I appreciate NetGalley and IDW Publishing for giving me access to this eARC. My review is based solely on my own thoughts and feelings.

4.5

Favorite quote from the book:

"Whoever you are... you can't possibly beat me up more than I do myself... I obsess over every little thing I've ever said that came out wrong. Every weird look anyone ever gave me." - Michelangelo

The brilliant writing and striking, deliberate illustrations from a variety of talented artists made this a highly captivating read. Each page held the promise of something exciting. I particularly loved the unique artistic interpretations of each character, which made them feel more intriguing and distinct.

As someone new to the TMNT universe, I occasionally felt slightly lost due to references to past lore, though this didn't detract significantly from my overall enjoyment and is in no way a criticism to the author.

This magnificent story masterfully highlighted the contrasts between the brothers through their individual illustration styles, personalities, and narrative arcs. Seeing a more authentic and raw side of the ninjas allowed me to connect with them on a deeper level. This is a fantastic experience for anyone who appreciates the TMNT saga, beautiful artwork from gifted artists, and clever, witty writing.

I have been a fan of the TMNT's since I was a kid. I loved the 90's cartoon and toys. And I have read some of the comics before.

Vol. 1: Return to New York is great. It starts off with the turtles separated after going their separate ways. Each story explains what they have been up to since then. And then how they come back together. The story and artwork are great.

I really enjoyed reading this new story about the TMNT and look forward to reading more of series.

This was such a great re-introduction to the Turtles!

They're all split up after the events of the previous run (of which I know nothing, to be honest) and the series begins by showing us what each have been up to. Each has their own chapter, with the eventual reunion coming together as Donnie's position becomes precarious.

I really loved how this was set out, and it was nice for the guys to have their own screen time. It's actually refreshing to see a little hostility - they've all become so focused on their own thing they've forgotten what it means to be brothers.

Artwork is fantastic and complements the story nicely. The turtles each have their own unique look now that kind of reflects what they've been through, and I enjoyed that detail a lot. Poor Donnie!

Overall, this was a really great way to start the new run. I've been reading the monthly singles as well and it's always a long wait for the next month to come along!

Immense fun - TMNT fans should be happy with Aaron's work on this one.

With thanks to Netgalley for an ARC of the collected edition

I have the original collected comics of the TNMT and have only read a small bit in the later comic years. So, on my return, this was a fantastic journey into a future where our heroes had a weak moment and are now trying to come to terms with their shared life - and how valuable it is. I think this sets up a potentially long run of comics, with new conflict. Now, it does bring back the Foot and a new "Shredder" heir - which almost made me think of how The Force Awakens was only a rehash of A New Hope...will we just see a rehash of the Turtles against a sinister Foot Clan or will we see something different?

As a kid I discovered the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles cartoon sometime in the mid-90s, and much like every other show I used to watch growing up, any new version or modern adaptation of such material immediately strikes a nostalgic nerve in me. Add to that the fact that 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Vol. 1: Return to New York' is written by Jason Aaron, whose Thor/Mighty Thor runs and work in the Star Wars comics I thoroughly enjoyed, and features art by Joëlle Jones, Rafael Albuquerque, Cliff Chiang, and Darick Robertson, and it's no surprise that I was really eager to read this book.

Having now finished the first volume, I can say that 'Return to New York' certainly didn't disappoint. Even though it's a continuation and not a reboot, it's a pretty good starting point for new readers. The story is noticeably grittier and more violent than the original series, but never gets exploitative or edgy for the sake of edginess.

The book starts with the turtles separated, each in a different place and situation, which works well in (re)introducing them, establishing their different personalities and perspectives, and setting up the story for when they eventually reunite. The plot worked well, making for a fast-paced read, the art, considering it involved such great talent, was everything I expected it to be, and the story is very much in the spirit of TMNT. I will absolutely be grabbing Vol. 2, no question.

A big thank you to IDW Publishing for offering me an Advance Readers Copy in exchange for an honest review.

A good take on the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. Though it feels like a story that has been told before, it's just different enough to feel fresh. The artwork is good for the majority of the collection though it is a bit jolting when the art style changes when transitioning between certain chapters. The dialogue is well done and the first volume leaves you on a cliff hanger that will have you reaching for the second volume immediately.

***No Spoilers***

I requested and received a digital advance copy through NetGalley.

This collection sets an incredible foundation for the series ahead—truly a must-read for any Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles fan. The artwork is outstanding, with each panel perfectly capturing the creators' intent and energy. The narrative structure, initially separating our heroes, offers readers a chance to connect deeply with each character’s individual perspective, adding depth and nuance to the storytelling.

Admittedly, I'm not fully caught up with recent developments in the TMNT universe, so I ended up reading this collection twice. The first read-through had me eagerly flipping pages due to the compelling narrative pace, while the second helped me fully appreciate all the story's layers. Each character's voice is distinct and well-realized, authentically portraying their unique situations. The action sequences are dynamic and fast-paced, never losing clarity or excitement.

Without giving any spoilers, the narrative delivers precisely what each character’s arc requires, even if it might not align exactly with your expectations. By the final page, my only frustration was having to wait for the next installment. If this first collection is an indication of what's to come, consider me thoroughly hooked—I’ll be following closely and purchasing every volume on day one.

Echoes of the Ronin: TMNT: Return to New York Delivers a Mature Take

Jason Aaron's 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Vol 1: Return to New York' is a masterclass in blending nostalgia with a fresh, compelling narrative. This comic feels like a genuine love letter to the foundational elements of the TMNT universe, seamlessly weaving in the spirit and energy that defined so many of our favorite turtle tales. Yet, it's not just a retread of the past; Aaron injects a mature and impactful storytelling approach reminiscent of the acclaimed 'The Last Ronin.'

Reading this volume is like stepping into a time machine, instantly reconnecting with the distinct personalities of Donatello, Raphael, Michelangelo, and Leonardo. Aaron perfectly captures their dynamic, their humor, and their unwavering bond. But this isn't just a lighthearted trip down memory lane. The stakes are raised considerably as the heroes in a half-shell grapple with a resurgent Foot Clan, now under the formidable leadership of Karai. This new dynamic brings a compelling layer of tension and intrigue to their familiar world.

Without giving away any of the exciting twists and turns, I can confidently say that if you've ever enjoyed any iteration of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles franchise – from the classic cartoons to the gritty comics – this is a comic you absolutely cannot afford to miss. Jason Aaron has delivered a powerful and engaging start to this new era of TMNT, honoring its legacy while forging a thrilling new path forward. Highly recommended!

prelude story of Long Way From Home #1-6
The turtles have idividually left new york city:
raphael in prison undercover
michelangelo is in tokyo living as a famous movie star
donatello is trapped in a mutant zoo, fighting rich men for money
with the new mayor causing trouble in NYC, the foot reappears and takes hold of the city while the new leader makes a skeezy deal with the mayor
the turtles must fight to reunite and stop the mayor and the foot in this dark, gorey, nostalgic ride

Review: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Vol. 1: Return to New York by Jason Aaron

I was a fan of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles growing up so I was really interested when this ARC became available to me!

Honestly, I was never one to read comic books in my earlier years, I mostly watched the TMNT cartoons/movies. BUT! I thought the illustrations and storyline of this volume was incredible. The artwork is amazing. I also loved how the turtles were introduced, and how it is different than what we typically see in the cartoons and films.

I think this book is perfect for TMNT fans and collectors.

This is a collected set of the brand new TMNT series by IDW, and they really have hit it out of the park with these issues. I have only ever really been a TMNT dabbler, but I always enjoyed what I have read from IDW runs, this one being no exception. This is a great way to get into the characters, this book providing a lot of build up that gives you a good idea of who the characters are, when they aren't fighting and eating pizza.

The tone of this is a lot different to what you may expect, it's quite gritty, the themes are darker and it is a little emotional. The writing and art really hit a sweet spot for me that really does evoke some strong emotions, especially for one particular turtle that is going through a tough spot.

If you have been interested in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, but don't want to read everything previously, this is a great start. There will be some questions or confusion, but that is always the case when jumping into a series and I think these issues do a great job in not making you feel like you have missed out on too much if you have never picked up a turtle comic.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an e-ARC of this book.

This is a very solid beginning to a gritty TMNT story. The story by Jason Aaron is well developed and allows for each individual turtle to be fleshed out. This is especially important when considering that the turtles have changed drastically from the characters that are often portrayed in popular media outside of the comics. They are scattered, broken, and hurting. Developing them in very distinct ways allows for their reunion to feel more impactful. Donatello is especially well-written in this volume and served as the standout story for me. The art is also phenomenal throughout, with a grit and grime that fits the story very well. I am excited to see where this story leads and how Aaron will continue to flesh out the new villain.

Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Random House/IDW publishing for providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I've always loved Jason Aaron's writing—he first came to my attention through Scalped and his incredible end to the Punisher MAX run—so I was beyond excited to see him take on Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Return to New York. He delivers a powerhouse return to form. The artwork is incredible and gritty, reminding me of the old school TMNT comics.

This wouldn't be a comic for fans of the Nickelodeon show. This is a much darker take on TMNT.

I was a big fan of the Ninja turtles growing up so thank you NetGalley , IDW Publishing , Jason Aaron and crew for allowing me to read this Advance copy in exchange for an Honest review.

This edition of TNMNT was different then I expected as it begins with all the turtles are in different places like Prison , Japan , India. battling enemies . They eventually reunite In NY to try to save NY from the Foote Clan.

I thoroughly enjoyed the Art as well as the Story in this. There was amazing story telling despite me not expecting the turtles to originally be separated and splinter Dead at the beginning.

One thing I had trouble with which I did not remove Stars for is the ARC had a Watermark the publisher put there and that watermark in many spots covered the writing of the story making it hard to read the words. If the Publisher is going to watermark an ARC next time maybe not cover words or make the watermark a lighter color so the words can be seen clear I found myself squinting at times to read parts due to this.

Been reading these as issues, and it's so freaking good, I asked Netgallery to send me a review copy to re-read and then spread the word.

THIS is a must-read for any TMNT fan, and it’s quickly become one of my personal favorite stories in the series. The character moments in this volume are fantastic, especially the interactions between the brothers when they finally reunite. There’s something special about the dynamic between Leonardo, Donatello, Michelangelo, and Raphael that truly shines when they’re together, but what makes it even more impactful is the fact that much of this story has them separated.

It seems like it could be a letdown at first, but the separation actually adds so much depth to their relationships. The tension, the unresolved issues between them, and their personal struggles all contribute to a much more satisfying reunion. This messy, complicated family dynamic really enriches the narrative and makes their eventual coming back together all the more rewarding.

Each issue of this volume also stands out with a different artist, which really helps set the tone for each turtle’s individual journey. It’s not just a stylistic choice, it works to highlight the emotional shifts in the story and enhance the reader's connection to each character. This is especially evident in the darker moments, which Return to New York dives into with no hesitation. The story takes a much grimmer turn, particularly for Donatello, and it hits hard. The stakes feel real, and the emotional weight of the narrative leaves a lasting impression. One that honestly blew me away with some of these issues.

If you're a fan of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, this is definitely one you won't want to miss. It’s a dark, emotional, and action-packed journey that is one of the finest TMNT stories out there. Highly recommended! Cowabunga dudes!!!!!!

I'm so excited to continue this series. My inner kid is healed. The story line is very reminiscent of the X-men anti-mutant story line with the nostalgia of classic TMNT.

I have such a deep love for the original Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles animated series, that every once in a while I will see something pop up as a good entry point for later works and I'll give it a shot to try to recapture the feelings that cartoon gave me. And unfortunately every time I leave a little disappointed. I think where I struggled most with this one was in the art style. It's personally not a style that I love, especially in Issue #2 and Issue #4, which is a shame because generally Michelangelo and Donatello are my favorites and those two issues center where Michelangelo and Donatello, respectively, are after some event broke up the gang. I did find the plot compelling and would be interested in going back to see how the Turtles got to this point and how they recover.

"Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Return to New York" follows each Turtle and shows us what they're up to, before reuniting them to face a bigger threat.
The idea works perfectly with the art: each character has a unique visual style that helps to differentiate one story from the other.

The pacing is uneven. It makes sense with the story, it feels like a choice. Regarding the plot, Donnie is by far the most interesting one. The book could focus on him and I'll be here for it. Leo has the weakest one, I'm giving it a pass because the art and use of color is incredible but plot wise I felt the story would be the same without dedicating so many pages to him.

The overall tone in the book is dark, but the story manages to add here an there some interactions between the brothers that lighten the mood, and feels on brand.

I really enjoyed the comic. It's visually incredible and the plot kept me hooked. Perhaps the least interesting thing here is the villain, whose plan seems quite simple. But, in general, I want to know more.

Loved the turtles as a child so thought I would give this a go and it was amazing.

It gave me a massive nostalgia hit whilst also feeling very mature. It appeals to all

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc of this graphic novel.

First off, the nostalgia I got from reading this was incredible. I’ve loved TMNT since I was a kid and this made me feel so many things from childhood. I loved it.

Second, the artists who collaborated with the author did such an amazing job on the story telling in pictures. I loved the incorporation of several artists. This was so much fun to not only read but to look at.

The ninja turtles are so badass. This was a great visualization of just how badass they are.