Gothic historical set in Italy? Yes please! This book was so delightful. The writing and characterization was delightful. This book absolutely had me by the throat. I loved Oriana and followed her journey with baited breath. I only wish there was more of the secret market. That was a bit of an unfulfilled promise for me.

I wasn’t familiar with Giovanni De Feo’s work before picking up The Secret Market of the Dead, but I’m so glad I did. This novel blends magical realism with historical fantasy in a way that completely captivated me. Set in 18th-century Naples, the story draws you into a world where the boundaries between reality and the fantastical are beautifully blurred.

The plot follows Oriana, a young woman who dreams of becoming a blacksmith like her father, despite the societal and familial expectations that try to hold her back. The themes of ambition, gender roles, and family pressures are explored in a way that feels both personal and universal.

De Feo’s writing creates a dreamlike atmosphere that immerses you in the story from the very first page. The characters are well-developed and relatable, each struggling with their own desires and obstacles.

One of the most intriguing aspects of the novel is its exploration of the “Night,” where dreams become both a source of inspiration and danger. This added an extra layer of depth to the story, making me reflect on the nature of ambition and the sacrifices that come with it.

Overall, The Secret Market of the Dead is a beautifully written and thought-provoking novel that blends elements of folklore, personal ambition, and family drama. It was a fantastic introduction to De Feo’s work, and I’ll definitely be keeping an eye out for more from him in the future.

The Secret Market of the Dead was a unique read filled with Night creatures and quests. I enjoyed the relationship and also the tension between twins Oriana and Oriano as they battle to become first apprentice at their father's forge. I really enjoyed the Italian gothic setting and folklore and the idea of the Night and how different of a world it was from the Day. This was a beautifully gothic fantasy read and so unique from other fantasies I have read. The pacing was a bit slow at first, but it picks up and although the ending was a bit abrupt, I felt like it fit the story well.

The Secret Market of the Dead by Giovanni De Feo is a gorgeously eerie and magical tale about fate, family, and defying expectations. Set in 18th-century Italy, it follows Oriana—a bold, headstrong young woman who refuses to accept that her twin brother is automatically destined to inherit their father’s forge. Determined to prove herself, she challenges him to three trials. But to stand a chance, she strikes a dangerous bargain with Emistuchivio, the Duke of the Under-Earth and Darkness, and ventures into the haunting Secret Market of the Dead—a realm ruled by seven immortals and powered by Moira, magic that can reshape destiny… but always comes with a price. Steeped in folklore, mysticism, and gothic charm, this story has it all—family drama, fierce ambition, and just the right touch of the macabre. I absolutely loved it! Thank you Saga Press , Giovanni De Feo, and NetGalley for allowing me and eARC and to read this wonderful book.

Thank you NetGalley and Saga Press for the Advanced copy.

What a beautiful world. I wanted to read this the minute I saw the gorgeous cover and I'm glad I did.

Note- this is not for the reader looking for an easy read. The world woven in this tale is intricate and full of rich, deep characters. I found myself reading slowly just to soak it in.

I enjoyed following Oriana's journey. She is spirited and determined and a joy to follow along.

4 stars

This is a charming and imaginative fairy tale, a novel about fate and destiny that kept me invested throughout. The story follows Oriana, a young woman who wishes to join her twin brother as heir to her father’s forge, forced by opposition to her dream to turn to magical means from the Night side of her 18th-century Italian city. The Night is a fey and perilous realm where nothing is quite as it seems and it is all to easy to become lost, but Oriana braves it with incredible courage and the help of magical allies.

I love that the beauty of the Night lies in the unexplainable. This is not a book with a hard magic system that could be easily spreadsheeted and made into the rules of a roleplaying game; this is a book that celebrates mystery, the sacred potential of the dark that contains unknown possibilities.

I would recommend this book to fans of historical urban fantasy and dark (not grimdark, just dangerous) fairy tales.

Content warning: cat death.

A magical fantasy story filled with rich imagination and beautiful descriptions, reminiscent of "The Night Circus" and "Spirited Away". One of my favorite elements was the Cat Parliament—such a unique and memorable touch. This book takes readers on an unforgettable journey brimming with creativity. While the beginning is a bit slow, it picks up around the 15% mark and only gets better from there.

The story follows a nine-year-old girl who is given a task in the Dead Market. Years later, when she realizes she can’t achieve her dream on her own, she returns to the market—where every deal comes with a price.

Beneath the whimsical worldbuilding, this is ultimately a tale of a young girl chasing her dream and growing up along the way. Oriana is hardworking and clever, yet also stubborn and naive. I appreciate that she is a good girl, but not a perfect one—flaws make characters feel real. And, just like in life, not everyone gets a perfect happy ending. But on the other hand, as a mother, it inspires me to communicate with my daughter more.

*Thank you to NetGalley and (publisher) for the opportunity to read this ARC. All opinions are my own accurate opinions.

Gorgeous descriptions of another world! Yet I could not follow the jumps, various routes and wild turnabout this book had in store. High hopes, and wasn't for me.

Wow what a beautiful story! I was completely blown away by the imagery, character development, and overall story. The author did an amazing job at creating such a strong-willed and inspiring MC like Oriana. It was refreshing to read in such an intense book. I had an amazing time reading it from start to finish.

this was a pretty good book! I like the way the familial dysfunction comes through, and how there are so many layers of secrets that shine through. I like this book, and enjoyed reading it! I liked the flow and the writing style of this book!!

Thank you to NetGalley, to the author, and to the publisher for this complimentary ARC in exchange for my honest review!!!

A gothic, utterly mesmerizing fantasy with a world so rich and rooted in darkness it practically breathes shadows and mystery into the night air! 🌙🔥

The Night and its Nocturnes feel impossibly alive! Shadowy, eerie and seductively enchanting with passing hints of creepy - the world building is intricate and in tune with its storytelling elements that enrapture the essence of the impossible world of the Night and Nocturnes. This story takes on a life of its own- descriptions that come to life off the page and melt us into the scene! ✨🖤

Oriana is a strong whirlwind of love, jealousy and sheer force. She dreams of becoming a smith at her father's forge despite long-standing tradition, family and fate standing in her way. When her father names her twin brother as heir when they reach of age (boo), she’s forced to fight for her place and when Night calls to her with its forbidden power, it whispers into her ear promises of destiny…but doesn't tell her of the danger until it's too late (and it's almost always too late). The world of the night is a world that his both mythical, mystical and as cruel as it is craven. Wrapping Oriana in its eerie, enchanting embrace, it is loath to let her go. And to be honest, she might not want to when all is said and done.

She battles the weight of societal expectations, perceptions of womanhood, familial obligations and parental favoritism/neglect (MY POOR BABY). I absolutely adore the way she gives not an inch and won't accept less than she deserves. The way in which Oriana reflects rejection of feminine expectations and the concept of her desire for masculinity as a shield to protect her opportunities, duties and expectations is a mirror of women's struggles which I applaud.

The pacing felt a bit uneven (why so much time on her childhood? Where were my extra 50 pages at the end?! I feel like I needed a longer wrap-up 😭) and her mother’s motivations left me scratching my head sometimes BUT the completion of the characters' complexities (her brother and father, namely) and the originality of the world more than made up for it.

With its dreamlike storytelling and a heroine who refuses to let the world define her, The Secret Market of the Dead is a beautiful, fast read. Definitely re-read worthy! 🕯️🔥

I am completely BLOWN AWAY! I went into this with a vague interest based off the description, and it was a total page turner. I loved the writing, I loved Oriana and I can only envy the author for such a colorful imagination and a way of telling it in a story. I sincerely hope this book finds its way to a wide audience if only so I could talk to someone about it. Thank you NetGalley, Saga Press and Giovanni De Feo for the ARC and for the existence of this tale.

All I can say is "WOW"! This was such a beautiful and mysterious gothic historical fantasy. This book was so well written and had an amazing plot! The author did an amazing job with the imagery of the book. I was able to visualize every scene and character perfectly. The beginning started off kind of slow but he more you read, the more it picks up and completely captivates you.

It took me a minute to get into this book, but the second I did, I was INTO it! I loved this and can't wait to read more from this author!

What a fantastic book! The first one I have read by this author but definitely can't wait to read more! The characters stay with you long after you finish the book. Highly recommend!

March 9, 2025
A fantastical tale rich in Italian folklore and imagery. The world and character building were excellent, and I was absorbed in the story right from the start. Would definitely read more set in this world or style!!


I received an arc copy of this book, provided by Netgalley.

Thank you to NetGalley and Saga Press for providing the DRC for review. All opinions are my own.

The Secret Market of the Dead by Giovanni De Feo is a magical tale about a young girl named Oriana, who has been touched by the Night. She dreams of following in her father’s footsteps to become a smith and inherit the family forge. However, society and her family deem this dream unbecoming, as women are expected to marry and bear children. In this world, Night and dreams are dangerous realms where sacrifices must be made to bring dreams to life. As Oriana navigates society’s expectations and the ever-increasing pull of the Night, will she be able to achieve her dreams, or will she become one herself?

“But that was also why she loved the Night, for not everything had to be explained, and so not everything was.” This quote from The Secret Market of the Dead perfectly encapsulates the experience of reading this story. Giovanni De Feo’s writing is remarkably beautiful. He weaves words together in a way that creates a hazy, dreamlike world that is both captivating and haunting. The characters and their surroundings feel as though they could have been lifted from a Guillermo del Toro film. The plot is intricate, touching on the dynamics between the dreams we have for ourselves and the dreams our parents have for us. Oriana is a protagonist we can all relate to—striving to achieve a dream while the world seems to conspire against her. The best parts of the book are when the focus is solely on her and her journey.

However, as the quote suggests, much of this book remains unexplained, and while I am generally okay with ambiguity, I found myself feeling lost for much of the story. There are numerous characters and creatures to keep track of, and I struggled to remember who was who or what they looked like. I do believe this is intentional—dreams rarely make sense, so why should the dreamworld follow logical rules? Still, there were sections of the book where I found myself glazing over, especially when the focus shifted to the backstory and history of the dreamworld and its key figures. This might be a nitpick, but there’s also an instance where Oriana’s twin brother’s name changes midway through the story, which only added to my overall confusion.

Despite these issues, I’ve found myself reflecting on this book long after finishing it. It’s a layered and complex story, and its ethereal nature makes it difficult to review. If you're up for the challenge, I would highly recommend it.

Be careful what you wish for and more importantly who you trust.

With a determination ahead of her time Oriana ventures into the ‘Secret Market of the Dead’ to return a prized tool to the Night Saints and finds herself bound to a world made of dreams and tricks as they test her will to succeed as the rightful heir as her fathers apprentice.

While I enjoyed the ideas brought forth in this story I wish the characters were aged up a bit to make it seem like it was meant for a younger audience the the young adult genre it’s billed for. The concept of the Night Market and how old sayings and cautionary tales could be undead things desperate to inflict their madness on to the living was one of my favorite parts of the story but staying in the mind of a child all throughout made it feel very middle grade.

I liked Oriana a great deal and as mentioned before she is very much a a character who is out of time as she sets her sights on ambitions far greater than the role of wife and mother that has been decided for her simply because of her gender. Her determination to rise above those restraints and work tirelessly to exceed those expectations was nothing short of powerful as she rallies against the wishes of her family and her peers as well as active sabotage from the apprentice she wishes to work under should she succeed.

This feels very much like a folk tale and I love that it is whispered as such with the beginning being told in this cautionary way for a saint no one dares speak about. The market lives as this dark underbelly of the city granting wishes at a hefty cost and punishing those for their greed or other sins but in the right hands Oriana was able to use this place as a tool all her own to push herself to become as great she always knew herself to be and I enjoyed that even still she was required to make a sacrifice true to the bargain struck in her childhood.

An interesting story with a lot of great ideas and imagery that will linger with me for quite some time but I wish it was aged up or I was far younger to feel more of that connection to the main character other than the desire to see women become what they want to be and not what others believe they should be.

**special thanks to the publishers and netgalley for providing an arc in exchange for a fair and honest review**

The only negative feedback I have is that I didn't like the way this book begins with the "this is what you dreamed" prologue. If this hadn't been an arc, I may have been inclined to DNF but that would have been a mistake because the rest of this book is top tier. It was a truly unique adventure that I couldn't put down.

This book was a wonderfully immersive story. Love when I get to learn about a different world's folklore. Such a different tale about growing up and becoming who your going to be.