There was much to enjoy here, but I found I couldn't connect with it. I'd read more from this author in the future though.

I received this book from the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. I recommend this book to anyone who is “into” the paranormal/time travel genre. Sadly, the internet goblins ate my first review of this work. I decided that a second read was warranted to be sure that the nuances of the story were fresh in my mind. That being said, I couldn’t put the book down, even on the second read. I was, once again, completely immersed in the story as it unfolded. Due to my love of all stories paranormal, I was immediately drawn by the book’s cover, and in fact, it was a major factor in my deciding to read it. So simple, yet so effective. The spooky image of a girl trapped in an ornate mirror. It’s safe to say that even before I read the synopsis, I knew that we would soon meet up over a steaming cup of coffee.
 
The characters, settings, and plot were excellently developed through a wide use of exceptional descriptors and “old time” language. I felt like I knew each character intimately and lived through their experiences as they did. Even the ancillary characters were memorable, from the stern Cornish mother-in-law all the way to the kooky antique’s dealer. Marlys artfully brings each character to life, as we read; we see the personal growth experienced in each. In addition to the awesomely quirky and loveable characters; the time-period references and descriptors were so vivid that I could almost see the scenes developing before my eyes. I loved traveling back to rural times; remembering that although so many hardships existed in the past, their way of living was so much more relaxed…. I suppose when it's man versus world many things are insignificant. Watching the town grow to present day technology was a treat as well. Marlys also transitions from past-time to present-time skillfully.
 
The heart of the story though is the development of the dual main characters. As I became more immersed in the story; I couldn’t help but worry about what the other character was experiencing at the time. The second half of the book quelled my fears and served to build my enjoyment of the book. I was delighted that the same level of culture shock existed in both halves of the book.
 
By the end of the story, I still had one glaring question that was not addressed to my satisfaction. What about the butterfly effect? There are portions of the book or rather parts of the story that were created/changed by the timeline shifts or perhaps incongruous actions of the time travelers. The plot hole that occurs (in my mind) is the only reason I couldn’t give this book five hearts. Those that are a bit less nerdy about time facts and ripples will love this tale unconditionally. I don’t know if there is a sequel planned or already in existence, but the end lends itself to a <i>“Neverending Story”</i> that I would welcome delving into. Very big recommend to all YA fans.