This book is described as “controversial” and “provocative,” and it could probably offend people of any political leaning. However, I think people of every political leaning will get something worthwhile out of it, even if they disagree with some points. I am rating this book based on the credibility and quality of its writing, not whether I agree with the author on every single one of his opinions, because that’s how I think reviewing a book should work.

To distill the book down to two main ideas, it advocates for
1. free speech (albeit not without consequences if you misuse this right) and sincere discussions
2. viewing people according “the content of their character” rather than the “color of their skin,” as Dr. King would say.
I would hope those are not all that controversial, yet apparently they are. That is why it is all the more important that Williams writes the way he does: with thoughtfulness and thoroughness. He discusses difficult topics with sensitivity and acknowledges their complexity. His
claims are backed up by abundant citations.

As indicated by the excellent title, this book is essentially a response to what transpired in the summer of 2020 and how America (and the world) reacted. It is ultimately about what it means to be American and what it means to be human.

This was close to being a five-star read for me. I would have liked it even better if it had felt a bit more accessible for all, and if it had had a bit more hope in terms of clear ideas for how to make things better. The ending felt abrupt and bleak (which, honestly, makes sense given the content and the title, but still).

I recommend this book to anyone concerned about the state of thought and speech in America today.

Thank you to NetGalley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor for the free eARC. I post this review with my honest opinions. This review is cross-posted on Goodreads and will be posted on Amazon and Instagram within one week of the book’s publication date.