping the reader invested in Camille’s journey. The blend of magic and personal growth makes for an engaging and well-paced narrative.

Character: ★★★★★
The characters are one of the book’s strongest elements. Camille is an incredibly lovable protagonist, and it’s easy to root for her happiness from the very beginning. The supporting cast is diverse and well-developed, creating a rich tapestry of relationships - some uplifting, some filled with conflict - that make the story feel alive and dynamic.

Setting: ★★★★★
The world is beautifully built, with a setting that feels lush, immersive, and almost tangible. The magical elements are seamlessly integrated, making the world feel both whimsical and grounded at the same time. Every location feels thoughtfully designed, adding to the overall charm of the story.

Illustration: ★★★★★
The artwork in ‘Muted, Vol 1’ is absolutely stunning. Every page is a visual treat, drawing the reader into the world and enhancing the emotional weight of the story. The character designs, expressions, and environments are all meticulously crafted, making it a joy to read.

Engagement: ★★★★★
From the very first page, ‘Muted, Vol 1’ grabs your attention and doesn’t let go. The emotional stakes, the magic, and the beautifully written relationships keep you invested throughout. It’s the kind of book you can’t put down, and once you finish, you’ll be eager for more.

Readability: ★★★★★
Miranda Mundt’s storytelling is smooth and accessible, making ‘Muted, Vol 1’ an easy and enjoyable read. The pacing is well-balanced, with a great mix of dialogue, action, and introspection. Whether you’re a casual reader or a seasoned fantasy lover, you’ll find the writing style engaging and effortless to follow.

Enjoyment: ★★★★★
I absolutely loved ‘Muted, Vol 1’. It’s heartfelt, beautifully illustrated, and brimming with magic and emotion. The story resonates deeply, making it easy to fall in love with both the characters and their world. It’s definitely a new favourite, and I can’t wait to see where the series goes next.

‘Muted, Vol 1’ is a fantastic read that blends romance, mystery, and magic into an unforgettable story. With gorgeous illustrations, lovable characters, and an engaging plot, it’s a must-read for fans of fantasy and emotional storytelling. Miranda Mundt has created something truly special.

I don't think I'll forgive the author for ending the story when she did. That being said, what a wonderful introduction to the series! Muted follows Camille, a young witch who prepares to summon a demon as part of a ceremony that every woman in her family does when they come of age. Except, it goes very wrong. I love the characters and how their relationships are set up. Parts of the magic system remind me of The Tea Dragon Society, but the cozy aspects are overwhelmed by a darker magic. This book deals explores belonging, self-expression, and coming-of-age themes. I cannot wait to read the sequel.

I had forgotten about this webtoon for a while, I had lost my account so I was very excited to find out that it was getting a published book! It was just as good as I remembered. Hope everyone else enjoys it too, thanks Netgalley for the access!

Muted is not only a magical portrayal of grief, loss, and healing. It is also visually stunning and heartfelt in a way the still stays with me after reading it

4⭐️

The art work for this graphic novel is absolutely stunning. The colors are bright and colorful. The illustrator did an amazing job capturing the scenes and moods.

This a pretty solid start to this series. A story of a young witch finding herself after tragedy. Also finding out about family secrets that helps explains who she is who she is.

I enjoyed the characters and the plot so far. We didn't find out a ton in this first book but it made a solid start to the foundation for more books to follow.

Thank you to NetGalley and Clarkson Potter/Ten Speed Press for this advanced reader copy. My review is voluntarily my own.

Thanks to NetGalley for the opportunity to read Muted: Volume 1.

The story starts in New Orleans and is about a young witch named Camille. You'd think a story about witches in New Orleans would be cliché and over done but Miranda Mundt tells the story in a way where it doesn't eel dull or over done and leans into the setting to tell the story. Also, the artwork is STUNNING and its the story perfectly.

I have not read the Webtpon so I am not sure how this version differs from the original, however, I really loved this so far. This is a story about a girl who has lost her mom in a fire and been under the care of her abusive aunt since. I don’t want to spoil too much of this but I’ll say it’s a really beautifully drawn story and really interesting. The world building is good and I find myself intrigued by all the various characters. Can’t wait to read the next volume!

Great artwork with a great premise of a graphic novel. A soft DNF for me currently, but one I do hope to return to within the next few months.

I am not giving a true star rating as I intend to return to the book and give a true rating then.

Another approved NetGalley ARC! I remember reading this on Webtoon when it came out a few years ago and I was entranced. Seeing it in a more refined graphic novel makes my heart happy! These sapphic witches make my heart happy and so does Toben and Beignet (the familiars). Breaking generational curses, found family, and a mysteriously deadly secret are some of the themes of this graphic novel series. I’m excited to see Camille (the FMC) grow as the novels continue. The art is so stunning as well and easily flowing dialogue that is easy to follow.

Thank you NetGalley and Miranda Mundt for the ARC! All thoughts and opinions are honest and my own.

I haven’t read lots of graphic novels before but it’s a genre I want to delve into more and I loved this one. The illustrations and art are absolutely stunning and evoke so much emotion and power. The storyline is intriguing with diverse and interesting characters that I want to know more about. I’m excited for volume 2 to find out what happens next!
Overall, I had a great time reading this and it was really beautifully put together. Will definitely be pre-ordering a physical copy for when it’s released!

After the tragic death of her family, Camille never really fit in with the family that took her in, and that's for a very good reason. Filled with the yearning of needing to know oneself with light sapphic tones, this is a cozy quick read for any witch at heart.

I really enjoyed the foray into this witchy matriarchal story and am looking forward to the next installment!

This. Was. AWESOME!

I can't remember if I enjoyed a comic this much lately - I read it in one breath.

It is full of magic, finding oneself, and a lot of dark, but also light and humorous moments.
It's a perfect balance in my opinion.

I am so invested in the world, and a lot of things are left to be fully developed in further books, which I can't wait for! I absolutely love the inclusivity of all possible groups in this book. It was done so flawlessly, too (mentioning this because sometimes it is done forcefully to meet a quota...).

The artwork and colouring were so vibrant and magical. They added another dimension to this graphic novel.

I am already holding my breath for book 2, and book 1 isn't even out yet. I recommend it wholeheartedly.

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and the publisher for granting me this ARC in exchange for an honest opinion.