Member Reviews

What a delightful book! I love the combination of a pied piper retelling with other fairytales sprinkled in. I especially love seeing a hero with a disability and his experiences addressed but not "fixed". I can't wait for book two!

Was this review helpful?

A retelling! For a story I don't normally run into a retelling for! So of course I had to give it a shot.

And boy am I glad I did!

This particular retelling, if you cannot tell from the title is of the Pied Piper story. You know the one? The one where the pied piper comes and plays his music and removes all the rats from the town.

Well in this one, once upon a time, he did do that...and then the village didn't pay the price that he asked, so he came and took all the children. Minus one - that kid couldn't make it. Or at least that is the story the town tells. But everyone else just believes them to be fairy tales.

Then we come to more of a now time in history and there are two kids, Max and Carter, are in the town of the story with their dad (a person who researches fairytales) and things start happening.

First they see a strange person hiding out in the shadows. Then they have their house flooded with rats....and then they find themselves in a strange place with all the children of Hamelin that were taken over 100 years ago!

Then from there the adventure starts. They, obviously, want to find their way home. And they want to help the kids find their way back too.

Of course, there are giant evil rats in the way. And some wizards. And some fairies.... And other creatures...

It is quite a fun story! I really enjoyed it! The adventure was actually quite fun, filled with little twists and turns. The world was very creative too. There were so many different types of "creatures" and "beings" that we encountered through the whole story. You never really knew who would turn up next. And the characters themselves were quite enjoyable. They all had their distinct personalities, and I found myself enjoying the crass old wizard guy

There are more books in this series, and yes I am totally going to read them!

This review is based on an eARC provided by the publisher in exchange for a fair and honest review. All thoughts are mine and mine alone.

Find more of my reviews here:
https://readingwithcupcakes.blogspot.com

Was this review helpful?

I truly loved this story - there was so much action and adventure going on throughout the book. This is a really fast-paced and action packed novel which teenagers will love. You see the struggle that the characters go through and how they can overcome these obstacles in life. A really distinctive book which will keep you hooked for more!

Was this review helpful?

"We Gotta Get Out of This Place...", (The Animals 1964)

Putting aside the magical apprentice, prophesied-one, and object quest fantasies, tales built around being taken away and having to get back home may be among the most durable of all story arcs. From The Odyssey to Wizard of Oz, people just want to go home.

The Pied Piper tale may resonate because it's one of the few tales with no traditional resolution. The children of Hamelin are taken away - but to where and to what ultimate purpose? This book starts at that point and spins out a continuing tale that's part Neverland and part folktale survey mashup.

The opening of the book is gripping and dark. Cody nicely captures the Piper's sinister and hypnotic call. We then switch to modern times and meet the two kids we know immediately will be drawn into the Piper story. Again, this is set up well, with portents, and dark figures, and a "rat extermination professional" instead of a piper. And our heroes, Max and Carter are fine. Having a mildly wild-child older sister and a thoughtful, shy younger brother doesn't exactly break new ground, but both characters are built for the long haul and have reader appeal.

But then we get to "New Hamelin". We start with loads and loads of exposition and explaining in order to get all of the characters and the reader on the same page storywise. I can see that as a real benefit to younger readers who aren't familiar with how these sorts of books work. NO SPOILERS, except to say that this then becomes a quest along a road in search of a way home. The book sticks with the Piper angle, but we get many more characters, more borrowings from other tales, (Baba Yaga?), and pretty much an anything goes fantasy and magical creature walk-about. I was O.K. with that, but be warned. While this could have been a tidy and entertaining stand-alone book, it is actually the first in a three book series, and is loaded with cliffhangers. I'm undecided whether this has was it takes to draw me through a trilogy, so be forewarned.

(Please note that I received a free advance ecopy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)

Was this review helpful?