Member Reviews
Many thanks to NetGalley for this advanced reading copy!
From the moment I started reading THE RADIUM GIRLS I was enthralled. The author’s goal for the reader to learn about each individual girl is thoughtful and ambitious. This is truly a book where the characters are at the forefront of the story. We see how each one, eager to earn a living, found Radium Dial and sealed their fate. The author handles the tragedy with diplomacy and underscored, yet effective use of detail, both medical and non (such as when one of the ill-fated girls catches a glimpse of herself in a mirror and sees her bones glowing through her skin. She realizes she has radiation poisoning and promptly faints.).
As I read, I became infuriated and frustrated with the way that the girls were lied to and manipulated by the company. Banking upon their innocence, the “doctors” that examined them kept the true results hidden, while telling them that they were the picture of health. Over and over, they would experience a toothache or jaw pain; the harbinger of things to come. Insidiously things progressed to such a degree that walking or eating without pain was impossible. Thankfully, finally, the stars aligned and the case was brought to court. I am still amazed that there wasn’t more public outcry at their plight; this would never happen today. (Or would it? See the author’s epilogue.)
The author’s style is clean and easy to read; letting the story shine through without calling attention to how it’s being said. Once the “how” overshadows the “what”, I lose patience with a book. The writing flowed naturally here, letting emotions build and always keeping the girls front and center.
Each life is carefully, lovingly recreated – all the hopes, dreams and horror each Radium Girl experienced. By making each “girl” have a background, this brings them to life and makes this tragedy more real. There are so many moments in this book that made me stop to think about these poor victims – if they were men, would things have progressed as far as they did? These lives were truly taken for granted to further Radium Dial’s needs. I’m not sure which is more terrifying; the fact that radium has a half life of 1600 years (meaning their bodies are still emitting radiation from the grave) or that no one thought to care more about these women who were clearly suffering. Even the dimunitive “girls” is simultaneously endearing and dismissive, if you think about it.
THE RADIUM GIRLS was one of the best books I’ve read in a while, partly because the subject is fascinating, and because it allowed me to feel a gamut of emotions; to have me truly invested in the story and its outcome. The strength these women possessed is evident on every page, keeping the tension high and making them heroines regardless of how they were treated.
Kudos to the author for illuminating their lives as she did! She took these “statistics” and made them human…forcing us all to think about how the girls were treated as disposable. The description of the court battles is very detailed, further underscoring the evil corporation’s plans to try to drag out the proceedings, hoping the women would die before they would have to appear in court.
I have nothing bad to say about this book; there is history, pathos, hope, and humanity on every page. This should be required reading for all managers and factory workers, both to keep these girl’s memories alive, and to prevent suffering like this from ever happening again.
A very compelling story, well told. I've already encouraged other colleagues to read it and gave a preview book talk to a woman waiting next to me at a restaurant - she is looking forward to finding it in her local library!
Extremely interesting book. This is local history as the Waterbury Clock Company is nearby with its own cadre of suffering girls and women. The event this book mainy fallows is the court case that winds thru the slow and though courts that the suffering women brought against the various clock companies to cover their pain and suffering and being unable to work during the Great Depression. The cost of doctors' and dentist 's care were huge in these women's life..
As strange as it seems now radium was seen as a wonder mineral and used as a wonder drug and tonic. Its was known have a vague sense of dis-ease and damage that it inflicted on its first handlers but was pushed from the get-go as a wonder drug for all ills. No concern was seen for the dial painters for handling the paint or for the girls' safety durning their time at the factory. (its ok. to eat at your desk next to the paints--its fun to paint your teeth and eyes during breaks with the brush wash water-- and take home your work smocks to be washed in the family wash. The only concern was the cost of the paints and not to waste the
the expensive material.
It was from these case and others that the modern OSHA was put in place for.. The martyred girls and women paid for OSHA policy in their blood and suffering.
What a haunting story author Kate Moore has captured in her new book, The Radium Girls. This is an account of a real-life tragedy: the deaths of a number of young women who painted watch dials with a luminous material made with radium in the 1920s. During that time, these girls (and many really were girls, as young as 15, 16 and 17) were proud to land jobs with a company that supplied the glowing dials to America's fighting men. The pay was good, they enjoyed one another's company, and they thought it was glamorous and fun when their hair and clothes and very bodies began to glow in the dark. One girl even smeared the material over her teeth, to make her smile gleam more brightly for her beau.
Then, as this true story recounts, the girls began to fall ill. Their teeth became loose, and when they had their dentists extract them, sometimes portions of their jaws came out, too. Ulcers and sores and the gaps left in their gums refused to heal, leaking pus and smelling putrid.
At first, doctors were mystified, and it was only after a few deaths that the dangers of radium began to emerge. Then another horror: their employers refused to admit what was happening, or assist with medical payments in any way.
Court battles raged for years, as the young women continued to die. Moore's subtitle is "They paid with their lives. Their final fight was for justice," and indeed it was. This is a shocking, unforgettable story of corporate greed, scientific ignorance, and, in the case of the girls, bravery, courage and faith.
According to the publisher, the book is based on trial transcripts, letters, diaries and interviews with relatives. It's a sobering, tragic, horrific story, made even more memorable because of the extreme suffering these women endured. The reader's heart breaks, after meeting them in the pages of this book and coming to know their personal hopes and dreams. Highly recommended, but not for those who may be disturbed long after the book is closed.
I don't usually read non - fiction but the topic of the dial painters intrigued me, and I'm really pleased I read this book as it felt a fitting memorial to incredibly brave women and the men who supported them. Ms Moore had obviously thoroughly researched her subject and managed to write an engrossing narrative which really bought the characters to life. At times I wished it had been fiction as the women suffered such devastating effects from the "magic" radium and even when they were removing parts of their own jawbones their company refused to believe there was any problem. Living in a country with an NHS I was also shocked by the cost of medical treatment and how finding the means to pay for care devastated families.
The end of the book, while sadly not surprising, is a challenge to today's women to continue fighting large companies so that they take responsibility for their employees and the environment in which they live and work.
The only negative was that my kindle edition didn't have any photos and it looked from the appendices as if the book will have.
The Radium Girls by Kate Moore
"LIQUID SUNSHINE" The element Radium was dubbed. It is 1917 and Katherine Schaub is fourteen years old. She is exited to be working the glamorous job painting the dials of watches and clocks at the Radium Luminous Materials Corporation. It wasn't considered a factory job it was described as a studio at Third Street, Newark, Jersey. Each dial-painter had her own supply. Mae said when she first started in 1916 that American girls did not take up the lip-pointing technique with blind faith. She and her colleagues had questioned it being "a little bit leary" about swallowing the Radium. Asking if this stuff could hurt you? And they said No.
Kate Moore did a remarkable job to humanize the girls in this part of history that we all owe so much too. Because of these girls and women we now have OSHA to protect us. It takes 1500 years for the effects of radium to wear off. These girls and women sacrifices have led to a safer environment for everybody. This book is a tribute to all of those souls that suffered but persevered to make a safer work environment. Both companies the USRC in Orange, New Jersey and the Radium Dial Company in Ottawa, Illinois employed young women at a higher wage to do a dangerous job. Only the women didn't know the dangers they were involved with painting these glow in the dark instruments.
Kate Moore tells the history of Radium beginning with Marie and Pierre Curie's discovery of radium in 1898. Bringing all of the girls and women to life on the page who didn't have any knowledge of the risks of exposure to working with Radium. These women were lied to and denied compensation when they were unable to work and were dying. After these loyal employees found out it was the Radium in the paint and powder that were causing their jaws to break apart, sarcomas, amputations, these Companies did not want to help compensate. They fought hard against taking any responsibility toward those whom were inflicted by working for them.
I am glad to have had the honor of learning about all of the courageous individuals that fought an uphill battle. I think the Attorney who paid the legal costs and court fees to fight all the way to the United States Supreme Court deserves accolades of thanks. He took on a job that a lot of attorneys didn't want to go up against these companies. I was pleased with the decision of cert. denied. I had some issues with a big corporation and I personally know that ERISA which was enacted to protect retirees pensions has no protection of promised Employee health care. I know what it is like to find an attorney that is willing to take on a corporate giant. Most are not interested.
Thank you to Net Galley, Kate Moore and Sourcebooks for providing me with my digital copy in exchange for a fair and honest review.
An amazing account of a little known piece of American history. This was an extremely difficult read strickly due to the subject matter. What these women had to endure was simply horrendous. Their bravery and sacrifice has made the world a better place for us all. Well researched and well written. Thank you for educating me on a previously unknown topic.
Very informative, there is so much information! I'm really glad I got to read this, though at times things got a bit confusing, as oftentimes when introducing the young Radium Girls it skipped from person to person a bit too quickly.
The Radium Girls wrapped up the whole situation from beginning to end in a nice, neat, easy to read, and interesting package.
I saw this and thought "this looks a bit different" . The blurb sounded intriguing. I did not realise what i was letting myself in for. That greed and power comes before health and safety. Thousands of women with radium, this book relates to just 34 of them.
Marie and Pierre Curie discovered Radium in 1898. A new element.
1917 Katherine Schaub went to work in the watch dial factory "Radium Luminous Materials Corporation" in Newark, New Jersey. The substance was used to paint onto watch dials so they glowed in the dark. The girls were using brushes thet they made onto a point by placing them in their mouths, then dipping into the radium paint and then painted the dials. A process known as Lip, Dip, Paint.
At this point any danger from radium was unknown, in fact it was heralded as "the greatest find in history" and was marketed as a cure all from pills and powders to drinks, though most of these didn't contain radium. It was a household name and nobody thought there was a risk. The girls working at the factory glowed in the dark as the powdery substance was ever present in the air, it was on their clothes, in their hair, they even painted on their nails and used it as make up so that they glowed in the dark. They would eat their luch at the table they worked at, they could never wash the powder from their bodies completely. It bcame part of them, Young girls wanted to work at the factory, it was "the" job to be in as it paid well.
Gradually the some of the girls started to get aches and pains, they had problems with their teeth and gums. When a tooth was removed because of pain, the resulting hole didn't heal, and in fact got worse and travelled through the mouth, more teeth were becoming loose. It got so bad that in some cases the girls actually lost some of ther jaw bones as they crumbled or came out in pieces while they ate. Dentists were at a loss and no connections were made. Doctors became confused when girls came in complaining of painful backs, hips knees or ankles. Girls had to deal with sarcomas, amputations, miscarriages and all were in horrific pain. They all had this in common, radium had settled in their bones and weakening them, but again no connections were made. Things then started to get more severe as some of the girls became immobile and immaciated, they couldn't walk without pain or eat without pain. Death occured and the cause of death was attributed to other causes, it couldn't possibly be radium. In fact it was, but because this was a new element there was no documented evidence to show any side effects. New intruments and ways of thinking had to come into to play before people began to realise that it was radium that was poisoning and killing the girls.
This book has brought me to tears so many times while reading it. This is one of the most emotional and humbling books i have come across. The author mentions that (she) "simply hope(s) that (she) has done them justice. In my opinion she has certainly done this and surpassed it. It is a story that has shocked me, and even now i am struggling to put into words the impact it has had on me. I got caught up immediatley in it. Kate Moore has told the stories of those involved in a very simple but articulate way. I couldn't stop reading, i had to discover the truth and the outcome.
The lesson of this story is still relevant today. Politicians say regulations kill jobs. Well, too few regulations kill people.
The story of the Radium Dial victims is summarized in every book about nuclear radiation or nuclear history. I'm glad to see this horrific part of history highlighted in a book like this. It is the kind of non-fiction that might appeal to readers who typically avoid that side of the library.
The author does an excellent job of telling this story that is full of horrors. Imagine reaching into your mouth and pulling free part of your jaw. This makes me shudder. Imagine trying to do simple things like talk and eat without your jaw. It really is unimaginable, yet it happened to young women, caused by (no, encouraged by) the company they worked for.
And when it became obvious that the radioactive radium they ingested every day was destroying their bodies, the company pretended it couldn't possibly be related to their work. The company used the courts and loopholes to deny duly-deserved compensation to dying women and their families. It was absolutely disgusting.
Even now, the sites of these factories are still dangerously radioactive.
I think anyone interested in women's rights, worker's rights and nuclear history, would enjoy this book.
The incredible true story of the young women exposed to the “wonder” substance of radium and their brave struggle for justice.
This book was really informative but heart wrenching for the women involved what they had to go through, most of them dying in the process, just terrible but really enjoyable book to read and learn about The Radium Factories of the time but equally annoying how Men in the 1920's repeatedly denied Radium had anything to do with teeth falling out, jawbone corrosion and many other ailments that was inflicted on the women.
It read like a thriller but was a True depiction and was very well done.
--I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are purely my own and not influenced in any way.--
Prior to reading The Radium Girls, my knowledge on the subject was essentially that they existed and ingested radium without knowing it was dangerous. While that is true, I had NO idea as to how complex an issue it was and what a fight the girls had to put up to get the radium corporation to admit that radium was a poisonous substance. I fell in love with the girls impacted: the book is written in such a way that you feel like you know the girls personally (which massive kudos to Kate Moore, clearly a lot of research went in to this to make sure that the girls get the recognition and portrayal they deserve) and you feel the anger, heartbreak, and above all hope that they feel. I wanted to scream with them about the atrocities the company was committing and stand with them in their fight for justice. Being that the Radium Girls actually existed, their story needs to be told richly and with respect while making them human instead of characters, and boy did this book do that! I loved Grace Fryer and Catherine Donahue's strength and courage that shone as brightly as the luminous paint did.
Quite honestly, I feel that this should be required reading lest we forget the abominable actions that the corporations did and so people would learn about these powerful unsung heroes of the modern world.
When I saw the topic of this book, I knew I had to read it. Not only does it deal with a fascinating and shameful era of history, but it focuses on the perspectives of the women where most affected, and who history has generally ignored. I very much respect and support Kate Moore's desire to the tell story of the women who died because of radium in their own words.
For the most part, this story tells a the story in a compelling manner. It alternates between broad historical facts to descriptions of the many girls who worked as dial painters to descriptions of their medical problems as they grew sick (and died). As such, there is a shifting level of narrative distance throughout the book - sometimes there is a more traditional 3rd person tone, other times, we see a doctor's appointment that one girl goes to from her perspective, complete with some lines of dialogue. This very close narrative style makes the descriptions of rotting teeth and jaws horrific to read, and very much humanizes the suffering these women underwent.
While I appreciate how much research went into uncovering the details of all of the lives of these women, and how Moore chooses to talk about so many of them, rather than a representative few, I do think it can be a bit hard to remember each "character." Often, they were introduced as a one member of a list of girls, with a few representative facts, and then referred to again later in the story. I found it somewhat hard to latch onto a single narrative or character for that reason and to keep track of every person in the story and their fates. I almost wanted to go back and make a list of characters so that I could update their timelines as I read along.
Overall, a very strong book, from a necessary perspective!
(I received a copy of this book via NetGalley for a fair review).
You are probably familiar with the saying “truth is stranger than fiction”. I think this book fits into that category perfectly. The events detailed in this work are like something out of a sci-fi movie. The pages of this book tell the stories of the young ladies who worked as painters in the radium dial industry starting in 1917. At the time the story opens, the scientific community’s understanding of radium and its effects was still in its infancy, but the substance’s characteristic of glowing in the dark made it a very profitable business venture. It was used commercially as a paint for the dials of clocks so that the numbers could be seen in the dark. As World War I began it became highly demanded for the instrument dials used in the military. The challenge at the time was that the painting of these dials had to be done by hand, this led to large-scale hiring of young girls as dial-painters. The girls were told that the substance was safe and they would even paint the substance on their bodies so that they could glow-in-the-dark when they went on dates. The painting technique involved putting the brush between the lips in order to form a point and in this manner the girls were ingesting the radium in dangerous quantities. Radium was also being used at the time as a treatment for cancer, and as an additive to health tonics.
It didn’t take long before some of the girls starting having health problems. Often the first indication that something was wrong was when a girl’s teeth starting to loosen and fall out. Some girls began to have sarcomas. One of the girls had to go so far as to have an arm amputated because of a sarcoma. It took a few years for the various doctors and dentists who were treating these girls to understand that the root cause of the symptoms was the radium that they had worked with. This diagnosis led to a long, drawn-out legal process as the girls tried to get the companies to take responsibility for having lied to them and to offer some compensation for the pain and expenses they had endured.
The author’s stated objective with this book is to tell the story of “The Radium Girls” from the perspective of the women themselves and she has done just that. I found this book to be both shocking and emotionally moving. These girls are heroes for the fight they put up, and without their efforts this country may not even have a process for protecting the health and safety of workers. Today, we take for granted, and are sometimes annoyed by, the safety procedures present in our workplaces, but after reading this book you will never take them for granted again. I think this book should be required reading and I am giving it a 5-star rating because of the quality of the writing and the importance of its message.
Books like Radium Girls brings to the forefront the important of women during difficult times and what they can and do achieve. Women rule!
This story broke my heart and also horrified me. Kudos to the author who honors these brave young women who were determined to fight for justice and to improve labor laws.
What a powerful book. It seems almost like fiction yet it is so recent still, clean up of radium was still occuring in 2015. Grace Fryer was never forgotten, you are remembering her now. How true that is, this is a book that will stick in my mind for some time to come. A must read.
A remarkable topic that needs no garish dramatic trimmings…
Some approaches to history and storytelling work more favorably than others, it just depends on the reader and audience. Unfortunately, The Radium Girls The Dark Story of America's Shining Women tested my optimistic blasé attitude toward different writing styling and I couldn’t help thinking that in place of “If it gets someone reading…” that maybe History sometimes provides its own commentary and little needs added after. Perhaps the facts surrounding the radium dial painters is one of those perfect examples of a topic that needs no garish dramatic trimmings, those brave women’s preserved words, court documents and scientific specifics all tell their own remarkable story. I understand the connection with the stage this author has but the incessant dramatic flamboyance with heavy passages just didn’t seem appropriate in several chapters (ex. the various exhumations and there were even places where I stopped and hoped not another morbid comparative awkward joke was waiting after an obvious little innocent appearing tangent but they were always there). There were also the thickly spread expressive conjectures in these pages that had me shaking my head, I can only take so much “perhaps, as though, they were thinking, she must have been thinking, he thought only etc” before those parts have me wishing I picked another title.
It saddens me to admit my disappointment with The Radium Girls The Dark Story of America's Shining Women and I do applaud the obvious research in other parts that didn’t seem just tacked on (you could clearly tell the author is fond of her subject) but the heavy chintzy figurative writing almost had me dreading turning another page and in truth I put this title down quite a few times. It was my absolute fascination with the serious subject that kept me coming back between looking up still frames, newspaper clippings and partial photos of the statue dedicated to the memory of those amazing women. Maybe in the end, this non-fiction work took certain flourishes a bit too far even though it was a relatively easy read in the beginning I still do not fully regret reading for the history and attention to such a serious topic. I just think I will find something more “appropriate” with something else on the available shelves.
*I would like to thank NetGalley and Sourcebooks for the opportunity to read The Radium Girls The Dark Story of America's Shining Women
I absolutely loved this fascinating, horrifying book! Coming into it, I assumed it would be the story of women in science. Another glory-filled retelling of strong American women acting as Rosie the Riveter. Partially correct, the story of these women is SO SO SO important. This absolutely terrifying tale is so very pertinent as women, once again, fight for their own rights in the workforce. As once again we find ourselves struggling with science and innovation versus safety. Who is it safe to listen to? With people like Dr. Oz filling their pockets as they sell vitamins promising new vitality and a younger look. Is it really such a stretch that radium, the wonder-element, was used, marketed and abused in such ways? Such an amazing, tragic story. That so many innocent, hard-workers had to die because management had to make their dollar. Heartbreaking and enthralling. I cannot shake this book and cannot stop telling people about it!!!
This was, in short, a marvelous book.
Ms. Moore has done an extremely impressive job in her research, bringing these women to life. Her interviews, along with newspaper clips and court transcripts, have created a vivid picture into everything these women went through. And oh, what they went through--I often found myself wincing just from reading all the health problems afflicting them from years of working with radium. Their pain and afflictions are presented in a matter-of-fact way, not glossing over history so we understand how important it was for the women to be recognized, and for those in power to own up to just how dangerous radium is.
There is a good handful of women whose lives we follow throughout this book, but Ms. Moore shows who they were as individuals, so by the time I was done I felt like I knew them. This is an important episode of recent history that I knew nothing about, and I am so glad the author has written this book, allowing the radium girls to tell their story even further into the future.
As soon as Amazon permits reviews to be posted of this book, I'll be posting one there as well and updating this review with a link.