Member Reviews

4.5 stars.

Jane Eyre is a beautiful gothic love story that shines in any format. Having read the book, I can compare the accuracy of the adaptation this time around. Though there was the modernization of a few dialogues, overall, the book was well-adapted, keeping all the main plot points intact.

I liked the chibi-style art better than their Jane Austen novels, though I'm not sure how well that works for Jane's character since she's supposed to be independent and mature for her age. However, that didn't lessen my enjoyment of the book, though. I liked the other character designs, especially Mr. Rochester. The backgrounds (Thornfield Hall) were well done. Overall, the art was good.

I think the manga format conveys emotion really well. The story is expressed much better in a visual format as you can see the emotions the characters don't always express in words. In a genre like romance, that carries value. A picture's worth a thousand words.

The story was dramatic from a modern reader's point of view, but more standard for a gothic novel. As I mentioned earlier, Jane Eyre has a solid storyline. The relationship development is believable, the twists engaging, and the characters likable, all leading to my favorite- the happily ever after. Gothic novels are usually pretty tragic (Wuthering Heights, I'm looking at you) so, I'm happy this one's an HEA.

Another thing that stands out about this story is Jane's character. She is an independent, strong-willed woman who chooses freedom over the convention, something which not many women did in the 1800s. As the reader, you want her to have a happy ending because she deserves it.

Overall, the manga was well-done and I highly recommend it to all Jane Eyre fans.

Pros:
1. Good art
2. Easy-to-read
3. Fairly accurate adaptation
4. Good emotion.
5. Stellar story.

Cons:
1. The chibi illustrations can be off-putting at times, especially because Jane and Mr. Rochester look so starkly different (in terms of art).

Was this review helpful?

Jane Eyre as a comic is very fun to read. I enjoyed the story as a book when I was a kid and it was very refreshing reading it again as an adult in comic book form. I liked that comic stayed true to the book and followed the story line. it was basically a picture book for the story. The pictures were expertly drawn and the story was very well written. I would definitely recommend this comic to anyone that likes the historical books but wants to see a more lighthearted side to the story.

Was this review helpful?

This story, Mr Rochester has always driven me up the wall and the conclusion--I just can't. That said this followed the story well. I think as an adaption it worked. The drawings lent more light emotions to this story than the novel.

For a story like this I think expressions are really important, because in the book Jane and Mr Rochester don't always say what they mean and it can make their eventual relationship feel forced and out of place. I still think it is even with this comic, but I think it did a better job of leading you to that point.

Was this review helpful?

Writing and art style: Well this is based on Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë, a classic I have never read. I originally requested this manga so that I could ease into the story by reading this first and see if I liked it. And I really did. It was interesting and so mysterious, right up my alley to be fair. The writing is as most classic books but most of the time we only have access to what the characters are saying so there's a limit to how advanced the writing can get. The art in this was fantastic. It was easy to understand but not simplified by any means. I love the attention to details and how the facial expressions portray every feeling.

Characters: I really liked Jane. She did what was the best thing for her and she never gave up on the things she wanted. Mr. Rochester has some appeal to him, I was rooting for him and Jane after all, but I think that had more to do with the fact that I wanted to see Jane have some happiness and Mr. Rochester was the only one she had any affection for. Because this is a much shortened version of the plot I didn't get to know many of the other characters well enough to make up an impression.

Plot: The plot was unique for its time, and to still be unique after all this time has passed is a rare thing. I'll have to read the original work to fully grasp the plot to its full potential, I need more details. What I did get through this edition though was great, the plot twists were also shocking which I'm always raving about. Really recommend this to people who have already read Jane Eyre and want the art aspect, but also to readers like me that saw Jane Eyre as a daunting task and wanted to test the waters a bit first.

Was this review helpful?

As Jane Eyre is one of my all-time favorite books EVER, I couldn't pass up the opportunity to read this version when I saw it on NetGalley. I mean, Jane Eyre with pictures?!

This is my first ever Manga Classics read and I have to say, they did an amazing job! The story isn't in it's entirety, but the writers managed to keep the integrity of the original story and include all of the most important elements.

Whether you have never read Jane Eyre and would like to start with this version, or if you're like me and have read it several times--I suggest grabbing a copy of this amazing read!

Was this review helpful?

I'm not a particular fan of this classic but I loved the idea of it being presented as a manga and so I decided to give it a go. I still don't really like the story itself but I loved the art! It's perfect if you like the book and would like to see it animated ^^

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book. Thank you very much for the chance to read it.
I've posted my review with pictures on my Goodreads account - that keeps growing daily with friends and followers. Bellow is the link.
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2341305176

Was this review helpful?

I was auto-approved by the publisher Udon Entertainment through NetGalley to review this title.
Charlotte Brontë’s <i>Jane Eyre</i> holds a special place in my heart and on my permanent bookshelf and I’m glad Manga Classics decided to turn it into a comic.
The artwork beautifully captures the atmosphere of the story and emphasizes the remoteness and isolation of the characters.
Overall, I enjoyed this comic tremendously and would recommend it to manga and classic literature enthusiasts.

Was this review helpful?

I was unable to read and therefore review this book because I couldn't get the proper file. I contacted the NetGalley help and despite their suggestions, I still couldn't open the files. I also messaged the publishers through the 'send opinion' option but they did not reply. Therefore, I can not review this book.

Was this review helpful?

As a child, Jane Eyre was mistreated by her relations and sent away to Lowood Institution where her consta​nt companions were isolation and disengagement. After turning 18, Jane decides to make her own way in the world and acquires a position at Thornfield Hall as a governess.
Shortly after, Jane meets the master of the house, Mr. Edward Rochester, and a strange feeling overcomes her.
Could this be love?
Yet the world is a harsh place with dark secrets, social boundaries, and hesitant hearts.
Still...despite everything...
...can love defy the odds?
🌟

From an artistic perspective alone, this work is an absolute treasure that belongs on your bookshelf. I loved reading the original book followed by "Manga Classic: Jane Eyre" that elevates classic literature to another level. The manga not only enables readers to connect with the past, but also conveys the gist of the story through visual narratives and translates the dialogue into understandable text for the modern age. The illustrations heighten the characters inner-emotions through their facial expression to the point where readers start to see the characters as individuals rather than constructs of fiction and literature.

Was this review helpful?

It's my first time to read manga classic and I really glad to get reading from one of my favorite classical book. I was enjoyed to follow the story of Jane Eyre and the manga version still related with the book. I love how the mangaka draw jane, in here she looks Kawaii and pretty. After all, it's pleasure to have chance reading this manga.

Was this review helpful?

I love the story of Jane Eyre. It's definitely a classic. You will enjoy this.

Was this review helpful?

I have see Jane Eyre in theater and on the screen but this is the first time I've actually read it. To read a beautiful classic as a manga first makes me want to go buy the regular written copy of the beloved book and I definitely will. I will also be buying the physical copy of this adaptation so I can have it on my book shelf.

Was this review helpful?

I highly recommend this book this book to anyone who has trouble reading classics. The greatest aspect of a these graphic novels is that these books have the integrity of the original stories, which are, in my opinion, great stories. The texts themselves are really challenging though, which is where the graphic aspect comes back. It's easier to understand the story with less prose and more images.

Was this review helpful?

Rating: 5/5
*A copy of this book was received for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I was really blown away by this adaptation, it captured the heart of the story with ease and kept me hooked right the way through.
This was the first manga I had read so found the included instructions on how to read it (back to front etc) very helpful. It didn’t take me long to get into the flow of reading it.
The art style is exquisite and matched very well with the story, it flowed beautifully from page to page and chapter to chapter. Each character is as thoughtfully detailed as those within the original novel, I adore Charlotte Brontë work and feel this adaptation more than does it justice.
The plot in line with the original novel follows Jane Eyre who was orphaned as a child and abused by her aunt before being sent away to school. Despite the hardships she experiences there she still gets an education and as a result a job as a governess at Edward Rochesters estate, there she discovers Rochesters terrible secret. Fans of Brontë’s work will know how this story ends, however this adaptation is still worth reading regardless of whether you have read the orginal version or not. It breathes a new breath of life on the classic tale.
Overall I enjoyed this book, it was an amazing experience to read the classic tale accompanied by beautiful art. I would recommend this to lovers of classic literature and manga, it perfectly combines the two.

Was this review helpful?

A beautifully told and illustrated text about a fascinating topic.

Was this review helpful?

<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/26591771-manga-classics" style="float: left; padding-right: 20px"><img border="0" alt="Manga Classics: Jane Eyre" src="https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1480975076m/26591771.jpg" /></a><a href="https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/26591771-manga-classics">Manga Classics: Jane Eyre</a> by <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/6113990.Stacy_King">Stacy King</a><br/>
My rating: <a href="https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2300627469">3 of 5 stars</a><br /><br />
Netgalley #19<br /><br />Many thanks go to Udon and Netgalley for the free copy of this book in exchange for my unbiased review.<br /><br />This is the third Manga Classic I’ve had the pleasure of reviewing. This one was another great one. For some reason I wasn’t crazy about Rochester’s rendering. I realize he’s not an attractive fellow, but his profile just had no detail. Again, the entire plot is included here. Nothing important is left out. Sometimes I get little butterflies when I read a specific part then I see the corresponding illustration. I think every book should come with pictures.
<br/><br/>
<a href="https://www.goodreads.com/review/list/6595648-bam-the-bibliomaniac">View all my reviews</a>

Was this review helpful?

I chose this as I am a huge fan of this novel but was a bit disappointing. It's still a great story, though.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely adore the story of Jane Eyre! It is one of my favourite books portrayed one of literatures most amazing female characters Jane Eyre. The magna edition makes this beautiful tale so accessible for everyone! The drawings are brilliant, very accurate of the time period the tale is located and the story plot is extremely true to the book!

5 stars!


An ARC of this comic book was provided via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?