I thought that this graphic novel was cute and a quick read. I just picked it up from the library so I could give it a proper review. I thought the story moved nicely, and the artwork was well done. I think the graphic novel series is a good way to introduce kids to The Boxcar Children.

As a reader familiar with the Boxcar Children series, I was always excited for this graphic novel adaptation. Now that I've read it, I find that this is a very, very abridged version of Surprise Island that the reader, familiar or not, will find it hard to follow. Readers interested in Boxcar Children should seek out the original source material. This does not do the series justice. It bounces too quickly and the mystery is never set up properly to hook the reader in.

I did not get the chance to read this book so I am unable to provide an honest review.