
Member Reviews

Thank you NetGalley and Severn House for the eARC.
Another great book from Caro Ramsay; tense, thrilling and chilling, I loved it.
Hiding away in an ancient castle in Scotland is a family famous for the stunningly beautiful Koi, famous the world over.
Detective Caplan is tasked with finding out what happened to Koi when her body is found on the rocks below the castle.
What she finds is a mystery: no body found, but a picture of Koi lying still on the rocks below the castle. Interrogating the family is almost impossible; they are almost like a cult, led by the father and his manager. They belong to a company that's making millions selling the family and wares on the Internet. P
Talk about a seriously mentally unstable family ... several members are traumatized and psychologically abused, all to keep the fans obsessed and buying anything related to them. Not that far away from today's reality!
And what a satisfying ending, I loved it!
It's a fantastic, beautifully written mystery, Can't wait for no. 5 in the series. Caro Ramsay is a genius!

This was a fascinating and compelling mystery which I think I half figured out what was going on from the start but was difficult to tell as the family involved is extremely complex. When I read I don’t get images of what’s going on in my head and I think that would have been useful for this in honesty as there’s some amazing descriptions of the castle but I found the geography confusing in honesty, there’s also some great descriptors of the family who are quite a nightmare. It really does a great job of reflecting how fame can impact a family and in this case the manipulation of the children was genuinely disturbing. The case is very challenging for the police and there’s an unexpected arrest for murder too., it’s a very twisty read but it’s the darkness of the characters that makes it so addictive.