Member Reviews

I enjoyed this adaption of Jane Eyre quite a bit! The artwork was lovely, and the text stays true to the source material (there are a few minor changes, explained in the author's and illustrator's notes at the back, and the changes made sense). The adaption itself absolutely deserves the 5 star rating I'm giving it.
As far as the story goes, well, Jane Eyre is my favorite of the classics, and I can't convince myself to knock off any points for the aspects of the book which always annoyed me. I appreciate how feminist the book was for its time, but the classism is still very present. I know that at the time, the classism was normal, common, and accepted, but it still niggles at my brain. My 20th/21st century sensibilities can't help creeping in! And the romantic aspect? Mr. Rochester is no prize, let me tell you, though I am always happy for Jane because she thinks he is. The Gothicness of the story though - the delicious tension in the story, the "is something supernatural going on here?" aspects, the drama!!! The original Jane Eyre has always been a fun read for me, a grab-the-popcorn kind of read that holds up under rereads, or beautifully illustrated manga adaptions!

Was this review helpful?

A very nice edition of Jane Eyre. I avoided reading it previously because I don’t understand the classics easily but this was probably the easiest time I’ve had of reading one. I’m glad to be able to know about this book as I’ve always been interested

Was this review helpful?

I'd like to express my profound gratitude towards Netgalley for providing me a copy of this amazing piece of work.

Trigger warning for fire, it is shown rather than described.

This book is a manga adaptation of Charlotte Brontë's Jane Eyre, a story many of us may be familiar with. Because of this, I'd rather not go into much detail about the plot. The main character is Jane, a young girl who has a hard past. She's given the opportunity to work as a governess at Thornfield Hall, the estate of the brooding and enigmatic Mr. Rochester. She falls deeply in love with him, but their social differences and Mr. Rochester’s murky past threaten to tear them apart.

What I liked:
- Faithful adaptation of the original text
- Literary value
- Gorgeous drawings, fascinating representation of emotions
- Atmospheric presentation of life in old ages (how different life was back then)

I recommend it for anyone who finds the original novel interesting. With this manga the whole experience this story can give becomes even more immersive.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC.

Great manga with lovely illustrations. This is a fantastic book to help reluctant readers conquer classics or for avoid readers to see classics in a new fun light.

Was this review helpful?

I love these manga classics, especially as a high school teacher. They are great for providing opportunities for reading accommodations and to get young readers interested in picking up a book! Love the drawing style of this one and a great adaptation.

Was this review helpful?

I feel like this adaptation was well done. It made the story very accessible to anyone. The art work really brought the story to life. The story itself was very emotional. It brought out a lot of anger. There were so many characters to hate. It was kind of depressing I don't know that I could have gotten through the long form in one sitting. I think it would be one of those stories that you have to set down often.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

This is the classic tale of Jane Eyre turned into a Manga. This is a story about Jane Eyre , a plane governess, who takes a job at Thornfield hall and falls in love with the enigmatic Mr. Rochester. Mr. Rochester has a secret is hiding from all including Jane.

This is my favorite book and the manga version did not disappoint. It was a great way to introduce this novel to a new generation but still keep the elements of the story true to the original ! I would recommend this book to any and everyone!!

Was this review helpful?

What a fantastic adaptation that breathes new life into Charlotte Brontë’s classic. The artwork is vibrant and beautifully captures the emotions and themes of the original story.

I really appreciated how the manga format made the story accessible, especially for those who might find the original text daunting. The pacing felt spot-on, keeping the essence of the plot while condensing it effectively. However, some subtle nuances from the original were sacrificed for brevity, which might leave purists wanting more depth in certain scenes.

Overall, this is an exciting way to experience this timeless tale, making it perfect for both fans of manga and newcomers to the story.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this adaptation of Jane Eyre. The story is, of course, the classic tale, but the art was lovely, and makes this classic story substantially more accessible to enjoy. While perhaps not a substitute for the original-don't use this for your English project, if you just want to enjoy the story, this is a great option!

I also appreciate the end bit discussing the process of adapting the novel to a manga format. It was very nice.

Was this review helpful?

Jane Eyre is a classic. However we know it can be difficult to read through some of the classics. They are great and tell wonderful stories but it seems there is always a lot of filler info in there that is trying to create an environment in our heads. The manga classic for Jane Eyre takes a lot of that world building filler out and draws the picture for you itself. This helps not only get the main story point across but really draws you in visually and emotionally. i recommend this for any teachers or parents who want their kids to learn about the classics but they are getting push back on it due to being in an older writing style. Personally i recommend this to adults too, its a great read. The art is what will capture your attention and the story really draws you in.

Was this review helpful?

I have read and reviewed several Manga Classics over the last year and have greatly enjoyed them all. I was not sure about Jane Eyre, but this is a satisfying, well done version of the story. I read through it quickly and easily in just 2 days. The text is clear, the artwork is excellent, and I look forward to reading more Manga Classics from this publisher. I never thought I would like this format, and if you have similar doubts, I recommend giving it a try. You may be pleasantly surprised. Udon, keep them coming!
*I received a complimentary copy of this e-book courtesy of Udon Entertainment through NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely LOVED this version of one of my all time favorite books.

This is written and adapted excellently, the tone and pacing spot on, and the illustrations and characters are just perfect. I couldn’t be more thrilled and would recommend this to any and all who love classics, particularly Jane Eyre.

*Thanks to NetGalley and Udon Entertainment for a copy to enjoy*

Was this review helpful?

Love that they're adapting all the classics into manga, it's translated really well and a good entry point for readers interested in classics. I love the explanation of why this has been adapted into manga as well as the little introduction to Charlotte Bronte at the end, it felt very respectful.

Was this review helpful?

Jane Eyre is such a great classic and I loved what this manga did to visualize it. Even though, what Mr. Rochester does in this story isn’t great and I don’t totally love their relationship. I understand the time this story was written in and Jane’s actions and her sense of integrity made her one of the strongest of women.

Jane’s upbringing was harsh and even from when she was young she stood up for herself. It makes me happy to know this book continues to be taught in schools because strong women should always be celebrated.

Jane becomes a governess and teaches Mr. Rochester’s daughter. Jane’s interactions with Mr. Rochester are at first cold. However, over time they talk more and more and a love interest strikes between them. While the manipulation that Mr. Rochester conducts is deplorable, and this isn’t the best example of a true love match, it shows how adults make mistakes and do weird things when their in love sometimes. I think in this day and age it is more common for people to catch certain tactics people use to manipulate, but it is still a story that happens to this day.

People will always try to make each other jealous in order to get the person they really like to make a move. However, it is not a good tactic and it often causes great heartache for all involved. In any case, in this story it works out in the end and Jane marries Mr. Rochester who has become blind after the fires that took his mansion.

It is a gothic romance that is timeless and has many iterations over the years. It is a story I love to collect retellings of and it finds its way back into my life over and over. I’m glad to have read this beautifully drawn manga version of Jane Eyre. It does the story justice.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to NetGalley and Udon Entertainment for providing me with a free digital copy of this book in exchange for my honest review! Overall, I really enjoyed this manga! It does stick very closely to the original Jane Eyre story, so chances are, if you do enjoy the original novel, you'll enjoy this adaptation. While I don't know a ton about art and manga styles in general, I will say that the art was pleasant to look at and did a pretty good job at bringing the characters to life! (Though, I will say, Rochester asking if Jane finds him handsome, while being a sparkly handsome anime man is pretty funny, in a way). I would say that the only actual issue I had with the book is that sometimes, for pacing/adaptation purposes, certain scenes or dialogue were paraphrased or rewritten, and sometimes it came across as anachronistic, which is a little distracting at times. The additional information about the making of the manga was also really informative, interesting, and nice to read. Overall, though, I think it's a solid adaptation. If you enjoyed the original novel, chances are that you'll probably enjoy this! I would probably also recommend this for people who maybe can't or don't want to read the original novel - this version is a lot more digestible, especially for young adult readers. 4 stars!

Was this review helpful?

The manga adaptation of *Jane Eyre* offers a captivating reinterpretation of Charlotte Brontë's timeless story. The artwork is stunning, effectively capturing the gothic atmosphere and the characters’ emotional journeys. Each illustration enhances the narrative, bringing a new vibrancy to Jane's struggles and triumphs.

While the pacing is generally effective, some complexities of the original novel are streamlined. However, the core themes of resilience and integrity remain intact, making it a great introduction for newcomers and a delightful revisit for longtime fans.

Overall, this manga adaptation successfully blends classic literature with striking visuals, making it a worthwhile read for both manga lovers and Brontë enthusiasts alike!

Was this review helpful?

This was a wonderful adaptation of Jane Eyre. The illustrations were enjoyable and engaging. The story was easy to understand. After the story, it explores differences between the book and different adaptations. It discusses why certain changes were made to adapt it to a manga format. Perhaps what I enjoyed most was that it made a book available to a struggling reader and allowed us to share in a literary classic in a way we've never been able to before. As my family has readers of various reading levels, this was a great way for all of us to enjoy a mini book club experience together.

Thank you to NetGalley and Manga Classics for letting me enjoy this book and share my honest thoughts and feelings about it with others.

Was this review helpful?

I read this courtesy NetGalley and Udon Entertainment/Manga Classics. The drama and tragedy of Charlotte Bronte’s classic comes alive in this manga. The emotions and voice that characterize and on occasion slow down the plot of the original novel have been smoothed and crystalized by use of the sequential art here, while sharpening the focus and motivations of Jane and the people around her, in particular Mr. Rochester. Included in this book are detailed sketches of the characters, author biography, and a discussion of how the manga format brings to life the novel. One of literature’s great love stories comes alive in this interpretation.

#MangaClassicsJaneEyre #UdonEntertainment #NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

The first Manga Classic that I've read is Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte. As I didn't know what to expect, I was a bit skeptical. The classic language was kept somewhat similar, which surprised me. I would like to see the pictures in color. In my opinion, this is a fantastic way to introduce the classics to the younger generation. One of my favorite classic books is Jane Erye.

Was this review helpful?

Being an adaptation, especially of a classic, is not easy, but this manga succeeds with stylized and consistent art style that became really addicting. I think the best thing, though, an adaptation can do is provide a new experience. And I can say this manga does. The paneling has this quality where it exudes perspective and life. Characters don't emote the same every shot, the paneling isn't repetitive in the slightest, the dialogue pops with personality and wholesomeness, in parts. Overall, a great read and impressive display of pure craft in regards to the artwork.

Was this review helpful?