Member Reviews

Reading this manga helped resurrect my love for this novel. I don't know why I enjoyed this novel as much as I did but the manga highlighted all the parts of it that I really enjoyed the most. I loved the adaptation.

Was this review helpful?

First thing to admit, I don't actually much like the original Jane Eyre. I think near everyone in it is ridiculous. I did not expect the manga version to change my mind on these points, and it didn't. But it WAS fun to see the story play out on the page.
I realize this is a manga, but part of the point of Mr. Rochester is that he isn't a traditionally handsome guy. Of course, every movie or TV version of Jane Eyre has cast him that way, so it's no real surprise that the book would, too, but I feel like he could've been just a little less pretty.
I quite liked the pages at the end that go into a little more detail about governesses and how they decided on the art and script for the book, it was quite interesting. I doubt I'd read it again, but for anyone who enjoys the story to begin with it'd a wonderful version.

Was this review helpful?

I've had a lot of trouble getting started with reading classics. I've always wanted to read them but I get overwhelmed when I pick them up to start reading. These Manga Classics editions really help. It can take some time getting used to, especially if you have never read a Manga before but you will quickly get the hang of it. I really enjoyed reading Jane Eyre in manga style and the illustrations were gorgeous but I think some of the characters didn't really fit the manga style. They were a little too polished and perfect. Sometimes you need to see someone's flaws to see the true beauty in someone and I feel that applies to fictional characters as well. I do recommend this to those who want to get into classics though.

Thank you Netgalley for giving me a digital copy of this book for free in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed Jane Eyre as a story, however I think that attempting to read it as a Manga was not the best decision for me personally. I still believe that many people could/will enjoy this title, but the style did not fit with how I tend to enjoy classics. Since I am both a fan of Manga and Classics I was expecting to enjoy this, but I think that attempting to read this in a different format after I already knew the story might have just been a bit overkill for me personally. I believe that my previous experience with this novel may have stopped me from enjoying it as much as I was hoping to.

Was this review helpful?

Another great manga edition. I have read several in this collection by now and I am amazed every time. Dark and mysterious! This artwork really gives you the feel of Thornfield Hall and Mr. Rochester!

Was this review helpful?

I really love the Manga Classics series!!

This was another great read, as it is one of my favorite gothic romances. I loved seeing Jane Eyre come to life in manga format. The art style is great, the story is faithful to the original Jane Eyre and at the end of the manga they give rough sketches, references, and story behind creating the manga! I'm definitely going to have to buy a copy of this for my own collection!

Disclosure: I received Manga Classics: Jane Eyre as an ARC and I'm voluntarily leaving this review.

Was this review helpful?

Manga Classics' adaptations of classic novels are becoming my new favorite. I read Jane Eyre last year, and since then I have never been over it. Adapting a classic into Manga format is quite challenging, especially since it's not possible to include all the scenes. But Manga Classics did an impeccable job and most importantly the essence of the novel stays intact. If you feel too intimidated to read classics, you can surely opt for this Manga and later read the novel. Getting started with Manga Classics can be a great way to get children into reading classics.

Was this review helpful?

Magna is hard enough to read backwards, but it’s even harder on an e book. The format made it difficult to understand the story as an ebook. The story itself was good, but I think magna needs to be in paper format.

Was this review helpful?

It's been a while since I've read Jane Eyre, but I really liked this adaptation.   It felt like it did the story justice.  It was well designed and carried the story across well.  I was glad to be able to revisit a story I liked as a teen in a way that was shorter and more accessible.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed the art style overall. The illustrator did a good job at drawing the settings and using descriptions from the book to capture the general atmosphere and mood of the work. The illustrations really brought this story to life in a meaningful way.

Was this review helpful?

Jane Eyre is my favorite work of classic literature. I’m happy to say that this is a very accessible edition of the work. It’s an easy read that is mostly true to the original book, and since it is in a manga format, it would likely be less overwhelming for many people to read. The e-book was a little difficult to read since it’s a manga (back to front), but it wasn’t the most difficult.

I really enjoyed the art style overall. The illustrator did a good job at drawing the settings and using descriptions from the book to capture the general atmosphere and mood of the work. The illustrations really brought this story to life in a meaningful way.

I only had a few things I disliked about this work. There were some instances of awkward wording throughout the manga (one example was “on equality with them”). Grace Poole was illustrated as a young and beautiful woman, but in the book she is explicitly described as older and not attractive. Similarly, Jane is supposed to be very plain, but she is drawn to be quite lovely. Mr. Rochester isn’t supposed to be handsome at all (major plot point), but he is drawn in a very handsome way. Now it might just be that it’s difficult to create ugly, non-cute characters in a manga style, but I still would have preferred some changes to the depictions of these characters. I also felt that this version wasn’t true to the intent of the book in one place in particular: when St. John proposes to Jane. Jane was firm the whole time about refusing, but in this version she seems to give in for a bit – part of Jane’s character is that she’s firm with what she believes and is true to herself, so I think this was misrepresented in this particular scene of this version.

For anyone who has felt intimidated or uninterested in sitting down and reading Jane Eyre, I highly recommend this version of the work. Except for a few minor things, this is very true to the novel and is a great take on a classic.

I received a complimentary copy of this work through NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.

Was this review helpful?

great adaptation of the classic! Thank you to Netgalley and Publisher for providing me with an E-Arc in exchange for a honest review!

Was this review helpful?

Well thought out, intriguing characters. Read from being to end without pause. Jane was relatable, and I am so glad she found a happy ending eventually.

Was this review helpful?

Jane Eyre is one of my most favourite classical books. This manga version has officially became my favourite because the illustration is captivating and it captures the true essence of the whole story. I'm so happy that the manga didn't miss any necessary scenes which makes it easier for me to understand the story. I highly recommend everyone to give this manga a shot!

Was this review helpful?

I found this book charming and the artwork really helped tell the story in a way that young readers can appreciate it. The artwork in this book helps them to get a glimpse of the land, being able to picture something helps to immerse themselves in the story. I also appreciated how the book has times where the artwork does the storytelling, there was not a need to use text to cover some of the art, it was enough on its own.

I think this is a great book that can introduce children to some of the classics their parents grew up on.

Thank you NetGalley for the chance to read this lovely book!

Was this review helpful?

I did greatly enjoy this book, the manga had a light and hopeful tone to it, I highly recommend it to introduce the classic Jane Eyre from older children up, the drawings are absolutely adorable, and Jane is a nice role model for both male and female, she relies in herself and at the same time she understands how being in love doesn’t make less of her.

Thank you NetGalley for the free ARC and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

Was this review helpful?

Somehow, as a graduated Lit student, I still never read the actual classic Jane Eyre. I read a good 40% of it in high school for an essay, but I skipped the last bit once I had enough to write said essay, since I had plenty of other things keeping me busy then. But I honestly enjoyed the experience of this manga classic so much that I really need to get back to the original version of this story!

I'm overall a big fan of adaptations of classics like this, because I feel like it both brings these classic stories into the 21st century, while also making it easier for more people to read and more accessible over all. The prose of classics is often quite hard and not fun to get through, so having options like this, or other accessible adaptations, can help introduce these classics to a new generation, keeping their stories relevant (though definitely not all classics need this treatment, some deserve to stay in the past!)

I'll definitely be trying more of these Manga adaptations, as I've now read two from this company, and I'd love to experience more classics in this format, both stories I've read before and are entirely new to me!

Was this review helpful?

I read Jane Eyre almost every year, it's one of my favorite classics, so when I saw this Manga I knew I had to request it.
I love the stile of the drawings, super cute!
Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for my copy.

Was this review helpful?

I read Jane Eyre for the first time a few years ago and fell in love instantly, so when I saw the Manga Classics version of the book I HAD to request it. Manga Classics has never failed me before and didn't fail me this time either. I liked how the story starts when Jane is still a child and not when she meets Rochester as many versions do, and I loved to see her grow up and become the Jane Eyre we all remember best.
The style of the drawings wasn't really my cup of tea as I found Jane had a 'childish' appearance even when adult (meaning she still seemed very young even when fully adult), but the drawings are lovely nonetheless, recommended!

Was this review helpful?

I actually never read the original novel Jane Eyre, but this was a fun way to experience the story. The combination of Japanese art with the old clothes and setting was very fun. I thought the story was told well being combined with manga. Great adaption for a younger audience especially.

Was this review helpful?