I would have enjoyed this title more if it had focused on the trial at the center of the story rather than the romance between the two jurors. The chemistry between Sydney and Damon felt flat, and the tension from their past relationship added little to the narrative. Overall, I was hoping for a more compelling novel filled with courtroom drama and came away disappointed.

I have loved everything Neely Tubati Alexander has written, so I was excited to read this. And it didn’t disappoint!

Sydney Parks has been selected to serve on a jury for a high-profile case involving Margot Kitsch, a reality TV star she adores. However, when she discovers that Damon, her childhood friend and first love, is also on the jury, not all the drama centers around the trial.

This perfectly blends courtroom scenes as the trial unfolds alongside Sydney and Damon’s evolving second-chance romance. Similar to the trial, we uncover details about Sydney and Damon’s past, their intricate family dynamics, and subtle elements that demonstrate their connection, despite being apart for years.

The jury is sequestered for the trial, creating an atmosphere of enforced proximity, while Sydney and Damon try to sneak around to be alone. While there are moments of humor and even a bit of spice, I found it to be more personally intimate and emotional at times as serious topics are addressed.

Some people may find themselves captivated by the trial (equally as much as the romance) as it unveils a fascinating mystery, with Margot playing a crucial role in the story. The ending leaves me wondering whether this is a cliffhanger or merely a loose thread. Regardless, I'm eagerly anticipating what Neely Tubati Alexander will write next!

Thank you @harperperennial and @neelyalexanderwrites for this gifted book. 🎧Thank you @harpercollins #harperaudio for the gifted audiobook narrated by Cindy Kay via #NetGalley.