
Member Reviews

I was completely enthralled by the first book in the Dee & Lao series, The Murder of Mr. Ma, and have been hoping for a second since the minute I turned the very last page of that first. So I was more than pleased to see this second book appear – even if finishing it has returned me to my earlier state, now hoping for a third book to be published.
Because this second adventure was every bit as marvelous as the first – and in some ways better as we already know these characters but now have the opportunity to plumb their hidden – and sometimes not so hidden – depths.
This second of Dee and Lao’s adventures is set in 1924 London. Both characters are based on real historical figures. Lao’s background and current profession were historically as the series portrays him. From 1924 until 1929, he was a lecturer at the University of London on the subjects of Chinese language and literature. Whether his students were as frustrating, and whether Lao himself was as utterly bored out of his mind as he is portrayed in the story, is not certain, but they certainly leave the fictional Lao ripe to be carried along in Dee’s adventures.
Dee Ren Jie is as much myth as he is historical, but the historical Dee was a magistrate in late 7th century China. How much the historical Dee resembles this fictional interpretation is unknown, but I think it’s safe to say that the original Dee never masqueraded as the English folk hero/demon Spring-heeled Jack – as Lao’s friend Dee often does.
The story combines these bits of history with a compelling, confounding mystery, as all the best historical mysteries do.
Dee has returned to London after a year’s absence as an agent of the then-current Nationalist government in China. But that government is shaky at best. There are movements within China, including but not limited to the Communist Party, to bring the Nationalist government down. And there are forces outside China, great and would-be great powers far from limited to Britain, Russia, Japan and the United States, observing and even influencing events hoping that to destabilize the Nationalist regime so that they can pick up the pieces.
Which is where Dee and Lao and their associates, the redoubtable Sergeant Hoong and young English pickpocket Jimmy Fingers come into this tale, which begins with the return of a precious stolen artifact, middles in a great deal of romantic misdirection practiced successfully upon the supposedly impervious Dee, and concludes with an explosive confrontation on the London Necropolis Railway. (The Necropolis Railway is another bit of history that seems like it must be fiction, but it did really exist!)
When the dust settles, and there’s LOTS of it to settle, the immediate crisis – at least the London branch of it – is over. Dee is left realizing that he’s been a fool. And that while this crisis has been ameliorated it has absolutely not been averted – but that the fight will take him to other shores in other guises. In addition to making a fool out of him, the conspiracy has also made him their scapegoat, and London has become much too hot for him – at least as long as he continues to present himself as, well, himself.
So poor Lao is stuck returning to the boredom of his academic existence, while the country he left behind and plans to return to, is in jeopardy from all sides – including the one that he himself espouses.
It all sounds ripe for another book, doesn’t it? I certainly hope so!
Escape Rating A: I loved this even more than I did the first book, The Murder of Mr. Ma, which means that I need to give another shoutout to First Clue Reviews for their featured review of that first book.
One of the reasons I liked this better leads around and back to the other reason I got into this series. Many of the reviews of Dee & Lao liken them to Sherlock Holmes, especially the more active Guy Ritchie movie interpretations. While I think that is debatable, one way in which Dee & Lao are certainly like Holmes and Watson (and also Barker & Llewelyn) is that Lao serves as Dee’s chronicler as Watson does Holmes, with the same amount of reluctance to participate in the process on the parts of both Dee and Holmes.
Which means that this story is told in Lao’s first person voice. This is his interpretation – with the occasional use of a bit of literary license – of the events. In that regard, the narrator Daniel York Loh does a terrific job of interpreting Lao’s voice, to the point that when I ended up reading the last part of the book because I needed to find out who the true leader of the conspiracy is and how all the issues and conundrums got resolved – I was still hearing Loh’s voice in my head speaking as Lao.
I couldn’t put this one down because of how effectively it combined the pure whodunnit of the theft and murder conspiracy in London with the depth of historical setting and situation that lay behind it and the increasing knowledge of and bond between the characters, this most unlikely band of ‘scoobies’ that includes a government official, a merchant, a scholar, a pickpocket and has increased by the addition of a knife thrower and a dog. Dee pretends they are a circus act and he’s not far wrong in some aspects, but if it is it’s a circus that manifests a well of competence and an ability to improvise on the spot and roll with the punches.
And not just the punches they are administering themselves.
This reader, at least, is already anticipating Dee and Lao’s next adventure. It’s sure to be another fantastic read. After all, thanks to the conspiracy it’s going to have to start with Dee coming back from the dead!

In 1924 London, Judge Dee returns to investigate a series of murders following the recovery of a valuable artifact. Aided by associate Lao, he must unravel a conspiracy linked to Chinese nationalism and the Chinese Eastern Railway before more lives are lost.
This is an interesting mystery, but I’m not the target audience. The characters are flat and the emotion nonexistent. There were multiple, long, elaborate fight scenes, which I fast-forwarded through. I guess some people like that sort of thing, but it doesn’t appeal to me. I’m sure others will enjoy it. The book is well written, and the audiobook narration is well done.
Thanks, NetGalley, for the ARC I received. This is my honest and voluntary review.

While this is the second book in a series, I had no problem following the intriguing duo of investigators along the winding path to uncovering this conspiracy surrounding a railway. What initially attracted me to the book was the cover that hints at an old-timey mysterious fun, but what kept me gong were not only the rich historical detail about the spread of communism in China amidst imperialist ambitions, but also the abundant and enticing descriptions of Asia food.
Thank you Netgalley for this ALC.

Cool premise and history -- a little too much action for me (I had not read book one) b ut I liked the characters and the plot twists. I've liked every "Judge Dee" story I've met :-)

This sequel, 'The Railway Conspiracy', is a culturally intriguing and action-packed mystery! With such a unique premise, I'm pleased that the books' descriptions truly do the series justice. I love following the unlikely band of characters as they root out evil in 1920s London. Professor Lao She's narration is especially entertaining, and I often chuckle at how he incorporates accounts from other characters.
I recommend this audiobook to any fan of historical action stories! Daniel York Loh is a top-notch narrator.
Special thanks to RBmedia and NetGalley for providing a complimentary copy of this audiobook. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.