Joining the Quigley back in the Crescent Moon was an absolute delight only added to by some new characters and some equally quirky settings. The forward movement of the sisters' lives keeps me gripped in the story, and the cozy hearths and tea and books keep me grounded. I'd love more of these sisters and their futures, but for now I'm more than content to sit in the comforting stories of the first book and now its equally delightful sequel.

Stepping back into the Quigley Sisters' world and the Crescent Moon is like getting the warmest hug on the coldest day of winter. Stacy Sivinski's writing has actual magic laced into every single word. I'm not the biggest fan of tea (don't tell the sisters), but every description of tea and cinnamon buns had me craving all the treats that are served at the Crescent Moon. I also loved the winter setting in this book, as a Chicagoland native, it was so funny reading about all the characters braving the cold city streets. The descriptions of going from the biting cold winds to the warmth of a shop or a tearoom had me feeling like it was still late January and below zero.

The sisters have all explored their skills and what exactly that means for their future and careers. But when all three begin to feel a snag in the road of their responsibilities, they seek the comfort of one another once again. While I enjoy each sister going on their own journey, there is nothing like the Quigley siblings all back together again. The way the sisters are able to give advice and comfort to one another has me itching for that sort of sibling bond.

I adored the inclusion of Jennings and the mysterious necromancer in this book. The banter and sweetness they added to the book had me smiling from ear to ear every time they were on page.

This is the perfect book to read curled up in a chair, under a blanket, with a heartwarming cup of tea or hot chocolate; it's exactly what the house would want, I think.

5/5 stars

Three sisters, Anne who runs the tea room, Beatrice who is from the circus and Violet the writer. All three have issues and men in their lives, and all three are witches and are triplets. Enjoyed this one, although a few times I was a bit confused, but that was minor. Would highly recommend this one.

The Witching Moon Manor is the second book in the Spellbound Sisters series. However, this book can be read as a standalone. It is full of magic, cozy feels and perfect for Fall vibes! I really enjoyed the storyline, characters, friendships and romance in this book! It has a whimsical feel throughout the entire book. I found it to be engaging and felt joyful after reading it! I highly recommend this book to anyone that is looking for a cozy fantasy read! I rate this book a 4 out of 5 stars!

Thank you to NetGalley, author Stacy Sivinski and Atria Books publishing for this digital advanced reader’s copy in exchange for my honest review! All thoughts and opinions are my own.

This book is expected to be released on October 7, 2025!

Loved this even more than the first book!!
A cozy and whimsical good time perfect to curl up on the sofa with some hot coco or tea to read!
Follow the Quigley sisters as they try to determine why the magic in their town is not as it usually is. We follow some new characters as well as characters from book one! Lovely to get to catch back up with them. My favorite part about this series is the sisterly bond! Definitely worth the read loved book me book two was even better and come on THIS COVER!!!

In this sequel to The Crescent Moon Tearoom, Sivinski serves up more cozy, atmospheric fantasy at its best. While I’m generally not a fan of sequels, I have to admit that I enjoyed this one even more than the first book. The stakes are still very low and the language still very flowery (occasionally a little over the top, to be honest), but it was great to see each of the sisters more firmly on their own journeys this time. The author clearly saw how much fans of the first book enjoyed the house as a character and has leaned into that a bit too hard in my opinion, but I loved the bookshop so I’ll ignore the sentient manor. While I enjoyed the awkward progression of romance for Bea, the very obvious enemies-to-lovers plot for Anne developed far too quickly and with an underdeveloped, underwhelming partner. All in all, The Witching Moon Manor is a great choice for fans of lush settings, charming characters, and the low-stakes coziness of a magical story to whisk you away.

This was so cute and pure and I had a fantasy time with this. It game me “A Witch’s guide to fake dating a demon” vibes that were just everything.

The Witching Moon Manor is charming, atmospheric, and full of heart—but also a little hard to follow at times. Stacy Sivinski really knows how to build a magical world that feels cozy and mysterious, and I genuinely enjoyed spending more time with the Quigley sisters. Each of their paths—Anne, Beatrix, and Violet —was interesting in its own right, and their reunion had that warm, nostalgic energy I love in sibling-centered stories.

That said, I found myself getting confused more than once. Some transitions felt abrupt, and there were moments where I wasn’t quite sure what the stakes were or how certain magical rules worked. The plot juggled a lot—necromancy, romance, looming danger—and while it was ambitious, it sometimes left me feeling like I missed a page (or five).

Still, the writing is lovely, the themes of identity and sisterhood really shine, and there’s a certain magic in the way Sivinski writes about healing and homecoming. I just wish I’d had a bit more clarity along the way.

If you liked The Crescent Moon Tearoom, you’ll probably enjoy this one too—just maybe bring a notebook.

I went into this hoping it would be like the first one and was not surprised! The characters as well as the plots flow beautifully and I really enjoyed learning more about the sisters. Definitely just a cozy fun read!

This was such a cozy story. I especially liked the scenes with the enchanted bookshop, and the sentient house was also a favorite character. This was a low stakes story, which made it easier to sink into the coziness and enjoy the comforts (and scents) along the way.

4.75
While I really enjoyed the first book the second was absolutely enchanting!

The story felt more cohesive from start to finish. I also found the balance of the sisters stories throughout the was quite well done and that we got a better look into their individual personalities and the bond they share. I loved that this time they felt like a team working toward the same goal, and we saw more of the love between them.

I adored this enchanted world, beautiful imagery and the message of how stories & love are stronger than death.

A wonderful cozy magical read✨🫖

ARC Review: The Witching Moon Manor

 *This ARC was provided by the publisher (Atria Books) via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.*

When we left off in The Crescent Moon Tearoom, the Quigley sisters were off on their own adventures. Violet went off to travel with Emil and the circus. Beatrix was off on her novel tour and continuing to write new stories. Anne accepted her role on the coven council as the new Diviner and continued running the shop. Now the sisters back under one roof and everything is not as picture perfect as it was before. Violet is shaken after a traumatic accident at the circus. Thankfully, both her and Emil are still in one piece, but it was terrifying, nonetheless. Beatrix is suffering from writer’s block in the worst way, even the words on her skin have disappeared. Anne receives notice that their dear friend Mr. Crowley was holding a secret much bigger than they could have imagined. He was not this mid-level magic user that they all believed. His task being unfinished will not be harmless. In fact, he was so incredibly strong that leaving his task unfinished will start unraveling the threads of destiny leading to strange occurrences and complicating the ability of other witches to finish their own tasks.
 
The sisters are troubled by this. By completing his task, he will pass on into the afterlife and once again be leaving Phillip behind. They must find a way to both complete his task and to help Phillip move on as well so they can be together. To do this, Anne must recruit help from the Crowley family in the form of his incredibly cold and mildly rude nephew, Vincent. While Anne pursues this avenue, Violet and Beatrix begin searching for a way to help Phillip and begin by renting the old bookstore and apartment that his family owned. In doing so, Violet begins reigniting her use of her magic to read the memories in the old building and Beatrix must also focus on trying to use her gift by writing according to Anne’s visions. 

Once again, we follow these sisters on a quest to help their friend, each other, and even some new friends we meet along the way. The ending of this book was so heartwarming and absolutely perfect for each sister. I adore the sentient tearoom/house, and the fact that we get a sentient bookshop too was so exciting. Reading these books feels like a cozy fall day curled under the blanket with a warm coffee and a good book. I really hope there’s more to come!

4.5/5! I loved this even more than the first one! Sivinski returns with their beautiful writing, descriptions, and enchanting characters. While this book can be enjoyed at any time of year, it is perfect for winter. It has such wonderful, immersive winter imagery. I loved being back with the Quigley sisters! Each of them has their own distinct voice, magic and obstacles to overcome. At the heart of this story though, the sisters are all struggling with one thing: getting their spark back. I love all the sisters but Beatrix has to be my favorite. Her magic is so unique and one that writers and readers will relate to. I loved being back with the sentient house but fell in love with the enchanted book shop! Sivinski is a master at sensory imagery. The descriptions of scents in particular make their writing so immersive and enchanting. The story has so many beautiful messages to it, but the one that stuck with me the most is the power that memories hold. The sequel was even more heartwarming than its predecessor. This series is such a warm, cozy, and comforting read. I would gladly read more from this world and look forward to what’s next for the author!

This was a great continuation of the series. The story was set in a great world with great characters in the story!

This was such a cute and cozy mystery. I really enjoy it.

https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/224049767

The Witching Moon Manor was just as magical as the first! I absolutely adore the Quigley sisters and couldn’t put this book down. The story was enchanting, the atmosphere was perfection, and I’m hoping for more adventures with these characters. If you love witchy reads, this one’s a must! ✨🌙📖

Fate reunites the Quigley sisters (Anne, Beatrix, and Violet) in Stacy Sivinski's enchanting follow up to her 2024 debut novel (The Crescent Moon Tearoom). As each sister struggles individually with her own chosen path, the sisters must also come together - with some outside help - to save their city from a precarious future and to help bring closure and peace to some deserving characters. The Witching Moon Manor is a charming, cozy, and heartfelt novel about the bond between sisters, love that transcends a lifetime, and the courage to embrace one's destiny.

I was so excited to read Stacy’s upcoming novel The Witching Moon Manor. I can only describe Stacy’s writing as whimsical and cozy and it’s my favorite to curl up with a cup of tea while reading her stories.
Her latest novel follows the Quigley sisters as they try to figure out why the magic in their town has gone wonky. With characters from the first book and a new enemy/love interest for Anne, the story follows their struggles while highlighting the bonds of sisterhood. I absolutely loved the story and now need to go find a cup of tea!

This was a great follow up to The Crescent Moon Tearoom. While this book can be read as a standalone, I definitely recommend reading TCMT first. What to expect from this book: cozy descriptions and heartfelt moments between sisters with a side of romance. Be warned, you will crave a hot cup of tea and a sweet treat after reading this book!

Thank you NetGalley and Atria Books for the arc in exchange for an honest review. This review can also be found on Goodreads.

Stacy Sivinski has done it again. I received an arc of The Crescent Moon Tearoom last year, and I fell in love. So, when I discovered the sequel on NetGalley, I was thrilled. The Witching Moon Manor is just as enchanting and endearing as the first book in the series, if not more. Fans of the first will be delighted with the continued story of the Quigley sisters.

Beatrix has been swept away on a tour for her books, Violet is flying across the circus tent, and Anne is wrapped up in the tasks of the Tearoom and being the city's Diviner. As busy as the sisters are, fate pulls them all home to the Crescent Moon in order to deal with a new task at hand. It seems that their dear Mr. Crowley's task has been left unfinished, and Fate is being unraveled with each passing day. The sisters come together to determine what is remaining in Mr. Crowley's task before it is too late.

Just like the first book, the coziness of the Crescent Moon spills from the pages. Their magical house makes an even bigger appearance in this novel (which I was SO happy about), and it all plays into the warm and fuzzy feelings you get while reading. Anne and Beatrix really shine in this novel. Their individual stories are explored much deeper than before, and readers are introduced to new (exciting) paths that Fate has for the two sisters. Violet's character is not delved into a great deal this go around. But, as book two wraps up, it seems that Violet's Fate will be a large focus of (what I assume will be) book three.

There is a quote from this novel that perfectly encapsulates the magic of Sivinski's storytelling that I will end with: "Even then, Beatrix had known that reading was magic. It transported her to places both within and beyond herself, where the flat words of the page took on a texture that felt more tangible than the boards beneath her feet."